[STANDARD] Alanna's Robin Hood Mafia - Congrats to the Town!

[LilyElizabeth]

*blinks* I've been away? Why didn't anyone tell me?  ;) Tal, seriously, how many games are you playing in right now? You seem distracted to me, not scummy.

 

I've just been rereading, trying to figure out what I want to do. There are a lot of suspicions floating around, and I'm looking for the substance to go with them. Other than whatever Pete's doing, I haven't got anything yet. Still, the more interesting pages are yet to come in my reread - I hope.

 

Aemon, I thought you had a vote on Tigs? She's one I always have trouble reading. I've played on scum teams with her where she barely checked in like this, and she does it when she's town. If I don't get anything better, I may place my vote there, just to eliminate a player we aren't getting anything from, as far as content. I'd like a better reason, though, so I'll read. Gotta check in on my game first...

 

 

[aemonkristen]

Vote Count:

Talya (3) - Pete, Rose, Pookie

Tigs(2)- Aemon, Talya

 

Not Voting (5): Lily, Tigs, Lia

 

Deadline is Wednesday @ 2PM CST.

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

Yup. I forgot to put my own vote there. I think the count is right now.

 

[mnwhiterose]

You know, Pookie is just evil enough to pull of a LLL. Or maybe I've hit that stage where I'm just paranoid. I think I should join AA after this game. Or MA.....or something.

 

Until then.....*clenches the Crown Royale bottle just a little tighter*

[Pookie]

Awww, Rose, *snuggles*

 

I intend a reread.  I'll either come back with quotes or a change in vote. 

[LilyElizabeth]

I really HATE to do a wall of text for you guys. Just read my thoughts, and then use the quotes for reference, if you need to, okay?

 

 

Aemon’s been going off half-cocked all game. I know he says he’s the vig, and I guess we have no reason to doubt that, but he stood out in my reread as unusually aggressive. (for whatever that’s worth) He seems to have settled down now, but I noted it anyway.

 

 

Actually, there's one piece of info I think we might have.  Unless there's someone who hasn't been on in the last two days when the vote was clearly looking to swing my way (besides Kati) then I'm pretty sure the mafia were all on me.  Otherwise they would have swapped there to make that last vote and get rid of an innocent. 

 

Pookie that logic is brilliant. I tend to agree with that statement and to further it on, I think Talya, Rose, and Aemon is where we should cast our eyes towards.

 

True that and I agree, it looks like Moggy was hit by Mafia (who got lucky) and Pete by a vig.

 

While not *all* Mafia may have been on Pookie's lynch, we can reasonably assume that at least ONE Mafia was on the lynch, if she was Mafia, they would want one on it so they could look "innocent" if she was taken down and if she is innocent, then they would have worked hard at making sure the lynch went through. I don't think they would have given up a "free" kill just to have a no lynch day.

 

So I think we should look at Tigs, Talya, Rose, Bela, Aemon, and Player.

 

*goes to do a re-read*

 

I'll admit, I had the opportunity to hammer Aemon and didn't take it.  When Pete was NK'd I believed it was either Aemon or someone convinced by Aemon.  The people who are actually playing this game right now don't seem like folks I'd expect to be easily swayed without evidence.  Aemon's been playing like he's roled (the "man on a mission" feel to his posts) so I believe his claim.  I still think a no lynch is better than killing an innocent for the mafia if we just can't decide who is mafia quick enough.

 

Player also voted for me with no reason given beyond "we need to get this moving".  As did Bela, who didn't vote day 2.  Talya, Lily and Tigs I'm not sure about, but Talya pings me the hardest of those.  I currently believe Rose and Lia to be innocent, though I'm keeping my eye on Rose since both bandwagons seemed to really get rolling after her vote each time.  If I'm going purely based on voting patterns, I'd pick Player, Tigs, and Rose as the 3 mafia, but of those three I'm least suspicious of Rose, as I lean towards believing her roleplay role claim thingies.  IF all 3 mafia were on my bandwagon, I can see how they might want to avoid doing that again so they might not have necessarily all voted for Aemon.

 

My order of most suspicious to least:  Player, Talya, Tigs, Bela, Lily, Rose, Som1, Lia, Aemon.  Rose and Lily are neck and neck.  I'm sure I'd suspect Bela more if she were around.  :P

 

Rose was on everybody's list (and both of Pookie's.) I never saw her give any reason, but everyone dropped her and never went back. Maybe something, maybe not, but worth noting. Just something that stuck out while I was reading.

 

 

THIS is the only thing I could find that anyone said about a reason to vote Talya:

 

[glow=red,2,300]Talya[/glow] upon my reread and our little back and forth between Aemon's and myself's back and forth you just seemed to come of scummy. Your posts seem a little to polished and something about you correcting Pookie's list just raised some flags.

