Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[csarmi]

You know that it would be untrue

You know that I would be a liar

If I was to say to you

Girl, we couldn't get much higher

[Thorum]

Sorry.

 

See, that's why I'm not a gambler at all 

[Niniel]

Thorum - you killed Csarmi?

 

I need to go back and check. Wasn´t there anyone that asked you to kill him? I could be wrong. 

[Thorum]

Three-fold reasoning: There were people that asked to kill him, he seemed a likely-but-not-obvious choice, and, most importantly, he seemed the most obvious choice for the lover.

[dicetosser1]

Darthe  im kinda stuck for the mo. I asked  RTE a question last night and still dont have an answer and i can only ask 1 at a time.

 

Thorum a) uve never played mafia at the Black tower have you? I came home to over 30 pages one day.  b) why was he obvious when ive been whinging that i think he was mafia?

[Thorum]

a) Once. And I had to stop because of an accident my sister had, halfway during day 1.

 

b) You would be wanting to hide him in plain sight, without treating him differently. I thought he was the lover because of some things salami was saying...

[Thorum]

Darthe is town or godfather. As per salami.

[berf]

ooooooooooh. 

 

 

 

CS = Mafia. Earlier God reveal by MCS should never have slipped the radar. What purpose does MCS have for claiming this? nil. Lynchable right there, but combined with the recent chainsaw defense of a 3rd party, well that is asking too many questions for me to find answers too without killing at this stage. 

Thorum = verdict is out. But with our 1 third party gone (pending Dice flipping true) and no CC you look better and better. My god do you sow some WIFOM you son of a bitch.

Dice = thanks for all the fish or so long you devil. Either Oracle or Mafia. Leaning Oracle based on below

Wombat - making the right wombatty moves for the most part.

Darthe Turning up to fight the good fight at the end, brownie points there. Still some near interesting votes coming forth at times, but leaning town. Don't know why we need to kill the Oracle either, on second thought... (See Below)

Cloud - A very strange end of D1 but mostly leaning town scapegoat. D1 end itself though along with the info on all your trains make you someone to look at later if all other leads come up empty.

Tina - Good casing if infrequent but has been busy. Town.

Praya - unfocused town, but posting on the most random of things, and might have missed the entire Mish reveal... Unknown quantity, especially given the Thorum situation with the shot.

Ithi - TAF 4EVA

Halli - Town but come on girl work that grey matter

Krak + Song- Who?

 

 

 

WHY ARE WE LYNCHING THE ORACLE BY THE WAY? -----> MISH WAS NOT TOWN AND CLUMSY SWITCH - DICE MUST HAVE GAINED THAT INFO SOMEHOW.

 

 

 

Updated with flips.

 

CS - Cop. Cleared Darthe. Deaded by Thorum

Thorum - Town Vig. (3rd party Dice info + No cc + CS death )

Darthe - Cleared by Cop + Casing efforts and voting = TAF status applied. (Pending Godfather flip whenever that happens)

 

Dice is not vetted but 90% town in my eyes, however a mafia tracker/cop role of some descript would account for the knowledge. Outside chance at this stage though it seems.

 

 

3 mafia then from;

 

Wombat, Cloud, Tina, Praya, Krak, Song/Dap

 

I know I am town before anyone mentions it.

 

We know Dice's Lover is Mafia, and with 6 suspects and 3 targets...

 

 

 

Wombat, Dap, and Tina get a pass so far for activity and general town vibes.

 

I'm happy to lynch:

 

 

Cloud - info kill and a lot of wifom surrounding day 1 movements. If you flip town, the case on you from yesterday or the day prior will be telling also. But mainly the day 1 vote shenanigans. 

 

Krak - Because come on man you're forcing my hand here.

 

Praya - Remove some Thorum wifom, and it might not have been Mish's thing at all that blocked something here.

 

 

 

VOTE KRAK - Speak up sunshine your time has come.

[Thorum]

I agree 100% (I was actually busy typing the exact same thing, with you included in the potential-mafia, and on the "pass for activity and general town vibes"), except on the last line.

 

vote Cloud seems a better choice to me.

[berf]

We have 3 days.

 

 

Trains gon' Choo.

[Pralaya]

You know that it would be untrue

You know that I would be a liar

If I was to say to you

Girl, we couldn't get much higher

 

+1 for Doors :)

[berf]

Unofficial But Awesome Vote Count

 

 

(1) Cloud - Thorum

 (1) Krak - Berf

 

 Not Voting (9) - Dice, Wombat, Darthe, Cloud, Tina, Praya, Krak, Dap, Peace

 

 - With 11 playing, it takes 6 to Lynch.

[Thorum]

Dice and/or lover, it's about time you give the name. That would make the list for today's lynches one shorter (and would probably have stopped my cop-kill yesterday).

[Pralaya]

 

Cloud - A very strange end of D1 but mostly leaning town scapegoat. D1 end itself though along with the info on all your trains make you someone to look at later if all other leads come up empty.

Cloud - info kill and a lot of wifom surrounding day 1 movements. If you flip town, the case on you from yesterday or the day prior will be telling also. But mainly the day 1 vote shenanigans. 

 

 

Your cloud reads keep changing every hour? You mentioned that he has been behaving weird ever since Day 1. But, that was not how you felt yesterday

For some reason, you were totally against a Cloud votes. Why?

