[Basic] JLM's Ad Icons Mafia - Game Over!

[csarmi]

My m---

 

Wait, I'm dead? Ouch.

[PruthvishK]

Well to tell you the truth here are my reasons:

1) I was like really bored so I voted for the first person I saw.

2) I've been going with the flow for too long so I decided to throw a few chillies into the mix, you know, spice it up a bit.

3) Mynd has been playing well.....a little TOO well maybe (I mean he always happens to have a perfect reason for everything, or almost everything)and I dono I just felt like he was Mafia.

[trench]

Pruth I am sorry but it is day 3 and those are some flimsy reasons to vote for someone. There has been plenty of conversation so far, you should be able to make a decent case and then vote based on those reasons. To me it seems like you are deflecting for a teammate. Now that 3 mafia members have kicked the bucket, the more inactive ones are now having to take a more active role?

[danneric]

I can't vote with this flimsy evidence on all three of the people that are right now being voted...If someone can justify in a bs but good way then i will see but right now i have a suspicion that trench is the scum but with barely any good evidenc i cant have enough to weigh my vote down.

[JenLenaMom]

Moon (1): Mynd

Trench (1): Moon

Mynd (1): Pruth

 

majority is 5.

[Christine]

Ach, ok. I was going to wait and see where the votes went, and if everyone wants to make a majority vote on someone else at random, I will go with that over a random lynching, but since it smells that everyone wants to go with Trench. My reasons have already been explained.

 

 

VOTE TRENCH

[Christine]

Alright just reread that post. I am very clearly exhausted as I didn't even write out a proper sentence. Forgive me, it is almost midnight and I have been up since 5. I think y'all got the jist of it though.

[trench]

I have been thinking about the mafia's choice for an NK last night. I have read and reread all of GMaster's posts, and he said nothing IMO that indicates he was the Vig. So why kill him? Like Mynd said he was a candidate for a lynch today along with, Ahmoon, Myself and Csarmi. This is my crackpot theory, and I think it holds water. The Mafia wanted to slim down the candidate list so they could focus on their intended targets, me and Csarmi.

 

If you look at it the only person who was after both me and Csarmi, was Ahmoon. I think her and her Mafia friends decided, to get rid of one of the options so they could lynch me or Csarmi. Except Gmaster fell into their trap and killed Csarmi, a Townie. That left me and now they are going ahead with a lynch on me. I can assure you all I am Town and will flip that way. The mafia have controlled yesterdays lynch, which backfired, and are now going after me.

 

With Christine backing Ahmoon's play here I think we can trust that one of the 2 are Mafia, Christine has mostly Bandwagoned on votes and could just be setting up Ahmoon for a frame scam, or they are in it together. Right now I think that Ahmoon is the best candidate for a Lynch, so Vote Ahmoon

 

If the town does decide to lynch me, once the dust settles, and I have been proven innocent, the rest of the town will know who to look at.

[JenLenaMom]

Moon (2): Mynd, Trench

Trench (2): Moon, Christine

Mynd (1): Pruth

[Myndrunner]

unvote

 

Those of you who remember that WoT Black Tower game, swooping in to vote without explanation has been PROVEN to be a GLARING Mafia tell, especially in a Basic game where it is extremely unlikely that there is a vote controller. Even if there was, Pruthvish would have gone out of his/her way to be blatant about it. Someone had to have told him/her to vote Mynd and he/she likely just came in to do it and then to go back to being inactive.

 

While, I feel Moon is definitely someone to watch, and I'm beginning to watch Christine and Trench carefully, our best move right now is to lynch Pruthvish. I'm pretty sure that voting Pruthvish is the way to go.

 

Who joins us in this lynch and who doesn't will tell us a whole lot about alignment.

[JenLenaMom]

Moon (1): Trench

Trench (2): Moon, Christine

Mynd (1): Pruth

Pruth (1): Mynd

[Niniel]

First of all. I don´t think we can learn about anyones alignment based on Killus lynch. He was a symp and that mean that neighter town or mafia knew his alignment. I guess there can be both town and mafia on his lynch. That is one of the reason that makes me suspicios of Moon. You chase Trench based on the reason that he was on Lilys lynch and not on Killus. Since the last lynch doesn´t show us anything this is a thin case. But the question is if you are scum? Early in the game Moon accuses Red, Key, Lily and Killu to be on a scum team. Why would she name two of her teammates? On the other hand she says that she didn´t vote Red cos she was afraid of looking like she just follows Mynd. Is that a good reason? I haven´t decided on what to think of Moon jet. I will continue to watch her.

