A Basic Game: Mafia Wins!

[Levity]

@AH (I can't quote on my phone; this is to answer what you said to me): prior to here, I have been used to statements such as "I am completely sure _____ is scum," and "_____ is obvscum" for instance. I only thought it indicated sheer confidence from the player making the case rather than always being a softclaim or a scumtell. It's a poor excuse at best, so I may not be looking at this correctly.

 

My comment regarding the erratic bandwagons yesterday was just that; I don't see how it would be related to me 'defending' Cosmic. If Cosmic flips town, I guess I'll know who to anylize more thoroughly tomorrow.

 

My biggest worry is not only Mynd having no coroner report, but that the janitor waited until the second night to use their power. Thoughts? I guess some players mentioned this already, but it's odd the scum picked him /: I don't really like the feeling I'm getting.

 

AH, I might have to read your posts again to provide a more accurate response for how I felt you acted on the first day. It's interesting that you would wonder why I didn't find your behavior odd? I'll keep that in mind.

[bgrishinko]

Mynd was an interesting choice to kill. You'd think you would want to keep around someone who was creating so much tension/so many arguments. Maybe we're dealing with inexperienced scum?

 

though it's intersting that the Janitor didn't cover Night 0's corner report as well. reflex reaction to Mynd's kill is the same as you Key, but my gut is screaming no and tellign me that maybe the scum sacrificed one of their own, and covered up his corner report to mislead and confuse us.

 

 

 

VOTE: AH

 

It's a one shot move. Check the sign up post.

 

If they were sacrificing their own... it seems like a wasted move to me.

 

AH is beginning to ping a bit in saying that someone must have disliked Mynd. Feels opportunistic to try and twist Mynds death and words to her own possible scheme.

[Nolder]

Votecount

Cosmic - BG, Key (2)

AH - Red (1)

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch

[keyholder21]

I could have sworn that Aemon had voted me at some point yesterday. I guess he was just looking suspiciously, which I don't blame him for.

 

Yesterday doesn't count as votes only count the day of and this day only started this morning. Are you skimming?

[Levity]

... analyze*

fdsjwierfhhdj wow wow wow I really do need more sleep

[Aiel Heart]

I'm just wondering if people had other reasons for voting me before. I know I was acting oddly at first. I was seeing how people would react.

 

And actually all I said on Forrest was thoughts on who would have killed him. Most likely scum, since we only consistently have one kill each night. Maybe there is a vig, but I'm not sure. That was simply speculation/thinking aloud. And unfortunately my long in depth post is going to have to wait until later because I have other stuff to do on dm in the next 10 minutes before I leave again

[cosmicpanda]

The idea of the Lyncher never even occurred to me. What I come back to is "I'm 100% sure" followed by "I'm not the cop". Doubtful that Panda is scum because it would just lead to his own lynch the next day when I flipped town. Doubtful that he is the Lyncher because he didn't press a claim of cop to push through a lynch on me. If he were the lyncher it wouldn't really have mattered as long as there was no counterclaim the same day and he could get me lynched. I'll be back later with more thoughts

 

So if its doubtful that he's scum and doubtful he's the lyncher, and he's 100% sure you are scum.......

 

Hmm, maybe Aemon isn't so scummy after all.

 

Right now I'm thinking that BG and Sakaea are scum.

[Sakaea]

Town

1 Cop

1 Doctor

1 Backup Doctor

8 Vanilla Townies

 

Mafia

1 Mafia Goon

1 Role Cop

1 Janitor

 

Third Party

1 Lyncher

 

No vig. Scummy skimmer who skims. In the words of Davy Jones, "Enough!"

 

Vote AH

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRcj6CAhe7s

[Sakaea]

Pray tell why you think I'm scum?

[John E. Kelley]

The idea of the Lyncher never even occurred to me. What I come back to is "I'm 100% sure" followed by "I'm not the cop". Doubtful that Panda is scum because it would just lead to his own lynch the next day when I flipped town. Doubtful that he is the Lyncher because he didn't press a claim of cop to push through a lynch on me. If he were the lyncher it wouldn't really have mattered as long as there was no counterclaim the same day and he could get me lynched. I'll be back later with more thoughts

 

So if its doubtful that he's scum and doubtful he's the lyncher, and he's 100% sure you are scum.......

 

Hmm, maybe Aemon isn't so scummy after all.

 

 

So once you catch some heat over a pretty scummy case, it's 180 time. That is scummy too. Two scummy's equal a vote.

 

Vote Cosmic.

[Nolder]

hmmm maybe my charger just wasn't working at my friends house for some reason

it's charging fine here at home...

[Levity]

Yesss, I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks Sakaea is scum! I'll have to get back to this soon, I'm still on my phone

 

also there isn't a vig in the setup, is there? And vigs can't janitor x:

[Levity]

and you know nolder even mod-confirmed the lack of mynd's coroner report is janitor's work

 

so

[aemonkristen]

Back from a long day job hunting. All caught up and still feeling that AH is a good option. Yesterday's behavior combined with today's apparent attempts to make us look for a nonexistent role are definitely enough for me to vote her. I am on my phone right now, so I'm going to post this and check the vote count before I vote to make sure I don't accidentally hammer.

