The Founding of Quahog (Peter's Progress) Mafia - Game Over

[Clovdyx]

 

 

Chris do you have any take on BFG's game so far?

Not really. I'm holding off on reading her right now for reasons and stuff

Can you elaborate?

On which part?

[BFG]

 

 

 

Chris do you have any take on BFG's game so far?

Not really. I'm holding off on reading her right now for reasons and stuff

Can you elaborate?

On which part?

Why you're holding off?

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I must be bad at this, im taking the guy at face value

In all seriousness though, I want to hear Darthe's explanation for this. I have no trouble believing that he could actually be doing it as town, but I'm fairly confident I saw Shad do something ~similar as scum in another game (though I can't for the life of me think of what it was).

 

Same goes for Verb.

 

 

Where did Verb claim or hint scum?

 

He didn't. I meant Verb's take on Shad.

 

Bookmarked

 

Not sure if Verb responded to this but Verb was reading Shad as null, what response were you expecting?

[Clovdyx]

Somewhat. Part of it is because this is the first time you and I have been in the thread at the same time and I think I'm fairly okay at reading you based on your approach to/interactions with me.

 

Part is because like 10 or 15 pages back maybe in PM?

[Clovdyx]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I must be bad at this, im taking the guy at face value

In all seriousness though, I want to hear Darthe's explanation for this. I have no trouble believing that he could actually be doing it as town, but I'm fairly confident I saw Shad do something ~similar as scum in another game (though I can't for the life of me think of what it was).Same goes for Verb.

Where did Verb claim or hint scum?

He didn't. I meant Verb's take on Shad.

Bookmarked

Not sure if Verb responded to this but Verb was reading Shad as null, what response were you expecting?

Somebody (Ben? You?) Said they thought it was more likely townie would claim because they have a lot more to gain. Verb simply replied and said "Disagreed." And left it there

 

I was trying to open up SOME sort of discussion to what he thought Macias advantage from it would be.

 

He answered it yesterday morning/afternoon I think

[BFG]

 

Lol I'll be back after work

 

@Sooh yes, in your magic game

You should know as well as anyone here that I don't remember specific meta- things.

 

And when I'm hosting? Forget about it.

 

You use meta when you have it :p

 

Besides as I said, it's already been mentioned in thread so regardless of your alignment you've genuinely forgotten. The point wasn't about you it was why Shad thought it was fine

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I must be bad at this, im taking the guy at face value

In all seriousness though, I want to hear Darthe's explanation for this. I have no trouble believing that he could actually be doing it as town, but I'm fairly confident I saw Shad do something ~similar as scum in another game (though I can't for the life of me think of what it was).Same goes for Verb.

 

Where did Verb claim or hint scum?

 

He didn't. I meant Verb's take on Shad.

 

Bookmarked

 

Not sure if Verb responded to this but Verb was reading Shad as null, what response were you expecting?

 

Somebody (Ben? You?) Said they thought it was more likely townie would claim because they have a lot more to gain. Verb simply replied and said "Disagreed." And left it there

 

I was trying to open up SOME sort of discussion to what he thought Macias advantage from it would be.

 

He answered it yesterday morning/afternoon I think

 

Ok thanks :)

[BFG]

Somewhat. Part of it is because this is the first time you and I have been in the thread at the same time and I think I'm fairly okay at reading you based on your approach to/interactions with me.

 

Part is because like 10 or 15 pages back maybe in PM?

[Tiinker]

 

 

Given last game, I can imagine Sooh giving the same responses as both town or scum.

 

Wut?

 

I don't understand this.

 

I was town last game as well.

 

What are you getting at?

You were pressured all game last game. If I had someone come at me from the get-go my next game over something as weak as this I'd be frustrated too regardless of alignment.

[Tiinker]

 

Lol can someone who has experience with Turin tell mr if he's taking the piss?

???

It means "messing around".

[Tiinker]

 

 

Ben you randed wolf again.

Close...I randed dog, but he's town.

