[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[_CLOUD]

@Tom: You are linking me and Dice together only because he said that I'm always scummy. I also think that this sounds like an easy excuse to get me lynched, and it is one of the reason that he is on my scumlist. I mentioned to you that he is usually seen as scummy in Mafia because you were wondering about it in a previous post. I already said that my vote on Kay isn't only based on her changing her mind about Key, and I have also already given my reasons for suspecting Golden/Krak so I don’t see why you are so dead set on on wanting me lynched.

 

Tried dropping a towntell here (I say towntell cause really a townie shouldn't be as concerned with how their moves make them look, should only really be concerned with catching scum). Seems forced tho.

You can call every reaction in this game forced if you are convinced that someone is mafia.

 

Urges a speedlynch on Kaylee

I didn’t even mention a speedlynch in this game. My comment towards Kaylee was just a meant to add some pressure.

 

Cloud says he doesn't have much of a reason... really a townie should never say something like this, especially not day 1. It's like an anti-discussion generator. You should always have a reason for your vote, even if it's something as lame as wanting to bandwagon (something Nolder likes to do), or consolidation.

I had a reason for my vote on Aida. I didn’t want to lynch AJ or Luci, and Aida was one of the highest trains so I voted for her instead. In a way it’s similar to consolidating on someone. You can’t expect me to have a gameplay reason for why I wanted Aida lynched because she hardly had any posts.

 

Combative attitude. No like. Town should almost always want to make sure a lynch is secured, so that SOME info can be obtained. Ping.

Where do you see a combative attitude? I only told everyone that I was going to bed, and wished them good luck on achieving a lynch. AJ looked to be the one who would get lynched, but I decided I wouldn’t vote for him after I saw Golden place that ridiculous scummy vote on him.

 

 

 

 

 

This is funny- Cloud went after Kaylee heavily day 1, yet switches to going after Golden day 1 because Golden is voting Kaylee. For a post meant to show a contradiction in someone else, it reveals somewhat of a contradiction on Cloud's part instead

I wasn’t contradicting myself when I voted for Golden because he switched his vote to Kay. My scum read on Kay hadn’t changed; I noticed that he was contradicting himself about his read on her which together with his vote on AJ made me think that he is scum. I admit that it made me second guess myself for a moment about my read on Kay, but he probably tried to distance himself from her and failed horribly with doing so.

 

Quoted mainly cause he says he has a town read on Key, which I don't agree with, and a scum read on Dice, and he eventually comes back to say Dice always appears scummy. Saying someone seems scummy to you, but then telling someone else that person always seems scummy = you yourself are scummy.

So you think I’m scum because I don’t agree with you about one player? I do have a scum read on Dice, and like I said I was only answering Tom when I mentioned that Dice is usually seen as scummy in Mafia. This doesn’t change my read about him in the slightest though, because his actions in this game were questionable and I’m not going to rely on meta when someone has been playing as he did.

 

Conclusion: Cloud is a pretty good lynch for today, can give us some info on Dice. He also has laid really low this game, which for him is a scumtell since he normally attracts a lot of attention early on in games.

When I talk a lot during Day 1 I get lynched because people think I’m always scummy, and when I try to change my meta by not being as vocal I get lynched again because I’m not talking enough.

 

You are very very wrong about me dude, and I know that because I viewed you Night 1. I'm the Cop.

[keyholder21]

Guess I was off about des. Sorry des.

[_CLOUD]

Luci, would you kindly vote for Kay? She is mafia. I don't even have to view her to figure that out.

[Darthe]

I actually am beginning to suspect everyone here. This game has a lot of spewed nothing and leaves little headway that isn't WIFOM. I suppose that's the price of not having a town core at this point.

[LilyElizabeth]

Having read all the way through, finally, the person I am most suspicious of is Darthe. (Big surprise, I know..) Got a town vibe from him for a while, which was scary, since it's never happened before. I could switch my vote there or to Luci. I want to give Krak more time to settle in, but Golden didn't look very good. 

[Darthe]

Guess I was off about des. Sorry des.

Don't be sorry about it. His play got your read on him and the apology looks like posturing from you.

[Darthe]

Having read all the way through, finally, the person I am most suspicious of is Darthe. (Big surprise, I know..) Got a town vibe from him for a while, which was scary, since it's never happened before. I could switch my vote there or to Luci. I want to give Krak more time to settle in, but Golden didn't look very good.

I have a wonka piv for this, courtesy of my dear friend mynd. Gimme a bit.