 

Well, the game is certainly heating up!  ;D

 

I can see both sides of this one. It could be a misunderstanding or it could be Talya being scummy. I've seen her like this when she's in too many games. On the other hand, I've never caught her as scum yet. I have, however, lynched her when she was innocent. (I'm still embarrassed over that one, Mary Poppins  ;)) And Pete is either making a lot of sense or misleading us. Too soon for me to tell.

 

For now, I'm going to watch closely, and make up my mind.

 

 

I'm not sure, but I'm leaning towards the bolded choices, although Pete may just be wrong and not intentionally misleading us. I'm adding Aemon's posts here because I think they make more sense than Pete's thoughts.

 

 

Actually, there's one piece of info I think we might have.  Unless there's someone who hasn't been on in the last two days when the vote was clearly looking to swing my way (besides Kati) then I'm pretty sure the mafia were all on me.  Otherwise they would have swapped there to make that last vote and get rid of an innocent. 

 

ooh

thats good. Im going to use that in other games too. It makes so much sense

 

Sounds like Player is trying to make us believe Pookie's theory, which leads me back to the same conclusion that made me shoot Pete. I don't think all of the mafia voted for Pookie and the only one not confirmed by a coroner's report is Lia.

 

After a reread, I get tend to think Talya is innocent for a couple of reasons. Several times she stated her suspicions of Player and she even voted him after he voted for himself. This was before the bandwagon on me started, so her vote could easily have started a bandwagon on Player.

 

Da Players (something I picked up from Mynd in Talya's LoTR game)

1. Kati Lily

2. Talya

3. Som1else - Mutch, Outlaw, Killed Night 2

4. Pete - Alan a Dale, Outlaw, Killed Night 1

5. Bela Pete 2.0

6. Tigs

7. Lia

8. Rose- Friar Tuck?

9. Player - Guy of Gisbourne, Mafia, Killed Night 2

10. Moghedian - Robin Hood, Tracker, Killed Night 1

11. Aemon- Vigilante, cried at Robin's death

12. Pookie- (I still have no idea which character she is)

 

At this moment, I feel that the remaining mafia will be found among Lily, Pete, Tigs and Lia. I have n o read on Lily. Pete just came in and Bela only made 2 posts while she was in the game, neither with any content. That means that for the moment I will have to vote between Lia and Tigs. I am going to vote [glow=red,2,300]Tigs[/glow] Because she was involved in both bandwagons and it looks like she and Player may have been double teaming to try and force through my lynch, as they posted withing 10 minutes of each other.

 

I have a feeling that Aemon is telling the truth (and no I don't believe it 100%) mainly because of Pete on day one.

 

I'm thinking now either Player or Pookie :-\

 

This is one of th main reasons that I think Talya is innocent. I admit that she might be throwing a teammate under the bus on this one, but in a standard game that's not very likely. Maybe if she is scum she put Player in there because she thought I'd go for Pookie instead. That is also a possibility. The thing is that those possibilities don't really convince me. I'm going to leave my vote on Tigs for the time being.

 

 

So, after all that reading, my vote is going along with Aemon and for the reasons I previously stated.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Tigs[/glow]

 

[Alanna]

 

Vote Count:

Talya (3) - Pete, Rose, Pookie

Tigs(3)- Aemon, Talya, Lily

 

Not Voting (2): Tigs, Lia

 

Deadline is Wednesday @ 2PM CST.

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

So Sis you are defending Talya why?

[Liathiana]

Sorry guys, the weekend was busy, I mainly just checked threads and read them, I didn't have time for many involved posts, especially in a game where I didn't have much to go on and thus, not much to say. Like Aemon said, I'm usually pretty quiet but I've been trying to change that.

 

Of the two players we have right now, I find [glow=red,2,300]Tigraine[/glow] to be more suspicious and I'd rather get a majority than a no lynch. I have to go to bed and tomorrow is my birthday, but I'll try and get on sometime tomorrow night or Wed to put up some reasoning. Mainly it's because I tentatively believe Aemon, he's thrown his support behind Tayla (linking them together in my mind a bit) and she did vote for Player.

 

Aemon, perhaps you should save your last ability until you have a target you're more sure of? There is no sense in wasting it if you don't have strong feelings/support for the kill. Because it *is* a kill and you're doing the Mafia's work for them when you kill an innocent. If you're thinking of nking me that is ;)

[aemonkristen]

I have strong feelings about a couple of players right now, but it all depends on who gets lynched and how they flip. Besides, I really don't want the doc to have to cover me tonight. Better that the doc do his own thing woth no pressure from us.

[Pookie]

Due to Tigraine being high on my suspicious list, I'll

[glow=red,2,300]unvote

Tigraine[/glow]

 

I'll atempt my reread later tonight, but feel more comfortable with Tigs at the moment due to some of the points folks who have played more with Talya are bringing up.

[Alanna]

Final Vote Count:

Talya (2) - Pete, Rose

Tigs (5) - Aemon, Talya, Lily, Lia, Pookie

 

Not Voting (1): Tigs

 

LYNCH REACHED.

 

Results coming up...

