[DPR MAFIA] The Cannibal Wars - Talya, MN & Verbal win!

[ctm123456]

You now have a medical testing kit. Majority vote one person by voting in lime green, nad the kit will tell you if they are a zombie without killing them.

Can we only do 1 per phase or is it like the blue vote?

 

Selfishly, CTM

 

if we want to do Jvor first, that probably makes more sense ..

[Talya]

I take it we can test more than one person and it doesn't have a one time go attached to it?

[Naeann]

I do know Kivam is a neighbor.  I have NO idea of his alignment.  I was under the impression Kivam can talk to both of us and we can talk to him.. but not each other?

 

If this medical kit IS a one time deal we need to be very carful about who we choose.

[The Crusher]

I do know Kivam is a neighbor.  I have NO idea of his alignment.  I was under the impression Kivam can talk to both of us and we can talk to him.. but not each other?

 

If this medical kit IS a one time deal we need to be very carful about who we choose.

 

 

I think it makes sense to test who the majority feels they need to.

 

I'm not ready to kill him but I'll vote pacfor the med kit test.

[The Crusher]

I do know Kivam is a neighbor.  I have NO idea of his alignment.  I was under the impression Kivam can talk to both of us and we can talk to him.. but not each other?

 

If this medical kit IS a one time deal we need to be very carful about who we choose.

 

 

I think it makes sense to test who the majority feels they need to.

 

I'm not ready to kill him but I'll vote pacfor the med kit test.

 

 

OOPs.  unvote pac vote jvorfor medical testing

[Pac]

Selfishly, CTM

 

if we want to do Jvor first, that probably makes more sense ..

 

lol.  Are you hoping to send the message that of course you can't be cult because you lime green voted yourself?  hmm.

[mnwhiterose]

I say we test out [glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]. He has the most zombie lynch votes right now, so why don't we at least try to save him (if we can) or confirm our suspicions.

 

Of course, what could happen is that we test him, and if he is innocent, he could be recruited the next night by the Cult Leader.

[Talya]

I think it would be good to find out if we get a once only time before we just vote!

[ctm123456]

lol.  Are you hoping to send the message that of course you can't be cult because you lime green voted yourself?  hmm.

No, I'm hoping that the lime green vote, similiar to the blue vote can be used multiple times per day, and am volunteering to go first, since I supposedly exhibited a PR

 

if it can only be used 1 time, then JVOR or Pale is the right call since their rolled and much more likely to be zombified  

[ctm123456]

I think it would be good to find out if we get a once only time before we just vote!

I agree. The way it reads, I'm assuming we can use it multiple times..

[Talya]

So am I, but I would rather know for definate before hand than after!

[Talya]

ooops I forgot, will it show who is the Cult leader though or just the zombies?

[loki redfern]

well if i were wrong, lynching nae lose us a mason group, and lynching you, we would lose the neighbour role (without you ctm couldnt talk to nae could he?) and also if your on our side thats alot better for us. which leaves CTM. its 50/50 hes mafia even if im wrong unlike nae,

 

its just there is a .. 'fearful symetry' between you being able to talk to two people and the cult leader being able to recruit two people that night. if we left this to jvor, assuming he is the lie detector, then its possible that he would get targeted in the night and you could use the 'its obviously to frame me' defence, and i really couldnt wait that long without geting bored, so it seems to me that the best way to slay this tyger is lynching ctm

Why is it 50/50 I'm mafia?

 

... cos you could be mafia , you could be innnocent .. ..er i thought that was you know sorta ..well simple ...but heh, each to their own

 

wait ... if plae says he has no role and igor says thingyblob  um   then well someone is lieing, cos there is a vig out there, so my blue vote stays on igor (i have a vote on him right) lies = bad. especiallly stupid lies like that. and someone on the first mision is lieing.

 

thinking about it .. it makes more sence that kivam is lieing.

