DPR Mafia - The Dark Monocle - Game Thread

[hotpocket2006]

lulz for not checking pms :P

 

I can vouch for not bob. I may know how to drive an airship or two.

[mmeeshal]

Holy wow, I'm not gonna be surprised if EVERYONE is in a guild.

[Razen]

Holy wow, I'm not gonna be surprised if EVERYONE is in a guild.

 

The way I read this, it seems like "I'm not gonna be surprised if EVERYONE but me is in a guild." I don't know why else you would make a statement like that. And that pings heavily to me.

[mmeeshal]

Sure, I'll make no secret of it. I'm not able to participate in any of the guilds.

 

As far as I know, everyone who died has been in a guild/is in a guild, and I WAS going to base my "possible scum" list on who wasn't in a guild. But if everyone is in a guild, then I'm going to have to do scumhunting the old-fashioned way. I figured it wouldn't be that simple.

[mmeeshal]

@Razen--to answer your question, because I get to see, but I am not to be seen. I must learn, and think, and put pieces together, but never tamper with the information itself.

[mmeeshal]

I do know that.

 

**edit**

And "in" is such a silly term. I'm not a member of any of the guilds. I cannot participate in them. That's what it boils down to. In that sense, you'd be right in saying I'm not "in" the guilds.

[mmeeshal]

Eurgh, I really don't want to reread...I should have just kept notes as things were happening. XD

[mmeeshal]

Oh snap, hold up. HOLD UP. Totally just realized what you said.

 

The only reason you can think of why I wouldn't be able to participate in any of the guilds is if I'm SK or Arsonist?

 

What about if I was mafia? If you aren't mafia, you'd think you'd have mentioned that possibility.

 

unvote

vote Razen

[mmeeshal]

For the record, I still think NotBob might be scum. If not original, then converted. Obviously one's membership in a guild does not automatically make one Town, and if his membership in a guild is the only thing saving him from being lynched, then that's not good enough. He hasn't been playing town. I will go back to NotBob/Sensei if everyone feels like swinging that way. But I do think I'm onto something here with Razen.

 

Who is a dried, shriveled-up grape. >.>

[Ithillian Turambar]

Razen is a Chemist with me and Kae and the Late Great Aemon CPRenson. We think The Mafia Team got given a safe Guild to claim, because of team Saudi Arabia in the Vampire game last year.

[mmeeshal]

I know Razen is a Chemist. Reread my last few posts and compare with your QT. My responses weren't to anything said here.

 

Also, all of the guilds that have been claimed thus far are not a mafia fake claim. I can't vouch for individual members of the guilds, but the Machinists, Glassmakers, Tophats, Pilots, and Chemists are none of them comprised of solely mafia, I know that much.

 

Like I said, there are dead townies in all of the guilds. Red--Pilots. Songstress and Maw--Tophats. Despothera--Glassmakers. Aemon--Chemists. Turin, Basel, and Key--Machinists.

 

(I don't know about Hoof, because he hasn't posted in any of the guilds, but I know Nolder was a Machinist before he was converted. He hasn't posted in the guilds, either.)

 

Do you mean to tell me that some of the dead townies are posting and willingly helping open mafias, or that all the mafias would be alive if they were in one safe location that an outsider had access to?

 

It's not that simple, Ithi.

 

**edit**

GRR, I spelled Basel's name wrong. XD

[mmeeshal]

Also, like I said:

 

If EVERYONE is in a guild, then logically, either:

 

1) There are no mafia and DPR is converting townies to scum and we need to lynch him

 

or

 

2) There are mafia posting in the guilds.

[Ithillian Turambar]

*note to self*

 

Do not call Meesh a crazy mentalist in the QT anymore.

 

 

She's a secret agent ...

[Ithillian Turambar]

Lynch DPR?

[mmeeshal]

I'm a HERO.

 

And I'm a traitor to pirate-kind. *sniffles*

[mmeeshal]

Lynch DPR?

Well, if there aren't any mafia, then who else can convert townies but the mod himself?

 

By the way, I wouldn't put it past DPR to put that as a mechanic in one of his games.

 

I'm half-tempted to try it, just to see what happens.

[DPR]

Lynch DPR?

Well, if there aren't any mafia, then who else can convert townies but the mod himself?