[Alanna]

Although the outlaws hadn't been able to agree on someone who might be a traitor before, this third day was different. Everyone seemed fueled by the death of Guy of Gisbourne, the Sherrif's righthand man, and pursued other traitors hidden amongst them with fervor. In the end, it was Little John who was decided to be most suspicious and, without even waiting to hear him defend himself, the rest of the outlaws killed him.

 

(Tigs) Little John, Innocent Outlaw, has been lynched.

 

It is now Night. You have until Wednesday, May 26 @ 11PM CST to get your night actions in. Get them in quickly, please! ;)

[aemonkristen]

well, I blew it on that one. I'm going to do a reread before making my decision for the final arrow.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

TALYA aemon, trust me.

 

 

[Talya]

Nothing like directing those with night actions Pete...Scared he might go for you again.

 

That sucks about Tigs though.

 

Yes, Lily I am a bit distracted, I'm supposed to be on semi LoA but in four games.. *sighs*

[LilyElizabeth]

So Sis you are defending Talya why?

 

I'm going to address this, even though I wasn't around this evening. I wish you would stop twisting people's words. I said that I couldn't see a reason for everyone to be so suspicious of her. In the whole game, there was one reason listed. Aemon has actually said he thinks she's innocent, but I don't see you asking him any questions. Bro, when you gun for someone this hard, you're the one who looks bad.

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Okay, I caught up with the rest of the posts. Guess we were wrong.

 

I'd rather trust Aemon's judgment with his kill. He's doing better than I did as vig...lol. At least he bagged one scum.

 

Pete, what is with you? You hate people guiding the vig's hand more than I do! I'm beginning to think you know something the rest of us don't.

 

[aemonkristen]

How many kills do you have Aemon?

I don't want to know on who, but are you planning on using it tonight?

Sorry guys, the weekend was busy, I mainly just checked threads and read them, I didn't have time for many involved posts, especially in a game where I didn't have much to go on and thus, not much to say. Like Aemon said, I'm usually pretty quiet but I've been trying to change that.

 

Of the two players we have right now, I find Tigraine to be more suspicious and I'd rather get a majority than a no lynch. I have to go to bed and tomorrow is my birthday, but I'll try and get on sometime tomorrow night or Wed to put up some reasoning. Mainly it's because I tentatively believe Aemon, he's thrown his support behind Tayla (linking them together in my mind a bit) and she did vote for Player.

 

Aemon, perhaps you should save your last ability until you have a target you're more sure of? There is no sense in wasting it if you don't have strong feelings/support for the kill. Because it *is* a kill and you're doing the Mafia's work for them when you kill an innocent. If you're thinking of nking me that is ;)

 

After doing a reread, these are the posts that stick out most in my mind. It looks like mafia trying to make sure I don't send out that last arrow until they get a chance to take me down I have sent in the PM for my final arrow. Because I am a firm believer in first come, first served, Pete gets it. He was the first of the two to try and find out how many arrows I had left and if I was going to use it tonight. Goodbye, Pete...Again.

[Tigraine]

Sorry guys, my 7 week old cousin has been in NICU...they can't figure out what is wrong with him and he's died at least 4 times and they kept working on him until they got him back. Thankfully he's out of NICU now, but they still don't know what's wrong with him.  Sorry I haven't been here.

 

And for the record, I have NEVER seen a person lynched without having the chance to defend themselves.  NEVER! Until now! :-\

[aemonkristen]

I hope he pulls through, Tigs.

 

I have seen it. It's even happened to me a time or two.  :D If it makes you feel any better, I now believe you are innocent.  ;D

[Pookie]

*hugs Tigs*  So sorry to hear about your cousin, but hopefully they'll figure things out soon and he won't have any more scares.  *sends healthy baby thoughts*

[Talya]

sorry to hear that Tigs, I hope everything turns out alright...thinking of you!

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Okay, I caught up with the rest of the posts. Guess we were wrong.

 

I'd rather trust Aemon's judgment with his kill. He's doing better than I did as vig...lol. At least he bagged one scum.

 

Pete, what is with you? You hate people guiding the vig's hand more than I do! I'm beginning to think you know something the rest of us don't.

 

 

Nothing is with me. I was actually gauging people by that remark.  :P

 

I want to see who would come up and defend Talya, if anyone did.  ;) You passed/failed depending on how you look at it.

[LilyElizabeth]

Sorry to hear that, Tigs. Sending love and positive thoughts your way.

 

Bro, just get it all out of your system quickly, if you have more to say. You'll be dead by morning, unless Aemon's faking out the mafia. And I still agree with him. If you survive, your scummy-looking butt is my vote tomorrow.

 

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

You forgot the sexy part before the scummy part.  :'(

 

Well Talya was my vote for yesterday game day. So I followed through with suggesting Aemon kill her to get reactions out of people. Then you spoke up defending Talya. Which in turn has raised my suspicions of you.

 

I hate anyone guiding any role, but people may make suggestions and opinions.