[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

Eldrick4221 · May 19, 2017

[unvote]

You're right.

It's been bugging me since she posted the second peek. As I said before, I'm not comfortable with claiming fake peeks while also trying to solve. The fact that she is means she is probably either the actual seer or she is scum.

Either way, lzm is probably town. Unless it's exactly alex/hally/lzm

Spadeszee · May 19, 2017

Guys, the clock is ticking. We need to figure this out and work together.

Ed hasn't been posting or solving any problems and has been threatening me a little.

Eldrick has consistently been making weird moves that just always ping me as wolfy. Especially him not caring about being lynched D1.

Cass-Dice have been fairly active, but a lot see their posts as fluffy. From someone who hasn't played with them they seem very confident which can be a scummy trait (having knowledge)

Hallia was GOAT and tagged Alex yesterday, do we trust her gut a second day and go for her vote?

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

@Tigs - in this type of setup the seer starts the game with the name of one confirmed vanilla townie in their role PM, known as a N0 peek - it's randomized by the mod.

That's why so many of us were hard clearing someone as town D1, to lay down cover for the actual seer to be able to reveal their results.

Okay I get that, spades said she was Hallia's N1 so where does Dice/Cass fall into scum role?

Shad_ · May 19, 2017

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Eldrick (1) - Adella

LZM (1) - Shanti

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

Ed (1) - Spades

Hallia (2) - Dice/Cass, Tigraine

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Eldrick

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

Guys, the clock is ticking. We need to figure this out and work together.

Ed hasn't been posting or solving any problems and has been threatening me a little.

Eldrick has consistently been making weird moves that just always ping me as wolfy. Especially him not caring about being lynched D1.

Cass-Dice have been fairly active, but a lot see their posts as fluffy. From someone who hasn't played with them they seem very confident which can be a scummy trait (having knowledge)

Hallia was GOAT and tagged Alex yesterday, do we trust her gut a second day and go for her vote?

No I don't trust her gut.

Cass has be game solving since day 1. The stuff about fluff isn't true

Eldrick4221 · May 19, 2017

So let's assume for a sec that she is the seer. And that lzm and spades are her peeks.

Where does that leave us?

I disagree with Aussie being scum. Cass has been doing a lot of work solving and dice is too emotionally invested for them to be scum imo

dicetosser1 · May 19, 2017

unvote

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

So let's assume for a sec that she is the seer. And that lzm and spades are her peeks.

Where does that leave us?

I disagree with Aussie being scum. Cass has been doing a lot of work solving and dice is too emotionally invested for them to be scum imo

Exactly. Her being the seer doesn't mean her gut instinctively points out scum. She has given NO reason for this feeling.

Spadeszee · May 19, 2017

@Tigs - in this type of setup the seer starts the game with the name of one confirmed vanilla townie in their role PM, known as a N0 peek - it's randomized by the mod.

That's why so many of us were hard clearing someone as town D1, to lay down cover for the actual seer to be able to reveal their results.

Okay I get that, spades said she was Hallia's N1 so where does Dice/Cass fall into scum role?

She said "Early on good feels, asking questions etc/ Dice being fluffy to start – Then Cass slips into it seems only question asking/answering mechanics mode, which can be done regardless of alignment"

It doesn't state what is wolfy exactly, but is says why they aren't cleared in her mind. As seer maybe self pres as well, I don't know and I myself don't see them scummy.

Eldrick4221 · May 19, 2017

[V]darthe [/v]

Mostly gut. Mainly because of how he handled my peek of him.

Shad_ · May 19, 2017

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Eldrick (1) - Adella

LZM (1) - Shanti

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

Ed (1) - Spades

Hallia (1) - Tigraine

Darthe (1) - Eldrick

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Dice/Cass

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Spadeszee · May 19, 2017

So let's assume for a sec that she is the seer. And that lzm and spades are her peeks.

Where does that leave us?

I disagree with Aussie being scum. Cass has been doing a lot of work solving and dice is too emotionally invested for them to be scum imo

Exactly. Her being the seer doesn't mean her gut instinctively points out scum. She has given NO reason for this feeling.

She also didn't give a reason for Alex last night and hit the nail on the head there.