 

Trench - Had a strange reason for voteing Lily day one. He says that it was the best chance to get a controlled lynch. But he was only number three on that lynch. Not a good reason in my opinion. As I said above I don´t think we can suspect him on the base of not voteing Killu. It was a fast lynch, he´s right there. So, don´t know about Trench eighter.

 

Deadly - haven´t anyone noticed that he isn´t on eighter lynch? Find somewhere that he actually make a case on someone (exept for voteing those that voted for him). We have a wage "I will maybe vote Trench" right now but the rest of the posts is just meaningless. FOS!!!

 

Alanna - isn´t making much cases eighter. When other players said that scum is ok with a random lynch she says that isn´t true and that scum is likely to vote for a controlled lynch. She was the one not voteing that day (Lily lynch). Is she just saying what is a fact or does she try to protect herself? She takes her time explaining rules, roles etc and that is really good but I would like to see some more thoughts about who is scum and who is not.

 

Christine - Red and Christine were suspicios of eachother but never voted the other one. A litle bit suspicios. She seems to agree a lot with Moon and if Moon turns out to be scum that wouldn´t be good for Christine. But I wonder if she would agree with a teammate so much in public?

 

Pruthvish - Just weird. Vote and leave. Vote and leave. Vote without a good reason. Big FOS!!!

 

I have not decided jet who to vote for. I think Deadly look very suspicious but noone else seem to consider him so I don´t know if it´s worth voteing for him.

[Niniel]

Ok, some of my ideas just disappeared. Deadly hasn´t voted for anyone when the final votes is counted. Thought I should add that.

[Myndrunner]

TinaHel is mafia. BIG FOS should earn a vote, but she dismisses it. She is trying to protect Pruthvish!!

[Christine]

I guess I shall speak up in saying that I am suspicious of Moon, but I agree already that Trench is suspicious. I already said I would gladly go wherever we could get a majority vote, but here we are now with 5 people having voted, Deadly isn't voting at all, and we have 4 different candidates. People will either need to start switching votes or else everyone that hasn't voted has to go with Trench, unless people start flopping.

 

The more I think about Pruth, the more suspicious it seems. My watch list at this point is Trench, Pruth, then Moon. That being said, I think Pruth's move on Day 3 makes him even higher on everyone's suspicion list.

 

I am going to stick with my vote for Trench for now, but if the votes slide toward Pruth I will gladly switch my vote. So really Trench or Pruth.

[PruthvishK]

Ok first things first: Mynd I am a BOY!!! I mean how in the world can Pruthvish EVER be a girls name? I mean come on man seriously!!!

2) Now Christine the reason my so called "defense" is so flimsy is that I happen to be a 15 year old kid who has to go to school (shocking right?? Well yeah I get that a lot) So I only have time to read a limited number of responses everyday. But if you think this indicates I'm the bad guy, well try this on for size :

 

Going with the flow (again) and keeping to the Townie side UNVOTE MYND and

 

VOTE TRENCH

 

try biting on that Mr

[PruthvishK]

@Trench: Sorry mate but I gotta look out for myself.

[Myndrunner]

Pruthvish is backtracking after being called out instead of defending HIS reason for voting me.

 

Total Scum!

[Alanna]

Alanna - isn´t making much cases eighter. When other players said that scum is ok with a random lynch she says that isn´t true and that scum is likely to vote for a controlled lynch. She was the one not voteing that day (Lily lynch). Is she just saying what is a fact or does she try to protect herself? She takes her time explaining rules, roles etc and that is really good but I would like to see some more thoughts about who is scum and who is not.

 

I've said that many times in different games; only no one listens, apparently. I will try to post more later, but I've been quite sick. Which is why I missed voting Day 1, because I was sick. I would never want a random lynch.

 

I will say I'm more suspicious of Ahmoon than trench; pushing the whole thing about who is on kill's lynch is weird, since mafia wouldn't have known he was their symp.

