[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[ReddBoiler]

For the record I'm villager Ashanti

 

Hope that that helps you solve

[Shanti]

No A there, but thanks for that. =)

[Cass]

 

If Darthe wasn't my peek, I'd still call him town. He's been aloof and not trying to control the thread. Those are good points for him.

Sooh what do you think of this post?

Who's this at? Sooh's not playing... if she is, she's Scum or PR by her post count :D

 

FTR agree with the bold, but with the caveat that I read your scum control of the thread more subtle when enough confusion exists in the Town.

 

Need more from you to be confident in a read. What's your thoughts on him saying this here?

[Shad_]

uhhhhhhhhhhh oh yeah

[Shad_]

Surprise, open set-up was bastard, Laughing Peg stole your vote.

[ed2funy]

 

wrong. every town lynch gets us closer to lylo.

 

you know this.

 

happy with the maroons vote. Elds apathy is weird cause shes right he fights HARD. some of his posts just look like busy work.

Of course a town lynch gets us closer to lylo. It also gets us information.

 

Fretting about being lynched day 1 is a waste of energy.

 

Probably part of why I don't care is I'm having trouble sorting this game out. I usually have a decent reads list by now and I don't. There are too many people I just don't have a read on, and it bugs me. I'm cool with dying.

"I'm confused, so I'm gonna give up."

 

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (3) - Shanti, Adella, Hallia

 

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Redd

 

Eldrick (3) - Spades, Dice/Cass, Darthe

 

Spades (1) - Ed

 

Tigraine (1) - Eldrick

 

Redd (1) - LZM

 

 

Not Voting: Songstress

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

[ed2funy]

Surprise, open set-up was bastard, Laughing Peg stole your vote.

 

I have better uses for pegs than stealing votes.

[Shad_]

Just remember she's only 7.

[Cass]

 

Claiming role is silly. There's only 1 non-vanilla role in the game. For all your know, I'm the seer. Saying so wouldn't save me.

[V] eldrick [/v] im already there but I wanna double down in case this is bastard and im a secret double voter

O.o

 

I don't understand you or Redd doubling your votes up this game. It hurts my head. Feels deliberately unnecessary and therefore somehow wolfy, but the actual votes are ok according to my current reads? >.<

 

>.< !

[Cass]

uhhhhhhhhhhh oh yeah

  

Surprise, open set-up was bastard, Laughing Peg stole your vote.

Oh whew.

 

:D

 

That clears that up then!

[Songstress]

Shanti displaying a fair amount of paranoia there, lol.

 

Seriously though, if joking about stalking people and using emojis is a scum trait, pretty sure I would be lynched IRL.

[Shanti]

I can't speak for everyone, others may know your playing style. Hence my disclaimer that it was just what I was picking up.

I'm just one lil ole person, I can't do much on my own, but my vote isn't even on you. Just said it did seem kinda woofy to me.

Maybe its all the pouncing and stalking? Just puts me in mind of a cute little puppy dog trying to play (hence woofy).

[Songstress]

[v]Tigraine[/v]

 

This is the one I feel most comfortable voting right now. Tomorrow should be slightly easier.

[Shanti]

I was actually about to ask why you don't have a vote in. Mind explaining your reasoning?

[Cass]

So what I see is that tress and dice are picking up, the many new faces are throwing most everyone off, and cass is way too organized which is causing me to tinfoil on her.

I need some reddboiler itt.

1. Organised isn't a bad thing

 

2. What are your thoughts on the Eld-LZM-Redd-Tig thing?

 

Can you give me your thoughts, reads on each of these and your top WTL aorn?

[Cass]

And @Darthe, your read on Ed?

[Shad_]

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (3) - Shanti, Adella, Hallia

 

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Redd

 

Eldrick (3) - Spades, Dice/Cass, Darthe

 

Spades (1) - Ed

 

Tigraine (2) - Eldrick, Tress

 

Redd (1) - LZM

 

 

Not Voting:

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

[Songstress]

I was actually about to ask why you don't have a vote in. Mind explaining your reasoning?

The main reason I hadn't voted was that I didn't have strong feelings about anyone as scum.

 

Tigs is the one who has stood out to me the most. I mentioned in my reads list that her "was that a slip" conversation with Hallia pinged me hard. Aside from that, she's been light on content and left what was clearly a joke vote on me up to now.

 

The other two of my bottom three I'm not confident I can tell whether they're scum or not, especially D1. I roll with what I have.

[Cass]

 

I return in glory, or something.

Probably something.

Snerked.

 

 

Also, Halli re-entry!

