PotC Mafia Game - mafia won!!

[amegakure]

aight guys im going to sleep. Ill be back in 9 hours or so.

[Nynaeve]

Kat woke up dead  (heh)

 

She was...

 

A vanilla townie and a mighty fine pirate wench

 

It is D3. With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

[Dragoon]

6 minutes ago, amegakure said:

you seem pretty confident in cass being town? how come? Why do you feel Darthe and I are scum? 

Honestly could you just flush out your reads a bit more. I need to see your thought process to get anything out of those reads. 

1) Clear communication is a big thing for Cass. When she is town she makes a big effort to clear up miscommunication. She will keep at someone until she has cleared it up (I know this from when we have discussed previous games she was playing). I believe this is what she was doing when she was interacting with you in the early game.

 

She also hasn't really been doing anything scummy which I think most people seem to agree with.

 

2) I am suss on Darthe because I just can't read him, it is like he talks in riddles and because of my limited experience I don't know all the tells and secret handshakes. Every time I ask him something I don't get an answer I can do anything with or it feels like I am getting played. So he just stays in my tinfoil box.

 

3) You just seem to always be in the middle of the suspicion, but keep sliding out of it. You keep saying don't use meta on me, I play an odd town game which all seem like ways to divert attention away from you, but you haven't really done much in the way of town play (this is just my opinion). Other than Eldrick you have been fast to place votes and not explore other options. You seem to be giving Darthe a lot of town cred for just a simple interaction (he didn't vote you) I am suss on him so it looks suss of you.

 

It that ok as a flesh out?

 

8.Dragoon (24 of 50)       

 

 

[bgrishinko]

If there is a cop, now is the time to bring that info forward. 

 

1 hour ago, Katiora said:

i'm kinda curious about me too because lately darthe has been saying he feels good about me I thought... now i'm in his bottom 2... I'd like some feedback.

 

kat6

 

Yerp, this happened to me too from him. Bye though Kat. 

Okay so final team is one of the following:

 

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Darthe-Dragoon

Amega-Cass
Amega-Dragoon

Cass-Dragoon

Dragoon feels town to me personally. But he might just be a great 1st timer or getting coached really well. Going off that feeling though:

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Amega-Cass

We have a 2/3rd chance of getting this right.

I think Cass or Darthe are probably the best options personally just on feeling. Cass is playing the low-key scum staying in the shadows, Darthe is playing the active prodding scum.  

 

[Darthe]

4 hours ago, bgrishinko said:

Come at me bro.

 

4 hours ago, Darthe said:

Oh hey a person!

 

 

I can def come @ u.  

 

Last game you were an aggressive pita and this game you've been absent for but chunks.  That's really what's on my mind, so why?

Yo respond to this.  You've been here to see it.

[Dragoon]

22 minutes ago, bgrishinko said:

If there is a cop, now is the time to bring that info forward. 

 

 

Yerp, this happened to me too from him. Bye though Kat. 

Okay so final team is one of the following:

 

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Darthe-Dragoon

Amega-Cass
Amega-Dragoon

Cass-Dragoon

Dragoon feels town to me personally. But he might just be a great 1st timer or getting coached really well. Going off that feeling though:

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Amega-Cass

We have a 2/3rd chance of getting this right.

I think Cass or Darthe are probably the best options personally just on feeling. Cass is playing the low-key scum staying in the shadows, Darthe is playing the active prodding scum.  

 

Sure not including yourself is ok from a self perspective, but we should be looking from a town team  perspective. 

 

So the options are 

 

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Darthe-Dragoon

Darthe-BG

 

Amega-Cass
Amega-Dragoon

Amega-BG

 

Cass-Dragoon

Cass-BG

 

Dragoon-BG

 

8.Dragoon (1 of 50)

 

[Darthe]

2 hours ago, amegakure said:

yea i kinda feel like everyone is waiting to see the NK and go from there. Im going to go out on a limb here and say darthe is probably town. I hope im not getting played but im just meshing with what he says. Im 100% on board with kat/bg having scum. 

 

Cass has me tinfoiling. She has had alot to say but im not sure she has been helpful in finding scum this game. Great writer, well thought out, but just on feels doesn't seem to have brought to much pressure on anyone beside me and then unfortunately RL hit and she dropped off so idk. 

 

Not feeling dragoon as scum but at this point im not letting noob stuff get in the way but on the other hand he hasn't done anything scummy. Obvi his partner could be coaching and having him be present and ask question but to coast on the noob vibe and not bring pressure on anyone to much. 

 

Wouldn't it be crazy if cass/dragoon were on a team? 

 

Cass would love some new reads from you. Dragoon how bout you? 

Lol if it is Cass/dragoon that's amazing and I'm not even mad.

 

Small qualm with this post though.  Kat died, and so it bugs me that you didn't address her here other than to say you could see her with BG.

 

What was generating your read on her?  I'd love if you could quote a wolfy post of hers for me.

[Darthe]

1 hour ago, Dragoon said:

1) Clear communication is a big thing for Cass. When she is town she makes a big effort to clear up miscommunication. She will keep at someone until she has cleared it up (I know this from when we have discussed previous games she was playing). I believe this is what she was doing when she was interacting with you in the early game.

 

She also hasn't really been doing anything scummy which I think most people seem to agree with.

 

2) I am suss on Darthe because I just can't read him, it is like he talks in riddles and because of my limited experience I don't know all the tells and secret handshakes. Every time I ask him something I don't get an answer I can do anything with or it feels like I am getting played. So he just stays in my tinfoil box.

 

3) You just seem to always be in the middle of the suspicion, but keep sliding out of it. You keep saying don't use meta on me, I play an odd town game which all seem like ways to divert attention away from you, but you haven't really done much in the way of town play (this is just my opinion). Other than Eldrick you have been fast to place votes and not explore other options. You seem to be giving Darthe a lot of town cred for just a simple interaction (he didn't vote you) I am suss on him so it looks suss of you.

 

It that ok as a flesh out?

 

8.Dragoon (24 of 50)       

 

 

I try to work with people in general, but it's LYLo so I don't much have time to let you waffle on me.  In my head rn I've got paranoia, and that says you could be playing up the noobie card, or using some skills you learned from your wife to try and keep me on the table.

 

Frankly I shouldn't be.  If you're town and you're confused about my slot it's because you didn't push to get the answers you felt you needed.  That's on you.

 

I need a good response to this btw.  Today's a day where every post matters.

[Dragoon]

35 minutes ago, bgrishinko said:

If there is a cop, now is the time to bring that info forward. 

 

 

Yerp, this happened to me too from him. Bye though Kat. 

Okay so final team is one of the following:

 

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Darthe-Dragoon

Amega-Cass
Amega-Dragoon

Cass-Dragoon

Dragoon feels town to me personally. But he might just be a great 1st timer or getting coached really well. Going off that feeling though:

Darthe-Amega
Darthe-Cass
Amega-Cass

We have a 2/3rd chance of getting this right.

I think Cass or Darthe are probably the best options personally just on feeling. Cass is playing the low-key scum staying in the shadows, Darthe is playing the active prodding scum.  

 

Someone else mentioned me being coached. 

 

I am happy to work through it.

 

Dragoon-Darthe

Dragoon-Amega

Dragoon-BG

Dragoon-Cass

 

What does everyone think about these combinations with regards to me being coached really well.

 

8.Dragoon (2 of 50)

 

 

 

[bgrishinko]

13 minutes ago, Darthe said:

 

Yo respond to this.  You've been here to see it.

 

For good reason. Here, I'll dangle a stick.

 

Vote Bgrishinko

[Cass]

vote: BG

[Darthe]

vote: BG

[Dragoon]

1 minute ago, Cass said:

vote: BG

@Cass go to sleep you 

 

8.Dragoon (3 of 50)

[bgrishinko]

Called it.

[Dragoon]

Is this game over?

 

8.Dragoon (4 of 50)

[bgrishinko]

I'd hoped to unvote quickly but failed, lol.

[Darthe]

Just now, bgrishinko said:

I'd hoped to unvote quickly but failed, lol.

We figured out a way around that a long time ago. People started setting a timer for 1/2when to place votes.

[Darthe]

3 minutes ago, bgrishinko said:

Called it.

To be fair you called every single combination possible that didn't include yourself

[Dragoon]

Unvote anyway

 

8.Dragoon (5 of 50)

[Darthe]

All that said, I'm not a wolf so I have no idea what you guys are talking about

[bgrishinko]

58 minutes ago, bgrishinko said:

I think Cass or Darthe are probably the best options personally just on feeling. Cass is playing the low-key scum staying in the shadows, Darthe is playing the active prodding scum.  

 

 

^^^

[Nynaeve]

Bg has been lynched. He was... vengeful townie.

 

Darthe got nuked. He was mafia goon.

[Nynaeve]

Scum wins!!!!!

[Darthe]

Figured, that's why I told Cass to hammer.  She had the BPV.

 

But it didn't matter cause doc was dead and we have an NK.

 

GG yall

[Dragoon]

Ok I see why people stop playing this game.

 

8.Dragoon  (6 of 50)