[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

[Hybrid]

 

I had BooBoo at the top of my list but he gets a respite for now due to his reveal.

 

Revised list: Ishy, Nolder, Tglems, ed, Katiora in that order.

 

Vote Ishy

 

The bold are my top 3

Wanna sleep with me?

 

Vote Ed

 

[John Snow]

Boo(3): Peace, Verb, Vam

Ishy(5): Leelou, Nol, Hybrid, Tina, Rand

Vam(2): Ape, AVM

Ed(1): Boo

Kat(1): Ishy

 

Not voting:

TGlems, Song, Lenlo, Ed, Kat

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Deadline: http://www.timeandda...=Day 2 Deadline

 

This is noon on the 4th in Mountain Timezone. I also believe that's DM time.

[Nolder]

Hey I'm awake

Got a headache though so I'm not gonna promise I'm gonna stick around all morning

[Vambram]

It appears that everyone is believing Booboo's role and character claim as Bob, the Town Reporter. Obviously, if he is telling the truth, then he is not someone that we ought to take a chance with on the lynch. Half of those who were on the BooBoo lynch vote have unvoted him and cast their vote elsewhere. For now, I will believe his character and role claim.

 

I UNVOTE BOOBOO

 

Therefore, who will I cast my lynch vote on now? A re-read of the last few pages of this thread provided me a few posts by Ishy that I thought are very scummy. My previous reasons for voting on BooBoo now apply even more strongly upon Ishy. He has been very erratic and extremely defensive, in my opinion. I think that Ishy's behavior is scummy and that the part in the Rumors section of the paper was meant to try to throw suspicion off of Ishy. However, I am placing a major FOS on Ishy because I now believe that he is scum.

 

VOTE  ISHY 

[Nolder]

I won't concede to your point that I'm intentionally pushing Ishy further from priority #1? Bullspit.

Your posts say it all so I really don't have to. All anyone needs to do is reread.

Maybe like you said it isn't intentional but look at it FMPOV. All I see is what you're doing and I have to interpret the why as best I can.

1. I moved jif up, by doing it of course I acknowledge I did shifted my ranks.

 

2. I explained specifically why, so in doing that i also acknowledged it. Scum tell ranks higher than hunch.

Fair enough but it wouldn't explain why you went after Jif and baited him to drop metatells for you in the first place.

3. What if this was all a ruse to draw out scum? You've seen me do it before, its not, but could be... Why are acting like you are trying to blow it up? Or like you are scared to get caught in it.?

Why waste time pondering if it was if it wasn't?

And do I look like I'm scared to get caught in anything?

The best thing anyone can do when scum is stay miles away from you because you're a whirlwind of destruction.

And that's not meant to be a compliment. You eff up town just as often as scum when you get caught up in the moment.

Just because you keep saying I'm not acknowledging it, doesn't make it true. You are also dodging the questions I'm asking in return, and one could EASILY make the accusation that you are trying to buy jif time just like you are accusing me of doing for Ishy.

You know what that's a fair point to throw my way so fine. I just wouldn't play this way myself so I'm at a loss with what I see you doing.

If I think I have scum (Ishy) with a solid chance of lynching them I don't waste my time on another potential scum (Jif) and try to build their case. I get the first scum lynched first and then I move on to the next one.

How about answering some of my questions now?

Which ones?

[Nolder]

I'm gonna go with my friends cousin on a quick trip I guess I'll be back in ~ 2 hours or so

[John McClane]

It appears that everyone is believing Booboo's role and character claim as Bob, the Town Reporter. Obviously, if he is telling the truth, then he is not someone that we ought to take a chance with on the lynch. Half of those who were on the BooBoo lynch vote have unvoted him and cast their vote elsewhere. For now, I will believe his character and role claim.

 

I UNVOTE BOOBOO

 

Therefore, who will I cast my lynch vote on now? A re-read of the last few pages of this thread provided me a few posts by Ishy that I thought are very scummy. My previous reasons for voting on BooBoo now apply even more strongly upon Ishy. He has been very erratic and extremely defensive, in my opinion. I think that Ishy's behavior is scummy and that the part in the Rumors section of the paper was meant to try to throw suspicion off of Ishy. However, I am placing a major FOS on Ishy because I now believe that he is scum.

 

VOTE  ISHY 

 

 

Sheesh, I remember playing with you in teh past and you doing this captain obvious type of explaining. The problem I have with this post though, is in bold. 

 

What posts by Ishy did you think are very scummy? Be specific. You don't seem to be casing, you are echoing sentiment from the majority and casting your vote with them.

[John McClane]

 

I won't concede to your point that I'm intentionally pushing Ishy further from priority #1? Bullspit.

Your posts say it all so I really don't have to. All anyone needs to do is reread.

Maybe like you said it isn't intentional but look at it FMPOV. All I see is what you're doing and I have to interpret the why as best I can.

>1. I moved jif up, by doing it of course I acknowledge I did shifted my ranks.

 

2. I explained specifically why, so in doing that i also acknowledged it. Scum tell ranks higher than hunch.

Fair enough but it wouldn't explain why you went after Jif and baited him to drop metatells for you in the first place.

