[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[Eldrick4221]

Curious what made you choose those 4 in particular :P

[Lenlo]

  On 1/23/2017 at 5:58 PM, Eldrick4221 said:

Curious why I'm lowest on your list, though.

That was in order of want to lynch, so your reading it backwards

[Sooh]

Host: The Twilight came, liberating the world from total darkness, and people were starting to wake from their slumber.

 

Niniel: Wait, you capitalized Twilight. Does that mean….

 

Verbal: Please don’t…

 

Host: In the small town of Forks, Washington…

 

MrsClov: I can’t believe it.

 

Host: … people left their houses to go to work or school. Some more sparkly than others in the small glimpses of sunlight that broke through the clouds,….

 

Ironeyes: Ugh. Why were they made to be sparkly! That’s ridiculous!

 

Host: … some who could have used a lint roller more efficiently.

 

Eldrick: Lint roller? Is that supposed to mean werewolves?

 

Host: Only one house never opened its doors that day, not from the inside anyway. When the inhabitant of the house never showed up for work, and was unreachable by phone, police were sent to the house.  Inside they found…

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

Bopolis, the Vanillaest of Vanilla Townies, in a pool of blood. Because of the extensive damage to his body, they were never able to determine the method in which he was killed. 

 

Bop: Great. I don't even know if a vampire or a werewolf killed me. Or maybe it was just another person. What is this game anyway? The narrations are all over the place. This never happens on....

 

Everyone: Ssshhh. You're dead.

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Sooh]

Vote count:

 

Not voting (9): Darthe, Ironeyes, Dice, Verbal, Lenlo, AJ, Eldrick, MrsClov, Niniel

 

 

 

 

EOD3 in: 

[bopolis]

xxxxxxxDEADxxxxxxx

 

i'm no longer the captain now

 

gg frands

 

[Eldrick4221]

That was a weird choice for a kill. As long as we don't have a deep wolf, we are closed to figuring it out.

[Eldrick4221]

Closer*

[Eldrick4221]

It also makes me feel like I'm on the right track. Bop and I were at very similar points. For him to be a threat would mean he was onto something.

 

Voting within Verb/Marsh/Lenlo today

[MrsClov]

Well, that was unexpected.

[MrsClov]

  On 1/23/2017 at 11:29 PM, Eldrick4221 said:

It also makes me feel like I'm on the right track. Bop and I were at very similar points. For him to be a threat would mean he was onto something.

 

Voting within Verb/Marsh/Lenlo today

My guess is one of those and a deep wolf. That's probably me just thinking it's way to easy otherwise.

[Eldrick4221]

Maybe, but I still think they could both be in there, and it's better to not go after deep wolves until you have to.

[MrsClov]

  On 1/24/2017 at 12:27 AM, Eldrick4221 said:

Maybe, but I still think they could both be in there, and it's better to not go after deep wolves until you have to.

Hoping you are right as well.

[Eldrick4221]

We still have room to be wrong, in any case. D1 scum lynch does that.

[MrsClov]

Once I get home going to do some research to see if we can get this figured out a bit more.

[Darthe]

Holy hell how much of this thread have I missed?  I am so sorry friends, let me dive back in.

[Andrej]

I was kind of expecting/hoping I'd be dead so I wouldn't have to worry about solving this game anymore. But all things considered I was probably going to always tinfoil a little bit on Bop so that helps. Gonna miss him motivation though :(

 

MrsClov and Dice are still off the table.

 

Like I said earlier, I don't think Verb/Nini would be scum together.

Wanna see what Darthe comes back with.

Lenlo needs to bring something to the table as well.

[Darthe]

  On 1/21/2017 at 9:11 AM, Eldrick4221 said:

 

  On 1/21/2017 at 8:51 AM, Nolder said:

 

  On 1/21/2017 at 8:35 AM, Andrej said:

That's exactly the argument.

That might be an argument to make in isolation...but given he false claimed Watcher that's two black marks as opposed to just one.

 

But let's put that aside for just a moment.

Does anyone recall Hallia using buddying as mafia before?

If she has a history of it I would be slightly more willing to hear this argument.

Not caught up yet, but this feels like a great point to address something.

 

I've given my stance on Darth a lot of thought. The blatant defense of a scum mate that I have been accusing Hally of having done with Darthe isn't her style. I feel like I have been completely wrong here. That Darthe is actually town.

 

Which means I am back to square one as far as scum suspects are concerned.

 

Well...mostly.

 

I'm suss of bop because of his quick agreeing with me about how if Hally flips scum, Darthe is next. Especially since he has changed his view since. It didn't sit well that he was on board so quickly. At the time it felt like distancing. Now it feels like appreciating support for a mislynch.

 

Eldrick is very probably a wolf.  I've seen a few scattered things as I was trying to find my last post that tie in, but this right here in and of itself is damning, because its the obvious logic he should have concluded twenty pages back and because of the switch on to bop who I suspect proved difficult to mislynch.  