 

kivam says he can talk to two people off thread

the cult leader has the chance of recruiting two that night

 

 

now if kivam is the CL as y'all like to call it, then he probably didnt get the neighbour role, now, if pale truly doent have a role then kivam must have the vig role. i recon the best way to check would be to zombie lynch CTM. if CTM isnt a zombie then kivam is telling the truth and we have to look at jvor and pale. and i dont see why the vig should be trying to hide.

 

oh yea so [glow=blue,2,300]CTM[/glow]

ftr, I know he's a neighbor and not cult cause the mod notified me. I'm sure Nae can confirm as well..

 

by the Gods of the facepalm.

 

of course you  and nae can 'confirm' that kivam is a neighbour. because thats what you would say if he had recruited you.. seriously i know i may not be the best at making sence but if you got that much .. .  ok lets try again. with numbered mallet points. i says mallet instead of bullet in the hopes they will drive it home

 

1) kivam says he can talk to 2 people of the thread because of his role (i.e. you and nae)

2) dpr says cult had 2 chances to recruit

3)2=2?

4)say kivam is the cult leader he recruits you, and nae. you say he has neighbour role. you know cos your on his side

5)kolo?

 

 

also im with talya, i would like to know for definate, dpr can you tell us?

[Pac]

I agree. The way it reads, I'm assuming we can use it multiple times..

 

I would think it's a 1 time deal.  Seems like too much of advantage for us to be able to test every game day.

 

Now that I'm thinking about it it might be a good idea to test either Pale or Kiv.  If they come up clean I think that would strengthen the case agains JVOR while clearing one of them.

 

Do we have to test BEFORE night actions are over?  If so than wouldn't the CL simply recruit who we just cleared?

[Kivam]

I say we test out [glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]. He has the most zombie lynch votes right now, so why don't we at least try to save him (if we can) or confirm our suspicions.

 

Of course, what could happen is that we test him, and if he is innocent, he could be recruited the next night by the Cult Leader.

 

This. I'm totally behind this.  Why would anyone think this wasn't the right play?

 

[glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]

[Naeann]

 

"Found one! It's one of the last testing kits from the hospital!"[/i]

 

You now have a medical testing kit. Majority vote one person by voting in lime green, nad the kit will tell you if they are a zombie without killing them.

 

 

 

Emphasis is in blue.  I think it's a one shot.

[Smash]

[glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]

[Kivam]

wait ... if plae says he has no role and igor says thingyblob  um   then well someone is lieing, cos there is a vig out there, so my blue vote stays on igor (i have a vote on him right) lies = bad. especiallly stupid lies like that. and someone on the first mision is lieing.

 

thinking about it .. it makes more sence that kivam is lieing.

 

kivam says he can talk to two people off thread

the cult leader has the chance of recruiting two that night

 

 

now if kivam is the CL as y'all like to call it, then he probably didnt get the neighbour role, now, if pale truly doent have a role then kivam must have the vig role. i recon the best way to check would be to zombie lynch CTM. if CTM isnt a zombie then kivam is telling the truth and we have to look at jvor and pale. and i dont see why the vig should be trying to hide.

 

oh yea so [glow=blue,2,300]CTM[/glow]

ftr, I know he's a neighbor and not cult cause the mod notified me. I'm sure Nae can confirm as well..

 

by the Gods of the facepalm.

 

of course you  and nae can 'confirm' that kivam is a neighbour. because thats what you would say if he had recruited you.. seriously i know i may not be the best at making sence but if you got that much .. .  ok lets try again. with numbered mallet points. i says mallet instead of bullet in the hopes they will drive it home

 

1) kivam says he can talk to 2 people of the thread because of his role (i.e. you and nae)

2) dpr says cult had 2 chances to recruit

3)2=2?

4)say kivam is the cult leader he recruits you, and nae. you say he has neighbour role. you know cos your on his side

5)kolo?

 

 

also im with talya, i would like to know for definate, dpr can you tell us?

