Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[csarmi]

Until later - unless they have something other than a Blocker, or they do have a Blocker and Dice is part of all of this.

 

But then I think about Dice and say hmmmmmm if I had a plot that required someone to be really focal and involved who would I choose to front it? And I would not choose Dice lol.

Agree with the bolded. I've played a few times with Dice and he's very good at endgames and quite good at hiding as maffia.

I'd add that I find Dice much more lurky when playing scum. He has a pretty high postcount around here. I can't see what his plot could be either - I just don't see how this would be worth the risk.

Also, his role makes a lot of sense to me - basically, I see it as a way our mod gives us the setup, making this an open setup

 

This makes me believe that Dice is telling the truth.

 

I'm working on putting Dice's claims together to have a full view.

Right now, what I can recall is that the game is supposed to have 4 titans (all town), 4 scum gods, 1 confirmed town god (Hallia), 1 named townie god (name: "the other God who isn't scum").

[csarmi]

Wait, that isn't right. It's possible that we have a single 3rd party God. So that's not exactly a named townie (technically speaking).

 

Ithi's claim is very solid in any case.

[csarmi]

• Ithillian 120
• csarmi 112
• Thorum 101
• Despothera 98
• dicetosser1 66
• WWWwombat 59
• _CLOUD 52
• ineedfourberfs 49
• Darthe 36
• ReleaseTheEvil 29
• Misheru Sedai 20
• TinaHel 18
• Basel Gill 13
• Hallia 13
• Pralaya 6
• Krakalakachkn 5
• mcs0083 5
• Song of Ice and Fire 2

 

Post Count for D1. Pralaya, Krak and Song are very low. No wonder I couldn't even remember they were in the game.

[Thorum]

I did as I said I would. As I will be doing all Game.

Someone go back and find out who was believeing despo the most - especially the person who said he knew which character Despo was pretending to be and that we should definitely be believing him - there's something about the secret weapon he had.

Mscsarmi is dodgy as owt.

Cloud is ridiculously Mafia

Tina should not be trusted

Trust your feelings - don't be led astray.

Thorum ... Was the last mafia left alive in the last game he played because everyone disregard the crazy things he said.

You think I'm mafia after what I did yesterday? That would make me the worst mafia ever.

 

One character fits perfectly. Mine.

 

Agree on cloud

[Ithillian Turambar]

@Ithi - the train started on you some 6h before the deadline bothers me. Doesn't it bother you?

It was started by Tina - who had been building up to it earlier on in the Game and then Despo who was Mafia.

 

Why are you troubled by it?

 

Thorum - what did you do previously that would make you the worst Mafia ever?

[Thorum]

Counterclaim against a mafia with a non-optimal role.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Also ... I thought it was Dice who said we should totally believe whatever Despo said.

 

That's one of the reasons I am troubled by him.

 

Part of me thinks its a made up plot. Despo's plan was exactly what I said it was and I don't have a good feeling about Dice because he was so keen to believe Despo.

 

But would a Mafia know the set up?

 

Tbh - with 4 alleged Titan Towns, Hallia, Me and possibly Dice >.> We have around 7 confirmed ish town

 

15 left now ... One possible death tonight or maybe more if the vig shoots.

 

Tbh it might have been better to get the Titans out in the open so that they weren't shot by accident.

[Thorum]

Don't be too sure you`re confirmed either... That role`s too valuable to counterclaim day 1.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Counterclaim against a mafia with a non-optimal role.

Despo wasn't the vig. You might not be the vig either. It could be a set up to make it seem like you are confirmed when they knew it was likely Despo was going to be lynched.

 

For all I know the real vig is someone else ... In fact for all I know there isn't a vig at all.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Don't be too sure you`re confirmed either... That role`s too valuable to counterclaim day 1.

Because I would have claimed it with two votes ... When one of the voters was a Mafia who was trying to get me Lynched?

 

Dear me.

[michellem]

Well that's easy to find out; if there is two kills one night, we have a vig (or a SK). Speaking of, Dice, maybe ask if the third party if survivor or serial killer?

 

 

I had completly forgotten Song was in this.

[michellem]

*if the third party IS

[csarmi]

 

@Ithi - the train started on you some 6h before the deadline bothers me. Doesn't it bother you?

It was started by Tina - who had been building up to it earlier on in the Game and then Despo who was Mafia.

 

Why are you troubled by it?

 

Thorum - what did you do previously that would make you the worst Mafia ever?

 

 

Actually, it was continued by Wombat (making it a serious idea).

It troubles me because 7h before dealine sounds too late into the day.

