Shadow over Fiddlesmouth Game Thread [GAME OVER, TOWN WINS]

[mcs0083]

Quite so Alys. And in my mind there is a prime sewer of these seeds.

[glow=green,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]DPR[/glow]

And this stll applies to my reasoning in my last post because he is mostly spouting senseless jibber jabber.

 

But I'm town... end of story. There, now everybody can relax.

Its all relative. I'm pretty sure I'm not the only one who finds you less believable.

[Anoxanmore]

Well fine then,

 

[glow=red,2,300]mcs[/glow]

 

He hasn't said anything all game till now either, so that is a really scummy move.

[Quibby]

To alleviate the nagging feeling in the back of my head, I'm voting for [glow=red,2,300]Barm[/glow].  Like I said, I can't come up with a concrete reason for you, but there's something in his playing that's bothering me.

[mcs0083]

Well fine then,

 

[glow=red,2,300]mcs[/glow]

 

He hasn't said anything all game till now either, so that is a really scummy move.

All in good health I suppose ::) But I've been more active then you sweetheart.

[Anoxanmore]

I don't like being called sweetheart, which is even more scummy.

[Alys Kinch]

several things. i want to congratulate al, if he is still reading. he successfully targeted 2 cultists on day one. it is kinda weird.

 

second, i am tracking down a theory with my reread. kinda sucks though since it cements who i cannot find any trust in. my list of probables has only hit 2.

 

third. anox, that was so ridiculous it was not funny. you just voted mcs for doing what you have done and called him scum. sounds like you want to die since that is too obvious for a ploy.

 

quatro. i half agree with quibs  vote of barms; he is only here just enough. his posts seem shorter than norm, less helpful.

 

incidentally, quibs, did you steal from me day one? at the point i am at, it was you or barms.

 

panda, there appears to be more than one set. the set of three will help save us.

 

[glow=red,2,300]anox[/glow]

[Naeann]

I agree Alys.. and [glow=red,2,300]Anox[/glow]'s posts since Kivam's warning have still been nearly nothing and a OMGUS vote basically. 

 

Anox try a post that is more than one sentence.  Try for a few paragraphs telling us what you think so far and who you think is suspicious and the like.  Also.. a day 4 vote on someone for being as inactive as you(a scummy vote only fit for day one) is more scummy than him being as inactive as you.

 

If that doesn't make sense.. I haven't taken my meds yet today.

[Quibby]

No.  I haven't attempted to steal from anyone yet.

[Anoxanmore]

As someone has said before its a valid strategy and no one here has been able to ferret out anything else about anyone else.

 

You are more suspicious than anyone else Alys, beating around the bush and playing Aes Sedai trickery.

 

I have been reading the whole time and since Kivam's warning MCS has decided to show up as well.

 

So its split 50/50. :P

[DPR]

 

Alys? Are you playing Aes Sedai trickery again? *snickers*

 

I'm not really moved in any direction atm. I'm for getting everyone on the thread and talking - that way we can look for tells. I do have the feeling that this is not one of those games that will last for too many days, and I think we need to be looking at relics to find the damn vessel before its too  late.

[Alys Kinch]

anox has voted with no reason every time. i think she does not have time to play, but could be a ploy. still workin ;g on my other theory...

 

so check this out. i laughed so hard. remember the bandwagon scum argument? should be around pg 51 (i have 104 and my pages get 5 posts per). anyway, if you remember ...dsworn said he specifically finds most scum to be in vote spot 3-6 including those sppts. thorum pops up and agrees. he was voting al in spot... you guessed it... 5. thorums follows that statement by saying scum is never the hammer.

 

draw your own conclusions; i know i have a few more things to check out, but here is the final al count in kivam's order.

 

dpr, hybrid, pookie, quibby, thorum, lia, alys, ed, lav, barms (10/13).

[Alys Kinch]

yes, aes sedia trickery. sure. wanna see my trap?

 

taking a break from my reread. i am halfway through the thread and have several pages of hand written notes...

[DPR]

 

<<...>>...^^

[DPR]

 

And because I like to SPAM! I'll tell you a short story: I had a notebook I was taking notes in - was, mind you - but the baby boy has now learned how to tear the nipple away from the bottle and throw milk everywhere. Yeah, it's been that kind of week...

[Anoxanmore]

I have not voted with no reason, the first time was due to random.org and with pandy being so inactive, might as well vote him too.

 

I voted on thorum like everyone else for thinking he is scum, unvoted with everyone else, and yet he still turned scum.  I was wrong, so was everyone else. Till the Lav reveal anyway.

 

I didn't get a chance to vote on day 3... it happened so fast it had to be a relic or something.  So you can't use that one against me.