 

Sorry, Loki - but I think this may be the silliest argument I've ever seen.  If I'm the Cult leader and Nae and CTM are my zombie minions, why in the world would I announce to anyone that I can talk to them off thread?

 

Not to mention the fact that I threw the people listed up for vote, and did that after the Cult Leader's first recruiting chance had finished.  (in other words, you all could have voted "Loki and Pac" and that's who I would have selected).  If the Neighbor role was a lie and I was just covering for Zombie talk (though, like I said above, that theory is crazy because there was no need to say anything at all if I were CL), then if you all had picked anyone different I'd have been dead.

 

Kolo?

 

BTW, this is exactly the type of Mafia obfuscation that got DSage pinched.  Were you in on that lynch?  Anyone want to go check?

 

[glow=red,2,300]unvote

Vote Loki[/glow]

[Naeann]

I'm only for giving JVOR that benefit if he's actually gonna start being around again.  I'd rather SAVE someone who is gonna be active.

 

 

Erm... Kivam?  It's night. ;)

[ctm123456]

This. I'm totally behind this.  Why would anyone think this wasn't the right play?

 

[glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]

Don't like this.. First off, we don't even know if this is a one shot deal or not, yes so why are we rushing to use it up?

 

Also I know for a fact that you are a "lynch the most guilty, investigate the most innocent" type of guy. I'd imagine you'd want to lynch me or Jvor and test yourself/pale/nae..

 

[Pac]

[glow=limegreen,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

 

Shouldn't we wait to see if we can do this once the day starts?  If anything it might give the CL pause before putting in his recruitment request tonight.

[ctm123456]

Emphasis is in blue.  I think it's a one shot.

If it's a one shot deal it should be saved.. Using it now only means the person we test it on will be converted tonight..

 

FOS anyone voting to use this before we know the deal

[glow=limegreen,2,300]

unvote[/glow]

[Kivam]

This. I'm totally behind this.  Why would anyone think this wasn't the right play?

 

[glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]

Don't like this.. First off, we don't even know if this is a one shot deal or not, yes so why are we rushing to use it up?

 

Also I know for a fact that you are a "lynch the most guilty, investigate the most innocent" type of guy. I'd imagine you'd want to lynch me or Jvor and test yourself/pale/nae..

 

 

Normally, that's how I's think.  But JVoR's role changes things.  He's claimed the lie detector role.  If he's not a Zombie, then he can test "I am not the Cult Leader" posts and we can believe his answers.  I'd save the kit for use in the morning, so we can be sure he won't be zombified overnight, but he's got to be the target, we can't just kill him.

[Smash]

[glow=limegreen,2,300]Unvote JVOR[/glow]

 

As scummy as JVOR has acted do we really need to waste a lime green vote on him ? My vote stays Blue on JVOR I would rather use the Lime green vote at a later date and not waste it on someone I feel very strongly needs to go. 

 

 

[Smash]

This. I'm totally behind this.  Why would anyone think this wasn't the right play?

 

[glow=limegreen,2,300]JVOR[/glow]

Don't like this.. First off, we don't even know if this is a one shot deal or not, yes so why are we rushing to use it up?

 

Also I know for a fact that you are a "lynch the most guilty, investigate the most innocent" type of guy. I'd imagine you'd want to lynch me or Jvor and test yourself/pale/nae..

 

 

Normally, that's how I's think.  But JVoR's role changes things.  He's claimed the lie detector role.  If he's not a Zombie, then he can test "I am not the Cult Leader" posts and we can believe his answers.  I'd save the kit for use in the morning, so we can be sure he won't be zombified overnight, but he's got to be the target, we can't just kill him.

 

What do we stand to gain by Keeping JVOR alive overnight ? Hes claimed Lie Detector and already missed his chance to do the town good and try to find a liar by not being here during the last night phase. Now he has dissapeared again and you want to give him yet another chance and waste a green vote as well. Come on, hes lieing about the lie detector role, or hes a zombie, or hes just a terrible town player doing us no good at all.