Lily's Dungeons & Dragons Mafia - the game - Congratulations, Town

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

All I have to add is I've been consistent, dpr you have floundered around and accused rose for day one randomness and then even said you believed me, then you flip and say I'm trying to cause a diversion. Good effort but, you've been found out. I am pretty sure I have narrowed the scum down and saying that has probably sealed the night kill on myself.

 

I am pretty sure aemon and David are innocent. David I'm about positive aemon I am about seventy percent in favor of his innocence. Dpr is giving me mafia vibes but tigs is pinging me as a sk, or maybe it is rose.

 

Just my opponion on the whole trying to live issue. That is an extremely selfish playstyle and anyone who does it should really feel bad. Survivors and sks are the only people who should worry about their own game life. All players should play with the team in mind whether it be an innocent or scum team, use everything to furhering your teams chances of winning. Use dead threads, roles, and whatever else you can. Like this game if I'd remain quiet I would stand a better chance of living but if I feel Ive found a scum so I played the hand I was holding.

[aemonkristen]

12 Players:

 

6 Townies

1 Cop

1 Doc

3 Mafia

1 Serial Killer

 

6 Townies

1 Cop

1 Doc

2 Mafia A

2 Mafia B

 

I got these from pandy's "everything you need to know" thread  http://forums.dragonmount.com/index.php/topic,44598.msg1368082.html#msg1368082 Sorry. Don't know how to change the name of the link, but there it is.

 

from the set ups common to a 12 player standard game, these are the only two that have a finder (cop) and a healer (doc). We did get 2 nightkills on day 1. I tend to think we are looking at a vig rather than two mafias. I do not think we have an SK in the game. Thought, ideas, opinions?

[DPR]

 

That's hysterical - Pandy's setup is overbalanced. heh

 

i'll be back.

[LilyElizabeth]

During the night, you had set watches, yet again, you did not see anything bad happen. However, that did not stop it from happening. As you all arise, Adella and DPR do not. You find a small dart with a black oily tip embedded in Adella’s neck – clearly the work of an assassin – and DPR’s throat was simply and cleanly cut.

 

Adella, Illusionist, with no extra powers, is dead

DPR, Druid, also with no extra powers, is dead

 

It is now day until Monday 8PM MST

 

With 7 alive, you need 4 to lynch

 

 

[Adella]

>:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:(

LAME!!!

[Tigraine]

2 kills again, man this sucks.

So they were both town?

[LilyElizabeth]

Yes, both town. Sorry. I just updated the OP, too. Somebody kick me when I forget, okay?

[aemonkristen]

I think we're dealing with 2 mafia (assassins guild) and 1 vig (no idea what character type he might be). adella's death was obviously assassin. Wes had his throat cut. Wes was the prime suspect for most people last night,as Amadine was on night 1. The vig is trying to help us and we keep choosing the wrong people. We need to choose correctly today and we need to help our vig choose correctly tonight. Only 5 townies left by my count. The numbers are getting too close for comfort. I'm going to do a reread and then post again, but I still think Rose looks suspicious for vote placement. More after the reread.

[David Hermes]

Pete,I TOLD YOU WES WAS INNOCENT! Man, just believe for once!

 

Here are the 6 players left: Me, Pete, Aemon, Tigs, mcs, and rose.

 

Who I think is innocent: Me(I know I'm innocent) ;D, Pete, Aemon and Tigs

 

Who I think is scum:mcs, and rose(far more likely than mcs)

 

Who I think is the vigilante: Tigs

 

By the way Lily 6 people are alive not 7.

So my [glow=red,2,300]vote is for rose[/glow].

Now vote for rose PLEASE! She is definitely scum, WITHOUT A DOUBT!

My hunches may not always right but I'm a damn sight better guesser than most people here.

[DPR]

 

Ba...*blood gurgles out of sliced throat"

[David Hermes]

*Closes the eyes of his good friend the Druid, and says a prayer of peace for the young Druid's soul. Then looks up at the rising sun,and watches the first morning rays illumine his friend's peaceful face and knows the Druid's death will not be in vain.*

[aemonkristen]

Just finished my reread and I have to agree with David that [glow=red,2,300]Rose[/glow] is my strongest suspect at the moment. I also have misgivings about Tigs, though it is possible she is the vig. Anyway, if we get it wrong today, it's up to the vig tonight to keep us going. The other mafia member, imo, is either Tigs or MCS.

 

 

EDIT:  Best bah post ever, Wes! You were trying to say "Rose", right?  ;D

 

Yep, Aemon i s right; the last mafia is Rose.  On day 1, when the lynch on Min ewas building, Min voted for David, then Rose, then Krak.

 

Those are your mafia.

 

Also, I don't think we're looking at an SK tonight - it would be too high-powered of a role for a 12 player game. (I figure David might be the Vig and got excited. R'm also wondering about Pete for a symp, but no matter...)

 

If I die, then it just makes tomorrow's lynch easier - Rose FTW!

 

We were all wrong about Krak, I think most of us are in agreement that David's playstyle right now indicates he is not recieving direction from anyone (putting him on my "least likely" list), and that only leaves Rose.