 

I haven't had a lot of time, I can't access DM at work unless I bypass the filter and that requires a lot of work to do. I wish that wasn't the truth but my work is putting up a fight :)

[Alys Kinch]

anox, rand.org is no reason in my book. and i do not think you read the thread clearly. thorum vote was a senseless bandwagon that started over a gender mistake. it just grew rapidly. so, no, i do not believe you felt he was scum.

 

in conclusion, still sticking with my assessment of you voting without a real reason every time.

[Alys Kinch]

ps pg 48ish is where my relic questions were. i know it was al who asked, but meh.

[Anoxanmore]

You didn't read my post very well, or at least comprehend it.

 

I said random.org voted for pandy, and with him being so inactive, he never challenged it.

 

I did jump on the thorum bandwagon, as did a lot of other people. I jumped off after we decided not to go through with it, which means everyone else who unvoted was wrong as well, not just me. I do not know how to make it more clearer than that.

 

Thusly [glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]. Half truths and pitiful answers get you no where [glow=red,2,300]Alys.[/glow]

 

 

[Alys Kinch]

random.org is not playing this game. using it to vote was lazy, but not too questionable on day one. thorum vote was a lazy join the bandwagon vote. day one, not terrible again. it is not wrong for day one to do these things, but you miss my point when i say you have voted the same all game including a day 4 vote on a player for a reason that colors you just as guilty. pot meet kettle.

 

the point is that it is day 4 and some of us expect a bit more reason behind votes than what you have presented. hence, my vote for you for lazy voting.

 

that said, i will reiterate that i am working on another player who has more issues than you, so calm down.

 

also, don't tell me what to do with my vote. i know full well what i am doing and none of this is spin or half truth, so enjoy.

[DPR]

 

Borrrrr-ing. meh

[Anoxanmore]

Then actually make a point instead of band-wagon-ing.

 

So far all you have done is talk, talk, and talk with nothing to show for it.

 

Your reputation preceded you and thus far I am completely disappointed. So until you have something firm, your half truths are definitely suspicious.

[Alys Kinch]

first, has anyone else voted you? if so, i missed it.

 

second, please explain the half truths you keep accusing me of. share your other reasons, thus far unposted, for voting those players. otherwise, it is a pretty damn true accusation. your defensiveness and inability to just say it was lazy only makes me feel it is a well placed vote.

 

and i don't care about my rep. i never agreed with it in the first place, so your taking a shot at it does not bother me.

[Alys Kinch]

dpr, talk to us about your suspicions?

[Anoxanmore]

You and Nae decided to jump on a bandwagon at the same time, which makes both of you suspect. 

 

However your lack of any real compelling evidence just makes you look that much more scummy. Nae could just be your lacky and that would explain it.

 

I'm talking about your circular logic round you had going to DPR for like four pages of you hinting at things but never voicing anything solid. In fact no one here STILL doesn't know what you are talking about. Which makes you even more suspect.

 

I voted for MCS originally due to him not in danger of being lynched, and he voted for me.  Since then he has unvoted me, then you and Nae jumped on the wagon. 

 

Therefore what appears scummy usually is, especially with such terrible reasons for voting for me to start with. Much like Barm did back 50 pages ago.

[Naeann]

One vote one someone isn't a bandwagon so your claim that Alys was "bandwagoning" on you is crazy.  It makes me content to leave my vote on you.  Also, so far, You have, without fail, attacked every one of the seasoned players and actually have gone so far as to insult their playstyle.  You did it to Barm and now you are doing it to Alys and I.  Make your point without slandering someone else's play style please.  We know what we are doing and know how to play ktxbai.

 

Tell me where either of us has shown a lack of evidence?  We are providing reasons for voting you.  Your reason for voting MCS was inactivity.  You were less active than he was.  Inactivity as a sole reason for voting on day 4 is scumtell.  How many more reasons would you like?

 

I'm not someones "lacky" I'm quite capapble of forming my own thoughts thanks.  I've been playing this game almost 3 years now.  I'm not the best player out there but I do know what I'm doing. ;)

 

I'm not going to pretend to understand anything about chthulu or the relics or anything.  That entire part of the game confuses me.  I do know we need to find the scum but that we can't even do that until we figure out this vessel thing or it won't matter if we find all the scum.

 

I can go find my "rant" about what "appears scummy" in this game if you like?  Frankly it boils down to EVERYTHING YOU DO IN THE GAME.  Everything will look scummy to someone.  If it doesn't the scum make it appear scummy to throw someone else on a lynch instead of themselves.  In other words... *hands Anox a captain obvious badge*