 

 

Continue with this cloud business then if you will - which will may or may not be telling. The reread continues. 

 

Leaning town on cloud so far.

 

 

If you are waiting for Mish to check in, good luck. Not the most vocal in this game and I've only seen more than one or two posts a day on one occasion this game. We'll see.

 

I understand wanting to hear from Mish, though.

 

@THORUM - why are you directing us onto cloud tomorrow? I'm still yet to see any actual case. All you say is that he is a liar because nobody counter claimed your vig-ness? I guess I'll spot it on the reread if it is so damn clear, eh?

 

[dicetosser1]

Im thinking I will out my lover cause if i dont im dead anyway cause you all will lynch him anyways.

 

Cloud

[Thorum]

So, Krak or Praya. Now is the time to declare yourselves if you have something to say.

 

unvote and vote Praya

[berf]

I was reading through D1 whilst keeping track of D2 to find the case on cloud. I have, and still do have, town leanings on his overall play. That being said, the Vote count thing at the close of D1 is a definite Bad Move.

 

And I've just been ninja'd. Cloud is the Lover and ergo mafia.

 

 

 

 

Dice that was an early reveal given the reason. Is your entire reason to reveal because you feel a cloud lynch is inevitable today? :S

[berf]

Either way. Leave cloud alive until we clean up everyone else. Done, son.

 

@PRAYA I need some reads from you man. You are giving nothing and there is an absolute PILE going on.

[dicetosser1]

i actually almost posted it in my first post tonight and yes cause if i didn't speak up he would be the lynch. he almost got done yesterday

[dicetosser1]

vote Praya   I still think he slipped

[Thorum]

I think we should keep both lovers for at least one other day. We can be quite sure Cloud is mafia, but probably not the godfather. And Dice can give some valuable contributions still.

 

2 mafia hiding in Wombat, Berf, Tina, Praya, Krak, Song/Dap

 

Should be smoke-outable.

[Thorum]

I got to Praya by exclusion:

 

- Wombat, Berf = very active, seem town-usefull

- Tina = not overly active, but made some intelligent remarks

- Krak = was NOT replaced, so prob least important role of the to-be-replaced trio Krak/Song/Ithi

- Song/Dap = new. give him a chance.

[berf]

Keep Calm

And

Don't Vote Cloud

 

*

[Pralaya]

vote Praya   I still think he slipped

 

What was the slip? Don't you see how berf keeps changing his reads based on the context - kind of looking for an opportunity

I addressed the same yesterday.

 

First it was all lynch either thorum/me and see what info comes out

Then he wanted to shoot Mish

Then he starts selling the idea that mish is mafia

Then he goes off on Csarmi and changes his reads about Cloud

 

 

I got to Praya by exclusion:

 

- Wombat, Berf = very active, seem town-usefull

- Tina = not overly active, but made some intelligent remarks

- Krak = was NOT replaced, so prob least important role of the to-be-replaced trio Krak/Song/Ithi

- Song/Dap = new. give him a chance.

 

 

Strange post. Active doesn't mean town. Active could also mean that one is leading the town to lynches.

 

You can lynch me, but when I flip town, remember this post

 

vote berf

[berf]

 

vote Praya   I still think he slipped

 

What was the slip? Don't you see how berf keeps changing his reads based on the context - kind of looking for an opportunity

I addressed the same yesterday.

 

First it was all lynch either thorum/me and see what info comes out

Then he wanted to shoot Mish

Then he starts selling the idea that mish is mafia

Then he goes off on Csarmi and changes his reads about Cloud

 

 

I got to Praya by exclusion:

 

- Wombat, Berf = very active, seem town-usefull

- Tina = not overly active, but made some intelligent remarks

- Krak = was NOT replaced, so prob least important role of the to-be-replaced trio Krak/Song/Ithi

- Song/Dap = new. give him a chance.

 

 

Strange post. Active doesn't mean town. Active could also mean that one is leading the town to lynches.

 

You can lynch me, but when I flip town, remember this post

 

vote berf

 

 

My Bolds:

 

 

1) Brings up his berf 'case' with Dice for no real clear reason. Let the case do the talking? Why do you have to point your case out to people? "Don't you see..."

 

2)

a) Yep, I wanted either you or Thorum dead to resolve the Vig, who I already didn't really trust, but didn't want to risk when something might have been up with YOU. Rather than blindly follow preconceived ideas, I judge what is the best move for town and then act accordingly. Why are you trying to paint that as 'inconsistency?" Anyway.

b) Yes I changed to wanting to shoot Mish because Mish was revealed as NOT TOWN. You'll recall I had many, many different plans of how it could work out. 

c) IF was 'selling' the idea that Mish was mafia, well... Why would I do that if I was mafia, when I would have known she wasn't? The info was coming out, so any WIFOM would die as she did... Doesn't make sense to me.

d) I went off on CS? How did I "Go Off?" I recall talking with him during the phase, and not agreeing with much that he said. He was advocating a cloud lynch and at the time I disagreed. And I don't think I ever really claimed a read on Cloud bar, as I'll state AGAIN for the record, a town vibe but with a very strange day 1 twist. 

 

3) Let the case speak for itself. If and when you die, people will know your reads if you put them out. Telegraphing it like this is just not needed.