[Advanced Mafia] Black Ajah - GAME OVER!

[Blackhoof]

well, i was just repeating what i've heard. the general sentiment seems to be against you and csarmi.

 

therefore, i have voted csarmi since i am suspicious of him. i am also suspicious of you, and will switch my vote accordingly at need.

[csarmi]

I find Curt and Blackhoof the most suspicious.

I don't think I'll have the time to do a reread, that deadline is just too close for me.

 

I think it's a mistake to look for scum at the two ends of the voting pattern (0 lynch votes, 3 lynch votes). I don't think a maffia player would act like that. A serial killer? Yea well if there was a serial killer, why would he stand out like that?

 

I'm not really sure why Blackhoof disappeared from our scum radar. He was acting scummy EVERY day and night.

 

Both of them voted with Red each time it mattered. They didn't get a lynch the second time though.

 

For now, I'm going to vote Blackhoof.

 

I realize that spreads out the votes even more and I'm willing to compromise, voting Curt instead, or someone else with a better case on him (for consolidation's sake).

I'm also willing to help a controlled lynch.

[mmeeshal]

I'll vote Csarmi pending a reskim of the thread.... I've nearly forgotten who my last suspects were, aside from Drew, and no one is really standing out to me at the moment.

[csarmi]

What do you mean?

[mmeeshal]

I mean you're my placeholder vote, since you have the most votes right now and we'll need a majority by tomorrow morning. I may change my vote, I may not, depending on what I find when I skim through the thread again. Don't have enough time for a full-on reread.

[csarmi]

Yea me neither :(

[csarmi]

Okay well nothing's going on, apparently.

 

UNVOTE Vote CurtDragon

 

Most chance of getting a majority on of those I find most scummy

 

(my shortlist is Blackhoof (fishing and acting scummy all the time), Curt (Red), leelou (yup that L-1 looking vote!))

[csarmi]

I thought we'd get a discussion but no one's really speaking.

Why is that?

 

You're town, you should speak. A lot. And try to do lynches.

 

mmeeshal, will you be back to change your vote if needed?

[Krakalakachkn]

Unvote

Vote csarmi

 

Sorry man, we need a lynch today. Honestly, I'm totally bandwagoning. I'll try to do a reread at some point today to see if anything sticks out. But for now...yeah.

[bgrishinko]

Unvote vote Csarmi I mentioned that black curt and cs were all who I was focusing on today. Csarmi has been pinging many people since day 1. And we need a lynch.

[DrewRiley]

Well I laid out my two suspects, Curt and Player, in a previous post. Not much has happened to change that since then, so I'm going to Vote Curt. I'll switch if it's the difference between a lynch and a no lynch, but unless something else comes up, that's the only reason I'd switch.

[Talmanes]

Well out of the two I'd say Csarmi sticks out more.

I still find Drew scummy, but Csarmi, you seem to be getting kind of desperate trying to save yourself, to the point, that it actually looks pretty scummy. Obviously people are going to defend themselves, but when you are getting that defensive trying not to get lynched, but haven't revealed or anything, it usually means you are Mafia.

 

Vote Csarmi

[Krakalakachkn]

I'd be willing to lynch Player. He's still really suspicious to me and really confirmed those suspicions when he immediately popped up after I voted him.

[Talmanes]

That did look odd, but mostly I attributed it to him just not being able to be very active.

[Krakalakachkn]

Yeah, well, as I mentioned before, Player hasn't been on 2/3 lynches and wasn't even on Drew's lynch the third day. He obviously doesn't have much interest in lynching town-believed scum and I think he could possibly be the SK. He denies it, but of course anyone would. I can understand inactivity, but he popped up for the first time in several pages immediately after I voted him which leads me to believe he's been skimming but not participating. Sketchy if you ask me. Sounds like someone who doesn't really care who's lynched (because he's the SK!!!!!!)

[csarmi]

Krak if you're so interested in a controlled lynch and willing to vote Player too, couldn't you unvote me and have a discussion?

 

It's not like we can't have a lynch there are like 20+ hours left still and I'm at L-1 (which I find pretty suspicious anyway).

[Krakalakachkn]

Sure.

unvote

[csarmi]

Great. I can go home now and do a readup then.

[csarmi]

Well out of the two I'd say Csarmi sticks out more.

I still find Drew scummy, but Csarmi, you seem to be getting kind of desperate trying to save yourself, to the point, that it actually looks pretty scummy. Obviously people are going to defend themselves, but when you are getting that defensive trying not to get lynched, but haven't revealed or anything, it usually means you are Mafia.

 

Vote Csarmi

 

This makes absolutely no sense. Where was I getting defensive?

I'm still posting a lot, but it's always like that. It's because I voted for someone, or what?

[csarmi]

The road home is about 1.5 hours long (I'm at work right now).

 

Krak, what do you think about Curt?

BG?

[csarmi]

BTW Krak you DO have a good point about Player. I still believe an SK shouldn't be skipping all the votes (suspicious in itself) but still.

 

I'll add him to my shortlist.

 

Well, I'll be back in 2 hours or so.

[Talmanes]

I realize we have time, but I for one don't generally like to leave a vote on someone I know won't be lynched (Drew). I did and have done this before if I do not find the person scummy, but you I find to be a bit scummy, though not the scummiest.

 

I guess mostly I'm just a little jumpy because I don't want a repeat of not being able to get on the lynch in time, and having a no lynch, which would just straight end the game at this point.

 

I know for a fact I will be on tonight, and probably should be on tomorrow before, but I can't guarantee it for tomorrow.

 

For now, I will unvote and put my vote back on Drew, until tonight.

 

If you haven't convinced me by then, unless Drew gets more votes, I will place my vote back on you, to make sure that I don't miss the deadline.

[Krakalakachkn]

Just did a reread focusing on Curt and Player. I have to say, apart from him voting with Red all three lynches, there's really nothing suspicious about him at all. He's really gotten active the past 5-6 pages where before that he just kinda popped in and offered whatever analysis or opinion. At the risk of being associated with him if he ever turns up scum, at this point I'd say that he's clean and most likely town.

 

As for Player, my suspicion of him stands. I was actually surprised to see how many people echoed the opinion that he could potentially be the SK (Drew, BG, and maybe Talm if memory serves right).

 

I'm also not sure where the link between Drew and BG came from (I think it was Red), but it seems like a few people are harping on it significantly...I'm looking at you Curt and csarmi. That gives me more suspicion towards csarmi and it seems like everyone is most suspicious of him and player.

[Krakalakachkn]

Also, I never named "him" in my first paragraph. I was referring to Curt.

[csarmi]

Well if I ever linked Drew and BG, please let me know when.

 

They have only one thing in common: both are on D1+D2 lynches (part of that group of six).