Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[Ithillian Turambar]

@CS reading now, I do recall your link-filled post though. Will get there when I get there.

That was just a list of statements that didn't really say anything but looked like thet did. It was quite clever really lol.

[csarmi]

Berf, currently I believe Dice is town, his lover is town and Mish is a survivor with a clumsy switch role.

Lynching a survivor is not free.

It costs a player who

1. wins with town
2. is confirmed unless counter-claimed

It's not necessarily a bad call, but not a good call either.

[berf]

Dice, if your Lover is NOT town...

 

What is the resolution from your lover lying to you?

[berf]

Above in regards to the NO CORONER result you recieved

[dicetosser1]

explain ure last sentence berf cause i dont get what you mean by resolution?

[csarmi]

 

delay delay delay ... wait for check in on qt ... delay .... pause ... seem to look useful

Why do you think she might be 3rd party?

 

Why do you think that Not Town does NOT = Mafia?

 

 

Because her role just screams 3rd party to me. A role that's equally likely to hurt town than maffia. A role that might not work exactly as she claimed to be working, btw.

 

Because we know that there are town, 3rd party and maffia and Dice told us she was not town. That means it's one of the other two. I think she is not maffia because of her play (absolutely no reason to hammer Despo if maffia - she could have logged in 10 minutes later if she wanted to). Also, the role fits 3rd party too much.

[csarmi]

By the way: if Mish is maffia, she can't just hide behind a 3rd party claim either. She'd get counterclaimed and lynched.

[csarmi]

Anyone notice that the Oracle just functioned as an insta-cop?

 

@DICE please ask

 

Is the DOC town

Is the Cop town

Is the TRACKER town

Is the ORACLE town

Is the INNOCENT CHILD town

 

 

I know these seems redundant, but please report back your answers for each as this is important.

 

Dice, do ask those questions, but do NOT share the answers with us. The maffia doesn't need to know what roles the town has access to.

[dicetosser1]

and yet you want to keep a role around that can potentially hurt town csarmi?

[csarmi]

As soon as you catch someone on a lie on this, do come out with the answers tho.

[berf]

@DICE - Well your Lover lied to you about being the/a Coroner. What did you did you do about this?

 

 

@CS - Fair enough I can see how you can see what you do, but do you honestly believe the randomness introduced by Mish' role could be beneficial to town?

 

 

At this stage, the flip itself will be revealing regardless. I am suspecting bussed mafia by mafia. 

[dicetosser1]

umm berf  did you see my big reveal?  that was in response to me thinking my lover was not town.

 

I have only found out the coroner question tonight and told you all

[Pralaya]

 

1st - indicates that he has only seen the claim, and not the NOT TOWN reveal by dice.

 

Yeah, well.Thread moving quite fast and came across it after I posted.

 

She could be third party, I think.

 

She also said that she affects only pr and the mafia is already one down. That means the probability of her blocking town is pretty high.

 

unvote vote mish

[csarmi]

and yet you want to keep a role around that can potentially hurt town csarmi?

 

We need to make a cost-benefit analysis on that.

 

Is wasting a lynch on a survivor a lesser evil than keeping the clumsy switch around?

 

As currently I believe that the clumsy switch role can hurt maffia more than town, I'd say that yea, I think we should keep pressuring Cloud (and others).

We can always go back to Mish as a potential safe lynch.

 

Not to mention the fact that it's a safe shot for the Vig too!

 

In fact, if I wanted Mish dead, I'd lynch someone I think town and have our Vig shot her at night.

[dicetosser1]

youd lynch someone you think TOWN?????

[csarmi]

TL;DR:

 

1) Wait for Mish to claim and everyone add their thoughts

2) If she claims 3rd party and don't get cc'd and we still want her gone, I'd rather have her shot by Vig.

[csarmi]

youd lynch someone you think TOWN?????

 

nope, that's a typo - I'd lynch someone I'd think scum

[Ithillian Turambar]

CSarmi = Mafia = God = mish team mate

[csarmi]

 

@CS reading now, I do recall your link-filled post though. Will get there when I get there.

That was just a list of statements that didn't really say anything but looked like thet did. It was quite clever really lol.

 

 

That was the list of my full notes on Cloud. It says more to me than you (it's in raw format), but I think the comments say a lot.

I didn't have time to turn it into a full case yesterday (been out most of the day) and now I'm working.

[dicetosser1]

im betting Ithi's side regarding Csarmi. and i will raise her praya

[Pralaya]

As currently I believe that the clumsy switch role can hurt maffia more than town, I'd say that yea, I think we should keep pressuring Cloud (and others).

We can always go back to Mish as a potential safe lynch.

 

Normally, it could be. But the mafia is already one PR down. So, she is most likely to affect town now.

[csarmi]

 

As currently I believe that the clumsy switch role can hurt maffia more than town, I'd say that yea, I think we should keep pressuring Cloud (and others).

We can always go back to Mish as a potential safe lynch.

Normally, it could be. But the mafia is already one PR down. So, she is most likely to affect town now.

 

 

The main point is that the maffia is likely to be stocked up with PR's and they would be trying to use their synergy, while town would be using their roles independently.

Disrupting maffia actions randomly may be very useful. Right now I'm betting that the random disrupting of actions might hurt maffia more.

 

Can I be wrong? Yes. But note that we don't have a clue what roles the maffia have.

 

Also, please note that this is the scenario when Mish is telling the truth - if she's lying, she'll be caught very fast.

[berf]

Got it:

 

 

Thorum shoots Mish tonight.

[berf]

Continue with this cloud business then if you will - which will may or may not be telling. The reread continues. 

 

Leaning town on cloud so far.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Actions happen all at the same time. She could still block me even if she got shot later tonight.

 

She has a terribly negative Role. She isn't Town.

 

We need to remove her ... and who said anything about her being a survivor that wins with Town. 3rd Party is 3RD PARTY.

 

They win with themselves.

 

I think that she will turn out to be the Mafia Blocker who doesn't exist according to Dice. They don't want her Lynched and are pushing the 3rd party thing so she can pop up and say yes she is actually 3rd party.

 

Because the house of cards is all about to fall apart.

 

ALL IN ALL IN ALL IN!