[Advanced] Hollywood 1940s Mafia - Game Over

[John E. Kelley]

Hybrid wasn't on the lynch ballot. Even more reason I think he is scum.

 

I don't like your agenda. You are starting to ping.

 

And 12 hours after calling out Jack, Wom is NK'd. Think Jack is scummy.

 

Vote Jack.

[John E. Kelley]

And agree with you Amega, c'mon people wake up.

[keyholder21]

While your case on Amega is interesting Ama, I have to admit that it's weird you dug up all those quotes in favor but didn't consider that she was also against him when it came to his lynch.

 

Also, coming in that close to the deadline and not voting for kill? I know he already had the amount of votes necessary, but you didn't even mention that so idk if you even noticed it.

 

Then, although you voted for him the day before, you suddenly decide that Amega is no longer scummy - what changed?

 

Plus you're way lurkier than I remember you being in other games I've played in with you.

 

Vote Amadine, but I'll be keeping an eye on you Hybrid.

[Hybrid]

but i am getting a major scum vibe from Hybrid, you keep trying to shift the focus around.

 

How exactly have I done that?

 

Jack's reasoning is sound

 

What do you think of my response to Jack?

[Amadine]

Then, although you voted for him the day before, you suddenly decide that Amega is no longer scummy - what changed?

 

Plus you're way lurkier than I remember you being in other games I've played in with you.

 

Yes I have been lurking a bit... In all my games, I took on too many games and then RL bit me, but im back to only 2 games and my shop renos are finished so I will be doing more now.

 

As for my change in opinion on Amega, I have info from last night that he's town. And yes, that is a reveal.

[Amadine]

but i am getting a major scum vibe from Hybrid, you keep trying to shift the focus around.

 

How exactly have I done that?

 

Jack's reasoning is sound

 

What do you think of my response to Jack?

 

Just so you know, I am not ignoring this but multi quotes is too difficult from my phone.

[John E. Kelley]

Well....hmm. Reveal you say? Not posting very much till now just to throw that out there. Not saying scummy, not saying I get a good vibe from either, but I am saying I'll go back now and reread everything you've posted till now, see if I see anything. Not throwing an FoS at you just yet but I am watching you atm.

[Hybrid]

OK.

 

Unvote, vote Lessa Nikia. Reasons stated previously.

[Sedai]

Hybrid wasn't on the lynch ballot. Even more reason I think he is scum.

 

Lulz I have more tact then that.

 

It would make sense for hybrid to kill wombat, to set me up and clear himself partially by that kill. The kill on wombat only reaffirms my position on Hybrid. Don't you think I'd know that people would look at me after wombats death? No if I were scum I'd sniper innactives or I'd try to incriminate someone else with my kill.

 

I don't like your agenda. You are starting to ping.

 

And 12 hours after calling out Jack, Wom is NK'd. Think Jack is scummy.

 

Vote Jack.

[keyholder21]

 

Yes I have been lurking a bit... In all my games, I took on too many games and then RL bit me, but im back to only 2 games and my shop renos are finished so I will be doing more now.

 

As for my change in opinion on Amega, I have info from last night that he's town. And yes, that is a reveal.

 

 

I don't like semi-reveals, and I know you don't either, so that's interesting too. I'll go along with you for now, however. Unvote, vote Lessa.

[Hybrid]

Lulz I have more tact then that.

 

It would make sense for hybrid to kill wombat, to set me up and clear himself partially by that kill. The kill on wombat only reaffirms my position on Hybrid. Don't you think I'd know that people would look at me after wombats death? No if I were scum I'd sniper innactives or I'd try to incriminate someone else with my kill.

 

WIFOM reaffirms your position? Massive ping. I'm now OK with a Jack lynch as well.

 

---

 

Ishamael moved up on my radar as well. I actually missed his post and thought he was voting for Amadine for some reason, and I was about to FOS him for leaving a vote on a Finder claimant.

 

Ishamael, in case you didn't know, this is what's know as Wine In Front Of Me (from the Princess Bride). It's circular reasoning from trying to figure out what someone's actions or motivations.

 

Example: What if Jack killed Wombat b/c Wombat was onto him.

But what if the scum killed Wombat to make us think ^^.