[aemonkristen]

VOTE AH

[keyholder21]

I'd still like to check out Cosmic, but AH has just been posting ping after ping.

 

Unvote, vote AH.

[bgrishinko]

The idea of the Lyncher never even occurred to me. What I come back to is "I'm 100% sure" followed by "I'm not the cop". Doubtful that Panda is scum because it would just lead to his own lynch the next day when I flipped town. Doubtful that he is the Lyncher because he didn't press a claim of cop to push through a lynch on me. If he were the lyncher it wouldn't really have mattered as long as there was no counterclaim the same day and he could get me lynched. I'll be back later with more thoughts

 

So if its doubtful that he's scum and doubtful he's the lyncher, and he's 100% sure you are scum.......

 

Hmm, maybe Aemon isn't so scummy after all.

 

Right now I'm thinking that BG and Sakaea are scum.

 

OMGUS a bit?

[Aiel Heart]

Ok, I admit, I've been playing badly. I forgot to eat dinner tonight, and I forgot that every role was posted and thought the mafia had a night kill. *Shakes head at self*

 

Ok, can we safely assume that Forrest was town then? Maybe they had him plant seeds and then killed him (covering that up) so we’d assume town and believe what he said? Or maybe they wanted us to think that and we should believe Forrest O.o it sounds just like a BG plot!!!

 

 

http://www.paperdragonartwork.com/princess%20bride/cssAssets/images/princess_bride_15_choix.jpg

 

 

If my counting is right I'm at 4/7 when I'm about to sleep and probably won't have time to check in the morning... eh. One more vote and I'd normally reveal anyway. Vote Heart. There we go. If you guys really want to kill another vanilla go right ahead. I’m not important to the town and it would keep someone more important from being killed. Even if Forrest was town we should still be ok as long as there aren’t too many more town lynches. Just keep a close eye on whoever hammers me.

 

My last words... Cosmik should’ve known how we’d react to the “100%” comment but I’m not going to condemn him for it. Kinda mixed on him at the moment... Wondering what has made him see town where everyone else seeing scum (nice to have someone on my side though). Scum buddying up? Idk...

 

I’m getting a scum vibe from Kae but atm I can’t put my finger on why.

 

Slightly townish read from Key? Mixed on Float.

 

Aemon hasn’t liked me from the beginning but is just now voting me. That seems interesting to me.

 

Red hasn’t liked me and stuck by that. Don’t really have a vibe on her atm but that’s telling to me.

 

Fex’s lack of reasoning behind that one post I didn’t like, but right now I’m getting a town vibe from him... Idk why I think I could count on one hand the number of posts he’s made. Arez and Ishy all have had posts that stuck out to me, I can’t think of any of them specifically at the moment, but I don’t think there’s any vibe yet... Maybe slight mafia on Ishy but...

 

BG and Amega haven’t stuck out to me yet. BG is always scum though ;)

 

Ok guys, up to you. I hope I’m still alive in the morning. If not, best of luck town.

[Aiel Heart]

oops forgot to put the link in the spoiler in an image box :P

 

 

 

[Nolder]

Votecount

Cosmic - BG, Ishy (2)

AH - Red, Sakaea, Aemon, Key (4)

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch

[bgrishinko]

Meh. Still doesn't make sense to kill off Mynd as a teammate since its hard to decide if he's rattling the bushes as town or setting up a scum plot. So its a moot point to me. Weird.

 

If I were them I'd have killed Panda and left it a mystery. If he was the Lyncher, they know they are safe but can still use the Lyncher argument easily. If not, we wouldn't have known and might still think he was the Lyncher... unless Panda is actually scum and they weren't going to self sacrifice. So I'm still cool with my vote.

[Nolder]

Countdown to deadline

[cosmicpanda]

Vote: Sakaea

 

It's the only strong feeling I have. Rolefished like mad when I said I thought Aemon was scum, and has been otherwise active-lurking - always there but not actually saying much.

 

Key's vote for me is a bit stupid. Why should I have known that you lot would take my "100% certain he's scum" as anything other than a figure of speech, especially after I explained it as such? Moreover, why should pressuring me after the entire affair lead to anything useful? Perhaps she's trying to squeeze more role information out of me.*

 

AH's town, guys. Like, srsly. Also, the mafia's hiding Mynd's flip indicates that he was obviously town. BG's 221 redeems him a bit in my eyes.

 

 

_________

 

* By the way, this isn't OMGUS. I use the definition provided by the mafiascum wiki: 'OMGUS stands for "Oh My God, You Suck (for voting for me)!". it is sometimes used as a shorthand to indicate that you are voting for someone primarily because they voted for you.'

[bgrishinko]

Yeah... I know. I tend to use it when people decide someone pings due to "you suck" even if they don't lay down a vote.

[bgrishinko]

So now 100% sure Aemon is scum and now AH is town... srsly.... why?