Death Note Mafia! Game On!

Thorum · May 9, 2009

I don't have time to search who these are right now; but Jeran is Near, and Whiterose is Mello.

Both with 50% certainty

ChronoCrosS · May 9, 2009

I was suspicious of CUBA, but now...

I'll have to look over the thread to see who was accusing who.

Jeran · May 10, 2009

With Thorum's information that makes Kira 1 of 2 people - DSage or Talya.

The only people I hadn't confirmed as innocent were Whiterose, DSage and Talya. My findings are 100%.

Chrono: From what I read in the Death Note Wiki I'm wondering if you can confirm that Whiterose is Mello?

Whiterose: If you are Mello do have any investigation results you can share to narrow down who is Kira? (I'm assuming Mello would have cop power.)

Liathiana · May 10, 2009

Very interesting, I want to hear what Thorum and Whiterose have to say

Talya · May 11, 2009

Thorum's info actually doesn't discount Jeran nor Whiterose. 50% chance of being right aren't particularly good odds.

However, I know I'm not Kira, so if Jeran is right, then Dsage is Kira.

But we can only trust him if Thorum was 100% right with his view.

From what I can tell, there are at least 4 factions here.

1. Kira's,

2.L's team (near and Mello if correct could be opposing each other),

3. Thorum's team (forgotten his name) :-\

4. Those with a second death note.

Damn I've run out of time.

Will come back to this

mnwhiterose · May 11, 2009

I have no cop abilities. Just another innocent.

Jeran · May 11, 2009

Thorum's info actually doesn't discount Jeran nor Whiterose. 50% chance of being right aren't particularly good odds.

However, I know I'm not Kira, so if Jeran is right, then Dsage is Kira.

But we can only trust him if Thorum was 100% right with his view.

From what I can tell, there are at least 4 factions here.

1. Kira's,

2.L's team (near and Mello if correct could be opposing each other),

3. Thorum's team (forgotten his name) :-\

4. Those with a second death note.

Damn I've run out of time.

Will come back to this

I have a couple of points about this post.

First: Talya, you seem to feel that everything hinges on Thorum's viewings. I am a 100% so how come you are basing your argument on Thorum's findings? By your own argument you can trust me because I am 100%. Furthermore Thorum agreed that I am Near. (Maybe I am reading your post wrong?)

**General Question** If Thorum is 50% doesn't that mean he has 50% chance of getting a result rather than a 50% chance of getting it right. I asked this many pages ago but it was not clearly answered. **

Second: I think using the word "factions" is too strong. "Groups" might be a better word. My win condition is that I win when the threat of Kira is eliminated - not when Kira and all other groups/factions are eliminated. Others have stated something similar (I think it may have been CUBA but I'm not sure) but it was many pages ago and don't want to try and find it. I believe that there is only the threat of Kira/Kira's group. In the story there were more than 1 group working towards the elimination of Kira.

Third: Since there has only been one death at night every night since the first and there has only been the one day death there doesn't seem to be any threat from a second Death Note. If there was one, maybe that character is dead already.

Since I am a 100% finder the only possibilities are DSage, Talya and mnwhiterose. The only possible catch is that findings give only a name. I still have to read on Death Note Wiki to see what that character did. The character names I have found so far seem pretty clear cut that they are working against Kira. Since there is some evidence that mnwhiterose may be innocent I'm still looking at DSage and Talya. Although, I would like to hear from ChronoCrosS to answer my earlier question to him which could help clear mnwhiterose or even someone else.

Jeran · May 11, 2009

I have no cop abilities. Just another innocent.

Does this mean you are not Mello?

Talya · May 11, 2009

I had just done some stuff for the Light faction in the BT, hence I used factions. The reason I'm saying about Thorum is that he says you are Nero, but he is on;y 50% sure. I thought it was they only had a 50% sure of being right. So if he is wrong about you, how do we know that what you are saying is 100% right. And that hinges on Thorum being who he said he is, which I think was verified by you, so that would be a quandary wouldn't it.

As there are no Coroner findings in this game, it make's it very hard to prove or disprove people, unfortunately.

As for the deaths. I have played in a game where there were two factions/groups (the word makes no difference ::) ) and each side had kill every other night. I believe there were a few killings the first night, but I think it was worked out that one was because Light died and the other a death note, and the third a vig kill. Don't forget Mynd was killed the first day, though I have suspicions he choose to written out of it, or maybe he was Mod killed.. :-\

I find it odd that Whiterose questioned about it being a Kira kill, would it be anything else, games I have been in a vig usually has one kill. But why they used it early on I don't know. If she is Mello then why doesn't she say so. I would have thought Mello and Nero would have had the same skills. Unless That is a viewing that was wrong.

I'm not saying that you aren't Nero, but we can't take it all on blind faith.

Mod do we have a time limit!

Jeran · May 11, 2009

I find it odd that Whiterose questioned about it being a Kira kill, would it be anything else, games I have been in a vig usually has one kill. But why they used it early on I don't know. If she is Mello then why doesn't she say so. I would have thought Mello and Nero would have had the same skills.

To be honest I am wondering the same things.

mnwhiterose · May 11, 2009

I am Mello. But, I do not have any "cop" abilities as stated in the rules. I am not a finder.

The reason I questioned the latest night kill was because it stood out to me. I have not read a lot about Death Note, so I did not know that Kira could "suicide" a person. Dumb ignorance on my part.

Talya · May 13, 2009

This is going on a bit too long, I know Leelou is waiting to start her game!

I will go for [glow=red,2,300]Dsage[/glow], based on what has been said above and that he is really really quite more than anyone else I think.

Thorum · May 13, 2009

Furthermore Thorum agreed that I am Near. (Maybe I am reading your post wrong?)

Let's call it 50% wrong. You are 50% sure Near.

**General Question** If Thorum is 50% doesn't that mean he has 50% chance of getting a result rather than a 50% chance of getting it right. I asked this many pages ago but it was not clearly answered. **

The second.

[glow=red,2,300]DSage[/glow]

For the why, you can read Talyas last post ;D

MsDanya · May 13, 2009

DSage (2): Talya, Thorum

Not voting:

Lia, CUBAREY, DSage, Chrono, Jeran, Whiterose

8 people alive, 6 to vote!

(I think I got that right!)

Jeran · May 13, 2009

CUBA's out of the game now, so just 7 people left.

Jeran · May 14, 2009

I'm pretty much 50/50 on the two choices so I'll go for [glow=red,2,300]DSage[/glow] too.

Liathiana · May 15, 2009

Agreed with what has been said. [glow=red,2,300]DSage[/glow]

ChronoCrosS · May 15, 2009

Well, since no one else will prolly get lynched, vote [glow=red,2,300]DSage[/glow]

mnwhiterose · May 15, 2009

Since are no other options at this point - [glow=red,2,300]DSage[/glow]

ChronoCrosS · May 15, 2009

Well THAT wasn't a bandwagon...

Thorum · May 16, 2009

the question is: WHO is bandwagonning...

ChronoCrosS · May 16, 2009

Indeed...

*ponders*

Talya · May 17, 2009

that looks like a lynch to me, where is the Mod?

mnwhiterose · May 21, 2009

Did our game die? Has anyone heard from Danya lately?

Thorum · May 21, 2009

On her personal site:

Last Active: May 17, 2009, 01:39:13 AM

Death Note Mafia! Game On!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook