[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

ed2funy · April 5, 2013

Peace, no offense, but your post doesn't make sense.

In my eyes, Boo, AVM, nor Verb are confirmed in any way.

In everyone's eyes, I'm sure I am not confirmed to them.

peacesells · April 5, 2013

it makes sense cause the reporters can be dealt with last.

peacesells · April 5, 2013

it's just a numbers game at this point.

BooBoo · April 5, 2013

Boo...why aren't you voting Lenlo?

Why should I?

I think at this point Ape has successfully accused every player in the game as being scum. *round of applause for Ape*

This is what the Ape does. And then he will eventually say, see I told you! And then gives us a 100 reasons why he didnt actually stay put on said player. We've also collectively hit 167 scum tells of his, yet all he's done is lead lynches on townies. This is where, "get behind the Ape" comes from. He's the scum MVP and literally decimates the town.

Anywho, I think you should die. <3

John McClane · April 5, 2013

@ peacesells - why don't you make a case on someone, rather than grill me for information. Me holding off blurting everything out is good for town, it won't be lost with my death. So move past it and focus on scum hunting. All you are doing now as pressing me for info, and making yourself look suspect.
I'm about as concerned with looking suspect as you are with town winning this game(sarcasm). Did you even bother reading my post. This game can be wrapped up by tomorrow or the next day.

Dude, stop role fishing. Make a case, if we run up someone I can vet, I'll vouch for them when they reveal. It's more informative to hold the information back.

This is the most significant effort you've put into the game so far, making the appeal for why I should out townies unnecessarily.

You haven't made a case all game, have you? Why aren't you scum hunting? I'm not going to suddenly change my mind on this, so why are you pushing it so hard?

BooBoo · April 5, 2013

Peace, Kat, Leelou

Game over.

You're welcome.

- Batman

John McClane · April 5, 2013

Unvote

Vote Peace

Katiora · April 5, 2013

Ok and as for who to vote for.. OMG how many people can you go through in such a short time.

I do believe Ape and Boo's claims.

I think leading any kind of lynch against them would be pointless and counter productive. As far as tina is concerned, I'm not so sure about her role. I think she's got a good chance of being the SK. But maybe she is just a vigilante like she claims. I don't know enough about the character content to be sure of how her character is supposed to read.

Ed's claim... I don't get it either. I find it highly unlikely there are two town reporters. but who knows. I've been wrong LOTS before so there would be no surprise there.

Unless we can prove otherwise i think it would be wise to believe that pretty much all the claims in the paper are fairly accurate. So Verbal and AVM seem innocent until we can find further proof to steer us firmly one way or another.

That leaves us with Song/Turin, Peace, Leelou, Lenlo, Nolder, Tglems, Rand, Hybrid

So I have 4 that I feel comfortable as probably not bad guys: Boo(as much as i hate to say it because quite frankly you annoy the heck out of me), Ape, Verbal, and AVM

that leaves 11 (counting me) that we have no proof on, so far. Of these we can guess that there are probably at LEAST 4 mafia, maybe more. And at least 1 SK.

One of my doubts with tina is that the most kills we have had are 2. It is fairly clear that in the first post there seems to be 2 distinct "bad guys/groups" at least in my mind. If she's a vigilante why have their only been 2 deaths? if there are 3 groups who could kill (a vigilante, mafia, and sk), why was there only 1 death last night?

Of the others... Rand has been pretty quiet, as has hybrid. almost as if they're just trying to fly right under the radar, which makes me suspicious of them. Leelou is about the same. Song/Turin, hasn't been in the game enough to have any idea with. Lenlo looks fairly scummy, Peace, i don't know what to think of because all i can think is surely someone mafia would play so aggressively and attack the person who has claimed and been shown as cop. Tglems has had lots of observations and questions but has been quiet so far today, of course so have I up until now. I would say he's probably the least scummy of the quieter ones to me. And nolder... Lord who knows.. I can't make up my mind...

A lot of ya'lls attacking each other leads me to not know how to think about any of you. I know apparently it's how you scum hunt, but your attacking and defensiveness throws off my scum radar lol...

John McClane · April 5, 2013

Actually,

Unvote

Vote Leelou

Sheeping me all game.

peacesells · April 5, 2013

Actually Ape..I've made a case against Boo. But you don't care about the truth...you are just an ape in a china shop. You are more concerned with pulling off your own gambit than town winning this game.

The fact that you can't recognize this is a numbers game at this point shows how far you'll go to win only on your terms. Damn the torpedos...full ape ahead.

Hybrid · April 5, 2013

So, you liked my case on Tina, but you didn't vote her when I led off the day making it look like I had a guilty on her?

Scum would know I was bluffing, and know not to bite on it, scum would also help facilitate the Ed vs. Boooboo thing, which is what you were essentially doing by asking Booboo who he reported on last night.

Then you come back and nudge the Tina train by saying you like the case, you specifically say case, as if you subconsciously slipped in acknowledging you already knew I didn't have a guilty.

Unvote

Vote Hybrid

I've had a strong town read on you all game. Well played.

