[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

[John Snow]

@mod - How much more game must be played before you replace the completely inactive players? No-shows like that impact the game balance, inadvertently.

 

*facepalm*

yep, I'll get on it.

[BooBoo]

The town Doctor died?  Was he not protecting himself?  Weird.  We lost the watcher, and it happened to be everyone favorite for scum (not surprised, i can tell the talent level isnt very high) and the creepy dude that got lynched is now dead?  Was he not dead during the night phase so thats why the Doc died?  Was he able to use his power?  I'm confused.

 

And wtf is a Chicago Citizen?

[John McClane]

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

 

Never heard of this before, but Vote Ishy. I can't imagine both are town, and I'm getting strong town read on AVM. He's my dude, and I read him well.

[John E. Kelley]

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

  

Or perhaps both town and mafia have a basic "outer" role where both AVM and Ishy are town and have been outed.  

If anything, I'd think that the first would be more plausible. I can't fathom a scenario where scum would want two confirmed townies on day two through actions of their own. What possible purpose would it serve them to narrow the field and risk exposing themselves?

 

Neither could be true as well, it could just be a gameplay mechanic, though I find that less likely.

[BooBoo]

Vote AVM  

[John E. Kelley]

 

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

 

Never heard of this before, but Vote Ishy. I can't imagine both are town, and I'm getting strong town read on AVM. He's my dude, and I read him well.

I'll take one for the team, my play Day one certainly warrants it, no question. However, I assure you that whatever mechanic was used to reveal my name and role, revealed the truth.

[Katiora]

 

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

 

Never heard of this before, but Vote Ishy. I can't imagine both are town, and I'm getting strong town read on AVM. He's my dude, and I read him well.

 

I HAVE seen something like this before... on a Myndrunner game... where one person could reflect someone else's role if they were viewed... but that's the only time i've ever seen it... Personally I find it unlikely, though not impossible, that both are not only good but both are townies... But we could just be lucky. It'd be nice for once.... Really the only way to be sure would be to lynch them both and see if one ended up being a bad guy... lol but that isn't a great option. 

[BooBoo]

 

 

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

 

Never heard of this before, but Vote Ishy. I can't imagine both are town, and I'm getting strong town read on AVM. He's my dude, and I read him well.

I'll take one for the team, my play Day one certainly warrants it, no question. However, I assure you that whatever mechanic was used to reveal my name and role, revealed the truth.

 

Okay, then what is, a Chicago Citizen?

[ed2funy]

It's in the rumors sections, their not-dead flips, so do we take it with a grain of salt?

[BooBoo]

 

 

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

 

Never heard of this before, but Vote Ishy. I can't imagine both are town, and I'm getting strong town read on AVM. He's my dude, and I read him well.

 

I HAVE seen something like this before... on a Myndrunner game... where one person could reflect someone else's role if they were viewed... but that's the only time i've ever seen it... Personally I find it unlikely, though not impossible, that both are not only good but both are townies... But we could just be lucky. It'd be nice for once.... Really the only way to be sure would be to lynch them both and see if one ended up being a bad guy... lol but that isn't a great option. 

 

Why? 

[BooBoo]

It's in the rumors sections, their not-dead flips, so do we take it with a grain of salt?

 

As in the mod is just revealing bull shit for no reason?  

[Leelou]

 

 

Something akin to an innocent child role where town and mafia each have a public "outer" that can use the IC role on someone else that night.  If that is the case then one of Ishy and AVM is town and has been outed and one of them is scum and has been fake "outed".

 

Thoughts?

 

Never heard of this before, but Vote Ishy. I can't imagine both are town, and I'm getting strong town read on AVM. He's my dude, and I read him well.

I'll take one for the team, my play Day one certainly warrants it, no question. However, I assure you that whatever mechanic was used to reveal my name and role, revealed the truth.

 

Your game play D1 and this post feel scummy. I don't mind voting you. Vote Ishy

[Tyler Glembo]

Or, whoever is the town "outer", rather than claiming your role, just out the other person you didn't.  

 

E.G. Town watcher is player X and they outed AVM.  Tonight they "out" Ishy to see if Ishy gets a different rumor tomorrow.  This could potentially be used by mafia also, but it entirely depends on what their "outing" role is.

[John E. Kelley]

 

Okay, then what is, a Chicago Citizen?

This game's version of a vanilla townie. I have no power role.

[ed2funy]

Yea, definitely interested in what a Chicago Citizen is.

 

 

Without knowing everyone else's roles, it is hard to guage whether or not it is a role that outs other people on each side (i.e. one on the mafia, one town). If that is the case, whoever the town outter is needs to be careful.

It could be a host of other reasons that two people flipped, though. Some super awesome mega doubling splitter-redirector (totally using that in a bastard mod game one day). Anyways, I'm not so sure lynching either is smart at the moment.

 

There is still plenty of info from yesterday to go off of.

 

 

 

New Replies: Booboo, as in maybe there is a role on the mafia's side that provides public false-claims for townies. Or some crazy shit. Who knows. It's Mafia.

[ed2funy]

People need to stop replying so fast.

[Katiora]

Next, everyone flips to the rumor section. Could it really be true?

Is AVM truly Anna Ash, a Chicago Citizen?

And what about Ishmael? Could he really be Gentleman Johnny Marcone, a Chicago Citizen?

 

 

One thing on this.... If you look at the orange.. it doesn't say that they ARE this... it only suggests that they could be... so..... It's very possible that ed has a valid point with it being in the rumors...

 

 

And it's not a good idea Booboo because IF they do end up both being town then we have wasted 2 days killing off innocents while the mafia will probably be killing more at night. so we could have up to 4 innocent/good guy roles dead and be extremely outnumbered by the mafia very quickly if we just start killing off people who are possibly revealed by the mod. I think more thought should go into it than that. 

[Katiora]

People need to stop replying so fast.

and this^^^^^^^^^^

[Katiora]

Also another point.... if two innocents got night killed is it safe to say that there are 2 (groups of?) bad guys?? or is one a "good" guy vigilante that royally screwed up?

 

I do find the opening, now that i've reread it to mean possibly that there are 2 separate bad groups.    

 

 

As dawn rises on Chicago, the supernatural community rises from their beds. They know something is up. Word has been spreading. Something has come hunting in their city, and they will fight back will all they have.

Elsewhere, their enemies plot to destroy any opposition. They will kill any who stand in their way.

 

It is Dawn. Do Not Post.

 

 

The two "bads"??? Just a thought... 

[Leelou]

There could also be a SK. 

[peacesells]

Very cool Mr John Snow.  That a new twist to the game. 

 

 

Everyone is caught up on the rumor page but no one seems interested in the 2 deaths.  Mafia have 2 kills?  Sk out there or a Vig?

 

Some of you guys apparently don't believe what you read in the papers?  Voting Ishy and AVM right away.  Boo comes out with no real explanation once again...maybe we will get some more bravado from him instead of scum hunting.

 

VOTE BOO

 

Nothing he has done has changed my opinion on him.

[peacesells]

Well..of course the 2 very posts that nina me mention the 2 killings.

[peacesells]

nina = hot ninja

[AVM]

 

 

Okay, then what is, a Chicago Citizen?

This game's version of a vanilla townie. I have no power role.

 

Same, fwiw

[Katiora]

Well..of course the 2 very posts that nina me mention the 2 killings.

 

 

LOL! I IS NINJA!