 

Even if it didn't prevent the Despo lynch, it made you claim.

[csarmi]

Well that's easy to find out; if there is two kills one night, we have a vig (or a SK). Speaking of, Dice, maybe ask if the third party if survivor or serial killer?

 

 

I had completly forgotten Song was in this.

 

Dice said there was 3rd party and no SK.

[csarmi]

Also ... I thought it was Dice who said we should totally believe whatever Despo said.

 

That's one of the reasons I am troubled by him.

 

Part of me thinks its a made up plot. Despo's plan was exactly what I said it was and I don't have a good feeling about Dice because he was so keen to believe Despo.

 

But would a Mafia know the set up?

 

Tbh - with 4 alleged Titan Towns, Hallia, Me and possibly Dice >.> We have around 7 confirmed ish town

 

15 left now ... One possible death tonight or maybe more if the vig shoots.

 

Tbh it might have been better to get the Titans out in the open so that they weren't shot by accident.

 

Brown: no we don't. Four players are too many to check. Quite easy to claim Titan as maffia.

Navy: we've been through this. Would you have us give the maffia a full map on townies just because a Vig might shoot wrong?

[michellem]

 

Well that's easy to find out; if there is two kills one night, we have a vig (or a SK). Speaking of, Dice, maybe ask if the third party if survivor or serial killer?

 

 

I had completly forgotten Song was in this.

 

Dice said there was 3rd party and no SK.

 

 

Right, well in that case, the third party is probably a survivor, and if there's extra kills, we know we have a vig. I really like Dice's role

[WWWwombat]

1. Dice said there is a vig.

2. Dice said there is no SK (doesn't rule out other anti-town 3rd parties though)

3. I voted Ithi 9 hours before deadline, not 7, and that was because I figured the Despo situation could be resolved by the real vig if he was lying. Csarmi trying to heap blame for outing Ithi on me is sketch.

[csarmi]

3. I voted Ithi 9 hours before deadline, not 7, and that was because I figured the Despo situation could be resolved by the real vig if he was lying. Csarmi trying to heap blame for outing Ithi on me is sketch.

 

Fair enough.

[csarmi]

Someone false claiming Vig is likely to get vig shot indeed. Somethign that crossed my mind too.

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

Also ... I thought it was Dice who said we should totally believe whatever Despo said.

 

That's one of the reasons I am troubled by him.

 

Part of me thinks its a made up plot. Despo's plan was exactly what I said it was and I don't have a good feeling about Dice because he was so keen to believe Despo.

 

But would a Mafia know the set up?

 

Tbh - with 4 alleged Titan Towns, Hallia, Me and possibly Dice >.> We have around 7 confirmed ish town

 

15 left now ... One possible death tonight or maybe more if the vig shoots.

 

Tbh it might have been better to get the Titans out in the open so that they weren't shot by accident.

Brown: no we don't. Four players are too many to check. Quite easy to claim Titan as maffia.

Navy: we've been through this. Would you have us give the maffia a full map on townies just because a Vig might shoot wrong?

 

I'm pretty sure the Mafia already know who the majority of the Town are.

[csarmi]

Ithi, you're missing the point entirely.

 

Why would you like us to tell the maffia who has what race?

[csarmi]

Cause it sure don't help vetting players.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Ithi, you're missing the point entirely.

 

Why would you like us to tell the maffia who has what race?

Did Dice say anything about whether they were vanilla or Roled?

 

And I love how you think I want to tell the Mafia. I want Town to share useful information.

 

Again - Mafia already know who is Town - apart from this possible 3rd party. They know Hallia is confirmed Town. They know I'm the Doc, they know Dice has claimed oracle lover and thorum has claimed Vig.

 

What would knowing our races actually give to the mafia? Apart from nowhere to hide.

 

It's because you're a God and Mafia isn't it?

 

Or you're a Titan and MCS didn't know the difference lol

[csarmi]

Ithi, the point you're missing is this:

 

If Dice claims are true, then the town looks like this:

 

11 town players (assuming a survivor)

2 gods: 1 of them is Hally (confirmed, the other was claimed by you)

4 titans

5 others 

 

Now tell me, how does it help us to know whether someone is a Titan or not? What sort of extra information does that hold that would help town?

[Ithillian Turambar]

And there's no blame to be had really.

 

I chose to reveal rather than have the despo Lynch stall.

 

And now I either die or I don't. Mafia Games don't need a bunch of roles for Town to win. I'm just one person so whatever. I felt like claiming from the off to be honest just so I could sledgehammer folks and not care that they would say oooooh that Ithi is SO Mafia lol