 

I'm not a fan of Family Guy, either. I watched a few episodes the first season, and while the baby was funny, the show just couldn't hook me, which is odd, because I liked Married with Children (until they added the little kid) and the first several seasons of The Simpsons.

I liked this last night, it's a little awkward sounding but the thought process seems quite convoluted if mafia

 

I'm less certain today, there's more of a gap between shads post and bens response than I realised yesterday and the follow on exchange still reads oddly

@Clov Here's a BFG post I didn't quite understand. Did you think that Ben saying the bold is revealing in some way? I'm not sure how saying that would involve a "convoluted" thought process if scum.

 

I thought I quoted this earlier but it apparently didn't post?

[BFG]

 

 

 

Ben you randed wolf again.

Close...I randed dog, but he's town.

 

I'm not a fan of Family Guy, either. I watched a few episodes the first season, and while the baby was funny, the show just couldn't hook me, which is odd, because I liked Married with Children (until they added the little kid) and the first several seasons of The Simpsons.

 

I liked this last night, it's a little awkward sounding but the thought process seems quite convoluted if mafia

 

I'm less certain today, there's more of a gap between shads post and bens response than I realised yesterday and the follow on exchange still reads oddly

 

@Clov Here's a BFG post I didn't quite understand. Did you think that Ben saying the bold is revealing in some way? I'm not sure how saying that would involve a "convoluted" thought process if scum.

 

I thought I quoted this earlier but it apparently didn't post?

 

if mafia the more obvious response is 'no' or similar not 'Brian's a safe claim let's respond with that'. I'd normally add that it involves a discussion about who gets what safe claim, but I think Bens impulsive enough to just claim without discussion even if there wasn't a couple of hours gap

 

Basically I don't think many people would immediately think of using a safe claim to answer a straight forward question. In reality it means little

[BFG]

Not going to quote 295 but I'm not sure what to make of either ben's town read on me, or vote on Shad

[Sooh]

 

 

Given last game, I can imagine Sooh giving the same responses as both town or scum.

Wut?

 

I don't understand this.

 

I was town last game as well.

 

What are you getting at?

You were pressured all game last game. If I had someone come at me from the get-go my next game over something as weak as this I'd be frustrated too regardless of alignment.

 

That's not what your original statement sounded like.

 

What's your take on my alignment now?

[Sooh]

[v]Darthe[/v]

 

Come play buddy.

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

 

Ben you randed wolf again.

Close...I randed dog, but he's town.

 

I'm not a fan of Family Guy, either. I watched a few episodes the first season, and while the baby was funny, the show just couldn't hook me, which is odd, because I liked Married with Children (until they added the little kid) and the first several seasons of The Simpsons.

I liked this last night, it's a little awkward sounding but the thought process seems quite convoluted if mafia

 

I'm less certain today, there's more of a gap between shads post and bens response than I realised yesterday and the follow on exchange still reads oddly

@Clov Here's a BFG post I didn't quite understand. Did you think that Ben saying the bold is revealing in some way? I'm not sure how saying that would involve a "convoluted" thought process if scum.

 

I thought I quoted this earlier but it apparently didn't post?

if mafia the more obvious response is 'no' or similar not 'Brian's a safe claim let's respond with that'. I'd normally add that it involves a discussion about who gets what safe claim, but I think Bens impulsive enough to just claim without discussion even if there wasn't a couple of hours gap

 

Basically I don't think many people would immediately think of using a safe claim to answer a straight forward question. In reality it means little

I thought him randing "dog" was a bad joke about being a counter to wolves lmao. Completely went over my head that there's a dog in the show.

[Andrej]

Vote Count

 

Shad_ - 1 - Gentled Ben

Turin Turambar - 1 - Tiinker

Tiinker - 1 - Turin Turambar

Darthe - 1 - Sooh

 

5 to lynch

 

Deadline in ~2.5 hours

[BFG]

That being said: 

 

Towny:

Turin

Ben

 

Shad

 

Neutral: 

the rest.

Can you explain?

[Sooh]

 

That being said: 

 

Towny:

Turin

Ben

 

Shad

 

Neutral: 

the rest.

Can you explain?

 

I thought I did.

 

Turin is because I think that while his push on me was annoying, it was one of those ??? things that Turin usually does as town.

 

Ben seemed town in the interactions with Shad.

 

Shad also seemed towny in those interactions, but slightly less so (or the bar is a bit higher) than Ben. 

[BFG]

Sooh looking good on 18 <3

[BFG]

Ok thanks <3

[Sooh]

Np. looking forward to when you're current to see what your summarized thoughts are.

[BFG]

At he moment very confused lol

 

Before I forget completely Tiinker, did you eplain who was dropping hard reads at the time you talked about meta? (Shad asked so i'm assuming there's an answer I haven't seen, but I don't want to forget)

 

I don't really follow the town read on Ben, currently his response to Shad reads a lot like his response to Liz _in as much as I remember) he accounts for the new info the 'if' argument this game, but it hasn't appeared to change anything, based on current VC

[Tiinker]

At he moment very confused lol

 

Before I forget completely Tiinker, did you eplain who was dropping hard reads at the time you talked about meta? (Shad asked so i'm assuming there's an answer I haven't seen, but I don't want to forget)

 

I don't really follow the town read on Ben, currently his response to Shad reads a lot like his response to Liz _in as much as I remember) he accounts for the new info the 'if' argument this game, but it hasn't appeared to change anything, based on current VC

Shad went to point out that now had hard claimed yet but then went to drop a hard town read on Sooh. My frustration from last game might have been leaking over, but yeah. Didn't take long.

 

As far as Ben goes, I said that his analysis had interesting points about Shads game play but I came out of that post saying I thought he was reaching and didn't think he had a great point in regards to Shads game play for this game I don't remember calling Ben town there?

[Gentled Ben]

Mindset. I like it. Not for you? You do you.

 

No, giving an active player a D1 pass is never for me. Why would you do that? 

 

I'll look at it again, might have missed some context

Earlier he said that he was leaning scum and would adjust if you posted more townie. That seems fine.

 

"You're mafia. Please lynch mafia and act like town." Not so much?

 

I can try to reread it again on lunch, but it seemed really inconsistent with the read he was presenting when I saw it.

 

That's not what I said. Do not put words in my mouth, especially within quotation marks like that. 

 

@ Ben what is your read on Clovdyx?

Slight scum lean.

 

 

 

 

 

Happily town after the previous debacle.

yes.

Is this to me?

That was at the start of the game though?

Yep. And?

 

I find that first posts can be useful. He hasn't pinged hard in a mafia way so far so I'm fine with leaving him to tomorrow to dig into.

 

Plus it was a very funny gif. Gotta give props.

 

And what use is a flavor gif? How does that help you read someone as town or wolf, much less to the point that you will not reconsider them for the entire day, the only day on which we begin with no information at all? Why refuse to collect information on a day when there is none at all? 

 

I mean Shad isn't lock clear but I ain't lynching him today.

That's lock clear, Turin, whether for a phase or an entire game, that's lock clear. Why would you lock clear someone over a gif? You say he hasn't pinged you since then, but you had already given him a pass for the entire day based on a cartoon picture, so how much pinging are you likely to pick up on?

 

While your focus has been off of Shad, you must have developed some insightful reads on the rest of us. Will you share them, please?

 

At he moment very confused lol

 

Before I forget completely Tiinker, did you eplain who was dropping hard reads at the time you talked about meta? (Shad asked so i'm assuming there's an answer I haven't seen, but I don't want to forget)

 

I don't really follow the town read on Ben, currently his response to Shad reads a lot like his response to Liz _in as much as I remember) he accounts for the new info the 'if' argument this game, but it hasn't appeared to change anything, based on current VC

I haven't seen any new info to change my view. What has he done since I said that that should sway me from scum to town or even to null? Why should that sway me? What do you think it means that I haven't been swayed by that? Why?