No, I just wanted to know whether or not I could trust you, since the second Reporter (ed) had had a truthful result. As an aside, as ed claimed Reporter, my read on Peace is no longer town. I thought he was the second Reporter.

I was second guessing myself a lot as I was tunneling on Ishy way too much D2. I had this ridiculous theory that the scum had a Reporter who could fake results and that you were fake-reported as Cop due to momentum shifting onto you during the Night. Utterly stupid in hindsight, but it made a lot more sense to me last night somehow.

And I said "case" specifically because you cased her.

peacesells · April 5, 2013

Nolder, Tglems, Rand...hiding all game. (Song/Turin too?)

Lenlo, Kat, Hybrid...hedging all game.

I'd say all the scum are in those 2 groups.

John McClane · April 5, 2013

One of my doubts with tina is that the most kills we have had are 2. It is fairly clear that in the first post there seems to be 2 distinct "bad guys/groups" at least in my mind. If she's a vigilante why have their only been 2 deaths? if there are 3 groups who could kill (a vigilante, mafia, and sk), why was there only 1 death last night?

My guess is that scum hit somebody who was protected. Me? ;)

Which is why peace role fishing is suspect. He wants to know who my deputy is? He wants to encourage scenarios where scum can narrow the pool of potential protective roles? That's why I'm being frenetic with my voting, which he also voiced displeasure with. I'm trying to create misdirection so that I'm not giving scum more information than I should about who they should be shooting at. He's looking for targets other than me... to take out whoever is protecting me, but I wonder has scum considered I might have a vest?

Hybrid · April 5, 2013

Vote Tglems

BooBoo · April 5, 2013

Ok and as for who to vote for.. OMG how many people can you go through in such a short time.

I do believe Ape and Boo's claims.

I think leading any kind of lynch against them would be pointless and counter productive. As far as tina is concerned, I'm not so sure about her role. I think she's got a good chance of being the SK. But maybe she is just a vigilante like she claims. I don't know enough about the character content to be sure of how her character is supposed to read.

Ed's claim... I don't get it either. I find it highly unlikely there are two town reporters. but who knows. I've been wrong LOTS before so there would be no surprise there.

Unless we can prove otherwise i think it would be wise to believe that pretty much all the claims in the paper are fairly accurate. So Verbal and AVM seem innocent until we can find further proof to steer us firmly one way or another.

That leaves us with Song/Turin, Peace, Leelou, Lenlo, Nolder, Tglems, Rand, Hybrid

So I have 4 that I feel comfortable as probably not bad guys: Boo(as much as i hate to say it because quite frankly you annoy the heck out of me), Ape, Verbal, and AVM

that leaves 11 (counting me) that we have no proof on, so far. Of these we can guess that there are probably at LEAST 4 mafia, maybe more. And at least 1 SK.

One of my doubts with tina is that the most kills we have had are 2. It is fairly clear that in the first post there seems to be 2 distinct "bad guys/groups" at least in my mind. If she's a vigilante why have their only been 2 deaths? if there are 3 groups who could kill (a vigilante, mafia, and sk), why was there only 1 death last night?

Of the others... Rand has been pretty quiet, as has hybrid. almost as if they're just trying to fly right under the radar, which makes me suspicious of them. Leelou is about the same. Song/Turin, hasn't been in the game enough to have any idea with. Lenlo looks fairly scummy, Peace, i don't know what to think of because all i can think is surely someone mafia would play so aggressively and attack the person who has claimed and been shown as cop. Tglems has had lots of observations and questions but has been quiet so far today, of course so have I up until now. I would say he's probably the least scummy of the quieter ones to me. And nolder... Lord who knows.. I can't make up my mind...

A lot of ya'lls attacking each other leads me to not know how to think about any of you. I know apparently it's how you scum hunt, but your attacking and defensiveness throws off my scum radar lol...

Plays the confused card wayyyyy too much. I'd lynch this one too in a heart beat.

BooBoo · April 5, 2013

Scum is so scared that I just nailed them all they wont even post.

///Batman'd

Leelou · April 5, 2013

Scum is so scared that I just nailed them all they wont even post.

///Batman'd

I'm not scum.

Niniel · April 5, 2013

Ok and as for who to vote for.. OMG how many people can you go through in such a short time.

I do believe Ape and Boo's claims.

I think leading any kind of lynch against them would be pointless and counter productive. As far as tina is concerned, I'm not so sure about her role. I think she's got a good chance of being the SK. But maybe she is just a vigilante like she claims. I don't know enough about the character content to be sure of how her character is supposed to read.

Ed's claim... I don't get it either. I find it highly unlikely there are two town reporters. but who knows. I've been wrong LOTS before so there would be no surprise there.

Unless we can prove otherwise i think it would be wise to believe that pretty much all the claims in the paper are fairly accurate. So Verbal and AVM seem innocent until we can find further proof to steer us firmly one way or another.

That leaves us with Song/Turin, Peace, Leelou, Lenlo, Nolder, Tglems, Rand, Hybrid

So I have 4 that I feel comfortable as probably not bad guys: Boo(as much as i hate to say it because quite frankly you annoy the heck out of me), Ape, Verbal, and AVM

that leaves 11 (counting me) that we have no proof on, so far. Of these we can guess that there are probably at LEAST 4 mafia, maybe more. And at least 1 SK.