 

By the way, I wouldn't put it past DPR to put that as a mechanic in one of his games.

 

I'm half-tempted to try it, just to see what happens.

 

"2. No matter what else happens, this is a Town against Mafia game."

 

 

 

[Razen]

@ Meesh: You are saying then that you aren't an SK or the arsonist? Why not just post a definitive statement saying you aren't? You obviously know what abilities we all have if you can read all of the QT's. The only reason I can think of for you to overreact so much is that you DO have something to hide.

[mmeeshal]

How am I overreacting?

 

I'm serious here--why did the possibility that I'm mafia never cross your mind? I find it highly suspect.

 

And nothing on the logic of there being mafia in the QTs. Why not?

 

But fine, here you go, for the LD among you all to check out if he or she so desires (see, I have no ill-will toward the guilds as a whole):

 

I am Town.

 

I am not a serial killer.

 

I am not an arsonist.

 

I have only the Town's best interests at heart.

 

There you go, plenty to work with.

[mmeeshal]

"2. No matter what else happens, this is a Town against Mafia game."

Oh hush you, I know that. I'm only joking about it being a possibility in this game. Gets the point across though, doesn't it? XD

 

But I still wouldn't put it past you to try it out in a future game.

[mmeeshal]

@ Meesh: You are saying then that you aren't an SK or the arsonist? Why not just post a definitive statement saying you aren't? You obviously know what abilities we all have if you can read all of the QT's. The only reason I can think of for you to overreact so much is that you DO have something to hide.

Also, to the bold--I can only read what DPR called "Town QT's." I mentioned it before: I was going to assume every guild member started out clean, but with all the town deaths and with all the claims of people being members of guilds, I'm starting to second-guess that strategy. I was told it's best not to take anything for granted about anyone, and that none of the QTs I can see are scum QTs, so I've come to the conclusion that the mafia can communicate and have a QT somewhere, but they've also infiltrated the guilds. Think about it--you're not masons, you're in a guild. Have you been TOLD that everyone in your guild is town, by DPR himself?

 

I'm not kidding--literally everyone except myself and I THINK Ishy has either directly claimed or hinted at what guild they belong to. I guess we'll have to wait till tomorrow to see if they really are what they say they are (as in, do they post on the QTs or not), but for now it's a fairly safe assumption that they're not lying about that, at least.

 

So, if everyone is in a guild, and all the guilds are comprised of only town, where are the mafia? I suspect Ishy might be Arsonist or something 3rd party, but WHERE ARE THE MAFIA?

[Razen]

And nothing on the logic of there being mafia in the QTs. Why not?

 

If you can read the QT's, you would know what we were discussing on ours about this very topic. And you would know that we indeed have discussed it at length. Only somebody who knows what is in our QT's would know that I brought up the point about you possibly being the SK or the arsonist. I didn't know it at the time, but with the fact that you can read what's going on in our QT and blatantly lying about it, I'm not putting it past you to be the Dark Monocle.

 

Unvote, Vote Meesh.

[mmeeshal]

I am not a serial killer.

Good book, by the way.

[mmeeshal]

And nothing on the logic of there being mafia in the QTs. Why not?

 

If you can read the QT's, you would know what we were discussing on ours about this very topic. And you would know that we indeed have discussed it at length. Only somebody who knows what is in our QT's would know that I brought up the point about you possibly being the SK or the arsonist. I didn't know it at the time, but with the fact that you can read what's going on in our QT and blatantly lying about it, I'm not putting it past you to be the Dark Monocle.

Nuh-uh, no you don't. I'm not lying about anything. I'm saying, you didn't respond here, in the thread, about my logic concerning there being scum posting in the QTs.

 

I'm not saying you aren't discussing scum, with your guildmates, in the QTs. Nice twisting, though.

 

Why would I be able to see all the townies and know who everyone is and what everyone thinks if I was scum? Doesn't make sense to me. It would make everything far too easy.

[mmeeshal]

And yes, I know there was a nice big freak-out about whether or not one of you or more had been converted.

 

Well, what if there was a leak the whole time?

 

I love your reaction, though. You haven't posted in your guild anymore--are you afraid you might slip up more in a way that would be obvious to someone who had a bigger picture than your guildmates do?