[Basic] Mafia with Quibby- GAME OVER

[bhskeeper11]

Amazing game, everyone!

 

Csarmi, you DEFINITELY had me squirming when you played the Tracker claim. It just so happened that I was the one to send in the NK on Tiinker, so it had some legitimacy (except I still wonder if you messed up the Red stayed with Red thing ). I just decided I would call you out and fight that tooth and nail. I think things might have gone differently if you had not backed down and outed yourselves as mafia.

 

I am also really surprised you guys tried to end it in a tie. I was SURE you would lynch Sakaea or myself, for the same reason we lynched Csarmi. We knew there were a few ways to win...and, well, I don't play to tie.

 

Quibby, you definitely had us on a roller coaster!

 

*whew*

 

I am so glad to be rid of this paranoia.

 

 

Edit...cos I can do that now... your night action sheet says Amega protected himself the first few nights, so he did lie about forgetting he was the healer. I wonder why he said that. I think that statement alone was enough to get him lynched.

[John E. Kelley]

Well, at least according to Quib, I didn't go out like a chump. Went out guns blazing, I like it. And no one can kill a Charlestonian except for another Charlestonian, eh Kate? And even knowing what I did your play had me thinking you really could be Town. Well played. And good setup Quib, sorry we ruined it for you on N1, all of us targeting Tink. What are the odds?

[Sakaea]

W00T! Good game everyone! I enjoyed this game so much. My first time as scum, LOL.

 

Yeah, Amega saying he forgot he was the doc was...interesting. Csarmi, nice hail-mary play. It almost worked. Nice fake claim, also.

 

Quibby, you are teh Lord of Mods. Love your scenes, disturbing as they are. I will definitely sign up for any future games you decide to do. Next time, I'll be prepared for...creative...setups.

[Kivam]

 

First of all csarmi, rule #14.

 

 

Created a monster, I have

[Quibby]

Mafia 1

Mafia 2

[csarmi]

Told you. Stupid noobs.

I have nothing more to add.

[csarmi]

Well one more thing.

I wasn't playing at anything. I was telling the complete truth.

I'm never going to play maffia again.

[bhskeeper11]

Well one more thing.

I wasn't playing at anything. I was telling the complete truth.

I'm never going to play maffia again.

 

What are you talking about? Everyone "plays" at mafia, except the occasional Townie. You played the Tracker claim; that was far from the complete truth.

[csarmi]

Okay I've had enough of your lies in game already, now stoop this farce.

I made the tracker claim to try and win. After that, the game was a draw.

 

Wanted it to go down alright with Quibby winning.

 

'Winning' it was more important for you.

 

With that, ignore ON.

[bhskeeper11]

Csarmi, I didn't play the game to lose or tie... neither of those outcomes are what we play this game for. My team and I worked hard for this win.

 

But, hey, I congratulated you on a game well-played. Just because the game didn't end the way you wanted is no reason to get all upset. However, if you really are this upset over losing, it's probably best that you retire from mafia.

 

 

Ishy, it is only appropriate. You played a great game...I look forward to playing with you again!

[csarmi]

I'm upset about the general level of stupidity in Maffia games. No one thinks logical.

And I didn't lose this game. This game is a tie, no matter what you say.

That, and I'm disappointed in our opposition.

 

I'm also upset about the dishonorable play pulled off by Sakaea (the thing I've already talked about).

[csarmi]

Maybe I should have claimed that Red visited Nolder (or whoever was killed Night1). I was pretty sure she would have had sent in the NK. But I was afraid that wouldn't sell because I tried to stop Red's lynch. Stupid of me, obviously anythign at all can be sold in a maffia game and I could have claimed I didn't vote Red because she hanged herself so I didn't have to intervene and I could keep my distance (and keep myself safe).

 

I didn't think it would make a differene, however, as I was sure the other team wouldn't buy my claim anyway, as they have full information onn the game too.

[Leelou]

Told you. Stupid noobs.

I have nothing more to add.

 

I am not a noob, after your reveal I was wanting to mess up your plan and I was hoping for the other team to take you out. :)

[Leelou]

Plus, I didn't like the idea of self protecting in this game.

[csarmi]

r

[csarmi]

If all you wanted was to ensure Kate's team's victory, you should have protected Kate.

[Leelou]

Didn't need to protect Kate, you said you were killing me and I figured I'd do my best to protect the last poor living townie.

[csarmi]

But you see leelou, it made a LOT of sense for Kate+Sak to go after Christine to frame us.

If that happened and Christine viewed Kate, then we would have been left with:

 

Kate+Sak alive (Kate confirmed maffia).

csarmi+Ishy alive

You dead.

Christine alive.

 

And if Christine didn't go with your plan of making Kate's team win, we could have won, or end in a tie.

[Kivam]

Okay I've had enough of your lies in game already, now stoop this farce.

I made the tracker claim to try and win. After that, the game was a draw.

 

Wanted it to go down alright with Quibby winning.

 

'Winning' it was more important for you.

 

With that, ignore ON.

 

Dude, enough. You're being ridiculous. You could have played for the win (kill Kate, convince the town to lynch Sakaea, win the WIFOM battle with the doc.

 

Instead, you outed your team and got angry when another team wouldn't go along with a (tbh) silly plan. What was in it for them?

[Kivam]

I'm upset about the general level of stupidity in Maffia games. No one thinks logical.

And I didn't lose this game. This game is a tie, no matter what you say.

That, and I'm disappointed in our opposition.

 

I'm also upset about the dishonorable play pulled off by Sakaea (the thing I've already talked about).

 

Stop. You lost. It's ok.

[Leelou]

I honestly don't get why you guys weren't trying to take out each other teams and decided to go with a tie?

[csarmi]

.

[csarmi]

.

[WWWwombat]

"In the game of thrones, even the humblest pieces can have wills of their own. sometimes they refuse to make the moves you’ve planned for them." --Littlefinger

[csarmi]

My posts are obviously not needed, as observed in the QT threads:

 

Messages 156-151 deleted by topic administrator 08-26-2011 10:49 AM

 

So there you go.