[Basic] The Walking Dead Mafia - Game Over. Theo Wins!

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Jumping off a train that ends up getting secured would make you look a LOT worse Err. If mafia were bussing her they would stay on it until it looked opportune for them. Peace's vote could qualify. He said Leelou was the scummier of the two, without ever explaining why.

 

Not sure how I feel about BFG now.

yes... but it was 7 hours of staying on that train with only a single vote remaining.... its just too big of a risk... we will have more information after the night.... but i am open to all possibilities.... i think theo is more likely towny

[GoldeneyesND]

Didn't Des claim Andrea? That would mean he and Ishy have been getting it on this whole time.

[peacesells]

Jumping off a train that ends up getting secured would make you look a LOT worse Err. If mafia were bussing her they would stay on it until it looked opportune for them. Peace's vote could qualify. He said Leelou was the scummier of the two, without ever explaining why.

 

Not sure how I feel about BFG now.

 

If I was scum and theo is town...then what benefit would there be in not hammering Theo earlier?  I voted who I thought was more likely the scum between the 2. 

[peacesells]

Didn't Des claim Andrea? That would mean he and Ishy have been getting it on this whole time.

 

Lol.. Thera is now a member of Ishy's harem. 

[Andrej]

^ lol

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Didn't Des claim Andrea? That would mean he and Ishy have been getting it on this whole time.

did he? i tried finding it ... couldnt find it

[Andrej]

They'd taken his mother from him.

 

He had been raised better by his father, but in his heart, he felt hatred.

 

He wanted revenge.

 

As the group slumbered nearby, he lay awake with his mind racing. He had already helped to find one of those who were out to betray them... perhaps he could find the others as well. He had heard people arguing yesterday that the eye-patch guy couldn't be the only one.

 

Grabbing a flashlight and pistol he went out into the chilly darkness to investigate. He wasn't exactly sure what he was looking for, but he figured he'd know it when he saw it.

 

The crunch of gravel behind him made him stop in his tracks.

 

"A little past your bedtime... ain't it kid?" The voice asked.

 

The bullet that took him in the back felt more like a punch. It knocked the wind straight out of his lungs and toppled him onto the pave stones.

 

The other approached and stood over his body for a few quiet moments before firing another shot into the back of his head.

 

Rule #2 for surviving Zombieland: The Double Tap.

 

 

Goldeneyes - Carl Grimes: Town Cop is dead.

 

It is now Day 4. The DL will be either Tuesday or Wednesday evening, I haven't decided yet.

[peacesells]

Well..maybe Mish isn't the Doc.

 

I might have to eat some crow for Err after the game if Mish is scum considering what I thought about him pushing against Mish.

 

Her little emotional outburst admonishing Err about directing her NK gives her a great excuse to say she tried to wifom the target. 

 

Also had a little emotional outburst concerning Ishy too, acting like she was betrayed by him somehow. 

 

Starting to come together.  Could there be no DOC this game...now that would be a strange occurrence for DM.  I've seen it once or twice before..but it's been awhile.  May explain my role being present.  I should never have revealed.

[BFG]

Need to reread (again), but it will be tomorrow.

[Andrej]

Vote Count 4.0

 

Not Voting: All yall.

 

6 alive. 4 to lynch.

[michellem]

No such thing, Peace. I cannot protect the same person two nights in a row. I protected Golden last night, and so I couldn't this night. I was hoping the mafia would try and go for me instead.

[Theodora]

Wow,sorry tro hear that,mafia is well informed now c:(

[Theodora]

Mish, why did you protect yourself (if doc), I guess policy of the Mod :( Golde,you've been a real help here. Mish, you dididn't have people worthy enough to ptoect but you?

[Theodora]

I am sorry for the spelling mistakes and for Goldy. You did an excellent job!

[michellem]

Because when both cop and doc are out in the open, the mafia wants both dead. They are confirmed townies after a while, and the mafia hates confirmed townies, they can't get them lynched. And since mafia wants as many town dead as possible... I was hoping the mafia thought I'd protect Golden and sacrifice myself. Even if there were other people I felt very strongly about being town now, the only person I could now was town was myself and Golden, and so I had to keep one of us alive, I hoped to be able to get us both alive by the end of the night, but alas I didn't outsmart the mafia. Or, they have a roleblocker and used that on me to make sure they got Golden down.

 

 

I have to say... I feel slightly better about Dora after Ishy's flip. I don't think that was a gambit. The downside is, now I'm back to scratch.

 

 

 

Also, since Err conviently laid the foundation to doubt me yesterday, I find it's the right time to reveal my character too. It's Carol Petelier.

 

Ugh... I personally would appreciate a Wednesday deadline AJ, but it's up to you of course.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

no no!!! y god y!! he was so young

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Because when both cop and doc are out in the open, the mafia wants both dead. They are confirmed townies after a while, and the mafia hates confirmed townies, they can't get them lynched. And since mafia wants as many town dead as possible... I was hoping the mafia thought I'd protect Golden and sacrifice myself. Even if there were other people I felt very strongly about being town now, the only person I could now was town was myself and Golden, and so I had to keep one of us alive, I hoped to be able to get us both alive by the end of the night, but alas I didn't outsmart the mafia. Or, they have a roleblocker and used that on me to make sure they got Golden down.

