Dirty Cops Mafia - GAME OVER!!!

[Talya]

I have told him before, it is something you are not allowed to do!

[Jeran]

Before I jump in with a Finding vote...Mod are we able to unvote the finding votes?

 

This is an odd question to ask.  I'm sure you can, but why would you want to?

 

At the moment there are only 2 choices.  What if someone comes along with a better sales pitch?  Seems pretty obvious to me.

[mcs0083]

So I'm not allowed to change my vote? :-\ I forgot the glow the first time anyway before you saw it. I did forget to unvote though. :-[

[peacesells]

vote [glow=green,2,300]Catina[/glow]

 

[Thorum]

Mynd, I wanted a green vote for someone both active and lesser-likely to be maffia (for now and subjectively).

 

Obviously no green vote for you because my red vote is on you. I'm sure you'ld LOVE that.

 

Oh, I'm going to sleep now :D

 

If someone gives me a posting hole

 

mcs, you are not allowed to edit a post. Changing a vote is in a separate post

 

To save you all the trouble, I have compiled and commented upon all of Verbal's posts. To use or disuse as you want.

 

Or read the short story: he kept his vote on Mynd all the time, and had a small accusation-like post on Barmy

 

 

 

Read & understood.

 

What's with all the votes right off the bat?  I know this isn't a vanilla mafia game, sooooo........I'll join the fun and place a vote.

 

Mynd

 

The game will be confusing enough with all the findings - getting rid of a muddler like Mynd will only help us, lol.

 

Good point :D

 

lol - the last time I was teamed with cosmicpanda, it didn't turn out so well.  Right Danya?  Wink

 

All metagaming aside (it is bad bad), you are correct, Mynd.  Voting you was not random - it was strategic.

 

Wow.  All I see are bandwagons, revenge voting, and hypocrisy.  Who's the hypocrite?  Mynd.  Here's how:

 

Quote from: Myndrunner on March 17, 2009, 10:02:31 PM

Hmmmm....now this is interesting.   Now he is dodging my accusations!  He was so quick to find out who I caught revealing themselves, but now that he knows I was bluffing and pointed fingers at him, he has backtracked.  Methinks I smell SCUM!

 

Uh, you were the one dodging accusations, Mynd.  DJ called you out for your little "bluff", and you backtracked by calling it exactly that.  Now you say he's dodging your accusations and backtracking?  Kettle, meet pot.  Wink

 

My vote stays.

 

Quote from: Myndrunner on March 18, 2009, 07:07:22 PM

WHOA!  Thorum, what is this all about?!

 

Mynd, read Thorum's sig.

 

Quote from: Myndrunner on March 18, 2009, 07:07:22 PM

Catina, was your vote on Danya random or coordinated?

 

Huh?  What do you think she is going to say?  "Yes, it was coordinated, Mynd.  My mafia buddy Thorum PMed me and told me to vote Danya.  Is that a problem?"

 

Roll Eyes

 

You're protecting Thorum a bit. I don't know what to conclude from that, but I'm quite sure some here can.

 

Normally, I would actually agree more with Danya, as I dislike voting on Day 1 as well.  However, this is not a typical vanilla mafia game, so I'm ok with voting on Day 1 - I just don't make it random.  I voted Mynd for a reason, and that reason will not change unless proof is delivered that he is innocent.

 

Of course, in the effort to actually get a majority as opposed to a random lynch, my prior statement flies right out the window and I'd switch my vote for only that reason.  Smiley

 

Important one

 

Hehehe...no, it won't.  Wink

 

mcs, I'm not sure - are you attacking Thorum or Danya?

 

Ok, nevermind then.  I must have misunderstood your post.

 

Quote from: Myndrunner on March 20, 2009, 07:38:57 AM

Dark Justice, on the other hand, I'm not sure exactly what the reason behind his vote was.  Same with MCS.

 

Are you conveniently forgetting that I was the first to vote you, and haven't changed my vote once?  You address both DJ and mcs, but ignore my vote?  Did I perhaps have a point when I voted for you?  Wink

 

Maybe.

 

/ranton

 

I gotta say this - who started the movement of calling mafia "scum"?  I know, I know, the site mafiascum does it - but we never did here until a few months back.  I want to know who's responsible for this...this...travesty....this sham....this mockery......this travestshamockery!

 

I'm gonna kick him or her in the shins.  Angry

 

/rantoff

 

Geesh...you people really banged on the keyboards since yesterday afternoon, lol.

 

To answer something previously said about me:

 

No, I don't have a vendetta against Mynd.  Barm, you said my argument was "reasonable", but then question me?  That doesn't make sense to me....I'm not reading other posts?  Of course I am....I just voted for the person who was most likely to be mafia in my opinion.

 

And if somebody gets a mafia read, unfortunately it doesn't mean they are correct.  DSage said there would be wrong answers...

 

Real comments on Barmy...

 

CUBAREY, I'm not trying to be a pain here, but could you use the quote function instead of the bolding?  Information is key here, and we can better see who or what you are referring to when you actually quote them.  Thanks!

 

Really important one, CUBA.

[Toy and Minion]

You can change your vote at any time on either Ballot.  What Talya was refering to actually means that once a vote has been place on you in the FB, you (the nominee) cannot take yourself off - at least until all votes are taken off again.

 

For example, now that Catina has a vote on her in the FB, she cannot remove herself from the FB.

[mcs0083]

Ok

Thanks D :)

[Myndrunner]

And Thorum, I can't see Cantina being the obvious reasons. She doesn't post until as soon as Dsage posts his night over. Maybe she was wanting to get that in early to make us believe she has a true viewing, when she doesn't at all but is mafia. Just a thought by the way. Not saying that is the case. But she can just as likely be having as on as Mynd could be.

 

How is this any different than what I have been doing all game?  Mrs. Pot? Hello, I am Mr. Kettle. 

 

MCS is a lying liar who lies, but I am reluctant to vote to lynch him at this time.  I don't trust my viewing because my gut is telling me something very different right now.

[mcs0083]

How am I being a liar Mynd? What did I say to make you feel this way?

[Toy and Minion]

Finding Ballot

 

Catina (3): Thorum, Mcs, peacesells

 

Myndrunner (0)

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 votes to Reveal.

 

Lynching Ballot

 

Myndrunner (1): Thorum

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 votes to Lynch.

 

Day 2 ends Thrusday 2 at 3:00 PM (MST)

 

[Talya]

mcs, I could have sworn you had glowed your vote for Mynd for the ballot and you had written about how it sounded interesting. Which is why I say what I did with my first post after that! So not only have you changed your vote in that edit, but you changed what you have written. So putting in there you had edited because you forgot the glow, is a lie! Simples.

 

Have you just been told to change your vote to Cantina. Mynd I may have said that about Cantina, but if mcs was instructed to change his vote then he could be in it with Cantina.

 

Mrs Pot over! ;)

[mcs0083]

Well I forgot to say unvote :(

[Talya]

You haven't changed your other votes on the first day by editing, so why did you then. You can see why it is suspicious and we don't have it on the game! If you have to double or triple post, but DON'T EDIT! at all, never, ever, zilch, not even for spelling. :)

[Myndrunner]

How am I being a liar Mynd? What did I say to make you feel this way?

 

You pretended that the only reason you edited your post was because you forgot to glow it; however, when you were called out, you feigned ignorance.  The fact is you knew it was a violation and you did it anyway.  You lied to us, and therefore are a lying liar who lies.

 

Quite frankly, I don't need you all to vote for me to reveal my findings.  The coroner report on MCS will reveal all the info I need to know.  I am quite confident that I am either the Naive or Crazy Cop, but his coroner report will confirm it.    

 

...and Mrs. Pot might be right.  Catina shows up out of the blue after being barely active all game?  Someone told MCS to change his vote to Catina, he just wasn't that slick about it.

[Myndrunner]

I vote [glow=green,2,300]Catina[/glow]

 

*edited because I forgot the glow*

 

The fact that your initial reason for the edit was that you forgot the glow when you knew you were changing your vote makes your argument complete bullshanks!

 

[glow=red,2,300]MCS[/glow]

 

His coroner report will tell me what I need to know about myself, and we are going to lynch a lying liar who lies while we are at it. 

[CUBAREY]

MCS is a lying liar who lies, but I am reluctant to vote to lynch him at this time.  I don't trust my viewing because my gut is telling me something very different right now.

 

Picking on a newbie for a dumb mistake is easy meat. Now if you could actually say something that might convince us you are not just blowing hot air?

 

 

Catina can you legally tell us who you viewed?

[mcs0083]

I never nominated myself for the finders ballot >:(

Thorum did ::)

 

How am I being a liar Mynd? What did I say to make you feel this way?

 

You pretended that the only reason you edited your post was because you forgot to glow it; however, when you were called out, you feigned ignorance.  The fact is you knew it was a violation and you did it anyway.  You lied to us, and therefore are a lying liar who lies.

I pretended and I knowingly made a violation? I think not. And why in the world would you vote to lynch me when off of the grounds of my info when I didn't even nominate myself? Either you are just ignorant or trying to cause chaos.

[Talya]

Mr kettle, you'd best not agree with me, we will be accused of being in cohorts!  :D

 

Of course an Idea could be to vote for Cantina to reveal her findings and then lynch her afterwards. That way it will show what her viewing means and may help give us an idea about mcs too!

 

Cubrey, It wasn't a mistake, I had already picked mcs up for editing on day one and he even acknowledged what I said. And then goes and does it again. Once as a newbie he can be excused. But twice after being told (and I think Dsage might have said something too) is a little too much even for a newbie!

 

MCS no one said you did nominate yourself you vote for Mynd and it was glowed green before you edited and changed your vote!

[Myndrunner]

MCS, from the start of this game, you have been acting scummish.  You have been flip-flopping your votes for the silliest of reasons.  You vote to lynch me because someone said I was a treacherous player, but you fail to explain how you heard this until much later in the game.

 

Because you lied in your post about only editing because you forgot to glow, how can me or anyone take anything you say as truth?

 

I could be a Naive Cop who always gets an innocent viewing or I could be a Crazy Cop who gets the opposite viewing.  I am definitely not the Paranoid Cop.  If I am the Normal Cop, then I may have found an innocent who looks scummier than I am. 

[mcs0083]

and your basing this off of me making a newbie mistake? That is all it was. I wasn't thinking. It has nothing to do with deception.

[CatinaSedai]

oh please.  myndrunner. he made a newbie mistake thats all.  you are blowing this all out of praportion. i am starting to think that maybe both you and talya have been faking an arguement this whole time.  what is it called? the kivams gambat?  you of all people dont want me to reveal my findings.  

[Myndrunner]

Catina, you show up out of the blue and suddenly are very active?  You have posted more in the last 30 minutes than you have the rest of the game?  I'm thinking that you and MCS might be in cohoots here. 

 

And Newbie mistake or not, he lied.  Lying is not a newbie mistake, that's a scum tell. 

[mcs0083]

My thoughts exactly Caitina. Mynd and Talya could be faking an argument to throw everyone off. If this is the case it seems like a scummy tactic. Are Mrs.Pot and Mr.Kettle the dumb code names you came up with? ::)

[Myndrunner]

*facepalms*

 

Ever hear of the expression the Pot calling the Kettle Black?  I'm beginning to suspect that the Mafia are Larry, Moe, and Curly....with maybe Shep as the Symp.  ::)

[mcs0083]

Of course I have. :-\ And that would be the perfect argument platform for the two of you to stage would it not?