 

I like Spadez asking for top 3s

 

AoRN mine probably Eld/Alex/Tigs/LZM

 

and yes, I know that's four and this is a maths themed game

 

Caveat I haven't finished this page #themobileishardandtextissmallandzomgImoldandtired

[Spadeszee]

 

 

 

 

 

You don't seem to be trying to figure me out. You seem to be looking for reasons to justify me being scum.

You have no idea how frustrating it is to try to figure out your alignment.

 

You really don't.

Then don't lol. Let the later phases sort me out.

 

You also didn't answer my question.

I don't even know how to answer your question.

....

 

How often do you figure out that I'm town?

 

 

....................

 

 

I 

 

Don't

 

Know.

 

 

I really don't remember whether I've ever figured it out.

 

I'm exhausted and very frustrated right now.

 

If I was trying to vote you, I would have already done it, to be frank.  I was trying to explain why I have such a ridiculously hard time reading you.

 

 

This doesn't feel like productive pushing to me. It really feels like Eldrick was trying to make Tress feel uncomfortable for forming an opinion about him, almost bully her out of coming to a conclusion. It wasn't even constructive questioning it felt like he was saying "You're always wrong, just give up on me now". I didn't like it at all.

 

 

Your reason is a good one. You're wrong about me being scum, but you'd only know that if you were scum, which I don't think you are.

 

 

I'm not worried, but I can see why you might think I am. I didn't ask about her opinions on other people because she has a reads list I haven't read yet.

 

I feel like you should be more worried if you were Town?

Why?

 

Only time a town lynch matters is at lylo. I have no reason to worry about votes on me. My death doesn't matter. All that matters is finding scum, and I believe I have in Tigs.

 

(Almost asleep yay. Friggin mafia adiction)

 

All town deaths matter and this is the main reason I am voting Eldrick right now. He isn't trying to game solve with this mindset. He suggested that if Tigs isn't mafia then it's probably Redd/Tress, but didn't explain why. Also, as far as I know, a town flip means nothing but we have less time to figure this out. This isn't progressive thinking.

 

Claiming role is silly. There's only 1 non-vanilla role in the game. For all your know, I'm the seer. Saying so wouldn't save me.

Here it feels like he's trying to scare us out of voting him. If you don't care about being lynched, why say this and basically soft claim? This is not a good look.

 

Mind explaining how me not caring if I gets lynched makes me scum?

 

Because from my understanding nobody likes to roll wolf, villagers want to solve this and work past it. Instead of focusing on people voting you, you should focus on finding the wolfs, which you're not doing!

 

 

Might as well start talking about who you'll go after when I flip town, then.

 

How do you feel about what I said about tigs-redd-tress?

Again, there is just so little information here to comment on your idea here. Give some quotes and explain more. This is the kind of vague stuff that reads so very wolfy to me.

 

 

This is my case against Eldrick right now. These are posts that really stood out to me as scummy, I don't like the way he tries to guilt Tress out of voting him and also is trying to guilt everyone else out by dangling being seer. This doesn't feel like a town being miss read to me. 

[LedZepMan]

So, we have a tie here with thirty minutes to deadline. Alex and Eldrick.

 

Hmmmm. My gut says both are town. Now, who to consolidate on?

 

Alex is not contributing anything, yet I feel he is town. Eld is contributing more, and I feel he's town too.

 

I don't know wether to let this go random or to hammer one or the other.

 

So, [unvote] for now. More reading ahead of me.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (3) - Shanti, Adella, Hallia

 

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Redd

 

Eldrick (3) - Spades, Dice/Cass, Darthe

 

Spades (1) - Ed

 

Tigraine (2) - Eldrick, Tress

 

 

Not Voting: LZM

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

[Cass]

Shanti displaying a fair amount of paranoia there, lol.

Seriously though, if joking about stalking people and using emojis is a scum trait, pretty sure I would be lynched IRL.

  

 

This.

 

:D

 

And wrt Shanti, I think the paranoia comes off pretty natural here at first glance.

 

 

So what I see is that tress and dice are picking up, the many new faces are throwing most everyone off, and cass is way too organized which is causing me to tinfoil on her.

I need some reddboiler itt.

1. Organised isn't a bad thing

2. What are your thoughts on the Eld-LZM-Redd-Tig thing?

Can you give me your thoughts, reads on each of these and your top WTL aorn?

@Ed

 

Can you answer the same questions as Darthe please?

[Spadeszee]

So, we have a tie here with thirty minutes to deadline. Alex and Eldrick.

 

Hmmmm. My gut says both are town. Now, who to consolidate on?

 

Alex is not contributing anything, yet I feel he is town. Eld is contributing more, and I feel he's town too.

 

I don't know wether to let this go random or to hammer one or the other.

 

So, [unvote] for now. More reading ahead of me.

Do you have any original thoughts or top 3's? Also could you perhaps pull up quotes and what is making you town read both of them?