 

There was another death last night. SK or vig? I still think vig from the victims.

 

I agree with Wes, ROSE FTW!!

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

[glow=red,2,300]aemon[/glow]. What compelling information do you have other than dprs word that rose is scum?

 

David how did you know dpr was innocent? Are you scum and that way you know who the townies are?

[David Hermes]

Pete I'm not scum, I'm basing my votes totally on gut-instinct as I really have nothing else to go on. I felt that DPR was innocent and I was right so don't make that look scummy, ok.

I myself am not entirely certain that aemon is innocent(sorry aemon), but he is VERY LIKELY to be innocent; so all you're doing is killing off townies. Why don't you suspect rose like me and aemon do?

Also two people(me and aemon) have voted for rose so you're just making it difficult to lynch the right person. I think you should trust me and aemon on this one and vote rose. I want to make this clear as well, I could be totally wrong about rose so if we lynch her and ahe is actually innocent don't think I'm scum, because that would have been an honest mistake on my part.

Also, Vigilante, I suggest that you go after mcs; just my opinion. 

[aemonkristen]

What's the vote for, Pete?

[David Hermes]

Yeah, explain please.

[aemonkristen]

I'll mor you and post my reasons for voting Rose again, Pete. Looking at the day 1 voting (which is quite helpful, as we hit scum right off), the final count was:

 

David(4)- Min, Rose, Krak, Amadine

Min(7)- Aemon, Pete, Adella, DPR, David, Tigs, MCS

 

Not voting- Ed

 

due to an error none of us saw at the time, pete was always listed as having a vote of both David and Min. This gave us the false impression of Krak and Amadine balancing the votes. Back to Rose...When the Ed bandwagon was picking up some big momentum, Ed revealed. People started pulling votes off. Min and Rose were the first to pull off their votes and they both put their votes on David. Looks like mentor and mentee to me. It would be highly unlikely that there would be more than 1 mafia voting to lynch Min and since Krak and Amadine were both innocent, that leaves Rose. I am torn on who the last mafia is. I am sure it is either Tigs or MCS. It's either the L-1 or the Hammer position, and I'm leaning heavily toward the hammer. Can you refute my logic, Pete? Do you believe that the entire mafia team voted to off one of their own on Day 1? I find that unlikely.

[Tigraine]

I have no idea why everyone thinks I'm the Vig or Sk because I am not but oh well!

 

Anyway, I'm gonna have to do a re-read just to be able to figure out my list of suspects. I'm not doing the re-read right now cause I'm coloring eggs with my boys.  Probably some time tomorrow, I will be on here to contibute.

[LilyElizabeth]

Vote count:

Rose (2) – David, Aemon

Aemon (1) - Pete

 

Not voting – Tigraine, Rose, Mcs

 

With 6 alive (thanks, David!) you need 4 to lynch

 

 

[Tigraine]

Okay, after my re-read, the biggest thing that I noticed was DPR and Pete going back and forth.  I think it is possible that DPR getting killed in the night is the work of Pete.  Here's why...everyone will think it would be too obvious for Pete to have the mafia make the kill because of their bickering and everyone would think it was someone trying to set Pete up.  I think that is what Pete was counting on and could safely make the kill and be in the free on it.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Pete[/glow]

[aemonkristen]

I think for today Rose is our best bet, just based on the voting. Once we get rid of her and see what the night brings I'll take another look at Pete. I was actually starting to think Gambit from the both of them.

[mnwhiterose]

Why don't you suspect rose like me and aemon do?

Also two people(me and aemon) have voted for rose so you're just making it difficult to lynch the right person. I think you should trust me and aemon on this one and vote rose.  

 

Trust me.....Isn't that what the bad guy says before he gets you involved in a really horrible crime?

 

Difficult to lynch the right person. Again - disagree with you there. I don't think Pete's mafia, because I've seen this sort of back-and-forth between old mafia buddies before. They are either both mafia, or both innocent.

 

I will go for [glow=red,2,300]Aemon[/glow] to tie up the voting. He seems as likely a suspect as anyone. I really don't like the way David has gone after me since day one, considering I don't think I've said anything to lay suspicion at my feet. If I have, please correct me, David.

[David Hermes]

You're right rose, you haven't said anything suspicious, but I still have this strong feeling that you're mafia. If I'm wrong then I'll say sorry, but I won't know till you die, if you die.

[Tigraine]

On my re-read, I clearly missed what happened to make rose look suspicious.  Could someone please let me know?  I would like a good reason to unvote Pete and vote rose.

[David Hermes]

The only suspicious thing about rose is that she was part of the bandwagon on me earlier.

You see, Min, rose, Krak, and Amadine all voted for me. Krak and Amadine turned out to be innocent. DPR, aemon, Pete, and me suspect that there was another mafia apart from Min in that bandwagon, so ie rose is very likely to be mafia.

Another thing DPR said was that he doubted that all the mafia people were in the bandwagon on Min, so at least one mafia must have been in the bandwagon on me. This is further "proof" that rose is very likely to be mafia.