Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[Thorum]

@THORUM - why are you directing us onto cloud tomorrow? I'm still yet to see any actual case. All you say is that he is a liar because nobody counter claimed your vig-ness? I guess I'll spot it on the reread if it is so damn clear, eh?

 

My reasoning to vote Cloud is on his voting behaviour at the end of day one. Nothing to do with the absence of a counterclaim... And now Cloud says Mish is mafia or third party, so that's more important. Cloud can wait another day.

 

 

Berf, why do you want dice to lose so much time on asking repeat-questions?

 

 

 

and yet you want to keep a role around that can potentially hurt town csarmi?

 

We need to make a cost-benefit analysis on that.

 

Is wasting a lynch on a survivor a lesser evil than keeping the clumsy switch around?

 

As currently I believe that the clumsy switch role can hurt maffia more than town, I'd say that yea, I think we should keep pressuring Cloud (and others).

We can always go back to Mish as a potential safe lynch.

 

Not to mention the fact that it's a safe shot for the Vig too!

 

In fact, if I wanted Mish dead, I'd lynch someone I think town and have our Vig shot her at night.

 

- I made the cost-benefit analysis with the limited data we have, leaving open a lot. If you have more info, please come forward with it...

 

- The safest shot for a vig is the unexpected one. So probably neither Cloud nor Mish. UNless I change my mind

 

And now, I propose dice, ithi, berf, salami and me stop posting for a few hours... We're loosing track of things with a huge post-overload.

[dicetosser1]

I agree Mish needs to go and go now

[dicetosser1]

im off to bed anyways  night

[berf]

Not willing to risk a Vig shot backfiring, eh?

 

If you are so sure on cloud, why not go for a two-fer?

 

Worst comes to worst, Mish can be tomorrows Lynch.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Official Vote Count

 

Cloud (5/8): Wombat, Mish, Csarmi, Hallia, Tina,

 

Pral (1/8): Cloud

 

Mish (5/8): Ithi, Berf, Thorum, Dice, Pral

 

Not Voting:Darthe, Krak, Song,

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

 

Deadline here!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Not willing to risk a Vig shot backfiring, eh?

 

If you are so sure on cloud, why not go for a two-fer?

 

Worst comes to worst, Mish can be tomorrows Lynch.

 

I don't like this and you are sliding further away from my good side. What part of NO allegedly accidental Doctor Deaths are you not understanding?

 

ugh.

 

Who will you Lynch today then Mr Berfington?

[Thorum]

I'm sure on Mish. And if she IS town, then Dice isn't. Which means we 100% sure get a mafia by a Mish-lynch

On Cloud, I have a hunch. Which could be right, could be wrong. Others have it too, though... I'm starting to have one on you too (berf), the way you're refusing to see the obvious.

 

Declaring in advance who you kill is the WORST a vig can do.

[csarmi]

- The safest shot for a vig is the unexpected one. So probably neither Cloud nor Mish. UNless I change my mind

I don't think I could disagree more. Blind shooting like tonight is not a good vig play.

[csarmi]

I'm sure on Mish. And if she IS town, then Dice isn't. Which means we 100% sure get a mafia by a Mish-lynch

On Cloud, I have a hunch. Which could be right, could be wrong. Others have it too, though... I'm starting to have one on you too (berf), the way you're refusing to see the obvious.

 

Declaring in advance who you kill is the WORST a vig can do.

You keep repeating that.

 

I'll spell it out for you:

 

No, we do not know that Mish is either scum or town.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Vote Count has been fixed. Thanks Csarmi.

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

I'm sure on Mish. And if she IS town, then Dice isn't. Which means we 100% sure get a mafia by a Mish-lynch

On Cloud, I have a hunch. Which could be right, could be wrong. Others have it too, though... I'm starting to have one on you too (berf), the way you're refusing to see the obvious.

 

Declaring in advance who you kill is the WORST a vig can do.

You keep repeating that.

 

I'll spell it out for you:

 

No, we do not know that Mish is either scum or town.

Are you forgetting that you believe Dice again? Dice said the role she was claiming was NOT Town.

 

And you did just type out that your would be ok with a Town Lynch.

 

And as we don't have any confirmed Mafia's knocking about ... it's probably best to go with the person that Dice has said is NOT TOWN.

 

Unless you know of some mafias of course.

[berf]

I'm sure on Mish. And if she IS town, then Dice isn't. Which means we 100% sure get a mafia by a Mish-lynch

On Cloud, I have a hunch. Which could be right, could be wrong. Others have it too, though... I'm starting to have one on you too (berf), the way you're refusing to see the obvious.

 

Declaring in advance who you kill is the WORST a vig can do.

 

1) You are starting to have a hunch, and yet I'm not seeing the obvious?

 

2) I'm still mid reread. I said I'm swinging town on cloud. I haven't formed a firm opinion, but reading this one would think I'm defending him mightily.

 

3) You really don't think a controlled shot (liberal use of the term controlled, granted) would help your cause right now?

[csarmi]

Actions happen all at the same time. She could still block me even if she got shot later tonight.

 

She has a terribly negative Role. She isn't Town.

 

We need to remove her ... and who said anything about her being a survivor that wins with Town. 3rd Party is 3RD PARTY.

 

They win with themselves.

Usually, a 3rd party winning by themselves are called an SK, otherwuse, they just win with either side.

 

Still, to be safe, it might be a good idea to clarify what the win condition of the 3rd party is. - I suppose Dice could ask about that?

[Thorum]

This post says she's not town. Quite literary.

 

 clumsy switch  town??  Nope!!!

 

Vote Mish

 

AND she's claiming (probably has) a role that's bad for town with the info we have.

