Enter the Dragon Mafia [Basic] D5: Town Wins!!

[Tsukibana]

that assumes he survives. Hallia put herself out there.

[csarmi]

I still think it's better to lynch Tsuki. Testing a cop claim by lynching is not very efficient.

[csarmi]

[i mean testing a cop claim by lynching the claimant]

[Tsukibana]

Dice's claim makes the assumption that there is a Roleblocker on the the Scum side. Not only did

he not volunteer new info, but he hinted at a power role for the scum. I would have to ask

if that is a Basic role? I'm definitely leaning towards Dice, though.

I don't think that a cop should be so lurky, but then again, I could be wrong.

Deadline in three hours.

[michellem]

In my experience, it's quite common in basic games with a cop, a doc, a godfather and a roleblocker. Not all games contain all of course; but they're all considered basic roles. Wich Dice would know very well.

[csarmi]

Basic roles

 

As far as I know, basic games usually have the 'very common roles' and maybe 1-2 less common ones. Also the roles are usually the same as on maffiascum (with slight variation). Roleblocker is listed as a very common role tere.

[csarmi]

I might be viewing this game too mathematically...

 

Well, you see, I'm about 95% sure that Dice is scum. 5% that he's a cop too. Make that 1% if you wish...

 

If we lynch him, and he flips maffia we'll be at the same place (except that then you can trust me more) - not much extra information gained.

 

If we lynch someone else, however, we gain info where we had none (just speculation).

 

----------------------------------------------------------------------

 

See my point?

[Tsukibana]

I thought so. So his claim of a roleblocker stopping him means nothing.

 

I don't like voting for a potential cop, either, but he's been too inactive, and his claim

doesn't ring true. I don't think TG would have put 2 cops in the same game.

He gave no new info.

VOTE DICE

 

Of course, Tigs was inactive too, but CS's questions at dice for what type of cop dice was seem 

accurate.

[Tsukibana]

Too true, mate, but I'm not self-voting, LOL.

And unfortunately, I'm not so confident about Mish anymore, and I really think we need the lynch.

[Tsukibana]

To whit: self-voting killed Rand.

[Tsukibana]

We could mass role reveal. Already have the important roles out in the open.

What would be the benefit?

[csarmi]

Also, that's me and I know for SURE that I'm telling the truth. You can't even be sure of that. So why risk?

[csarmi]

Can we has a votecount?

[Tsukibana]

Call it gut, call it inexperience. I don't like his reveal, the method of the reveal, the fact that he had no new info,

the inactivity, the probability of two cops is nil, the fact that he only revealed under suspcion.

Hally revealed to save (Dap and) Peace...

 

Damn it... UNVOTE

 

good at making me second guess myself, aren't you?

[Tyler Glembo]

CURRENT VOTE COUNT

 

RTE(1) - Tiinker

Dice (5) - RTE, Nolder, Darthe, Dap, Mish

Tsuki (1) - CSarmi

 

Not Voting (5): Dice, Tsuki, Millon, Hallia, Peace, 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch 

 

Deadline

: The Deadline will be Tuesday at Noon EST (US). Countdown: http://www.timeandda...on Mafia: Day 3

[Tsukibana]

Dice could have only revealed under the circumstances in which he did.

Until under suspicion, he was free to move about, casing. he couldn't have revealed sooner,

especially if he was already RBed once. He'd never get a read again, and won't.

Poor Hallia... I'd hate to try to figure who to protect tonight!!

[Tyler Glembo]

I'll be gone for the next hour and a half at least...should be back in time for Deadline.

[csarmi]

Tiink, Peace, others: what do you guys think?

 

With 2 hours left we don't have much choice btw. We don't have anyone else we can lynch. I believe that lynching Dice is better than no lynch, and now there don't seem to be any runners-up.

 

I'm gonna unvote[/red] now, and I'm going to vote Dice in 30 minutes if no other sensible lynch comes up.

[csarmi]

unvote

[peacesells]

If there is a roleblocker out there...it doesn't matter who Hallia protects.  Csarmi will be dead and then Hallia the next night.

 

I'll hammer Dice.

[csarmi]

Vote Dice

[Tiinker]

I'm around to hammer too. unvote

[peacesells]

we have an hour and a half. 

[Hallia]

I don't like the idea of a dice vote, he claimed cop, and I'm pretty leery of that whole can of tuna.

[peacesells]

I don't like the idea of a dice vote, he claimed cop, and I'm pretty leery of that whole can of tuna.

 

What are your thoughts on his investigations?