Enter the Dragon Mafia [Basic] D5: Town Wins!!

[peacesells]

Maybe Mish.

[dapianoplay3r]

its actually your second 2) but i know what you meant

 

i believe you more than dice actually. He did claim to of viewed already confirmed people

[Tiinker]

I believe Mish because what she said about her PM is pretty much identical to the stuff I got and I'm vanilla town & Lee.

[Tiinker]

I'd be alright with votes on Millon or possibly Noldor. I've been holding off voting him because he's actually active.

[Tsukibana]

Question: dice claims he was roleblocked, and CS claims 3 shots, with one left.

If dice is right, and there is an RB for the scum, what happens if he (the RB) blocks CS tonight?

Would his shot be wasted? Also, can a 3 shot submit no NA and shoot on any night he wants, or does it have to be first three nights?

[dapianoplay3r]

If dice is telling the truth Csarmi is probably lying and not a cop

 

Normally the shot would be considered wasted, its the way most Mods do it

 

he can choose any 3 nights normally as well

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I told you guys. Really need to get your scum hunting back on track Dap.

 

I think Mish and Tsuki are town as I suggested. My vote stays on Dice as I know with certainty that at least one of csarmi's reads is accurate.

[Tsukibana]

Could BOTH be cops? Not one full, one 3 shot, but two 3 shot? is that balanced, or way over-powered (the potential for 7 confirmed town on day 2, with

no overlap between Doc and cops)?!? just typing that tells me it's OP as hell :)

Who's lying just became the question of the day.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I am suspicious of Nolder as well though. More gut feeling there though.

[csarmi]

Tsuki, I'll ask TG about the RB.

 

I think I can use my 3 shots any night (I didn't ask TG directly about this).

I have no doubts that it was a good idea to use those 2 shots. The idea was that the sooner I got the results, the better. As for the 3rd shot, I'll think about it, but I don't see any reason not to use it.

[Tsukibana]

Actually would me 9 town, counting 2 cops, 1 doc, and 6 targeted town... No way.

 

RTE says that CS is telling the truth, but that's because CS claimed to have cleared him.

Seems... team-ish, if you ask me.

[csarmi]

Well, in fact, I did claim that Player, RTE and me are on the same team. Town.

 

While I know that we are, they can't be sure, however.

[Tsukibana]

RTE might have been talking about your read on Player as the confirmed one... Not as team-ish, guess.

Dice reveals, gives no new info.

CS reveals, gives one new name.

 

I could see a scenario for CS's claim being false, covering RTE, and giving a scum a place to hide, especially

since we can almost guarantee that either the cop or the doc dies tonight (50/50 on an actual death, though.)

 

Also, CS, you claimed to have voted Dice, yet my name is the last vote you made. You explained your (non) vote on DIce,

wanna explain the actual vote against me?

[csarmi]

I voted Dice. He claimed cop. I unvoted and voted you.

 

I unvoted him, because I couldn't be 100% sure that he was lying (and I still can't be).

 

Why vote you? 

 

Well, at that point I didn't really have much of a choice (I know that RTE is town) for a lynch candidate. In my experience, DM is not the place where you can start a new train 5 hours before deadline.

 

I also believe that lynching you is a good shot. I think you might be scum. I also think that lynching you should give us a lot of information, even if you aren't.

 

I strongly believe that we DO need to lynch (explained it earlier).

[csarmi]

I voted Dice in post: #581

[Tsukibana]

A lynch is good, but do you really believe TWO cops in one game? A BASIC game at that.

See the earlier posts by me - that is the potential for 9 confirmed town at the beginning of Day 3.

In a game of 13?? Scum wouldn't stand a chance. I can't see TG doing that.

One of you is lying. 

[Tsukibana]

You are correct, sir. I thought you referring to your most recent vote.

[peacesells]

A lynch is good, but do you really believe TWO cops in one game? A BASIC game at that.

See the earlier posts by me - that is the potential for 9 confirmed town at the beginning of Day 3.

In a game of 13?? Scum wouldn't stand a chance. I can't see TG doing that.

One of you is lying. 

 

If they are both N-shot...maybe.  That's the hitch.

[Tiinker]

If Dice is an N-Shot cop then sh*t he should've said so. I can't imagine he's a naive cop or any other cop variation. This is supposed to be a basic game.

[Tsukibana]

even with two 3-shot, the potential for 9 on Day 3 is there. To me, there is no hitch.

Dice's post is suspicious, because he contributed nothing new.

CS is suspicious, because he claims that Tigs investigated one known, and then

cleared someone under suspicion.

[csarmi]

I find it almost impossible that Dice is a full cop.

I find it very unlikely that there are two cops in this game. 

 

I do believe, however, that we can't be 100% sure at this point.

[Tiinker]

We could mass role reveal. Already have the important roles out in the open.

[Tsukibana]

I do believe that your lack of "being sure" fails to hold to Occam's Razor.

I DO NOT believe that TG would have made the game so one-sided.

[michellem]

I'm more tempted to believe Csarmi at this point. Like someone mentioned; he provides a new name. When fakeclaiming, you almost always want to go with people you are sure of.

 

unvote vote Dice

 

 

Csarmi, I'll suggest you view either me or Tsuki next time.

[csarmi]

Tsuki, what do you suggest we do then? Lynch Dice?

 

Mish, suggestion noted.