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Key (1): Dice
Dice (2): Krak, Tom
Cloud (2): Kaylee, Des,
Kaylee (2): Cloud, Lily
Ishy (2): Key, Kaylee

With 11 alive, 6 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (2): Ishy, Dice

Deadline 2am Saturday GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131214T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D2

[Darthe]

 

 

If your playstyle efffectively caught mafia I wouldn't have issue with it Lily. Not trying to be rude here but even a gut feeling deserves some reason if you want it to be considered credible.

 

unvote vote kaylee sure.

 

Btw, starting to get into this again thoigh Key is offputting.

So, what you're saying is that you don't think I'm good at mafia. I can't say I don't agree with you there, but it's fun to play.

Actually I think you are fairly good. I just think you become biased pretty easily

[_CLOUD]

Darthe also voted for Kay.

[_CLOUD]

I actually am beginning to suspect everyone here. This game has a lot of spewed nothing and leaves little headway that isn't WIFOM. I suppose that's the price of not having a town core at this point.

 

It is a weird game. I give you that,

[LilyElizabeth]

 

Having read all the way through, finally, the person I am most suspicious of is Darthe. (Big surprise, I know..) Got a town vibe from him for a while, which was scary, since it's never happened before. I could switch my vote there or to Luci. I want to give Krak more time to settle in, but Golden didn't look very good.

I have a wonka piv for this, courtesy of my dear friend mynd. Gimme a bit.

 

Can't wait! I guess it wouldn't be mafia if I didn't suspect you. heh

[Tommyrod]

Okay so Des is town as I said

 

Cloud is cop, fair enough

 

I would still go for Dice or Luci

 

Key feels okay to me

 

I think Kaylee is good too

 

Could be wrong since I am very lazy

[hazelkrs1]

 

Guess I was off about des. Sorry des.

Don't be sorry about it. His play got your read on him and the apology looks like posturing from you.

 

Unvote

 

WTL either Dice, Luci, or Darthe at this point. Who's game?

[Darthe]

Honestly Dice is about spot on for his meta. The only point against him is how quiet he is. He reaallllyyyy lurks as scum and that is his big tell.

[Darthe]

 

 

Guess I was off about des. Sorry des.

Don't be sorry about it. His play got your read on him and the apology looks like posturing from you.

 

Unvote

 

WTL either Dice, Luci, or Darthe at this point. Who's game?

Between you and lily I have two votes on the back of my head from beginning to end of any game I am in ).)

[LilyElizabeth]

 

 

If your playstyle efffectively caught mafia I wouldn't have issue with it Lily. Not trying to be rude here but even a gut feeling deserves some reason if you want it to be considered credible.

 

unvote vote kaylee sure.

 

Btw, starting to get into this again thoigh Key is offputting.

So, what you're saying is that you don't think I'm good at mafia. I can't say I don't agree with you there, but it's fun to play.

Actually I think you are fairly good. I just think you become biased pretty easily

 

Thanks. I know I'm not as good as I used to be. Jack always brought out the best in me, and since he left, it's not the same. But, like I said, it's fun. I'm better as a "gut instinct" player, so I'm going with that now. No more trying to fit in. 

 

I'm out for a while. Going to go bake some cookies. 

[Luciena]

I offer myself up as sacrifice since almost everyone wants to, I am the weakest player.

 

I can't vote for myself but you guys can. 

 

@Mod Am I invisible or something? 

[_CLOUD]

What's up with everyone wanting to get themselves lynched in this game? If you are actually town you would do everything you can to stay alive and hunt down the mafia, especially in a basic game.

[hazelkrs1]

Vote Dice]/b]

 

He's not lurking as much this game so isn't a vt. Apparently Cloud is Cop, who just so happened to view me even tho he was convinced all day yesterday and today that Kaylee was scum, and I doubt that Dice would play this visibly as Doc. So looks like he's scum to me. Will Iso him later tonight.

 

Speaking of which, Key, iso is short for isolation, as in isolating one player's posts from the rest and analyzing. I still got my eye on you btw

[hazelkrs1]

Stupid backwards bracket

 

Vote Dice

[keyholder21]

I prefer a dice vote over a kay vote.

[keyholder21]

gah.  Ninja'd.

[keyholder21]

Speaking of which, Key, iso is short for isolation, as in isolating one player's posts from the rest and analyzing. I still got my eye on you btw

 

Ah, awesome, thanks.

 

LOL.  I would never think otherwise.

[_CLOUD]

He likes the way you walk