[Basic C9++] Murder Mystery Mafia D5

[Kaylee]

Official Vote Count

 

Kronos (4): Shadory, Manbat, Clov, Seph

 

Niniel (3): Ed, Darthe, SoJames

 

Darthe (3): DPR, Niniel, Kronos

 

Not Voting (3): Songstress, Tigraine, Killashandra

 

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Deadline set for Monday April 17th at 8pm MST

 

  

 

 

you would think, but i am an enigma

a riddle wrapped in a twinkie

 

 

Now I want a banana Twinkie. *pouts*

 

 

On the other hand, I did ask my wife if she thought I was acerbic. She laughed. I took that as an "of course not".

Kudos on finding a woman who's willing to put up with ya.

[Cory Caboose]

I found several interesting things reviewing DPR's previous games. Tried to note different habits; admittedly his mafia game was from 2014, but he had a 3P game recently and throughout I saw a lot of things he gravitates toward as a villager but does not do in separates roles.

 

A) DPR is actually a pretty transparent villager. Some of his theories are out there, but he's generally pretty forward with what he thinks and will explain it at length if necessary. His attitude is typically congenial unless he feels attacked. He's event-focused (rather than player-focused) and typically juggles multiple suspects but not always aggressively.

 

B) DPR as [non-villager] can probably be described as "aggressive" - he's more player-focused, generally focuses on a smaller group of players and attacks on a logical level. His reads in general are more concise and the long, multi-paragraph explanations disappear. He's more "on edge". He's not afraid of posting or attention; volume isn't really reliable as a shortcut to reading him.

 

After absorbing his games and reading his ISO in this one, this game looks a lot more like B to me - there are some oddities that stick out to me as weird but nothing that really makes me think he's a villager. The argument me and him earlier the game was very similar to an argument he had with bopolis in a previous game (circle jerk vs. handjob club), but his distaste for that style of play never reeled in whereas here he's been more conciliatory and easier to handle. Which I prefer either way, but unfortunately the sudden change in even the more subtle aspects of his attitude are hard for me to chalk up to him trying to amend his villager game to the current meta.

 

tl;dr - I think DPR is a wolf and is one that is probably quite capable of going deep should sounder minds find their way to the graveyard.

[monstrman]

Official Vote Count

Kronos (4): Shadory, Manbat, Clov, Seph

Niniel (3): Ed, Darthe, SoJames

Darthe (3): DPR, Niniel, Kronos

Not Voting (3): Songstress, Tigraine, Killashandra

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.Deadline set for Monday April 17th at 8pm MST  

 

you would think, but i am an enigma

a riddle wrapped in a twinkie

 

Now I want a banana Twinkie. *pouts*

 

On the other hand, I did ask my wife if she thought I was acerbic. She laughed. I took that as an "of course not".

Kudos on finding a woman who's willing to put up with ya.

sexual joke about bananas

[Kaylee]

*waggles eyebrows*

[Cory Caboose]

I don't know exactly how I feel about Darthe, but he's had quite a few mafia rands lately and I think it might simply be he's fatigued from it and trying to skate to a later day in that role.

 

He sometimes takes awhile to get going, but this game for him can be categorized more as a series of false starts (he has a burst of content that looks like he's gaining momentum and then it evaporates). I feel like at this point we'd have seen the REAL darthe by now and he'd have a more realistic sense of urgency. The false starts aspects feels more like he's a wolf that is trying to get into the game to gain town equity but wears out quickly than a villager who's having trouble staying with the game.

[Killashandra]

Cory I liked your breakdown. 

 

I want to see DPRs response to it.

 

I also do not think you are tool about Kronos. I wont go as far as saying he is a lying wolf but a lynch for him gives everyone else time to suss out who is who and only lose a inactive player.

[Shad_]

[Cory Caboose]

WBK has given me pause but not enough to move him out of my general bottom four. Niniel is in there as well.

 

Seeing what Kronos sees re: Niniel might shore some things up in this regard, because at this point I'm mostly confused.

[Killashandra]

Well then again we would lose a villager to at night.

 

This is a hard game...

[monstrman]

WBK has given me pause but not enough to move him out of my general bottom four. Niniel is in there as well.

 

Seeing what Kronos sees re: Niniel might shore some things up in this regard, because at this point I'm mostly confused.

qft

 

except the moved out of my bottom four bit

 

on that part we disagree

 

i'm still open to him being villa if he comes back before EoD

[monstrman]

Cory I liked your breakdown. 

 

I want to see DPRs response to it.

 

I also do not think you are tool about Kronos. I wont go as far as saying he is a lying wolf but a lynch for him gives everyone else time to suss out who is who and only lose a inactive player.

ok this is a villagy sequence tho

[Cory Caboose]

Tress I've seen glimpses of her villager game but nowhere near enough for me to be comfortable. If she doesn't get better d2 I'd kill with fire. (<3)

 

Tigraine/Killa I don't really have much a clue how to read which is going to limit my ability to have a confident read in either, but both have seemed genuine up to this point and I can sort of understand the way they are viewing the game. Wouldn't lynch either today.

[monstrman]

Well then again we would lose a villager to at night.

 

This is a hard game...

these two posts stupid multiquote stupid phones stupid dumbness

[monstrman]

if this is ks' first wolf game she might be on par with besie

[Cory Caboose]

 

WBK has given me pause but not enough to move him out of my general bottom four. Niniel is in there as well.

 

Seeing what Kronos sees re: Niniel might shore some things up in this regard, because at this point I'm mostly confused.

qft

 

except the moved out of my bottom four bit

 

on that part we disagree

 

i'm still open to him being villa if he comes back before EoD

 

 

He didn't move out of my bottom four.

[monstrman]

ooooh okay i didnt see the not

 

brain twins then

[monstrman]

kids don't inject heroine into your eyeballs before playing mafia

 

it will make you lose your mind

[monstrman]

i missed this so much

[monstrman]

as much as i hate this game sometimes this is the only place i get to talk to you guys it feels like

[monstrman]

the new people are cool too

[monstrman]

i cannot remember if i have ever played with niniel before

[Cory Caboose]

feel good

 

Sooh

 

Manbat

Seph

 

searching for clarity

 

Clov

 

Songstress

Killashandra

Ed2funy

Tigraine

 

want to lynch

 

Kronos

Niniel

 

Darthe
DPR

[Cory Caboose]

could be lolcory, could be corygoat, but that's what i'm working from

 

i would want to lynch out of the bottom four there ~always, so let's get talking

[Killashandra]

DM needs a discord. I found a discord for a podcast I listen too. Its pretty cool. Works well even on mobile. Much better than irc even. Because you can see earlier responses in the text chat. 

[Cory Caboose]

three of them are wagons so i guess that's a good start

 

i imagine at least one of those is a villager wagon though