 

 

Dice, maybe an additional, very detailed, question : can the clumsy switch work on EVERYONE randomly, or not ?

[berf]

 

Not willing to risk a Vig shot backfiring, eh?

 

If you are so sure on cloud, why not go for a two-fer?

 

Worst comes to worst, Mish can be tomorrows Lynch.

 

I don't like this and you are sliding further away from my good side. What part of NO allegedly accidental Doctor Deaths are you not understanding?

 

ugh.

 

Who will you Lynch today then Mr Berfington?

 

 

My vote is still on Mish I think. And since Thorum seems unwilling to take the opportunity to build some credit toward his cause, it remains.

 

The above is called baiting. You can surely see what I'm going toward here...

[csarmi]

Are you forgetting that you believe Dice again? Dice said the role she was claiming was NOT Town.

What's your point. I claimed that I think Dice is town. What do you think that means about me believing him?

 

And you did just type out that your would be ok with a Town Lynch.

No I wouldn't. I never said that. Unless you want to count my obvious typo, of course.

 

And as we don't have any confirmed Mafia's knocking about ... it's probably best to go with the person that Dice has said is NOT TOWN.

 

Unless you know of some mafias of course.

No, unfortunately I don't. But I believe Cloud to be a good lynch.

[Thorum]

 

I'm sure on Mish. And if she IS town, then Dice isn't. Which means we 100% sure get a mafia by a Mish-lynch

On Cloud, I have a hunch. Which could be right, could be wrong. Others have it too, though... I'm starting to have one on you too (berf), the way you're refusing to see the obvious.

 

Declaring in advance who you kill is the WORST a vig can do.

 

1) You are starting to have a hunch, and yet I'm not seeing the obvious?

 

2) I'm still mid reread. I said I'm swinging town on cloud. I haven't formed a firm opinion, but reading this one would think I'm defending him mightily.

 

3) You really don't think a controlled shot (liberal use of the term controlled, granted) would help your cause right now?

 

I'm wrong on the reasoning for you. Somehow, I got you and salami mixed up.

 

What do you mean with this?

 

 

 since Thorum seems unwilling to take the opportunity to build some credit toward his cause,

[Thorum]

I'm not gonna tell you who I'm gonna kill. That would be stupid.

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

Actions happen all at the same time. She could still block me even if she got shot later tonight.

 

She has a terribly negative Role. She isn't Town.

 

We need to remove her ... and who said anything about her being a survivor that wins with Town. 3rd Party is 3RD PARTY.

 

They win with themselves.

Usually, a 3rd party winning by themselves are called an SK, otherwuse, they just win with either side.

 

Still, to be safe, it might be a good idea to clarify what the win condition of the 3rd party is. - I suppose Dice could ask about that?

Wifom ... Wifom and Delay!

 

Of course I am incredibly suspicious and this could also be seen to be a buddying type defence as you know that Mish is NOT on your Team and so you know a NOT TOWN reading means she must be 3rd party.

 

But I don't mind getting rid of a Third Party and your certainty that she is 3rd party will certainly come back to bite you in the arse.

[csarmi]

3) You really don't think a controlled shot (liberal use of the term controlled, granted) would help your cause right now?

Interesting. Why do you ask him about his cause? Why not town's cause?

[berf]

@THORUM Cool. 

 

Mish can hang then. We can pick this up in the morning.

 

@ITHI http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/84403-greek-mythology-man-vs-gods-advanced-day-2-a-brother-slain/page-10?do=findComment&comment=3020803

That's an example of you knowing about baiting someone.

 

@CS - I believe Mish is mafia based on earlier Despo interactions at this stage. I've read up to my link above. Take a gander if you would

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

I'm sure on Mish. And if she IS town, then Dice isn't. Which means we 100% sure get a mafia by a Mish-lynch

On Cloud, I have a hunch. Which could be right, could be wrong. Others have it too, though... I'm starting to have one on you too (berf), the way you're refusing to see the obvious.

 

Declaring in advance who you kill is the WORST a vig can do.

You keep repeating that.

 

I'll spell it out for you:

 

No, we do not know that Mish is either scum or town.

Are you forgetting that you believe Dice again? Dice said the role she was claiming was NOT Town.

 

And you did just type out that your would be ok with a Town Lynch.

 

And as we don't have any confirmed Mafia's knocking about ... it's probably best to go with the person that Dice has said is NOT TOWN.

 

Unless you know of some mafias of course.

Try reading the quote of yours I quoted - or would you prefer that people not see.

 

you say Typo ... I say slip.

[berf]

@CS - Because I'm talking about his defense.

[csarmi]

 

 

Actions happen all at the same time. She could still block me even if she got shot later tonight.

 

She has a terribly negative Role. She isn't Town.

 

We need to remove her ... and who said anything about her being a survivor that wins with Town. 3rd Party is 3RD PARTY.

 

They win with themselves.

Usually, a 3rd party winning by themselves are called an SK, otherwuse, they just win with either side.

 

Still, to be safe, it might be a good idea to clarify what the win condition of the 3rd party is. - I suppose Dice could ask about that?

 

Wifom ... Wifom and Delay!

 

Of course I am incredibly suspicious and this could also be seen to be a buddying type defence as you know that Mish is NOT on your Team and so you know a NOT TOWN reading means she must be 3rd party.

 

But I don't mind getting rid of a Third Party and your certainty that she is 3rd party will certainly come back to bite you in the arse.

 

Ehm, where'sthe wifom here?

[Ithillian Turambar]

It's everywhere ... it's in everything that people say and do. Nothing is confirmed apart from Hallia. Everything could be one thing or it's exact opposite.

 

You keep on trying to be reasonable ... it's not working.