Jump to content
We have a Patreon! Support this website and get exclusive content ×

DRAGONMOUNT

 A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

Create-a-Role Mafia Game Thread: Game Over!

cosmicpanda

By cosmicpanda
in DM Mafia Games

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 397
  • Created
  • Last Reply
cosmicpanda Spam Master

cosmicpanda

Posted
  • Author
Posted

oh, and another Mod Note:

 

The various talk threads will be revealed after the game. So, now's your chance to clean them of any content you don't want the world at large to see.

DPR Spam Master

DPR

Posted
Posted

 

I've beat the Mynd drum to death and have been really clear about the connection I see between him and Talya.

 

So I'm going to throw out my other ideas about what's happening because I don't have high hopes of living through the night.

 

*Thorum, who is now Barm: The only reason anyone would suggest that a finder be killed is if they were mafia and they knew that they had been found.  That's it.  It looks like he might have had a role that lets him know if he has have been viewed or not. I think that Thorum/Barm is likely the mafia that was supposed to lay low, and got viewed. With nothing to lose, why not go for a "rogue finder" theory?

 

*This is bad news for Barm, becuase he got whacked before and I am still not convinced that he was mafia at all. I've looked up and down through the roles and I can't see any way that a bluff like that would have worked for him. If he was mafia and he knew he was going to die, then he would have tried to add collateral damage to the mix. Barms is by far smart enough to take someone else with him by making it look like they were partners, or something to that effect.

 

* Lia being a "Vote Giver" bothers me more. If that means she could give a vote, then that would explain why Barm died on 7 instead of 8. And if it was a silent vote, that that would almost certainly make her mafia. Which points to the question: Why do we have "Rainbow Mafia" and "Nearly Vanilla Townies"?  The names are obviously intended to make the mafia sound harmless, and the townies sound suspicous. What if Pandy has switched the alignments that we were given? That would explain Barm: The mafia would have known that he was not one of them and they would have benefited from kiling him.  But that would mean that a vig hit Lia, and that would mean that other players know a lot more than they are sharing.

 

We really need to hear from Moggy, Dae and Barm. Come on out and play folks, we're losing daylight.

Myndrunner Grand Master

Myndrunner

Posted
Posted

I think I know why Moggy isn't talking, but more on that later.  I would like to hear from Barmy, the go-to stand-in, since he has been able to look at this game from two perspectives.  What was the truth behind the Miller deal?

Barmacral Spam Master

Barmacral

Posted
Posted

As pandy has stated, I cannot say anything about the miller situation. As a result, I will not be saying anything about it.

 

As for my current position, first I'm going to [glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow], since I think the vote is still on Dark Justice.

 

I don't know why Thorum voted the way he did, there is absolutely no logical sense behind it, and all it did was make him look suspicious. Unfortunately this makes me look suspicious, which is bad since I'm an innocent.

 

As for how the game goes... I'm suspicious of Talya right now, DPR is making some very good points, and is directing his ire at Mynd, and Mynd is retaliating, none of this is unusual, but Talya is blowing all of DPR's points off by saying that he's been spouting fluff. I'm sorry Talya, but I don't see how any of what he is saying is just fluff that he's been throwing out there. He's been saying the same few points all along, and you're just blatantly ignoring him I think.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote: Talya[/glow]

Talya Spam Master

Talya

Posted
Posted

Barm, sorry but that is not true. DPR hasn't come up with anything against me at all. He has accused me of being Mafia with Mynd, sorry not true! thats all I can say to that. I have had my own thoughts about DPR and he hasn't really addressed tham. He say things like he was the one trying to prevent on your lynch, but there he went and put the last vote on. Now he says that Lia was Mafia beacuse she was a vote giver? That sounds to me like she gives her vote to someone not votes twice. I put it too him that she gave her vote to him. After supposedly trying to get everyone to not vote his vote kills you (the other you).

 

Now you come back and vote for me. We have 15 hours (minus whatever it maybe now) and you try to start a new lynch. You are working with DPR simple. Why else would you go for someone not voted this close to the final day. You don't want a lynch, at least not one unfavourable to you. Thorum probably voted DJ to get the heat away from DPR.

 

So come up with something substantial I can reply to otherwise I'm not going to bother.

 

So Mynd why is Moggie quiet and hoe would you know!

Myndrunner Grand Master

Myndrunner

Posted
Posted

What specifically do you agree with DPR on, Barmy? You say he has made some very good points.  Why not cite them specifically, please? 

 

Talya, Moggy was allowed to communicate with me when I was silent, but that ended when I was released from whatever it was that had me silent.  Now, DJ has gone silent and unlike Thorum, he has not been replaced.  There has not been a public MOD warning to him either, so I am inclined to believe that DJ is very much in play but silenced.  Moggy is likely communicating with him like she did with me. 

 

I have more to say, but I want to hear from Barmy now.  What specific points did DPR make that you agree with?

DPR Spam Master

DPR

Posted
Posted

 

Gotcha.

 

Mynd says that he and Moggy were communicating while he was silenced. That would make him mafia or a mason - right?

 

Well, if he were a mason, Moggy would not have messed up the Barm vote, would she? Because they would have talked about that plan before he launched it.

 

Of course, if they were mafia, then they would have planned for her to vote for Barm.

 

*When I asked Mynd why he did not want to revise his plan, he did nothing - because I hit on exactly what he wanted to do!

*If Moggy was in contact with DJ, she ould tell us his findings!