One of my doubts with tina is that the most kills we have had are 2. It is fairly clear that in the first post there seems to be 2 distinct "bad guys/groups" at least in my mind. If she's a vigilante why have their only been 2 deaths? if there are 3 groups who could kill (a vigilante, mafia, and sk), why was there only 1 death last night?

Of the others... Rand has been pretty quiet, as has hybrid. almost as if they're just trying to fly right under the radar, which makes me suspicious of them. Leelou is about the same. Song/Turin, hasn't been in the game enough to have any idea with. Lenlo looks fairly scummy, Peace, i don't know what to think of because all i can think is surely someone mafia would play so aggressively and attack the person who has claimed and been shown as cop. Tglems has had lots of observations and questions but has been quiet so far today, of course so have I up until now. I would say he's probably the least scummy of the quieter ones to me. And nolder... Lord who knows.. I can't make up my mind...

A lot of ya'lls attacking each other leads me to not know how to think about any of you. I know apparently it's how you scum hunt, but your attacking and defensiveness throws off my scum radar lol...

lol

Vote Katiora

Katiora · April 5, 2013

I state the obvious and Tina doesn't like it and votes me

Vote TIna

This confirms my suspicions that tina is in fact the SK.

peacesells · April 5, 2013

meh...no one gets it.

I'll just work of the list of those I think the scum are hiding in.

VOTE LENLO

John McClane · April 5, 2013

meh...no one gets it.

I'll just work of the list of those I think the scum are hiding in.

VOTE LENLO

I get what you are saying, it's just not as simple as "just a numbers game".

You went about selling pragmatism the wrong way, if you are town, I do it all the time. It comes across like you want to know who the deputy is, who may have protected me if it wasn't me, etc.

There's absolutely no rush to get the information you are asking for out in the open. The ONLY people it serves well are scum. Period.

John McClane · April 5, 2013

Oh, and nice self-preservation down-shift... LOL

BooBoo · April 5, 2013

Scum is so scared that I just nailed them all they wont even post.

///Batman'd

I'm not scum.

^^^^^^^ scum

Ok and as for who to vote for.. OMG how many people can you go through in such a short time.

I do believe Ape and Boo's claims.

I think leading any kind of lynch against them would be pointless and counter productive. As far as tina is concerned, I'm not so sure about her role. I think she's got a good chance of being the SK. But maybe she is just a vigilante like she claims. I don't know enough about the character content to be sure of how her character is supposed to read.

Ed's claim... I don't get it either. I find it highly unlikely there are two town reporters. but who knows. I've been wrong LOTS before so there would be no surprise there.

Unless we can prove otherwise i think it would be wise to believe that pretty much all the claims in the paper are fairly accurate. So Verbal and AVM seem innocent until we can find further proof to steer us firmly one way or another.

That leaves us with Song/Turin, Peace, Leelou, Lenlo, Nolder, Tglems, Rand, Hybrid

So I have 4 that I feel comfortable as probably not bad guys: Boo(as much as i hate to say it because quite frankly you annoy the heck out of me), Ape, Verbal, and AVM

that leaves 11 (counting me) that we have no proof on, so far. Of these we can guess that there are probably at LEAST 4 mafia, maybe more. And at least 1 SK.

One of my doubts with tina is that the most kills we have had are 2. It is fairly clear that in the first post there seems to be 2 distinct "bad guys/groups" at least in my mind. If she's a vigilante why have their only been 2 deaths? if there are 3 groups who could kill (a vigilante, mafia, and sk), why was there only 1 death last night?

Of the others... Rand has been pretty quiet, as has hybrid. almost as if they're just trying to fly right under the radar, which makes me suspicious of them. Leelou is about the same. Song/Turin, hasn't been in the game enough to have any idea with. Lenlo looks fairly scummy, Peace, i don't know what to think of because all i can think is surely someone mafia would play so aggressively and attack the person who has claimed and been shown as cop. Tglems has had lots of observations and questions but has been quiet so far today, of course so have I up until now. I would say he's probably the least scummy of the quieter ones to me. And nolder... Lord who knows.. I can't make up my mind...

A lot of ya'lls attacking each other leads me to not know how to think about any of you. I know apparently it's how you scum hunt, but your attacking and defensiveness throws off my scum radar lol...

lol

Vote Katiora

lol

Unvote

Vote Katiora

John McClane · April 5, 2013

Hahahhaha... HAHAHHAHAHAAAA... I like.

peacesells · April 5, 2013

meh...no one gets it.

I'll just work of the list of those I think the scum are hiding in.

VOTE LENLO

I get what you are saying, it's just not as simple as "just a numbers game".

You went about selling pragmatism the wrong way, if you are town, I do it all the time. It comes across like you want to know who the deputy is, who may have protected me if it wasn't me, etc.

There's absolutely no rush to get the information you are asking for out in the open. The ONLY people it serves well are scum. Period.

I think you don't give my argument credit cause I've made it clear I believe your play has been horrible. You are holding a grudge. It's all part of your win with you gambit or dont win at all attitude.

[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook