[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

dicetosser1 · March 30, 2017

So far, we have three options...

1. DPR is right and he recruited someone and there was no NK.

2. The Mafia was as inept as DPR has been saying, and targeted Tress knowing there was a high probability a Doctor/Healing type would protect her.

3. They targeted me and didn't kill me.

Anyone else have any other ideas on what could have happened.

You were kinda obvious, Ed. Like "vanilla town trying to draw the NK" obvious.

I sincerely doubt they would have targeted you with the kill.

However inept they may or may not be, they weren't as observant as I expected them to be, though.

Tress, you make no mention of roleblockling here.

So here's the thing about me and mafia. It's very much like me and playing pool.

I'm not particularly all that good at it (probably because I never took physics), but every so often I pull off a truly impressive shot that makes me look like I know what the hell I'm doing. Sometimes it's even what I intended to accomplish. Those moments are exhilarating and make me love it so much that I'm willing to suffer all the times I scratch, actually miss hitting the cue ball entirely, or utterly fail to separate the balls on the break.

N2 was one of my flashes of brilliance. N3 I tried to pull something tricksy assuming the mafia wasn't actually dumb enough to target me, but were observant enough to catch a couple of hints I dropped earlier in the game.

N1 I watched BFG, like I mentioned, and I saw Crusher target her. My assumption was that he was a town power role, probably doc, as she was being widely town read and I was wavering between her and Sooh for the most likely to be targeted for the NK. I tossed Crusher in my list of "people I'm not so much interested in voting today" D2, but when BFG called me on it I realized I didn't have any justification for town reading him based on his actual game content, and I didn't want to broadcast my PR that early, so I played it off as "I thought I saw something, but wasn't sure what it meant". Which was actually true.

Crusher went inactive D2, and I kept my thoughts on him to myself - DPR's little drop of meta that Crusher tends to bring his "A" game when he's scum gave me enough justification to keep him out of my serious POE for D2 anyway.

When I revealed D3 I assumed Crusher's spot was going to stay inactive without a sub and I would be a dead duck. Just in case, at the beginning of N3 I stated my intention to watch myself... and then I started having all these amazing swirling thoughts about who the mafia team could be, and I thought just mayyyyybe one of them might be sharp enough to spot my little D2 Crusher slip. And so when Zander replaced Crusher, instead of watching myself get protected and risking missing the kill, I watched Zander.

Saw nothing.

So there's my results from N3, and I hang my head in shame for trying to outWIFOM the night kill and assuming the mafia team was eagle eyed enough to spot who I assumed was the doc.

You also don't mention being role blocked here.

Funny that you're suddenly predicting that you'll be role blocked tonight.

I am predicting that IF THEY CAN, mafia will probably roleblock me and not kill me so I can continue to suck and not have any useful information to share.

But you just offered to bring us meat. How does that work? And why would they think you suck - makes no sense at all.

But more than that, you've spent a good amount of time setting me up as a potential mislynch between your recruit theory and throwing shade at me during the fight phase and your insistence that it's a heavily vanilla game and nitpicking my mentioning a potential thought that literally did not cross my mind until this morning.

I made a point to say you were not a potential recruit. I pointed out that your case against me started before last night. I threw shade at you because your 3-way-gambit scenario is way over the top and not something that a player with an informative role would have to waste their time coming up with. As for vanilla roles, that's all we got so far, as I pointed out earlier.

If your plan is to retaliate against me for suggesting you were gambiting with Darthe, you can give it a rest. I am willing to reconsider your slot independent of Darthe based on your own merit and bring up concerns you can respond to.

We're playing mafia.. we turn over stones... I appreciate your offer to be friends now, but I must regretfully decline.

How about you let me do that and then we'll talk.

How about we'll see what we get this afternoon and then we'll know.

I'm in blue.

Blue fixed.

In your recruit theory why would Tress NOT be a potential recruit, she'd be the best choice best on whats occurred thus far imo.

i can think of a reason. I will wait til DPR answers tho

Zander? · March 30, 2017

Songstress is dead. She was -

Jack's complete lack of surprise, watcher, townaligned

Its now day five.

FML

RIP TressGOAT <3 <3 <3

I will try to avenge you!!!!

[v] DPR and Hallia [/v]

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

Welp, figured if we had a doc they'd protect her? Did they try to WIFOM?

Gah, I can't drive anymore guys. :sad:

#aminext

[v]Hallia[/v]

Zander, what's your theory?

DPR · March 30, 2017

Welp, figured if we had a doc they'd protect her? Did they try to WIFOM?

Gah, I can't drive anymore guys.

#aminext

[v]Hallia[/v]

Zander, what's your theory?

ed, you made the decoy play. The other candidate for Doc was Crusher/Zander, and that's where we have a real problem:

According to Tress, she viewed Crusher visiting BFG on N1.