 

 

I have to say... I feel slightly better about Dora after Ishy's flip. I don't think that was a gambit. The downside is, now I'm back to scratch.

 

 

 

Also, since Err conviently laid the foundation to doubt me yesterday, I find it's the right time to reveal my character too. It's Carol Petelier.

 

Ugh... I personally would appreciate a Wednesday deadline AJ, but it's up to you of course.

see Mish i have a problem with one thing u just said..... if you protected yourself how do u come to the conclusion that mafia has a roleblocker???? u would say that if u protected Golden and he still died... there is no possible way for u to come to that conclusion.... care to elaborate??

[Babar Hasan Khan]

No such thing, Peace. I cannot protect the same person two nights in a row. I protected Golden last night, and so I couldn't this night. I was hoping the mafia would try and go for me instead.

:) here you are saying that u had no choise.... because if i am assuming that ur role as a doctor includes not saving the same person twice in a row?? so u had no option to save golden period..... then in ur next post u contradict by saying that  u were hoping to keep both of u alive so u took a gambit.... if u were bound by the game rules... then the second over explanation doesnt hold...... and if not then this one doesnt

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Didn't Des claim Andrea? That would mean he and Ishy have been getting it on this whole time.

des can u confirm this... cause i cant find the original  post

[GoldeneyesND]

Why?!!!!!!! 

 

Thanks to everyone for my first game. I really enjoyed it.

[michellem]

Ugh read my posts properly will you Err?

 

No, I cannot protect the same person two nights in a row.

 

 

As I said, I was trying to outsmart the mafia, hoping they would think that I protected Golden, even though I was actually unable to, but they couldn't know that. But, maybe they either decided to hope that I would be selfish and protect myself, OR they thought I would protect Golden, but they have a roleblocker so they blocked me (thinking they blocked my protect on Golden) and killed him. Get it now?

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Mish.... i am looking at it from an other angle too..... u see there is a possibility there is no doctor.... mafia didnt knew that..... you claimed u were a doctor without a single vote on u and any real pressure (as golden had put it)

 

i think it was a gambit just like Ishy claiming to be survivor.... and when no one came up to contradict u as a doctor... u knew there were no doctors in the game.... and i see that mafia didnt take their sweet time to play a bet on weather to aim for cop/doc.... 

 

it may be a horrible think to say... but i preferred if you had died and golden lived... because we are in lylo again... if golden had inspected one more mafia this day his job would have been over.... u job was over already if u had saved him and sacrificed urself we wouldnt have needed a doctor again... there was no need of a doctor the day after.... and we just had to figure out who the god father is left..... and with around a 1000 posts we would have figured it out probably

 

and if u say that u needed a doctor because we would have a towny vote... i dont agree... because if golden had inspected a towny we would still get one in replacement for ur sacrifice..... saving golden was the optimal path... u just didnt take it

[Babar Hasan Khan]

Ugh read my posts properly will you Err?

 

No, I cannot protect the same person two nights in a row.

 

 

As I said, I was trying to outsmart the mafia, hoping they would think that I protected Golden, even though I was actually unable to, but they couldn't know that. But, maybe they either decided to hope that I would be selfish and protect myself, OR they thought I would protect Golden, but they have a roleblocker so they blocked me (thinking they blocked my protect on Golden) and killed him. Get it now?

no... if u had no choice of saving golden..... u wouldnt say i was trying to outsmart the mafia.... u would simply say u had no choice period.... there would be no other because

 

u had no choice thats it...... u dont have to go and say u were trying to outsmart the mafia if u had no choice....  and then u make a definite statement they HAVE a roleblocker?? an other assumption of no way of proving... because the only say u would know that is if u saved golden and he still died. 

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

Ugh read my posts properly will you Err?

 

No, I cannot protect the same person two nights in a row.

 

 

As I said, I was trying to outsmart the mafia, hoping they would think that I protected Golden, even though I was actually unable to, but they couldn't know that. But, maybe they either decided to hope that I would be selfish and protect myself, OR they thought I would protect Golden, but they have a roleblocker so they blocked me (thinking they blocked my protect on Golden) and killed him. Get it now?

no... if u had no choice of saving golden..... u wouldnt say i was trying to outsmart the mafia.... u would simply say u had no choice period.... there would be no other because

 

u had no choice thats it...... u dont have to go and say u were trying to outsmart the mafia if u had no choice....  and then u make a definite statement they HAVE a roleblocker?? an other assumption of no way of proving... because the only say u would know that is if u saved golden and he still died. 

 

for me instead of putting out a single theory... u are putting out three... and telling everyone to pick one and choose which one to believe.

 

1. i had no choice my role doesnt allow me to save the same person twice in a row

2. i was trying to outsmart the mafia by playing the gambit.

3. they HAVE a roleblocker to they were confident if u had saved golden they would still kill him

 

i chose none of the above!!

[Babar Hasan Khan]

and if u couldnt save golden the night after ur claim.... then y make the claim if it would put townys in an disadvantage???? u could have waited for people to vote for u atleast???? no??