BASE MAFIA - Mafia Wins!

[Tyler Glembo]

I'm hesitant to believe that Time is mafia, mainly because of how quiet she's been.  It seems to me that her teammates would be pushing her to be more active as she's been looked at.

 

I played a game where I was Mafia with Time.  She was equally quiet.  I don't think it's a scum tell, I think she is just busy IRL.

[lolguy26]

 

 

Well I saw ishy or mish, or maybe both of them and time is innocent :shrug:

So you read Mish, Time, Hallia, myself and you as Town?

Well actually when I was reading the thread ( afew days ago) I put myself in null cuz I wasn't posting much, but I'd say time and mish (and maybe you in one of their places) are my best thoughts for the remaining scum

[Hallia]

So if she turns out to be town, and you are as well CHuckles, then you think we should look towards Mish/Ishy?

[lolguy26]

Pretty much yeah

[wheeloftime13]

okay... home and will be posting my thoughts within the next 5 minutes or so...

[lolguy26]

Can't wait

[wheeloftime13]

 

I'm hesitant to believe that Time is mafia, mainly because of how quiet she's been.  It seems to me that her teammates would be pushing her to be more active as she's been looked at.

 

I played a game where I was Mafia with Time.  She was equally quiet.  I don't think it's a scum tell, I think she is just busy IRL.

 

ummm... i've only been mafia in one game... and that was the one where you were tracker...

[Tyler Glembo]

 

 

I'm hesitant to believe that Time is mafia, mainly because of how quiet she's been.  It seems to me that her teammates would be pushing her to be more active as she's been looked at.

 

I played a game where I was Mafia with Time.  She was equally quiet.  I don't think it's a scum tell, I think she is just busy IRL.

 

ummm... i've only been mafia in one game... and that was the one where you were tracker...

 

Am I off?  I thought you were mafia with me in the Percy Jackson game...or maybe we were framing you...hmm...whatever

[lolguy26]

Anyway I'm off to bed, cya in the morning (or not)

[wheeloftime13]

here it is: revisiting the

list... color code: dead town, dead mafia, people I think are town, town, unsure, people i think are the remaining mafia...

 

1. Hally (Mentored by Kaylee)- viewed by TG as town.... as
nobody has cc'd him, then Hallia is town

2. Mish- a little too buddy-buddy with Ishy for me... suspicious

3. Andrej - Town Vanilla Lynched Day 3.

4. Rand Ishy- rand's play has made me very
suspicious of him from the beginning, and his play with Mish is about as
buddy-buddy as she is with him…although I think Ishy is the more suspicious…

5. Chuckles- goes missing for a bit do to dm issues and school,
then comes back and just tells who he thinks is who without really saying
why... i don't like that.... then when asked why about something he says
"gut read".... proceeds to ask questions to people without really
saying anything himself, and then he posts unofficial vote counts, then
basically says he won't vote unless he absolutely has to (i.e. deadline)… then
later he catches up again and just asks questions without saying anything
himself and defends AJ (could be mafia trying to look town by defending a town
member because he knows how he’ll flip)… brings up that there might be a GF
even though it says in the OP that there are no other roles than 1 shot cop and
vig… later goes on to say he’s willing to lynch for info even though if he were
town, that’s not really the best idea right now because mafia would then be
starting to get even more of an advantage…

6. RTE - Town Vailla Lynched Day 2.n

7. TG- cop... viewed hallia

8. Snow - Town Vanilla Killed Night 2. 

9. WoT

10. Turin- killed Night 3
 

11. Peace - Mafia Member Killed Day 2.

12. Tiink - Town Vanilla Lynched Day 1.

13. LZM - Town Vanilla Killed Night 1.

 

14. Dap- still getting a town read…

[wheeloftime13]

sorry if the formatting is weird... i copied straight from my notes...

[Hallia]

Not bad at all, thanks for putting it out there!

[Lenlo]

Official Vote Count()

 

Chuckles(2/4): Mish, Hally

 

Not Voting(5/7):  Ishy, Chuckles, TG, WoT, Dap

 

 

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch!

 

Deadline is in 48 hours.

[Tyler Glembo]

vote Dap

 

Hokay, so...here is the earth...ROUND... 

 

After going back and looking at D1 interactions I think Dap and Peace are on a team.  They echo'd each other's words and thoughts on casing Tiink, Snow, and Rand/Ishy.  Dap hardcore buddied AJ and then distanced starting D2 and has looked like quite the scumhunter since, but those earlier interactions are really bothering me.  Also, he was casing quite a few people on D1 : RTE, Snow, Tiink, Turin, Rand.  He mentions others a few time but focuses on players we now know are town.

[wheeloftime13]

vote Chuckles

[Tyler Glembo]

EBWOP: Not that we know Rand/Ishy is town, he could be scum.  I'm saying Dap spent more time "scumhunting" players that have since flipped town.

[Tyler Glembo]

And if Dap is scum then WoT is his scummate.

[Tyler Glembo]

And, in case I'm completely wrong, then it would make sense for the other scum team to be Mish and lolguy.

[Hallia]

vote Dap

 

Hokay, so...here is the earth...ROUND... 

 

After going back and looking at D1 interactions I think Dap and Peace are on a team.  They echo'd each other's words and thoughts on casing Tiink, Snow, and Rand/Ishy.  Dap hardcore buddied AJ and then distanced starting D2 and has looked like quite the scumhunter since, but those earlier interactions are really bothering me.  Also, he was casing quite a few people on D1 : RTE, Snow, Tiink, Turin, Rand.  He mentions others a few time but focuses on players we now know are town.

 

o.o Oh my.  If Chuckles ends up getting lynched, and turns out town, I would def. say we should look at that.  You make some really good points.

[wheeloftime13]

And if Dap is scum then WoT is his scummate.

 

and why would that be??

[Tyler Glembo]

Based on your casings throughout the game

[Tyler Glembo]

Dap is the one person you have consistently steered clear of saying anything about other than that you have a town lean on him.  Everyone else, not so much.

[wheeloftime13]

i will admit that most of the reason is because of the whole him not being added to the list until later... but that's not all of it... and now that you mention it, i do find it odd, but i still believe that it would be ridiculous for Darthe to have made him mafia when he'd already said there was 3... and if dap were mafia, then it's highly likely that there would be 4 mafia instead of 3...

[Hallia]

He didn't get added until later though, his PM just got missent, meaning his role was already defined.

[wheeloftime13]

oh... but at first wasn't he not on the list??