But what if Jack killed Wombat to make us think ^^.

Etc.

[Amadine]

Not sure how you read that as a semi-reveal but yes I m the finder.

[John E. Kelley]

Mega thanks for that Hybrid, I've been wondering what that acronym meant for a week now....but I still feel ok with my Jack vote right now and am kinda confused....are you FoSing me for my Jack vote? B/c I'm certainly not trying to call out our finder if Ama is in fact our finder.....

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Hybrid (2): Jack, Ama

Lessa (2): Hybrid, Key

Jack (1): Ishy

 

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is Monday 11 AM EST

[Amadine]

but i am getting a major scum vibe from Hybrid, you keep trying to shift the focus around.

 

How exactly have I done that?

 

Jack's reasoning is sound

 

What do you think of my response to Jack?

 

 

 

Let's see...

 

It was a twist on the usual Beloved Princess role -- night was skipped instead of day.

 

Vote Sakaea again though I'm OK with a killuliu vote too.

 

Votes Sakaea, and points FoS at Kill

 

 

Unvote

 

I don't like killuliu's over-reaction either, but I'm going to hold off on voting him until I've had a chance to consider all the possibilities.

 

More FoS at Kill

Innocent points for Wombat and Piano, IMO. Wombat initially put the pressure on killuliu, Piano was the one who put killuliu in the lead when killuliu and I were tied at 2 votes.

 

Ishamael pinged for his unvote near the deadline then his typo in the revote.

 

Amegakure and Amadine both pinged for posting near the deadline but not voting for the majority, considering that there was no precedent of leelou counting poorly formatted votes.

 

FoS at Ishy, Amega & Ama (me)

OK, done with the reread.

 

Top suspects:

Amadine

- Active lurking

- Reasons I stated a couple posts back concerning her most recent post

Conclusion: Lurking scum vibe.

 

Lessa Nikia

- Laying very low

- Only votes of significance were bandwagons on Red and Vambram. The Red one is worth noting: Here she only comments on Wombat's weird voting, even though the argument is well under way. Later here, she comments on Red being super scummy for overreaction, but this is only after a couple other people chimed in with suspicion against Red. So this feels like an opportunistic bandwagon to me.

- Notably did not show up to vote for killuliu. (Though this could just be due to RL)

- Lots of comments on "nothing jumps out at me"

Conclusion: Timid scum vibe.

 

Christine

- Reacted very strongly to my comment about Red + inactives here. Granted, my comment was contingent on Red being scum, but the strength of the reaction is worth noting.

Conclusion: No read yet. I just thought it was worth noting.

 

People I think are innocent so far:

amegakure

Sakaea

Piano

 

I'm going to keep my vote on Amadine right now because I'd like to see what happens if she gets a little pressure, but I'm also OK with a Lessa lynch.

 

FoS pointed at Ama (me), Lessa and Christine

OK.

 

Unvote, vote Lessa Nikia. Reasons stated previously.

 

votes Lessa

Lulz I have more tact then that.

 

It would make sense for hybrid to kill wombat, to set me up and clear himself partially by that kill. The kill on wombat only reaffirms my position on Hybrid. Don't you think I'd know that people would look at me after wombats death? No if I were scum I'd sniper innactives or I'd try to incriminate someone else with my kill.

 

WIFOM reaffirms your position? Massive ping. I'm now OK with a Jack lynch as well.

 

---

 

Ishamael moved up on my radar as well. I actually missed his post and thought he was voting for Amadine for some reason, and I was about to FOS him for leaving a vote on a Finder claimant.

 

Ishamael, in case you didn't know, this is what's know as Wine In Front Of Me (from the Princess Bride). It's circular reasoning from trying to figure out what someone's actions or motivations.

 

Example: What if Jack killed Wombat b/c Wombat was onto him.

But what if the scum killed Wombat to make us think ^^.

But what if Jack killed Wombat to make us think ^^.

Etc.

 

points FoS at Jack and Ishy.

Reads as jumping around to me.

[Krakalakachkn]

Looks like he's Fingered FOS'ed everybody. That tells me he's just hoping that one of them sticks.

