[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[hazelkrs1]

Hehe only one I was missing was Ishy. Had em all pegged otherwise. Good job Ishy, you seemed really town to me this game.

 

Still frustrated game got called. I think town woulda won this

[hazelkrs1]

Oh well. Mish for hosting a great game for us, sorry you had to deal with all the lame schtuffs. I was def having fun with it.

 

Darthe, how could you think Tommy to be scum after his catch up posts? He made it pretty obvious he was town there, had the look of town developing reads organically as he went along, not scum going forward with predisposed stories.

 

I thought Key might be Survivor when I looked back and noticed her reaction to Cloud pushing the outing of Survivor thing. But I still thought it looked a bit too much like she had teammates, too many peeps defending her. And I figured Darthe would mebbe be the Survivor still.

 

Anyways, good game everyone.

[michellem]

Des, I didn't think it was fair for town in the slightest when 5 out of 9 town players had to be replaced. It got to the point where I felt it would hurt the town too much. I had decided basically after Lily replaced it, that that was the final replacement the game could deal with.

[Darthe]

@Des he is scary good as scum. I could only base it off of comparison to my own thoughts.

[hazelkrs1]

Soooooo. Gonna try and not hold a grudge at last person who quit out(not Aidanna). Gonna be tough, but Imma try.

[Darthe]

Des, I didn't think it was fair for town in the slightest when 5 out of 9 town players had to be replaced. It got to the point where I felt it would hurt the town too much. I had decided basically after Lily replaced it, that that was the final replacement the game could deal with.

Wasn't going to say it in game but this is what was bumming me. Had too much shifting around to keep up with how each persons meta might change my views on the roles.

[hazelkrs1]

@Des he is scary good as scum. I could only base it off of comparison to my own thoughts.

Hmm. Will have to see for myself. Thanks for bringing all these pros to DM btw Darthe! That plus the vurry promising new bloods around here have a real shot at revitalizing DM mafia a good bit!

[hazelkrs1]

I tend to just put off replacements when I'm scumhunting till the new one can establish their own gameplay. Or later when I'm doing isos.

[_CLOUD]

That plus the vurry promising new bloods around here have a real shot at revitalizing DM mafia a good bit!

 

Thank you. I try my best

[Darthe]

Actually got something in the works for that. More on it when everything gets sorted out though.

[keyholder21]

I figured the cop would view me or Kaylee, so I thouhht it was weird when Cloud said it. Wasn't going to question an un cc'd cop though. Good way to get speedlynched lol.

[hazelkrs1]

 

That plus the vurry promising new bloods around here have a real shot at revitalizing DM mafia a good bit!

Thank you. I try my best

 

You ain't no newblood!

 

You aint half bad tho either

[keyholder21]

^ sais it meaning when he said he'd viewed Des.

[Andrej]

Sucks that this game ended this way. Sorry about that Mish

 

I was actually looking forward to replacing in, damn you guys for lynching me on D1

 

And it figures the one time I intentionally tried not to read Cloud as scummy, he actually was.

[_CLOUD]

I'm always open for feedback on how I can improve my play, you know :P

[keyholder21]

And it figures the one time I intentionally tried not to read Cloud as scummy, he actually was.

Same here AJ!

[hazelkrs1]

I figured the cop would view me or Kaylee, so I thouhht it was weird when Cloud said it. Wasn't going to question an un cc'd cop though. Good way to get speedlynched lol.

I fully advocate questioning un cc'd cops if they still seem scummy, btw. Not a fan of auto-clearing someone after they claim when the setup could be wildly different than you imagine (no cop, multiple cops, etc.)

[Darthe]

I think I am the only mod afound besides DPR that consistantly does no cop setups.

[peacesells]

I hand Ishy to the town team on a platter and you guys don't lynch him.  Shame, shame, shame.  Wow.

[_CLOUD]

Yeah me too. It was a desperate claim.

[hazelkrs1]

I'm always open for feedback on how I can improve my play, you know :P

I honestly think part of it is that random.org just hates you.

 

#Cloudisalwaysscum

 

[Andrej]

I don't think I am one to give you any pointers Cloud

[keyholder21]

I hand Ishy to the town team on a platter and you guys don't lynch him. Shame, shame, shame. Wow.

Not sure what you are referring to here. I knew he was mafia though *g*. Perhaps why he kept calling me scum lol, because he knew I could read him like that.

[hazelkrs1]

I think I am the only mod afound besides DPR that consistantly does no cop setups.

Nol's KoH game didn't have one, and I can think of several more games that might have had investigative roles of some kind but no actual cop.

[michellem]

 

Des, I didn't think it was fair for town in the slightest when 5 out of 9 town players had to be replaced. It got to the point where I felt it would hurt the town too much. I had decided basically after Lily replaced it, that that was the final replacement the game could deal with.

Wasn't going to say it in game but this is what was bumming me. Had too much shifting around to keep up with how each persons meta might change my views on the roles.

 

 

Yeah it bummed me too... It's been really hard for me to keep my own motiviation for modding up. Golden threw a hissy fit when I gave him a soft warning for the "tedious" comment; I had a couple players react to me privatley and I decided to give him a soft warning as I'd said I would in the rules. After that I've been struggling to keep up my good mood, and I guess it shows in my extremely messed up VCs, I haven't been able to give the game my all. Snow didn't have time after all to play and Hallu just vanished. I even tried PMing him. I saw what that amount of replacements did to Heart's Halloween game in the Aiels. Granted, there it screwed the mafia over and not town, but the same was gonna happen to town here. I didn't want to let that happen.

 

 

 

 

Hey, Key, if the mafia had given you the deal to win with them like we talked about, would you have taken it now that you know who the mafia was?