Death in the Artic - Mafia Game!

[SBoydW]

Well there definately aren't 4 mafia, or like Danya said they would have won by now.  Which probably means either there were four and there are now only three or there were three and now there are only two.

[ilgross]

It is possible for any of the remaining teams to win, at this point in time.

 

Thorum did not have any abilities at the time of his death.

[Dark Justice]

This is very very confusing. It doesnt really make sence at all. "Any of the remaining teams" how many are there? Really need a re read of the entire thread now. wich will take forever.

[Dark Justice]

Oh. And one question. What was the navigators role?

[Toy and Minion]

8 players and how many of us are innocent?

 

We must be extremely cautious now, people.  We can't afford to let another day go by without lynching an evil.

[Safir]

Aw man...

[Barmacral]

Any of the remaining teams... how many are there?

 

And I am saddened by Sira's death. Why? Because we killed the bartender. How are we supposed to get our drinks mixed for us now?

[Thorum]

at least I won't be saddened too much by that problem... :D

[Barmacral]

Say Dark Justice, is this a new record for length of time without dying for you? :P (Or am I thinking of Kyros? Don’t remember. :-\)

 

So, I’ve gone through and reviewed all the remaining people, and so far 1 person stands out more than the rest. Twitch.

 

Super Active Man here made his debut on page 10, claiming that school and swimming and such were taking up all of his time. In fact, the only valid excuse for being inactive in the entire post was that he had just bought Halo 3.

Anyways, nothing too bad here. He just votes FDM for captain.

 

Post number 2 – Page 22. Again, starts his post with defending his inactivity. Then complains bitterly (valid complaint at that point IMO) at how many new pages had been added. At that point in the game he may have only been gone for a day, so there’s not much to that. He then suggests that he thinks he might believe FDM over Vem and votes Wes. No explanation for the Wes vote though. And with the commitment to neither FDM or Vem’s case, that’s not the biggest innocent tell in the world, voting with no explanation on day 2.

 

Next time he appears he immediately harps on Vem through meta-gaming. Vem quickly points out that he is wrong. He then unvotes Wes and votes FDM, again without stating his reasons. He also goes on to say whom he believes to be innocent, simply he says to avoid his being nigh-killed.

 

When questioned on his lack of information, he says its because Sira had convinced him that both Wes and FDM were evil, and that he voted FDM because she had more votes. I believe at this point Wes had an overwhelming majority of the votes between the 2.

 

He also flip-flops on whom he believes, stating that he believes Vem over FDM now. Why? Because he believes Vem completely on the whole FDM killed the captain thing.

 

Twitch gets himself involved in this debate, backing up Vem every step of the way, believing his every word despite not believing Vem previously because Vem sometimes false-claims. He feels that Vem wouldn’t get as specific a PM as the one he did get. Fair enough. Can’t fault him for the only real reasoning he’s given all game.

 

This is about the end if his actual content until he later votes Sira with once again… you guessed it. No reasoning whatsoever.

 

So all in all, from what I’ve discovered, Twitch is a lurker who’s gotten by this far in the game by being so completely far under the radar that nobody has noticed him. And he has yet to give a reason for most of his votes. This reads as a fairly major scumtell to me.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote: Twitch[/glow]

[Dark Justice]

Nope.  :P

About a year ago i survived till the end, and got killed by werewolfs on last day, when we were 2 vs 2 or something...

 

Interesting what you say about Twich though.

[Twitchy]

:(

 

I could just say I'm a really crappy player.

*Kicks ground*

I'm a lover, not a fighter.

 

[Alys Kinch]

Well... I don't know what to say. I expect us to be on the verge of losing. Treacherous as you all are... *sigh* Dsage, without going all weird on me, because you are the other confirmed innocent, what do you think?

[SBoydW]

I'm going on a gut hunch here....

 

[glow=red,2,300]Barmacral[/glow]

[Alys Kinch]

evidence for the hunch? because i just don't know and more opinions with reasons would be super helpful.

[Barmacral]

Is this the same hunch that had you voting for Dsage? Cause that one turned out real strong.

 

Really Soybomb, I'll pose the same question to you that you did to me. Do you have any evidence towards me? Or are you just going after me because I thought you suspicious earlier in the game?

 

Well, almost the same question anyways...

[Toy and Minion]

sigh* Dsage, without going all weird on me, because you are the other confirmed innocent, what do you think?

 

"All wierd" ?  Hmm...  Is that how I've been coming across lately?  Oh well.

 

Boyo is really sticking out to me at this point, but I'm not sure.  Like I said, we can't afford to take chances.  We have to be reasonable.

 

Even if Boyo's vote for me was accidental, doesn't make him any less of a scum.  Just thought I'd point that out.

 

Twitch has also been acting too curious for my liking.  Barm basically laid it all out for us to see.  But these things never are as simply as they appear.

 

I'm deffinately going to have to think this over.

[Alys Kinch]

i meant all weird like in previous games where your play got you lynched almost as fast as wes seems to get. in other words, don't make me question the veracity of the viewing, but please tell me what you think.

 

btw, love the avatar. :D

[MsDanya]

I'll just go with [glow=red,2,300]Twitch[/glow] here. Barm has a better reason for voting him than Boyd has for voting Barmy  ::)

 

I do realise that this lynch might win us or make us lose the game, but i'd say Twitch is the best candidate  :-\

[Leelou]

I'm at a toss up now between Twitch and Boyo who seem the most mafia-ish to me. I'm going to do a quick read through first before I vote.

[SBoydW]

Well I'll go ahead and nip this scum talk in the bud. I'm the healer, and my hunch is just that a hunch.

 

Barm has a better reason for voting

 

Most of Barm's reasonings is from guessing at wether or not twitch actually has a life outside of DM, and acussing him of the same actions thoughts as just about everyone left alive in the game (regarding FDM and Vemy).  Not exactly air tight.... seems he's grasping at air, or in other words going on a hunch, only he's trying to fabricate reasoning so he doesn't seem "suspicious".  I have a bad feeling about him, which could be wrong, but none the less it's there and I'm acting on it.  If  none of you share the same bad feeling then don't vote for him, vote for twitch or whoever else you think is guilty.  I'm not trying to force anyone here.

[MsDanya]

well he did  :P

 

at least he had some reasoning behind his vote otehr than a "hunch"

[Dark Justice]

Hmm.. I just cant decide. I had a bad feeling about Sboyo. But if he is in fact the healer, then I have to think a bit more. I have a couple of people on my suspition list. Leelou, Danya & Barmacal is all high.

[Barmacral]

Dark, care to explain why each of the 3 that made it onto your list are all high? Because if we have some other leads, thats never a bad thing.

[Leelou]

[glow=red,2,300]Twitch[/glow] since Boyo claimed healer.

[Dark Justice]

Because you just dont do any profile. You are all 3 players that has not really stood out. That is good tacticks. Cause what we have done this far the players that have stood out is gone. (well almost all of them anyway...)

You are all 3 very good players. But you dont stand out in any way. Difficoult to explain, but I have to just say its a mix of that, and a hunch.