[Darthe]

  On 1/21/2017 at 9:55 AM, Eldrick4221 said:

Like I said, I'm glad scum took that situation away. Although seeing who agreed with me about going afyer he could have proved fruitful.

What situation?

[Darthe]

Ftr im glad Nol is dead because that gets grating, but he was prob at least right on Verb also.  Haven't seen much from the old man yet but my read on him prior to absence had him low.

[Darthe]

  On 1/21/2017 at 2:18 PM, bopolis said:

maybe im just wrong on eldrick, why set up to CC as a wolf because it would be a 1-1 trade when wolves are already a woman down.

 

doesn't make sense

This is a fair point against my Eldrick rationale, I don't have a good explanation here.

[Darthe]

  On 1/21/2017 at 4:57 PM, Eldrick4221 said:

What I don't get is why you suddenly dropped your suss on Darthe. It isn't explained at all. You say he is a concern because of Hally's defense of him. You have him on your suss list for...lack of presence.

 

Then suddenly you agree with AJ that he has been villagery. Pretty sure you are townreading him now, so my suss of you is for this flipflop

Quoting this to see if it matches up

[MrsClov]

Okay, I ISO'd Hallia again, to see if I can find something of note. Going to ISO others in a bit, but wanted to start with her first.  Make of this what you want. I'm just trying to figure out interactions with the knowledge that Hallia's scum. 

 

Her town list was Bop, Me, AJ, and Darthe. Listed in post #267

Her scum reads were Nolder and Eldrick, obviously Nolder we now know to be town. 

 

The only time she addresses Iron is to say that she agrees with him. She doesn't specifically say on what, but I can assume it was Iron's post #59 or #60. Her agreeing was post #62. 

The only time I saw her mention Verbal was to say that she agreed with what he said when AJ accidently voted for Darthe and meant to vote for Nolder. Verbal's comment was "......" and "Ok NVM AJ said what my impression was. Although .... captures it pretty well, too." Post #165 and #166. 

 

As far as I can tell she didn't interact or say anything about Lenlo at all.

 

Lenlo, on the other hand actually had quite a bit to say about Hallia. In post #503 He said he wouldn't fight a Hallia lynch that hard because he's never sure of his read on her.

 

In post #927 he restated that he's bad at reading her without Zander or Shad in a game.

In post #391 he posts his reads list and his notes.  He had Hallia as Null-Town because they were agreeing.  In the spoilers, he says Hallia sees what he sees #75. And then doesn't get Dice's vote on her #208 Disagrees with my read on Hallia in post, but it was well thought out so he can't fight it.  Again states that he usually sheeps someone to figure out Hallia, but wanted to try on his own this game. #366

[MrsClov]

Here are some more interactions of note. Verbal commented on AJ’s list saying that he doesn’t want to lynch Marsh either and says to call it a hunch #403

 

In post #542 he comments on the Hallia train stating that he doesn’t “recall any type of defense from Hallia, seeing as she’s the main train with < a day left until DL. Hmm”

 

He did ask an interesting question of Hallia when the lynch was going down. Hallia asked why Wifi was scum reading her and in post #642 Verbal asked Hallia “Why are you only aiming at the 1 person who could be the lynch instead of you.... Instead of asking the others on your train?”

 

Post #645 is where he voted Wifi and stated that he needed to lynch her to clear up his thoughts on Hallia and me.  His suspicion of Wifi was based on Bopolis’s “findings”. Hallia’s response in #647 was that Wifi was on currently.

 

In post #657 Verbal quotes Dice who says that post #645 was a contradiction. Verbal states his point on Hallia stands and that he was switching to her because of Wifi’s claim.

In post #768 he states that Marsh’s vote switch from Wifi to Eldrick didn’t look good at all.

I don’t think that Verbal and Ironeyes can be w/w, not guaranteed but I find it highly unlikely.

[Darthe]

  On 1/21/2017 at 10:09 PM, dicetosser1 said:

im ok with bops reasons for voting wifi. Showed he was paying attention. Was a valid reason to sus. COULD be done by a scum but i lean to doubting it.

 

Marshs vote on eldrick has me wondering. most scum wouldnt have voted a completely off train then but he could be smarter then the average scum i guess.

 

AJ has me a little worried but its fully based on my own paranoid expectations of his dice reading abilities. gonna shelve that for now

 

i have it in my mind  and could some one confirm for me  cause i also have to catch up in another game    do i remember hally linking me and verb?

 

Dice you tend to split up your posts about people into seperate posts, one for each person.  Moreover, what has you paranoid about AJ's ability to read you specifically?  That's a throwaway statement in this game.  

[Darthe]

  On 1/22/2017 at 12:59 AM, MrsClov said:

The whole Bopolis theorizing about lynches and NKs if we lynch him today feels weird to me. I can't wrap my brain around how sort of offering yourself up like that that would be a townie thing to do instead of just trying to figure out who the scum is. I don't really know how to expand more on my thoughts other than it feels weird. 

This is a possible justification for the bop kill.