Basic Mafia: Game of Thrones. Game Over

[Christine]

  On 7/31/2012 at 3:38 AM, alannalynn said:

  On 7/31/2012 at 12:07 AM, David Hermes said:

Ah right, that's what pregame meant. Unvote Christine.

hahahaha!

 

Okay, I'm good now.

 

Sort of laughed at David.

 

 

  On 7/31/2012 at 3:02 PM, John Snow said:

  On 7/31/2012 at 2:55 PM, Christine said:

Also, revealing, really? You're ruining the spirit of the game.

 

Bwahahahaha.

I eat the spirits of games. Just ask someone who was in the WoTopoly game.

 

 

Ignored everything about his reveal, just made a joke. (Later responded to the reveal)

 

 

Responded to the reveal:

 

BG, John (2nd post), Lily

 

  On 7/31/2012 at 6:40 PM, Nightstrike said:

I haven't been in many games, but I think I've seen how it could be working either way.

 

Defending the reveal?

 

Responded to the reveal:

 

Hoof, Arez (2nd post)

 

 

Arez claims intoxicated and previous game for his joke vote on John. Not trusting it.

 

 

John put David at what he assumed was L1 without waiting for any sort of rebuttal.

 

 

Vote Count for Lynch

David: 6 (Christine, Blackhoof, Arez, John, Rand, BG)

Christine: 1 (David)

 

Not voting: Lily, Alanna, Nightstrike,

 

 

So, my thoughts at present:

 

Bg hammered. Sacrificed?

Arez claims drunk. Whatever, we shall see.

Hoof. Actually not a scum read.

John is either a noob or scum.

Lily is always calm and clearheaded. If she offers to hammer, then she will do so. There is no hopping around the line. I believe she would have hammered, and we were in no rush.

Alanna gave no reason as to why she would not hammer, just kept trying to prod, as if asking for another answer (see below).

New, but would not be surprised if other scum.

 

 

  On 8/2/2012 at 9:09 PM, alannalynn said:

Then why would you reveal like that and bring all the attention to yourself like you did? Doesn't that seem rather counter-productive to scum-hunting?

 

This reads of coaching.

 

 

Vote Alanna

[John Snow]

@Christine Isn't L-1 the point at which the rebuttal comes? I wasn't aware I was supposed to wait

[Nightstrike]

  On 8/6/2012 at 1:51 AM, Christine said:

  On 7/31/2012 at 6:40 PM, Nightstrike said:

I haven't been in many games, but I think I've seen how it could be working either way.

Defending the reveal?

Quite the opposite, actually. I thought it could be a disadvantage for town to rely on role reveals. I've already seen it. I posted immediately after Lily, and I agreed with her.

  On 7/31/2012 at 6:20 PM, LilyElizabeth said:

David, I don't like that reveal one bit. It won't take much more for you to get my vote.

  On 7/31/2012 at 6:40 PM, Nightstrike said:

I haven't been in many games, but I think I've seen how it could be working either way.

[Nightstrike]

  Quote

Vote count 25:

 

David: 6 (Christine, Blackhoof, Arez, John, Rand, BG)

Christine: 1 (David)

 

Not voting: Lily, Alanna, Nightstrike,

Lily was critical to David's reveal pretty early, even though she didn't vote him. Christine was the first on the list. Isn't it likely that neither are scum?

[Nightstrike]

  On 7/31/2012 at 9:16 AM, Christine said:

Excellent, thank you dear.

 

 

Vote David Hermes

 

 

Half Joke Vote : I don't know you! Who are you? (And John Snow and Night Strike too, for that matter)

 

Half Legit D1 Vote : You were overactive in getting us going in PRE GAME. A little trigger happy?

 

 

 

And, honorable mentions : BG, Hoof : It feels weird. D1, and neither of you are my first vote. I dislike this.

No, wait, was this the first vote on David? She didn't vote and unvote? She could have pretended they hadn't been introduced.

[Christine]

David Voted, then Unvoted me.

 

I then proceeded to Vote him, after which, he did his reveal.

 

 

I do not see how Lily was critical to his reveal. He revealed in response to my vote.

[Nightstrike]

I thought bgrishinko might have hammered a team mate as a last resort, but he seems to have been among the first to react in any truly negative way to the reveal.

  On 7/31/2012 at 3:03 PM, bgrishinko said:

  On 7/31/2012 at 2:35 PM, David Hermes said:

And just want to reveal early on. I'm Bran Stark and I'm a vanilla townie.

 

Big Game might still be a townie, I think. At least I haven't noticed anything really scummy there.

[Christine]

  On 8/6/2012 at 2:34 AM, Nightstrike said:

I thought bgrishinko might have hammered a team mate as a last resort, but he seems to have been among the first to react in any truly negative way to the reveal.

  On 7/31/2012 at 3:03 PM, bgrishinko said:

  On 7/31/2012 at 2:35 PM, David Hermes said:

And just want to reveal early on. I'm Bran Stark and I'm a vanilla townie.

 

Big Game might still be a townie, I think. At least I haven't noticed anything really scummy there.

 

And y'all accuse me of big game hunting. *rolls eyes*

[Nightstrike]

I hunt everybody, since I don't know who's what. Vote Christine .

[Nightstrike]

#155 & Big Game list makes me think Christine is scum.

[Christine]

Seriously, there was someone coaching the scum, and no one but me notices?

 

 

Sad.

 

 

Also, why in the world would I have voted for my scum buddy, and then sheeped him? I could have easily defended him, and we would have moved on. Instead, I pushed it.

 

 

Also, if I was scum, why would I have guessed that the scum was given fake claims? I would have kept that to myself. Instead, I pointed out the possibility of it, and continued to attack David.

 

 

Use your brains, then get back to me.

[LilyElizabeth]

Christine, I didn't realize you were joking. That is a really sore issue with me.

 

I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. Unvote

[Nightstrike]

  On 8/6/2012 at 3:09 AM, Christine said:

Seriously, there was someone coaching the scum, and no one but me notices?

 

 

Sad.

 

 

Also, why in the world would I have voted for my scum buddy, and then sheeped him? I could have easily defended him, and we would have moved on. Instead, I pushed it.

 

 

Also, if I was scum, why would I have guessed that the scum was given fake claims? I would have kept that to myself. Instead, I pointed out the possibility of it, and continued to attack David.

 

 

Use your brains, then get back to me.

I've reread the first few pages, and I can see how it could be seen as coaching. She expressed some negative stuff about the reveal, but I guess that's expected. Anyway, Unvote .

[Christine]

Not to be cocky, but I'm kind of nearing on big game too. I'm not going to big game hunt.

 

 

The real problem in these games are the newer players can hide their scumminess by claiming newness.

 

 

The older players? They do anything slightly off, and it paints a huge target on the back of our heads.

[cosmicpanda]

Votecount 22:

 

Christine (1): Hoof

Alanna (1): Christine

 

Not voting: John, BG, Arez, Alanna, Nightstrike, Lily

 

With eight alive, it takes 5 to lynch! Activity has picked up, and I won't give you a deadline just now.

[alannalynn]

I would hardly call that coaching, there wasn't enough discussion going on and I didn't want to hammer without answers.

 

As for Christine, you were joking? After all that talk and such and you only just now say "oh, it was a joke"

 

FOS Night for jumping on and off the Christine vote so quickly.

[bgrishinko]

I'm wondering what happens when vote count reaches 0.

[Blackhoof]

im a little concerned about that as well.

 

 

  On 8/6/2012 at 3:09 AM, Christine said:

Seriously, there was someone coaching the scum, and no one but me notices?

 

 

Sad.

 

 

Also, why in the world would I have voted for my scum buddy, and then sheeped him? I could have easily defended him, and we would have moved on. Instead, I pushed it.

 

 

Also, if I was scum, why would I have guessed that the scum was given fake claims? I would have kept that to myself. Instead, I pointed out the possibility of it, and continued to attack David.

 

 

Use your brains, then get back to me.

 

a little too emotional for my liking, but you have made some valid points.

 

also.... you didnt seem to be joking. but still...

 

unvote

[bgrishinko]

So I see

 

Lily, Hoof, Nightstrike vote Christine...

Lily, Hoof unvote Christine...

Nightstrike's vote wasn't counted, hasn't unvoted.

 

I think Hoof's vote and subsequent unvote were opportunistic and mirroring Lily.

 

Vote Hoof

[John Snow]

@BG Night has unvoted. Post #163

[bgrishinko]

Doh.

[bgrishinko]

I guess that makes Nightstrike fall into that same category then. Hoof or Nightstrike for me right now.

[Nightstrike]

I unvoted because I reread the first few pages and thought I might have made a mistake in judging Christine. It's probably not enough to read one person, or one page, separately. There's also the trouble of reading between the lines, and trying to figure out people's motives. Just because I unvoted doesn't mean I think Christine should be cleared of all suspicion. I'm thinking Alannalynn or Christine might very well be scum. I'm not sure who of them, if it really is that way.

[Christine]

FoS Hoof for just following Lily around.

 

 

I would rather you vote for me on your own decision (even if it is absurd) than just follow someone else's voting pattern.

 

 

Regardless, I think that Alanna is scum for coaching.

[alannalynn]

  On 8/6/2012 at 2:49 PM, Nightstrike said:

I unvoted because I reread the first few pages and thought I might have made a mistake in judging Christine. It's probably not enough to read one person, or one page, separately. There's also the trouble of reading between the lines, and trying to figure out people's motives. Just because I unvoted doesn't mean I think Christine should be cleared of all suspicion. I'm thinking Alannalynn or Christine might very well be scum. I'm not sure who of them, if it really is that way.

Not liking your repeat fos's and thoughts. Anyone/thing pinging that hasn't been mentioned already? And reasons?