So, if he wasn't the Doc, what was he doing?

DPR · March 30, 2017

I have a very hard time believing that Doc Zander wouldn't cover Tress.

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

Checking something before I throw my second vote on

BFG - VT

Sooh - Assuming Town

Cuth - VT

Noldy - VT

Tress - Watcher

Darthe - Goon

Ed - Commuter (Limited Use - Nights 1, 3, and 4)

Zander - Town (PR/Doc via Tress's Watching?)

Dice

Seph

Iron - Leaning town

Hallia - Lurking Scum? |||||| DPR - Agressive scum?

[v]DPR[/v]

Zander, did you not try to protect Tress?

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

Me checking was literally spending 20 minutes to go through that list. Lol

DPR, don't ask the same questions I am.

Zander? · March 30, 2017

DPR is Scum

DPR · March 30, 2017

DPR is Scum

I'm VT.

What's your role Poncho?

DPR · March 30, 2017

Me checking was literally spending 20 minutes to go through that list. Lol

DPR, don't ask the same questions I am.

I didn't.

You're giving Zander a free pass. Where was he last night?

Zander? · March 30, 2017

DPR is Scum

I'm VT.

What's your role Poncho?

Is VT Pirate talk for Scum?

I can tell you Im not VT

DPR · March 30, 2017

DPR is Scum

I'm VT.

What's your role Poncho?

Is VT Pirate talk for Scum?

I can tell you Im not VT

Well, when you're ready to quit stalling let everyone know what I asked, you let us all know.

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

DPR · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

You have him listed as Doc.

Tress only assumed he was Doc... there was no view or confirmation.

Zander? · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

I will claim last.

I think today is the day for all claims to get out there,

DPR · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

I will claim last.

I think today is the day for all claims to get out there,

Cool. I'm VT.

Zander? · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

I will claim last.

I think today is the day for all claims to get out there,

Cool. I'm VT.

Cool. I dont believe you.

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

Welp, figured if we had a doc they'd protect her? Did they try to WIFOM?

Gah, I can't drive anymore guys.

#aminext

[v]Hallia[/v]

Zander, what's your theory?

ed, you made the decoy play. The other candidate for Doc was Crusher/Zander, and that's where we have a real problem:

According to Tress, she viewed Crusher visiting BFG on N1.

So, if he wasn't the Doc, what was he doing?

Surprisingly good point/question.

But, if he wasn't, someone would have countered before D5

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

I will claim last.

I think today is the day for all claims to get out there,

Agreed. Was just gonna say I'm gonna push for it.

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

Not good you wanna claim last.

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

You have him listed as Doc.

Tress only assumed he was Doc... there was no view or confirmation.

Thus the question mark. Tress assumed and a few seek to reasonably believe it.

Zander? · March 30, 2017

Welp, figured if we had a doc they'd protect her? Did they try to WIFOM?

Gah, I can't drive anymore guys.

#aminext

[v]Hallia[/v]

Zander, what's your theory?

ed, you made the decoy play. The other candidate for Doc was Crusher/Zander, and that's where we have a real problem:

According to Tress, she viewed Crusher visiting BFG on N1.

So, if he wasn't the Doc, what was he doing?

Surprisingly good point/question.
But, if he wasn't, someone would have countered before D5

dude dont fall into DPR's trap.

He was sure Nolder was Scum...he wasnt.

He shaded Tress and me all day and night with his woe is me BS.

And what did Tress flip??? Thats right....Town!Watcher.

His talk about recruitment, and throwing shade and avoiding/side stepping or "not understanding" basic Mafia stuffs.

Dude his Scum.

Unless ofc youre Scum too....

Zander? · March 30, 2017

I'm not letting him off. I asked him about it. Zander, answer.

You have him listed as Doc.

Tress only assumed he was Doc... there was no view or confirmation.

Thus the question mark. Tress assumed and a few seek to reasonably believe it.

Dude think about it.

Tress knew what I was and Im pretty sure Iron knows too.

Just think bout what I said I did and what did or didnt happen since I said it.

ed2funy · March 30, 2017

*seem

DPR · March 30, 2017

Welp, figured if we had a doc they'd protect her? Did they try to WIFOM?

Gah, I can't drive anymore guys.

#aminext

[v]Hallia[/v]

Zander, what's your theory?

ed, you made the decoy play. The other candidate for Doc was Crusher/Zander, and that's where we have a real problem:

According to Tress, she viewed Crusher visiting BFG on N1.

So, if he wasn't the Doc, what was he doing?

Surprisingly good point/question.
But, if he wasn't, someone would have countered before D5

Not if we don't have a Doc.

We got a Watcher instead of a Cop - and I don't believe for a second that a cop missed 4 nights in a row on investigations. That info would solve the game anyway, so we woulda heard.

[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook