[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[DPR]

Okay, that was trolly. 

 

BUT IT'S TRUE.

[DPR]

 

 

 

I see the scum among Seph, Hally and Zander.

 

Need to hear Zander's reveal to resolve his slot.

 

Would lynch Hally first.

 

Vote Hally

 

lololololol

 

Disregard my last question.

 

Touch on your Scum team makes sense with darthe if you dont mind please

 

 

 

Darthe was clearly enamored with his false reveal.

 

Seph saw him as town/supported/whatever he-wants-to-call-it, with Darthe in the early days. Hence my comment about not liking his game in the early days.

 

Hally is self explanatory.

 

Your slot has been viewed as a PR. You have decided to not elaborate on that, despite the fact that it would be easy to cover what you have implied.

 

 

No this is your reasoning behind why you think each is Scummy, Im asking based on interactions and game play etc how they make sense WITH Darthe,

 

 

First, stop asking people to answer questions if you won't. 

 

And why don't you tell us all about Darthe?

[Zander?]

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

[DPR]

 

 

 

Dice's point about mass reveals making a road map for Mafia is valid, yes. Yet he neglects to mention that sitting at 4/2, Town would also benefit from working to see who may be hiding behind a VT claim or PR that counters.

 

 

Lol, watch Hallia come in and counter Zander. I'd die

 

Bold is what im getting at.

 

AND THATS KINDA WHAT IM HOPING FOR!!!!

 

 

But you're high on teh horse killing drugs, right?

 

 

What?

 

 

OMG.

[DPR]

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

 

Yeah. It has protected your scum a$$ from getting lynched.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

I see the scum among Seph, Hally and Zander.

 

Need to hear Zander's reveal to resolve his slot.

 

Would lynch Hally first.

 

Vote Hally

 

lololololol

 

Disregard my last question.

 

Touch on your Scum team makes sense with darthe if you dont mind please

 

 

 

Darthe was clearly enamored with his false reveal.

 

Seph saw him as town/supported/whatever he-wants-to-call-it, with Darthe in the early days. Hence my comment about not liking his game in the early days.

 

Hally is self explanatory.

 

Your slot has been viewed as a PR. You have decided to not elaborate on that, despite the fact that it would be easy to cover what you have implied.

 

 

No this is your reasoning behind why you think each is Scummy, Im asking based on interactions and game play etc how they make sense WITH Darthe,

 

 

First, stop asking people to answer questions if you won't. 

 

And why don't you tell us all about Darthe?

 

 

Oh so now your at the kindergarten "i know you re but what am i" phase/defense.

 

good stuffs

[DPR]

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

 

Didn't heal Tress all that well, now did it.

[Zander?]

 

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

 

Yeah. It has protected your scum a$$ from getting lynched.

 

 

i will more then gladly step into the ring with you dpr.

[Zander?]

 

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

 

Didn't heal Tress all that well, now did it.

 

 

Correct

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

 

I see the scum among Seph, Hally and Zander.

 

Need to hear Zander's reveal to resolve his slot.

 

Would lynch Hally first.

 

Vote Hally

 

lololololol

 

Disregard my last question.

 

Touch on your Scum team makes sense with darthe if you dont mind please

 

 

 

Darthe was clearly enamored with his false reveal.

 

Seph saw him as town/supported/whatever he-wants-to-call-it, with Darthe in the early days. Hence my comment about not liking his game in the early days.

 

Hally is self explanatory.

 

Your slot has been viewed as a PR. You have decided to not elaborate on that, despite the fact that it would be easy to cover what you have implied.

 

 

No this is your reasoning behind why you think each is Scummy, Im asking based on interactions and game play etc how they make sense WITH Darthe,

 

 

First, stop asking people to answer questions if you won't. 

 

And why don't you tell us all about Darthe?

 

 

Oh so now your at the kindergarten "i know you re but what am i" phase/defense.

 

good stuffs

 

 

Yep.

 

You had all day yesterday to tie people to Darthe. Instead, you tunneled on me with Tress and her amazing 3-way-gambit idea. 

 

Now you ask everyone to work with you, but you aren't giving anything in return. Hell, ed even offered you a way to keep things cool and you won't take the offer.

 

Tress is dead and healing roles aren't informative, so i have a hard time seeing what you've got to offer.

[DPR]

 

 

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

 

Yeah. It has protected your scum a$$ from getting lynched.

 

 

i will more then gladly step into the ring with you dpr.

 

 

Blah blah blah. We know.

 

And then you'll ask a bunch of questions and refuse to answer any. It'll be great.

[DPR]

Alright. I'm off it. 

 

If Zander is scum, then there is no hope left in the world.

 

[v] the Hallia [/v]

 

[v] the Seph [/v]

[Zander?]

 

 

 

I will say that in part my role has protective abilities

 

Yeah. It has protected your scum a$$ from getting lynched.

 

 

i will more then gladly step into the ring with you dpr.

 

 

Blah blah blah. We know.

 

And then you'll ask a bunch of questions and refuse to answer any. It'll be great.

 

 

 

 

The only thing i havent directly answered was my role,  ive even got more posts then you do.

 

ive put the f'in work in considering ive just subbed in so back that bs up and check it at the door.

[Zander?]

as many posts my bad.

[DPR]

as many posts my bad.

 

Shh

[Zander?]

And the fact youre deliberately trying to rile me up is also Scummy AF.

[Zander?]

Alright. I'm off it. 

 

If Zander is scum, then there is no hope left in the world.

 

[v] the Hallia [/v]

 

[v] the Seph [/v]

 

18 hours of....

 

[DPR]

And the fact youre deliberately trying to rile me up is also Scummy AF.

 

 

Narrow this down and tell us what is not scummy AF.

[Zander?]

 

And the fact youre deliberately trying to rile me up is also Scummy AF.

 

 

Narrow this down and tell us what is not scummy AF.

 

 

Me, Im Villagery AF

[DPR]

 

 

And the fact youre deliberately trying to rile me up is also Scummy AF.

 

 

Narrow this down and tell us what is not scummy AF.

 

 

Me, Im Villagery AF

 

 

 

You're on drugs and can't figure Darthe out, soooo...

[DPR]

I was serious, btw. Give us your thoughts on ties to Darthe. 

[ed2funy]

 

 

 

 

Dice's point about mass reveals making a road map for Mafia is valid, yes. Yet he neglects to mention that sitting at 4/2, Town would also benefit from working to see who may be hiding behind a VT claim or PR that counters.

 

 

Lol, watch Hallia come in and counter Zander. I'd die

Bold is what im getting at.

 

AND THATS KINDA WHAT IM HOPING FOR!!!!

But you're high on teh horse killing drugs, right?

What?

OMG.

*sigh*

 

Zander, you really do realize why DPR has an EXTREMELY valid point, right?

 

You're waiting to see if anyone tries to pre-counter you so you can come in with your super secret fancy details and be like "ha, you are teh scum!"

But, you're also basically saying there's still a possibility that you're waiting for the real protective role to reveal so you can glean info and then claim some extra fancy details and be like, hahahaha this is the real role and only the real X Protective would know it!

 

We already *know* you're a protective role. The only thing you have going for you is that no one has claimed/countered yet.

[ed2funy]

 

 

And the fact youre deliberately trying to rile me up is also Scummy AF.

 

Narrow this down and tell us what is not scummy AF.

Me, Im Villagery AF

 

Really busy at work but lawd I need this thread right now

[ed2funy]

Where is everyone?

[Ironeyes]

 

I was gonna make a longer post with quotes right meow, but I'm exhausted. 

The gist of it was going to be that Zander is spazzing out a bit and DPR is making some good points on game play/mechanics, even if Zander wants to every single thing because he thinks DPR is scum. 

I still hold that Zander should at least partial reveal. Most likely what he's sitting on is some sort of detail related to his role/how he can use it, but that doesn't mean he can't claim. Zander, if I were in your spot (using my role as an example), I could have said I'm Commuter, but would have waited to give the nitty gritty like I did. Soooooo, yeah. 

 

Still think DPR is scum. A few good points does not a Townie make. 

 

Guys.

 

I'm not scum.

 

1. Seph - Went inactive and I haven't developed any different opinion on him. Hated his early game - has recovered a bit, but now seems a little apathetic, which is a good spot to hide in. Could go either way.

 

2. Hally - At this point, it would have been appropriate for her to post that rl is keeping her from the game and to replace her. Said she would post a lot - hasn't been back. Doesn't look good. The irony will be if she's voted into the ring and suddenly appears. High probability scum.

 

3. Iron - Rode the fence like a sheep with goggles in the start. Hasn't been too active or too inactive, but is making sense with posts. If he's scum, he's playing it well. Likely town.

 

4. dice - Nothing he's said has pinged me. If he's scum, he's doing a very nice job of it. Likely town.

 

5. ed - I got no problem with his claim. Liked that he stuck his neck out for Tress. 

 

6. Zander - Makes no sense to me. His slot was viewed as a pr, but he has refused to go into any details about it. Just me here, but that's a scum move. Then he calls for a mass reveal, but doesn't lead the charge. Instead, he says he'll go last, knowing that we have a MIA player. This is not even close to town behavior. But the kicker is that Tress is dead when everybody assumed Zan was the Doc... and he still won't comment on that???  On the other hand, everybody believes him and thinks I'm scum, so there we have it. 

 

7. Me - ed's favorite.

Not a bad read list. I'll take the comments on myself to be a compliment  ;) 

 

 

Yo Zander, you an evenescence fan too?

 

2nd fav female singer behind Halestorm.

My favorite is Paramore, but Halestorm is awesome too! I really like the crossover she did with Lindsey Sterling. 

 

 

 

Dice not willing to claim is Scummy AF imo.

 

But kinda of funny DIce's post or 2 before this is him asking me for my role tho...?!??!?!?

I'm pretty sure it's just dice being dice. He's not fond of being forced into things. That's a null tell for me.