*Given that Verbal was a confirmed Mason, that would make 4 Masons in a 12 person game - NO WAY PANDY WOULD LOAD THE GAME LIKE THAT!

 

Hear all those alarms? THAT"S THE SCUMDAR RINGING!!!!

 

Talya, I have no idea where you fit into this, but you are totally ignoring my posts. You're probably the Symp...

 

 

 

Talya Spam Master

Talya

Posted
Posted

i thought whats he called was the symp, when DJ outed him and we lynched him. I doubt there would be two symps in one game that would be odd.

 

I'm not ignoring you DPR, I just don't know what I'm supposed to answer too. You have accused me of being Mafia, and I have said I'm not. what more do you want me to say.

Barmacral Spam Master

Barmacral

Posted
Posted

 

This is getting crazy - just so everyone is clear, this is where I stand:

 

1. Do not kill the finder - I have no idea what the logic is behind Thor's suggestion, but as long as the healer covers the finder at night, we should be cool. If he's silenced, then fine. Buit he is still finding, and as soon as the one silencing him is lynched, we'll get all of that info. We don't even know if he has been silenced - he could have just not posted yet. Sheesh.

 

2. Do not reveal what roles you sent in to Pandy - It does nothing but help the mafia figure out who is who and what powers they have. Lia died because she shared her info and made herself a target. Mynd chooses to ignore this fact even though I have pointed it out numerous times.

 

3. Do not be thrown off track by weird logic! - Every time we go down that road, the mafia wins. If we stick to straight forward information gathering, we will out the scum.

 

My vote stays on Mynd and Thorum looks to be first on my list for tomorrow.

 

 

There you got it, his 3 points.

 

Tayla, I Never said he made anything against you, I said you were ignoring what he said. I am not working with DPR, plain and simple. I'm going after the person that I feel is the most suspicious in this game. I disagree with your DPR lynch. As for there being a limited amount of time left in the day, really, what does it matter? All the active players amount to you, me, DPR and Mynd, and we're all here playing.

 

Now, your turn to come up with something substantial.

Myndrunner Grand Master

Myndrunner

Posted
Posted

The Moggy and Me communication thingy only took place while I was silenced.  It was quite useless actually since I did most of the talking, Moggy just quietly sipped her tea and nodded.  She didn't reveal anything about her character, almost to a point of playing coy....but I digest...

 

With Pandy's comment about how all the side threads will be revealed at endgame, I hasten to believe that there may be more than one off thread like the one Moggy and I partook in.  I wonder if there is one for the mafia?  Perhaps...

 

What I do relish about these mafia games is that the scum tends to overthink themselvs and end up revealing a lot by who they agree with....and who they don't.  DPR, the only alarm I hear is above your head....your post makes absolutely no sense.  ;D

Talya Spam Master

Talya

Posted
Posted

Actually I said about Thorum's silly decision about going for the finder, so I don't need to answer on that one.

 

I haven't even mentioned or wanted to reveal roles, but then neither has anyone else apart from Mynd and DPR. So why are you singling me out to comment on this. I don't really have any feelings either way. They would have been chenged anyway that people maynot even recognised theirs anyway, and we don't know the chenges!

 

As for the wierd logic, I don't find my logic wierd but quite straight forward so why should I comment on that again! Just because I'm active you pick on me, very good Barm, thats another poor excuse!

 

You have commented on these except you don't know why Thorum voted for DJ. Nor has anyone else commented on them. So your logis is flawed and wierd, I suggest you take the third point and apply it to myself.

 

YOU haven't answered something of mine, why you voted for someone who wasn't voted on before so close to a deadline. It is an obvious mafia move to prevent a lynch. DPR has two votes, so let me guess who you could protecting. Another night for a night kill without losing one of your own would very useful right now, no doubt!

 

 

As forr not saying anything against me, if that is true why vote for me. Now your logic is coming undone. You are wasting time!

 

So because you disagree with my vote you vote me as well, you logic is just going down the fantasy realm there Barm.

 

 

 

Barmacral Spam Master

Barmacral

Posted
Posted

Well, clearly my arguments on Talya are wasted right now, so I'll get back to answering them the next game day, for now I'm going to [glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow] and [glow=red,2,300]vote Myndrunner[/glow], as I don't think DPR is evil... Mynd I'm not nearly so sure about.

cosmicpanda Spam Master

cosmicpanda

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Vote Count No. 11

 

Vote Count:

 

Moggy (0)

Talya (0)

Danya (0)

Thorum (0)

Dae (0)

Mynd (2) - DPR, Barm

DJ (0)

DPR (2) - Mynd, Talya

 

Not voting - Dae, Danya, DJ, Moggy

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

OK, deadline is one and a half hours away as of this post.

Myndrunner Grand Master

Myndrunner

Posted
Posted

Oh, and a note to Mynd since I know he'll read it here: sorry about our MSN convo, don't know what's happening.

 

I was just hoping you got my bribe...... ::)

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

About Dragonmount

Dragonmount is a fan-maintained website dedicated to Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time fantasy series. It is an online community of people from all over the world who have come here to experience the series to the fullest.

Twitter

Facebook

Copyright © 2024, Dragonmount Powered by Invision Community

© All borrowed artwork is used with permission. The Wheel of Time books & franchise are © Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

The phrases "The Wheel of Time‚" and "The Dragon Reborn", and the snake-wheel symbol are trademarks of Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

×
×
  • Create New...