[Hybrid]

Mega thanks for that Hybrid, I've been wondering what that acronym meant for a week now....but I still feel ok with my Jack vote right now and am kinda confused....are you FoSing me for my Jack vote? B/c I'm certainly not trying to call out our finder if Ama is in fact our finder.....

 

I'm FOSing you for WIFOM, which is your stated reason for the Jack vote. The thing about "calling out the Finder" was me getting confused and thinking you were voting for Amadine.

[Hybrid]

Let's see...

 

Unvote

 

I don't like killuliu's over-reaction either, but I'm going to hold off on voting him until I've had a chance to consider all the possibilities.

 

More FoS at Kill

Innocent points for Wombat and Piano, IMO. Wombat initially put the pressure on killuliu, Piano was the one who put killuliu in the lead when killuliu and I were tied at 2 votes.

 

Ishamael pinged for his unvote near the deadline then his typo in the revote.

 

Amegakure and Amadine both pinged for posting near the deadline but not voting for the majority, considering that there was no precedent of leelou counting poorly formatted votes.

 

FoS at Ishy, Amega & Ama (me)

 

I don't see how this is jumping around. Kill was dead, so I couldn't continue to FOS him. Instead, I gauged people's reactions to his lynch train. Pretty normal scumhunting.

 

OK, done with the reread.

 

Top suspects:

Amadine

- Active lurking

- Reasons I stated a couple posts back concerning her most recent post

Conclusion: Lurking scum vibe.

 

Lessa Nikia

- Laying very low

- Only votes of significance were bandwagons on Red and Vambram. The Red one is worth noting: Here she only comments on Wombat's weird voting, even though the argument is well under way. Later here, she comments on Red being super scummy for overreaction, but this is only after a couple other people chimed in with suspicion against Red. So this feels like an opportunistic bandwagon to me.

- Notably did not show up to vote for killuliu. (Though this could just be due to RL)

- Lots of comments on "nothing jumps out at me"

Conclusion: Timid scum vibe.

 

Christine

- Reacted very strongly to my comment about Red + inactives here. Granted, my comment was contingent on Red being scum, but the strength of the reaction is worth noting.

Conclusion: No read yet. I just thought it was worth noting.

 

People I think are innocent so far:

amegakure

Sakaea

Piano

 

I'm going to keep my vote on Amadine right now because I'd like to see what happens if she gets a little pressure, but I'm also OK with a Lessa lynch.

 

FoS pointed at Ama (me), Lessa and Christine

OK.

 

Unvote, vote Lessa Nikia. Reasons stated previously.

 

votes Lessa

 

Lulz I have more tact then that.

 

It would make sense for hybrid to kill wombat, to set me up and clear himself partially by that kill. The kill on wombat only reaffirms my position on Hybrid. Don't you think I'd know that people would look at me after wombats death? No if I were scum I'd sniper innactives or I'd try to incriminate someone else with my kill.

 

WIFOM reaffirms your position? Massive ping. I'm now OK with a Jack lynch as well.

 

---

 

Ishamael moved up on my radar as well. I actually missed his post and thought he was voting for Amadine for some reason, and I was about to FOS him for leaving a vote on a Finder claimant.

 

Ishamael, in case you didn't know, this is what's know as Wine In Front Of Me (from the Princess Bride). It's circular reasoning from trying to figure out what someone's actions or motivations.

 

Example: What if Jack killed Wombat b/c Wombat was onto him.

But what if the scum killed Wombat to make us think ^^.

But what if Jack killed Wombat to make us think ^^.

Etc.

 

points FoS at Jack and Ishy.

 

I'm just replying to what I see in the thread. If people act suspicious, I will call them on it. I'm certainly not trying to derail anyone else's lynch train. Again, normal scumhunting.

[Leelou]

Lessa has been replaced by Nolder.

[Leelou]

So I'm thinking about making deadlines shorter going forward.

[John E. Kelley]

Sounds good to me O Mod Goddess. Might get a few of the less active players to pick up the pace.

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Hybrid (2): Jack, Ama

Nol (2): Hybrid, Key

Jack (1): Ishy

 

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is Monday 11 AM EST

[Nolder]

hi everyone

[Amadine]

Welcome nolder :-)

[Nolder]

may I ask why I have votes on me?