A Basic Game: Mafia Wins!

[aemonkristen]

I cleared Cosmic night 0. We need to choose among Levity, Key, Boyo, and Razen.

[Sakaea]

1. Ishmael Forsaken, Town

2. Bgrishinko, vanilla town, NK’d Night 2

3. Red, vanilla town, NK’d Night 3

4. Razen 2.0[replaced Pale Merlot (replaced Amega)], possible town

5. aemonkristen, cop

6. Arez Al'Loke, Backup Doctor, Lynched Day 3

7. Razen, vanilla town, Lynched Day 1

8. Mr. Soy Boyo, vanilla town, NK’d Night 0

9. cosmicpanda, town

10. Soy Boyo 2.0 (replaced Perf)

11. Aiel Heart, Lyncher, Lynched Day 2

12. Myndrunner, Killed Night 1

13. Sakaea, town

14. keyholder21

15. Levity

[Sakaea]

We've had a kill every night. So to me, that kinda clears Razen 2.0, cus Amega and then Pale weren't on much. So really, we should be choosing between Soy 2.0, Key, and Levity. Key has been the most active of those 3, right?

[keyholder21]

I am town. I don't know what I can do to convince you of that, but I am.

[Sakaea]

So I'm gonna go ahead and Vote Key cus I think she's our best candidate for scum right now.

[Sakaea]

Ninja'd. Sorry sis, but my vote stands for now.

[keyholder21]

lol Aemon, you always think I'm scummy. Unless you're scum and then you always try to get me lynched. I will forever remember that MJ game where you went after me SO hardcore.

[keyholder21]

I have good news and bad news. The good news is I can narrow down the field for us quite a bit because I'm the cop. The bad news is that we are at LyLo. Here are my findings:

 

Night 0: Cosmicpanda = "town" This is why I never chased after him when he made his "100%" comment. I knew he was a townie who felt sure of himself.

Night 1: AH = "not town" This is why my first post that day was to throw an FoS on AH. I wanted to see if there was support for the lynch without having to reveal so early.

Night 2: Kaea = "town" I decided on her that night because there was a lot of conflict that day phase and she was at the center of it.

Night 3: Ishy = "town" I chose Ishy because he had been looking scummy ever since he cased Arez and then voted for Mynd. I wanted to finally clear him and move on.

Night 4 Red = "town" Unfortunately, I chose the wrong person to check last night. I went for Red because she is an extremely experienced player and I didn't like the way she was trying to steer us to see Mynd as scum. Now I may have to revise my opinion of her theory.

 

Any way we look at this, there are only 4 people left and at least 2 of those are scum.

 

I'l go whichever way you all decide, but I am leaning heavily towards Key at the moment. Amega was replaced by Pale was replaced by Razen. Most scum do their best not to get replaced, so I'm leaning town on Razen 2.0 for the moment.

 

Hey Aemon,

 

How'd you get FIVE views when we've only had FOUR nights? I went through and counted.

 

Night 0/1 (whatever you want to call it): Soy Dead

Night 1/2: Mynd dead

Night 2/3: BG Dead

Night 3/4: Red Dead

 

Vote Aemon, you LLL.

[Razen]

Key's right. How can you get five views on only four nights so far? The math doesn't add up here. And besides, Aemon, your targets were very convienient. We already knew that AH and Red were town, and viewing them the nights before they died would be easy for any of us to claim. Also, Levity did claim finder. I'm trying to go back and find the definitive post, but she subtly hinted at it before.

 

Hey, Key! You don't at all consider some other possibility why I would defend Cosmic so vehemently like that? Really? Especially since, you have to admit, that statement was blown out of proportion.

 

Here Levity hints at Finder. If she wasn't the finder, why would you wait until today to contest her claim, Aemon? You are definitely scum. Vote: Aemon.

[Sakaea]

Wow. Fail. Unvote Vote Aemon

[Sakaea]

That's 3 of 5 votes. Wonder how he's gonna try to save this, LOL

[Nolder]

Votecount

Aemon - Key, Razen, Sakaea (3)

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

[aemonkristen]

I knew I should have used my fingers when I was counting the nights. That's okay, Key. Let's just keep the rest of this on the QT for now. I'll still be able to help you out from there when I'm gone.

[aemonkristen]

Razen, AH was the lyncher. She wasn't town at all.

[John E. Kelley]

All too easy. Perhaps you and your team were getting too excited at how easy you've had it till now.

 

Vote Aemon.

[Sakaea]

Key tomorrow, methinks

[Nolder]

Votecount

Aemon - Key, Razen, Sakaea, Ishy (4)

 

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

[keyholder21]

Key tomorrow, methinks

 

'cause you're mad I called out your scum buddy?

[Razen]

I don't think Aemon would just out one of his scum partners like that. No, I think he's trying to put us on the wrong track. We know that AH was the Lyncher (my mistake from earlier) and that Red was Town. Levity has vetted Cosmicpanda, so that leaves Sakaea and Ishy on the list that Aemon gave. How much would anyone be willing to bet that either Sakaea or Ishy is scum with Aemon?

[Sakaea]

I knew I should have used my fingers when I was counting the nights. That's okay, Key. Let's just keep the rest of this on the QT for now. I'll still be able to help you out from there when I'm gone.

 

 

Key tomorrow, methinks

 

'cause you're mad I called out your scum buddy?

 

LOL, you're funny. No, cus you were my top suspect anyways, and then he outs you anyways. Epic, that.

[Sakaea]

It's not me, Raz. So if you think Key isn't it, it has to be Ishy. Could be both of them tho....

[aemonkristen]

Unless, of course, it is just a clever way of throwing suspicion on someone else because you forgot AH wasn't town, Razen. No need to thank me. I got your back, brother.

[Sakaea]

Now Aemon is just trying to sow confusion for sure.

[SBoydW]

Vote Aemon

[Sakaea]

And that's the hammer. Nolder come back!