3. What if this was all a ruse to draw out scum? You've seen me do it before, its not, but could be... Why are acting like you are trying to blow it up? Or like you are scared to get caught in it.?

Why waste time pondering if it was if it wasn't?

And do I look like I'm scared to get caught in anything?

The best thing anyone can do when scum is stay miles away from you because you're a whirlwind of destruction.

And that's not meant to be a compliment. You eff up town just as often as scum when you get caught up in the moment.

Just because you keep saying I'm not acknowledging it, doesn't make it true. You are also dodging the questions I'm asking in return, and one could EASILY make the accusation that you are trying to buy jif time just like you are accusing me of doing for Ishy.

You know what that's a fair point to throw my way so fine. I just wouldn't play this way myself so I'm at a loss with what I see you doing.

If I think I have scum (Ishy) with a solid chance of lynching them I don't waste my time on another potential scum (Jif) and try to build their case. I get the first scum lynched first and then I move on to the next one.

How about answering some of my questions now?

Which ones?

 

 

 

You are going to have to get over the fact that you don't understand how I play, and that doesn't make me scum.

 

What questions did you not answer of mine? All the ones that ended with question marks, how about that? It's one thing to be a doosh, it's another to be purposefully evasive when asked questions. You are pissing me off, but I've still taken the time to try to address your concerns about my play. You have not done the same in kind.

[John E. Kelley]

Unvote. Vote Ishy.

 

I deserve it after the personal attack. Sorry.

[John McClane]

Also, Nolder part of why I approached yesterday the way I did was because we just had a scene where AVM and Ishy were put into a mod-created wifom. I figured they'd be the obvious lynch candidates. I also figured they'd be the subject of most, if not all, of the debating/casing. 

 

So, I wanted to make sure that with a deadline a couple days away I got in some scum hunting on other people on my list. The fact that you've over-subscribed to my FOS rankings, and my night time casing in such a black/white, serious way is alarming. You know I put a lot of litmus tests out there, to get and gauge reaction.

 

Now, do me a favor and try to reply to some of the questions I posed to you, eh?

[John McClane]

Unvote. Vote Ishy.

 

I deserve it after the personal attack. Sorry.

 

What is this crapola, and what personal attack?

[John McClane]

Unvote. Vote Ishy.

 

I deserve it after the personal attack. Sorry.

 

 

What are your thoughts on Vambram? The case on him, his vote on Booboo and now his echoing case/vote on you? Who are your top 3 right now?

[Katiora]

 

Unvote. Vote Ishy.

 

I deserve it after the personal attack. Sorry.

 

What is this crapola, and what personal attack?

 

 

I think this is the "go screw yourself" etc etc type stuff he posted... one thing, that kind of behavior might be common at JN but it is not very common and frowned upon here where we are PG-13 and are told to play nice together or get your spankings (and not in a good way lol)... "Personal attacks" here are frowned upon greatly by staff.. DM prides itself on at least TRYING to have a friendly and welcoming attitude. *takes off staff hat*

 

 

Though i have to say voting yourself in this situation is pointless... seems like he's trying to pull a 360 like boo did yesterday when he was almost lynched and everyone was voting him. I find this scummy enough to vote. Unless he can pull a role reveal out of his butt and make us believe it.. and that's not gonna happen

 

I vote Ishy

[Tyler Glembo]

Ishy, before getting hammered you should claim if you're going to.

[Katiora]

Heh all he needs to do now is start cussing us all out and then apologize and start speaking in poetry... 

[Tyler Glembo]

I'll bet Ishy's poetry is mind bogglingly beautifulimous.

[John E. Kelley]

I've already claimed. Twice. Stop skimming.

[Tyler Glembo]

Yes, that's right.  Sorry, I forgot.

[John Snow]

Official Vote Count:

 

Boo(2): Peace, Verb

Ishy(8): Leelou, Nol, Hybrid, Tina, Rand, Vam, Ishy, Kat

Vam(2): Ape, AVM

Ed(1): Boo

 

Not voting:

TGlems, Song, Lenlo, Ed

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Deadline: http://www.timeandda...=Day 2 Deadline

 

This is noon on the 4th in Mountain Timezone. I also believe that's DM time.

[John McClane]

Oh man, this totally screams Ishy throwing in the towel as scum, and Katiora coming in for the bus vote. Was that the hammer vote?

[John McClane]

[John McClane]

So, momentum turned to Vambram... and he came and voted Ishy, then Ishy threw in the towel, and then Katiora put Ish at L1.

 

Katiora, the same person it looked as though Ishy thought Tina had viewed. 

 

Can it all be this simple?

[Katiora]

Not a bus vote.. and not the hammer He still lacks one vote. When i asked for a VC earlier I did it because i didn't want to be the hammer or seen as a bus, but his stupidity has overwhelmed my desire not to look suspicious because I happened to vote towards the end, which btw, is normal for me. I like to hear all sides of the argument before just throwing my vote out there. 

[John McClane]

Ishy reluctant to help scum hunt at all on his way out. Instead contradictions one after another?

 

Unvote

 

[John McClane]

greatest animated gif i've ever found btw