[Basic] Jaws: Game Over - Town Wins

[csarmi]

Back to csarmi again, why paint Darthe as fishing now that Peace has already revealed. Peace gave a good response of why he doesn't want to share his results and Darthe didn't push it.

 

How was he fishing at this point in the game?

 

He asked for results in the first place. You don'T nudge the cop.

[csarmi]

Also that was Ishy I was talking about, not Darthe?

[bgrishinko]

Did I say Darthe? I meant Ishy. Darthe is dead. lol

[peacesells]

 

Back to csarmi again, why paint Darthe as fishing now that Peace has already revealed. Peace gave a good response of why he doesn't want to share his results and Darthe didn't push it.

 

How was he fishing at this point in the game?

 

He asked for results in the first place. You don'T nudge the cop.

 

Csarmi is quite correct here.  Why are you guys pushing this angle.

 

So with this being correct is Ishy now a bit scummy for that push before I posted?

[John E. Kelley]

So with this being correct is Ishy now a bit scummy for that push before I posted?

So to recap, you claim Cop, with no prodding whatsoever. And I merely wonder at the beginning of the new day whether or not you found scum....and that makes me scummy?

 

You people are idiots.

[csarmi]

 

So with this being correct is Ishy now a bit scummy for that push before I posted?

So to recap, you claim Cop, with no prodding whatsoever. And I merely wonder at the beginning of the new day whether or not you found scum....and that makes me scummy?

 

You people are idiots.

 

 

Yea it does.

 

-- an idiot

[peacesells]

 

So with this being correct is Ishy now a bit scummy for that push before I posted?

So to recap, you claim Cop, with no prodding whatsoever. And I merely wonder at the beginning of the new day whether or not you found scum....and that makes me scummy?

 

You people are idiots.

 

 

You need to re-read my question and rethink who you are calling an idiot because your grasp of the language is suspect.

 

I was asking those who claimed that you had not looked for a result before I posted have changed their view once their incorrectness was pointed out.

 

And..what an emotional response. 

[Lenlo]

so will you atleast post something useful?

Hows this?

 

So I went back and reread the entire game to catch up and get a good head for this. It seems to me that the scum killed Hallia because she was an easy pick. She hadnt much interacted with people in a game way so this makes me think that we have an experienced scum team or atleast one experienced player on said team ((Could have been Dap.)). I also noticed that while Chuckles has alot of posts most of them are pictures, not part of the game or just one line posts asking people for things. No real cases or opinions from him that stood out to me as putting himself out there.

 

Now Dap bugging us/agreeing with Ishy on Rand not being around much ((Not that can talk.)) also stood out to me. It felt like distancing from an afk team mate or leading to an afk teammate getting lynched to score some town cred. With Ishy questioning the cop though... that feels towny to me. I have done it more than once myself and I think that town is much more likely to question a freebee than scum who would just want to fit in but whats hanging me up on this is that it wasnt an AFK teammate that Peace found, it was Dap who was very active and a very big part of the scum team I feel. I am very conflicted on Ishy.

 

Heres a full player list:

 

 

3. Peace - Cop

5. Vam - Not much

7. Lenlo - Town

8. Rand - Possible Mafia

9. BG - Not much

10. CS - Not much

12. Chuckles - Mafia

13. Ishy - Conflicted

 

Now I think that we are looking at a 3 man scum team in this game cause with 13 players any more is to much imo. With Dap gone I say that leaves us down to 2 and my best pick for those are Chuckles and Rand, though as I said I am conflicted on Ishy.

[peacesells]

I like that post.

[bgrishinko]

Seems well thought out.

[csarmi]

Posting preferences sounds like a good idea.

 

I think Ishy is Maffia. Chuckles is a close second on that list.

 

I have no read on Vam or BG, But BG bugs me. However, he seems to bug me in every single game lately...

 

Lenlo and Rand reads town to me.

[peacesells]

how does Rand read as town to you?

[John E. Kelley]

Posting preferences sounds like a good idea. I think Ishy is Maffia. Chuckles is a close second on that list.I have no read on Vam or BG, But BG bugs me. However, he seems to bug me in every single game lately... Lenlo and Rand reads town to me.

Reason being......?

[bgrishinko]

Difference between CS and Lenlo's post is explanation and we'll thought out thinking. CS, please provide reasons.

[csarmi]

Rand is just way too inactive. If he was scum, I think he would try and make at least a minimal effort.

 

As for Ishy, almost every post of him yells 'scum' at me. I suck at cases but my instinct is usually quite good.

[John E. Kelley]

Rand is just way too inactive. If he was scum, I think he would try and make at least a minimal effort.As for Ishy, almost every post of him yells 'scum' at me. I suck at cases but my instinct is usually quite good.

Guess you'll have to lynch me to find out. Peace nailed scum for us already, so if there was a time to test someone, now would be it. Come on then.

[csarmi]

He can also view either of us. I'm getting more and more comfortable that we'll win this game.

[John E. Kelley]

He can also view either of us. I'm getting more and more comfortable that we'll win this game.

I'd rather not direct the Cop's viewings though. If he were to view me, well and good, it will only vindicate me, but the WIFOM generated for the scum team by Peace keeping his viewings a secret, at least beforehand, is too valuable to lose.

[csarmi]

True, the thing now is to scumhunt and let Peace do his work. The more of it is obscured, the better. Ideally, he'll have to find more townies he can confirm AND make sure the maffia don't target them.

 

I'm pretty sure he knows his job very well.

[csarmi]

He can also view either of us. I'm getting more and more comfortable that we'll win this game.

Note: I'm not trying to direct the Cop here, sorry if I gave that impression.

[lolguy26]

you guys do remember that rand did ask to be replaced right.....

 

@len: your saying that im scum because ive been spamming and havent cased anyone yet?

               (in essence posting almost nothing useful?)

[csarmi]

Yes, he's been inactive, asked for replacement, then went even more inactive.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Mod Announcement: Darthe 2.0 will be replacing Rand effective immediately. Red will update the first post asap. Any votes against Rand (if there were any) have been reset. I will now post a VC.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Deadline:   Thursday May 9th @ 12pm CST or when hammer has been reached.  8 alive, 5 to hammer

 

Vote Count

 

Lenlo (1): Chuckles

 

BG (1): Ishy

 

Ishy (1): CS

 

No vote: Lenlo, Vam, Peace, Rand Darthe 2.0, BG

 

Shark fact: Sharks that eat their siblings' eggs in the womb aren't vicious. They're just seeking out nutrients to sustain themselves as they grow.

[lolguy26]

welcome back darthe