[JenLenaMom]

Moon (1): Trench

Trench (3): Moon, Christine, Pruth

Pruth (1): Mynd

[Myndrunner]

Seriously, out of Trench, Moon, or Christine any of them or all of them could be scum, but we need to secure the lynch on Pruthvish. Think about the ideology behind it. Who swoops in to vote without any justification? Someone who was told to hurry up and vote!

 

..and in a basic game like this, there can be only one QT and that is for the mafia!

 

Pruth will flip scum, and those who were reluctant to vote will be the ones we should go after next!

[Niniel]

I´m still not surtain. If it was just the last days post that mattered then I would vote Moon. But if she was scum why name her teammates on day one?

 

What about Pruthvish? JLM wrote in the beginning that each roll was randomly choosen to each player. So he could be a newbee scum who is getting told what to do. But he could also tell the truth and be just a newbee town. If we should lynch him and he turned up town, what would that tell us? He hasn´t interact with other players, just gone mainstream.

 

Deadline is thursday?

[danneric]

Pruthvish is backtracking after being called out instead of defending HIS reason for voting me.

 

Total Scum!

 

Mynd is accusing everyone left and right Total Scum!...jokes aside i havent been voting because if i do pick on of the people to vote and they flip town i will have aligned myself, in your guises eyes, with the mafia so why would i vote without seeing anything scummy???

 

The deadline is in about 30 hours so i think i have some time before they lynch...

[JenLenaMom]

Deadline is Friday at 4:00pm CST. Actually closer to 45 1/2 hours. Right now it is approx 7:30pm CST.

[Myndrunner]

I'm telling you all, Red is definitely mafia. Did you see how she tried to slide in that No Lynch with no explanation behind it? I can somewhat allow for a "random Day 1" deal, but she's trying to give the mafia a full day advantage by going with No Lynch!

RED IS MAFIA!

 

Red, the Verizon Can You Hear Me Now Guy, Mafia has been phoned to death

 

I TOLD YOU GUYS!!!! Red was mafia!!!!

 

Vote KILL

 

The obvious choice!

 

Killulia, iPhone and TMobile MyTouch Phone, Mafia Symp has been lynched.

 

^The above are quoted for easy reference for the next person to question my scum hunting skills.

 

Now then, these are the reasons we should lynch Pruthvish.

 

1)Nearly always a vote without reason is not only unhelpful, but it is typically when the scum team tells one of their less active players to swing by and vote real quick. Considering Pruth's lack of activity, this fits the MO.

 

2)Upon being pressed on this, Pruth had every reason in the world to argue back against me; however, instead back-tracked and now is voting Trench.

 

3)This....

Well to tell you the truth here are my reasons:

1) I was like really bored so I voted for the first person I saw.

2) I've been going with the flow for too long so I decided to throw a few chillies into the mix, you know, spice it up a bit.

3) Mynd has been playing well.....a little TOO well maybe (I mean he always happens to have a perfect reason for everything, or almost everything)and I dono I just felt like he was Mafia.

I've read some weak reasons for voting before, but this reads like a bunch of reasons people have used in past games, rolled into a blender, diluted with some lime juice, set to puree and then splattered on the floor. Are we supposed to pick which one to believe? He was bored....no wait, Mynd was playing too well and he's gotta be Mafia....I mean, wait, I just wanted to not go with the flow.

 

4)but then there is this....

Ok first things first: Mynd I am a BOY!!! I mean how in the world can Pruthvish EVER be a girls name? I mean come on man seriously!!!

2) Now Christine the reason my so called "defense" is so flimsy is that I happen to be a 15 year old kid who has to go to school (shocking right?? Well yeah I get that a lot) So I only have time to read a limited number of responses everyday. But if you think this indicates I'm the bad guy, well try this on for size :

 

Going with the flow (again) and keeping to the Townie side UNVOTE MYND and

 

VOTE TRENCH

 

try biting on that Mr

For someone who didn't want to go with the flow and spice it up, looks like he changed his mind. And how does he know he is keeping to the Townie side? The only people who know who are actually town and who are not are the mafia!

 

I am loving Tina's defense of him too. It's like a Mafia Godfather defending the newb on the team. And while we are on the topic, being a newb does not entitle you to special treatment in this or any game, nor is it a reason to NOT lynch someone!