Songstress · May 19, 2017

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

[v] unvote [v/]

But I'm still not lynching someone on the seer's gut feeling....maybe she ate tacos that didn't agree with her. I just don't see the reasoning.

Shanti · May 19, 2017

I personally do not view dice/Cass as scum at this time so my vote is staying put for previous reasons

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

[V] unvote [/v]

Shad_ · May 19, 2017

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Eldrick (1) - Adella

LZM (1) - Shanti

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

Ed (1) - Spades

Darthe (1) - Eldrick

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Dice/Cass, Tigraine

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Eldrick4221 · May 19, 2017

Guess I'm staying up for DL :P

Spadeszee · May 19, 2017

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

I have also been advised about Cass' ability to ask questions and seem present and Dice's ability to give detailed reads and I haven't seen any of that from that slot. But they still haven't read wolfy to me.

I'm stuck between Ed and Eldrick, honestly. What are your thoughts for those two.

Also what about Darthe? Where did he run off to?

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

So let's assume for a sec that she is the seer. And that lzm and spades are her peeks.

Where does that leave us?

I disagree with Aussie being scum. Cass has been doing a lot of work solving and dice is too emotionally invested for them to be scum imo

Exactly. Her being the seer doesn't mean her gut instinctively points out scum. She has given NO reason for this feeling.

She also didn't give a reason for Alex last night and hit the nail on the head there.

Right but he pinged A LOT of people. Plus it was Day 1. Not as much to go on.

Songstress · May 19, 2017

I'm on my phone at work and trying to keep up with replies, but this is moving fast and I'll probably miss stuff... feel free to requote anything I ought to respond to >.>

dicetosser1 · May 19, 2017

Thank you for covering other people, tigs. I'm gonna go check out Adella's iso for myself. She's the one that jumped out the most on your list.

@dice that vote feels very much like OMGUS. Do you have more reason to vote there?

@Spades nice catch on Hally. Looking forward to seeing how this develops. Could move my vote there.

id already given them. she wasnt solving. her tone sucked.

Tress gets it...

neither of you get it.

[unvote]

You're right.

It's been bugging me since she posted the second peek. As I said before, I'm not comfortable with claiming fake peeks while also trying to solve. The fact that she is means she is probably either the actual seer or she is scum.

Either way, lzm is probably town. Unless it's exactly alex/hally/lzm

what town says this?

[V]darthe [/v]

Mostly gut. Mainly because of how he handled my peek of him.

thats it. ure either scum or i just give up on you

vote eldrick

Eldrick4221 · May 19, 2017

@Tress, I really need your help here. My gut tells me to trust your instincts and experience right now.

Eldrick is screaming wolf at me, but Ed is also. I don't see Cass-Dice, but I don't know them well like you do.

Cass is coming across as very town. The only thing about her play that worries me is the fact that she was able to give a detailed explanation of why mafia would have considered Redd to be seer over anyone who gave a clear N0 peek.

Cass has been known to fool me, so I don't trust my town read on her too much.

Dice, however, is someone I have a long history of gut reading correctly when he's town, when a lot of other people struggle with it. There have been times I missed him as mafia, but those games were ones where I had a milder town read on him and got distracted looking elsewhere.

This game I haven't gotten that strong gut town read from him, and it worries me. I don't expect everyone else to go with it, but I can't shake it.

I'm willing to switch if necessary, there are 2 mafia alive and I have at least a couple of people I am not comfortable with as town.

I have also been advised about Cass' ability to ask questions and seem present and Dice's ability to give detailed reads and I haven't seen any of that from that slot. But they still haven't read wolfy to me.

I'm stuck between Ed and Eldrick, honestly. What are your thoughts for those two.

Also what about Darthe? Where did he run off to?

Quoted for you, tress.

Tigraine · May 19, 2017

I want so bad to vote ed but I don't want to leave it to a random decision. This is crazy

Shad_ · May 19, 2017

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Eldrick (2) - Adella, Dice/Cass

LZM (1) - Shanti

Dice/Cass (2) - Hallia, Tress

Ed (1) - Spades

Darthe (1) - Eldrick

Not Voting: Darthe, LedZepMan, ed2funy, Tigraine

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook