[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[BFG]

 

 

 

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

 

id rather you and marsh actually.

 

Why?

 

 

because marshs vote is horrible and because i think cuth is viable.

 

i could live with the darthe push but then he names marsh and sooh. doesnt want to push marsh tho. sooh just cause he doesnt understand his feelings.

 

and then theres those last posts about crusher. his reasons on crusher suck and he knows it! yet hes not voting his number 1 or number 2.

 

What do you mean by viable?

[BFG]

 

@ironeyes

 

the whole substance of my game has been an attack on darthe

 

explain to me how my being "eager", given the context and everything you know about me, makes me scum

 

in addition explain to me why you thought i was towny beforehand until that specific point

 

like seriously

Yeah but there's a huge difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and just telling people to vote them because #raisins

 

That's the difference between trying to solve the game and trying to manipulate it, which is also 90% of the difference between town and scum.

 

Cuth has several posts detailing why he's scum reading Darthe though

[Cuth]

yes, dice

 

i don't want to push marsh because one alarm bell is not enough for me and i feel like a little bit more from him will make me feel certain about that read

 

i don't want to push sooh because i'm in no way convinced she's scum, though she's one of my top picks 

 

i am voting my number one, yes, i have been doing so the entire game

 

i'm not pushing anybody else yet because i haven't felt that any person other than dice has behaved in a scummy enough fashion for me to call for their lynch, particularly given darthe being a very strong scum read 

[seph]

OK Cuth

1. His play this game is by far one of the most scummy. This has been a towny game I'm and he has put in 0 effort to solve it, with lackluster reasons for his votes, which he has 0 progression on.

2. I never said I don't see his play not Coming from a town perspective, I said it to you earlier.

 

3. My vote isn't based on this game compared to that 3p game. I am staying it is entirely different though.

 

4. You can see how hard he tried to solve it, there is a big difference and makes me think I am right though.

 

5. When he does post there is nothing actually helping us solve this game

[dicetosser1]

 I think theres stuff there to point a finger at and say this guy might be scum. No guarentees but I DO think theres one between him and iron.

 

irons vote just set me off but cuth seems to have largely ignored it iirc.

 

those two are bugging me and i want it sorted

[Cuth]

 

[v]ironeyes[/v]

 

more productive place for my vote atm

How is it more productive? You moved you scum read from 2 votes (one behind the highest train) to having iron at two votes?

 

Tress was my other 1 but I did like her recent post. I haven't noticed anything to different to how she plays as town as she is generally better after flips. But she hasn't given me enough to not put her in the fight pitts.

 

how is it counterproductive in your eyes

 

again i don't particularly care about my other vote

 

that said i was using it on one of the higher wagons to make sure that the people i feel are town are not the sole options as wagons

 

in this case i am currently of the opinion that iron has higher scum equity than crush, the person i voted in my first post (?iirc)

[Cuth]

 I think theres stuff there to point a finger at and say this guy might be scum. No guarentees but I DO think theres one between him and iron.

 

irons vote just set me off but cuth seems to have largely ignored it iirc.

 

those two are bugging me and i want it sorted

i ignored the post i responded to at length? with questions?

 

no, i did not

[seph]

 

@ironeyes

 

the whole substance of my game has been an attack on darthe

 

explain to me how my being "eager", given the context and everything you know about me, makes me scum

 

in addition explain to me why you thought i was towny beforehand until that specific point

 

like seriously

 

Yeah but there's a huge difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and just telling people to vote them because #raisins

 

That's the difference between trying to solve the game and trying to manipulate it, which is also 90% of the difference between town and scum.

Imo this post is towny even though I don't agree with it 100%

[seph]

So wait did you invite darthe? I may have gotten a bit confused

[dicetosser1]

But, I've delayed it long enough now. Must go to bed.

 

5am deadlines.

 

*huffs*

 

I feel like Dice.

 

So you feel AWESOME!!??

 

:D:D:D

 

 

yes, dice

 

i don't want to push marsh because one alarm bell is not enough for me and i feel like a little bit more from him will make me feel certain about that read

 

i don't want to push sooh because i'm in no way convinced she's scum, though she's one of my top picks 

 

i am voting my number one, yes, i have been doing so the entire game

 

i'm not pushing anybody else yet because i haven't felt that any person other than dice has behaved in a scummy enough fashion for me to call for their lynch, particularly given darthe being a very strong scum read 

 

 

stupid double vote system. missed you were also on darthe. still dont like the crusher vote tho

 

 

 

and so now im scummy? how?

[Cuth]

OK Cuth

1. His play this game is by far one of the most scummy. This has been a towny game I'm and he has put in 0 effort to solve it, with lackluster reasons for his votes, which he has 0 progression on.

2. I never said I don't see his play not Coming from a town perspective, I said it to you earlier.

 

3. My vote isn't based on this game compared to that 3p game. I am staying it is entirely different though.

 

4. You can see how hard he tried to solve it, there is a big difference and makes me think I am right though.

 

5. When he does post there is nothing actually helping us solve this game

i'm not saying you said you couldn't see his play coming from a town perspective

 

i am asking you

 

right here

 

and right now

 

whether you think not solving is >rand scum

[Cuth]

dice, "dice" should read darthe

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

 

i'm not taking them as 100% serious

 

but i'm trying to see if they make sense as town, and if they line up with perspectives and such

 

and as a result i have determined him to be probably scum? :P

Fair enough.

 

...

 

and ergo you should vote there :D

 

 

 

 

A belated good evening all <3

hello

 

may i suggest a vote on darthe

 

I thought you were towny until this happened. Little eager are we? [v]Cuth[/v]

 

 

vote ironeyes and cuth

 

Why?

 

 

i'm all for a thunderdome with darthe, if you guys would like to vote the both of us up

 

id rather you and marsh actually.  

 

Again, why?

 

 

Cuth has several posts detailing why he's scum reading Darthe though

 

Again: His tunnel on darthe is not scummy. His callouts to two other people to "vote Darthe" which I quoted in the post where I dropped my vote were scummy. Like I said, there is a difference between making a case and straight up manipulating people. 

[Ironeyes]

That sentence needs a few more commas. Sorry it's so difficult to read...

[Cuth]

 

@ironeyes

 

the whole substance of my game has been an attack on darthe

 

explain to me how my being "eager", given the context and everything you know about me, makes me scum

 

in addition explain to me why you thought i was towny beforehand until that specific point

 

like seriously

Yeah but there's a huge difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and just telling people to vote them because #raisins

 

That's the difference between trying to solve the game and trying to manipulate it, which is also 90% of the difference between town and scum. 

 

and? what is that difference

 

what, tell me, is the difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and then telling people to vote them?

 

tell me how i am "trying to manipulate the game"

[Ironeyes]

Should have read: "His callouts to two other people to "vote Darthe" (which I quoted in the post where I dropped my vote) were scummy.

[dicetosser1]

ironeyes ive already answered ure q's in the last couple pages

[Ironeyes]

 

 

@ironeyes

 

the whole substance of my game has been an attack on darthe

 

explain to me how my being "eager", given the context and everything you know about me, makes me scum

 

in addition explain to me why you thought i was towny beforehand until that specific point

 

like seriously

Yeah but there's a huge difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and just telling people to vote them because #raisins

 

That's the difference between trying to solve the game and trying to manipulate it, which is also 90% of the difference between town and scum. 

 

and? what is that difference

 

what, tell me, is the difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and then telling people to vote them?

 

tell me how i am "trying to manipulate the game"

I would consider towny play to be stating your reasons, then letting people make their own cases and decide for themselves. Just insisting that everyone vote a certain way reminds me strongly of a power lynch strategy, that, ironically, I first saw used by Darthe himself as scum. 

[Cuth]

 

Again: His tunnel on darthe is not scummy. His callouts to two other people to "vote Darthe" which I quoted in the post where I dropped my vote were scummy. Like I said, there is a difference between making a case and straight up manipulating people. 

show me the difference

 

show me how i am not making a case, but am rather straight up manipulating people

 

do it

[Ironeyes]

ironeyes ive already answered ure q's in the last couple pages

Literally all you've said was, "I didn't like his vote" and then not explained why. I need a little more than that

[seph]

 

OK Cuth

1. His play this game is by far one of the most scummy. This has been a towny game I'm and he has put in 0 effort to solve it, with lackluster reasons for his votes, which he has 0 progression on.

2. I never said I don't see his play not Coming from a town perspective, I said it to you earlier.

3. My vote isn't based on this game compared to that 3p game. I am staying it is entirely different though.

4. You can see how hard he tried to solve it, there is a big difference and makes me think I am right though.

5. When he does post there is nothing actually helping us solve this game

 

i'm not saying you said you couldn't see his play coming from a town perspective

 

i am asking you

 

right here

 

and right now

 

whether you think not solving is >rand scum

Yes I think putting no effort (not just solving) is indeed. Especially in a game like this where I feel confident or at least good about most people.

 

 

Sooh

WiFi

Dice

Ed

Bfg (though I disliked her recent interaction with Cuth a bit)

 

Iron

 

Tress

Darth

Hallie

Crusher

 

Cuth

Dpr

 

IA pretty much how I feel atm

[Ironeyes]

 

 

Again: His tunnel on darthe is not scummy. His callouts to two other people to "vote Darthe" which I quoted in the post where I dropped my vote were scummy. Like I said, there is a difference between making a case and straight up manipulating people. 

show me the difference

 

show me how i am not making a case, but am rather straight up manipulating people

 

do it

 

 

 

 

 

I would consider towny play to be stating your reasons, then letting people make their own cases and decide for themselves. Just insisting that everyone vote a certain way reminds me strongly of a power lynch strategy, that, ironically, I first saw used by Darthe himself as scum. 

Especially on day one, certain players can be influenced to vote just based on who's loudest. I would know cause I'm usually one of them. Been trying to change that lately

[Cuth]

 

 

 

@ironeyes

 

the whole substance of my game has been an attack on darthe

 

explain to me how my being "eager", given the context and everything you know about me, makes me scum

 

in addition explain to me why you thought i was towny beforehand until that specific point

 

like seriously

Yeah but there's a huge difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and just telling people to vote them because #raisins

 

That's the difference between trying to solve the game and trying to manipulate it, which is also 90% of the difference between town and scum. 

 

and? what is that difference

 

what, tell me, is the difference between making a case on someone, even tunneling them, and then telling people to vote them?

 

tell me how i am "trying to manipulate the game"

I would consider towny play to be stating your reasons, then letting people make their own cases and decide for themselves. Just insisting that everyone vote a certain way reminds me strongly of a power lynch strategy, that, ironically, I first saw used by Darthe himself as scum. 

 

so telling people what you believe and that they should believe it after giving actual reasons is manipulation?

 

i should just make a case, sit back, and let the wolves manipulate the lynch?

 

because i guarantee you that's what would happen if nobody tried to persuade anybody else

 

if everyone presents arguments without pushing their arguments, it's less productive

 

in this case darthe is scum

 

therefore i am calling for his lynch

 

is this unreasonable

[dicetosser1]

cause my gut hates it. 

[dicetosser1]

cause my gut hates it. 

 

this was at marsh