FIDDLES-ON-SEA -------- The Pirates Game

[the dude]

cool man, cool. 8) was just a little psychological warfare is all.

[GoodGrief]

So can we have a player-by-player run down of all the roles? I know for a fact that Alys wasn't the only one with a secret role and I'm curious as to whether there's a third ...

[Kivam]

Nothing for me. Just your ordinary, run of the mill villager clever enough to get himself killed immediately.

[Kivam]

So can we have a player-by-player run down of all the roles? I know for a fact that Alys wasn't the only one with a secret role and I'm curious as to whether there's a third ...

 

So what was your secret role?

[Sirayn]

Apparently, I had the paralysing stupidity role. :roll:

[Kison]

So, when does the next game start?!

[Guest Barmacral]

there's a 2 thread game in the Illuminator's that started today. Those not participating get to have a vote as well, and can discuss things in their thread. Raena is hosting it, you should check it out.

[Zylazlo-]

Wow... this game was so close! But well played my chaotic good opponents. And I'm sorry to anyone and everyone I just had to kill or got killed along the way, see? I'm a nice evil! :D

 

Now just in case I don't see the sign up thread opening, sign me up anyone.

[GoodGrief]

My ultra-seekrit role involved flipping out like ... a ninja!.

 

I was told that if I was lynched the second last person to vote for me would also be killed. So I figured it was better to run the risk of getting nightkilled than to run the risk of getting another innocent taken out with me. Thanks to Barmy for preventing the lesser of the two evils from coming to pass and thanks to everyone else for not suspecting me of anything :lol:

[Zylazlo-]

I suspected you of being innocent if that's anything :P

[SBoydW]

Why was I suspected all the sudden.... :cry:

[Kivam]

1) You rang Kison's scumdar. Once we knew he was innocent, that carried weight.

 

2) You were the last one in on the lynches of your comrades. You should have jumped on Sirayn early - like as soon as Winter Mist announced, early - and you should have been the first to put a vote on Zy as well. Instead, you waited until their lynch was a foregone conclusion.

 

3) Goodgrief was likely innocent - she was a vocal supporter of taking down Sirayn, and Zy from the start, including day 1. The Dude was obviously innocent - both because he used his hunch on Sirayn (with his hunches, Dude would have a powerful tool if he's ever evil - he can just point us in the direction of a target and fall back on "I guess my hunch was wrong. Bound to happen eventually") and because Alys' finder said so. That left you and Barm - and Barm not only hadn't done anything particularly suspicious, but he'd been early on Sirayn's lynch. Finally, you called down the dude - the one obvious innocent - and didn't counterclaim Barm (with no deaths at night, it was obvious that the healer was still alive. With no counterclaim, there wasn't any reason to disbelieve Barm's reveal as the 3rd innocent)

[Talya]

:oops: GG sorry I forgot to put yours down...Had to have a ninja amongst the pirates to make a true fiddles game :lol:

 

I think you were right avoid getting lynched I think it would have taken out an innocent...Tha means a Ninja won....grrrrrrrrrrrrrr....like pirates :(

 

It was a well played game and had me glued all the way.

 

As Barmy said we have one going in the Illuminators and WE NEED YOUR SUPPORT...so please come along and post on the public thread. You get to vote for someone to have an extra vote...I think that's it anyway.

 

Just make your comments as well...who you think is guilty and why should be fun :D

 

And yopu may recognise a few of your fav, fiddles games faces

[SBoydW]

Yeah.... you didn't really have to answer.. :roll: :P

[Toy and Minion]

Woah, so...sorry people. I have had a lot of things going on...*cough Prom cough* and didn't really have time to post. But if Im able to next time, Ill do better, promise!

[GoodGrief]

lol Toy, you last showed up six pages ago, unless I'm wrong. That was just after the Sira lynch!

[Toy and Minion]

Yeah, well it was a lot of stress to deal with and...*fades off*

[Alys Kinch]

you know, i wouldn't have suspected boyo until right around the time griefy tossed his name out there. anyway, great game guys. glad you saw through the facade! and really glad barmy had a great reason for not protecting mist. i thought he fell asleep on the job for a moment there. ;)

[SBoydW]

I should have killed the dude... :cry:

[Toy and Minion]

I got him sick...