[Basic] Mafia with Quibby- GAME OVER

[bhskeeper11]

Csarmi, to say that if you live in the US, you can afford a fancy phone and mobile plan is just ignorant. I can't say how things are in your country, but you obviously don't know a lot about mine, so let's just leave it out, okay?

 

And, back to the game...

 

Perhaps someone can answer this, in DM games, does the finder learn alignment and role or just alignment?

 

I am suspicious of Christine for claiming she looked at BG, because we know his alignment and role from the coroner's report. But if finders only learn town or mafia, then it wouldn't matter who she claimed 'cos she would know everyone if she is mafia. So, yeah...can anyone help ease/confirm my suspicion?

 

I still think two healers claiming on D1 is too complicated...but a third claim means two of the three were mafia. I still don't like how Lee's CC was so timid-feeling, so Vote Lee.

[bgrishinko]

Welp. That's that. Day 1 and 2 were super fun, day 3 is getting pretty heated. Lighten up and have fun ya all! OUT!

[Quibby]

Finder only learns alignment.

[bhskeeper11]

Thanks, Quibby.

 

Well, I guess my suspicions are lessened for now and since we have no CC, I am pretty much ready to accept Christine's claim.

[Sedai]

vote Lee

 

Previous reasons.

[Christine]

Kate, I am not allowed to reveal my results until Daytime. Hence why I did not say who I viewed until after we found out the person I viewed died. Sorry. I saw BG and Red being friendly, so I thought that perhaps he would have an arrow on his chest today. I wish I had viewed Amega now.

[amegakure]

Yah i wish ya would have to but no harm done. Theres about 4 or 5 votes on me. I said it would ruin your plan not that i knew your plan. dont twist my words csarmi. For the people who voted me. You dont got a very good reasoning and obviously didnt look that hard at the teamwork going on between leelo and csarmi.

[Sedai]

Dude, you've got no real grounds to be saying that. From people's quick votes on you, to your counter which ha such townie timing is the reason I'm not voting you. Just because you may be a healer doesn't make you omniscient. BG was town and sided with scum, it happens. Keep more of an open mind. Not criticizing just trying to help. :)

[csarmi]

I said it would ruin your plan not that i knew your plan. dont twist my words csarmi.

 

True. But I hoped you would enlighten me on those plans you would ruin.

 

For the people who voted me. You dont got a very good reasoning and obviously didnt look that hard at the teamwork going on between leelo and csarmi.

 

Maybe you should make a case there instead of posting two-liners? I'm really interested in hearing about the teamwork between me and leelou. Maybe others would too.

 

I believe you should start make some casing at L-2. If you're the healer and leelou the liar, you should convince us.

 

Kate, all I did was the math. I reslize it's probably not about the price, but also the upkeep? I'm sure there would be a lot more phones like that around here if they costed $20.

 

I didn't mean it as an attack anyway.

 

I apologize to the Lord Mod.

[csarmi]

Sept 24 I'm eligible for for upgrade to an iPhone. I'm holding out till then, bc free is better than $200. What can I say I'm spoiled to a big screen, lol.

 

That's good to hear.

[csarmi]

Christine, why are you voting amegakure? I ask you in particular because you're an uncontested finder and your votes/words are

quite important.

[John E. Kelley]

 

For the people who voted me. You dont got a very good reasoning and obviously didnt look that hard at the teamwork going on between leelo and csarmi.

 

Maybe you should make a case there instead of posting two-liners? I'm really interested in hearing about the teamwork between me and leelou. Maybe others would too.

 

I believe you should start make some casing at L-2. If you're the healer and leelou the liar, you should convince us.

 

^^This. With the CC that the both of you have foisted on us, I have no reason to believe one over the other, except for one thing. You ask us to look at the interplay between Lee and Cs. Yet I have seen very little interplay between Lee and anyone at this point except for her and Red. She and Cs haven't looked to be working together much at all unless you have some posts you can quote me. So with that said, all I can look to are the individual posts you and she have made and while she seems to be laying low, you seem to be doing nothing but literally asking us to throw FoS's at you due to your erratic behavior. I get that it can irritating to have a role that you may know that you have and to have no one believe you, but it's your job to make us believe that you actually have said role. All I've seen to this point from you is "Well you don't believe me, so I'm going to make personal attacks against those that don't believe me and those that CC against me." And before you start in with the whole "But if the only person Lee had interplay with flipped scum", let me explain my reasoning:

 

1) Red claims doc.

2) Lee CC's, and this could be a scum tactic to throw us off.

3) After Red's lynch, you throw a CC on a CC, which may or may not be a continuation of the scum's tactic to throw us off (I still have a sneaky feeling that you, Red, and Lee are our scum team).

4) That being said, with that being my suspicion, I fall back on my premise that I can only go one what the two of you have posted since then. Lee, while posting sparingly, hasn't stirred the pot too much. You, on the other hand, have done nothing other than make personal attacks, flail around wildly, and even cause the Lord God Mod to call you out. If you were town, I would think that you would try a lot harder to convince us of what Lee has done to paint herself as scum, but instead you continue your back and forth with Cs (who I'm still not sure of either).

 

In conclusion, I'm fairly happy with where my vote stands, unless your method of convincing us takes a dramatic turn.

[amegakure]

Im in the middle of doing just that. But what personal attacks have i made ishy. I was told to shut up and was called annoying. i replied with the same comment. How is that a personal attack?

[John E. Kelley]

Yours and Cs's back and forth, while entertaining, were a little over the top. I like fast and furious gameplay as much as anyone else, but the two of you just really haven't been very sportsmanlike to now. I get that this game isn't supposed to be polite, but some of those exchanges had me and others cringing a little bit.

[John E. Kelley]

But if you're in the middle of doing just that, then well and good. Like we've said, fight man!! Convince us, I don't want our doc getting taken out anymore than anyone else. If you're legit than we want you here.

[amegakure]

haha yah true it did get heated. Kinda reminded me of dprs game with john mclane. I miss that guy. I dont remember ishy were you in that game.?

[John E. Kelley]

I've seen him around here on DM, but no, believe it or not, this is my 2nd mafia game ever, on any site. Had to learn the way my dad taught me to swim. He threw me in the deep end when I was five and said "Swim or drown."

[csarmi]

Heated? Nah.

[csarmi]

I still think we should be looking entirely elswehere.

 

Ishy looks like scum to me. I can make a quite good case on him if anyone interested (day 1 activity and his sporadic activity which always seems to be pointed at getting lynches asap), but I don't want to distract town if we go by this 2-way choice (which I don't muich believe necessary as the finder can check one of them out if really needed and our finder still seems to be safe).

 

Jack is very scummy to me as well, what with his hinting day1, his strange activity (he just plays like completely differently as I saw him play town before).

 

If I had to decide between the two 'healers', well at this point I would pick leelou as the real one. By a hair really and maybe I'm biased because of our going back and forth.

[csarmi]

For now I'm hesitant to put you at L-1.

[Leelou]

I would just like to point out that when I cc it was when I was able to be online. It was when I noticed that Red was lying since I have the role of healer. And when she was lynched day 2 she turned up scum. Sorry if it seemed rushed or whatever, but I really was super busy at work and my living situation isn't the best right now so getting online isn't a first priority for me of late. If you lynch me today, you will have another lying mafia tomorrow. I am willing to sacrifice myself if need be for that reason. I am waiting for ameg's case of me working with cs so I have something to reply to.

[amegakure]

so this is what i was doing here

 

I agree with this totally My link

 

buddy up with red here My link

 

leelo casting slight suspicon on bg who is a nk townie i believe My link

 

Heres were cs trys to slow down the red lynch My link

 

cs once again cast doubts on a red lynch My link

 

 

 

So i quess i miss spoke. There wasnt much for info between lee and csarmi but plenty of interplay with red and cs. I guess you guess will have to make a gut decison on me or lee. but this is enough for a case on cs. But this is the go down. I watch the red and lee cc fight but at that time i had totally forgot my pm. I believed my role was roless and as such was in the same predicament as you all were. Then i remember i wa the healer and double check my pm. Thats when i linked red with the scummy things she had done and got the lynch without revealing. Then i guess i thought you would believe me and take a lynch on lee and i cant see there being two healers in a basic game so thats when i pressured her. and the reveal happened. so thats what i got. IF you guys feel a lynch is nesaccary then you can lynch me and that will lead to a sucessful lynch.

[csarmi]

Well, this is what you wanted, so:

 

unvote vote amegakure

 

I'm just tired of arguing with you. Those links you posted doesn't show what you indicate.

I was trying to slow down the healer lynches, because I think losing a healer for a scum isn't a good deal.

 

I changed my mind. Losing a healer for a scum is a good deal, if you're the healer (cause then leelou should be scum) and if you aren't, even better.

[csarmi]

Also, we need to be clear of this healer-claim distraction because it is getting us nowhere.

[amegakure]

i will accept this but it shall be your downfall and lees. But i will be a sacrifice if need be. I know they didnt prove your connection. i spoke to soon. and i said that but either way its all fun and good.