[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Shad_]

 

1) I think the first question about nyn switching languages is more about curiosity than game related. If it is game related i'd like to hear more about this line and what you think it may or may not mean

 

>.>

 

 

I'm actually extremely interested in how she answers this.

[Eldrick4221]

Reminder to snow that if you intended to update the roster and phase listing, you haven't yet.

[Shad_]

1) the lenlo question looks like she's just asking to point out the posts where it happens 

 

2) The question to DPR is anwsered in the post she quoted.

You're making me second guess myself so I'm going to pull up an ISO comparison and resolve this one proper in a minute.

 

Wifi makes me tinfoil on her like 20 times in a game and then I laugh at my stupidity the minute I reread her scum games.

[Shad_]

I don't read it as antagonistic at all and i would go so far as to say that labeling it as antagonistic is a gross misrepresentation

But this part is not wolfy at all for her.

[Shad_]

Nice I've burnt 1 out of 2 hours I allotted for myself tonight and I've progressed through three pages.

 

lolshad

[Andrej]

Wifi's best post this game was when she was asking Eldrick why people just simply saying "sheep me, vote so-and-so" is Town read worthy.

 

She's Town.

[Shad_]

Yeah she's a villager.

[Shad_]

Her game-related content has been down but this would be a better performance than her two previous scum rands by a landslide.

[Shad_]

@ bop ISO her in this game, she subs in D2 or 3 and mostly busses but you'll get a feel for her.  lmk what you take away.

 

I respect that most people don't want to ISO other games but I highly encourage any first-timer with Wifi to go through this process.  it's... enlightening.

[Eldrick4221]

So I went over tink's ISO. Definitely get the "just existing" vibe. Very little solve in there.

 

 

 

 

What's your thoughts on Calder?

 

Randomly pushing a lynch in the way he has seems incredibly obnoxious. For scum to do it and keep doing it this late into the day phase while providing absolutely zero other contribution seems like a ridiculously shitty way to draw attention to yourself. If he's scum, what would really be the point? I dunno, it would seem to be just a terrible play to me. On the other hand, it would appear he's almost succeeding given the amount of attention I'm getting. I can't believe I'm saying this but I'm leaning town.

Town reading him for basically doing nothing makes it pretty easy to get away with, no?

 

I'm not town reading him for doing nothing. I'm town reading him for openly playing like a moron while seemingly sticking to his guns despite the fact he's going to obviously get flack for it.

Also the wording in this post. Who is the "getting flack" obvious to?

[Eldrick4221]

@ bop ISO her in this game, she subs in D2 or 3 and mostly busses but you'll get a feel for her. lmk what you take away.

 

I respect that most people don't want to ISO other games but I highly encourage any first-timer with Wifi to go through this process. it's... enlightening.

I prefer firsthand experience. When I try to read games I'm not a part of and didn't follow along with the events as they unfolded, I just can't stick to it.

 

Sounds shallow when I say it like that, but it is what it is.

[Eldrick4221]

Tink hasn't given me a reason be on my nice list, and is slowly making his way to my naughty list.

[Eldrick4221]

That's the annoying thing about scum hunting. The real scum get there slowly. The "obvious scum" are usually town.

[Eldrick4221]

I think Notbob is nice. I don't know him well enough to have a confident read there, but I saw similarities to what he did last game, and that's enough for me for now.

[Shad_]

I prefer firsthand experience. When I try to read games I'm not a part of and didn't follow along with the events as they unfolded, I just can't stick to it.

 

Sounds shallow when I say it like that, but it is what it is.

It's not something I expect anyone to do and I pull in quotes from other games if I think they're important enough that all eyes ought to see them. (See: justifying my town read on Marsh in TG) Wifi is really the only exception where I hold people accountable to do some homework before lynching her.

 

Because otherwise she would be lynched in every game always and she's a super easy read.

[Shad_]

 

 

 

Pg 1 - 19 Fluff and crap because I dont wanna read it

 

Pg 20 - 25: I still dont see what Eldrick is saying in regards to AJ/Tiink and the antagonistic response. Eldricks self meta is null, he was asked a question, dont really care about it. Here Eldrick posted like 4 times before DPR could explain a post. Could be figgiting about DPRs read, could just be hyper Eldrick. Gonna remember it though. This is gamblers fallacy and you know it (#446). This read by Bop (#472) seems really lazy to me. Lazy town or pocketing wolf? His reasing about post counts later on is alright though.

 

Did this bob vote ever get resolved? (#485). Cause Bop is claiming a role here that told him Bob is wolf. From what im reading everyone is glossing over it.

 

Pg 25 - 30: So Bop is asking questions and learning the people around here, which is good, but makes me more concerned over that random Bob claim. Hesitant AJ agreeing (#543) Already explained the red flag to Shad (#578). I disagree with Calder but I think the argument hes making comes from a towny mindset (#596), the whole no-lynch argument.

 

 

Pg 31 - 36: Around here, im noticing Nyn is throwin around alot of posts but not a whole lot of relevant gameplay. Only really getting involved with the no-lynch and PPP stuff. Prals in! I agree with this post by Shad (#644). The idea that Bop was covering for Eldrick is a reach, as neither was in that bad a place all things considered. Sooh and DPR worry me now, because thats a wolfy idea to be pushing imo. Possibly this and maybe that (#679), a good case does not make. Whats the case on Tiink? (#701). Decent post from Bop, but im awaiting Hallia as shes the one thats gonna decide the slot for me (#713).

 

Pg 37 - 40: WIFI (#737), I am to lazy to go back and get you post numbers, but basically DPR says "This post is Terrible", Eldrick says "What about it" and then 3 other posts immediatly after DPRs post. The red is just my general estimation of all his posts.

 

 

Things that need to be followed up on:

-BOP, wth is that not bob role read thing? This legit? WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT IT

 

Not ordered at all, just grouped

 

bopolis

Eldrick4221

Shad_

Wildfire Sedai

 

Darthe

Tiinker

BEWBS MCGEE (AKA Nynaeve + Hallia Hydra)

Pralaya

Randomh3r0

Andrej

Not Bob (鲍勃不是我的名字)

Calder

 

Sooh

DreadPirateRoberts

 

Where im at atm. Sorry I was absent, but those first like 20-30 pages just made my eyes glaze over with stupid amounts of fluff posts.

 

 

 

 

@Lenlo why are bop and I in your top pile?

[Eldrick4221]

And I refuse to. I can see she's nice on my own tyvm :)

[Eldrick4221]

Oh. I totally forgot to mention cuz when I was caught up in had more important things to talk about.

 

Lenlo. I missed your catchup spoiler notes. It's refreshing to see them again :)

[Shad_]

And I refuse to. I can see she's nice on my own tyvm :)

 

Wow you two have never played together before.  I didn't realize that until just now.

[Shad_]

I've only been to a Starbucks once in Prague and I didn't know what to order... so I just had plain coffee >.>   #dork

Black coffee or gtfo

 

All that frilly stuff is nauseating.

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

Pg 1 - 19 Fluff and crap because I dont wanna read it

 

Pg 20 - 25: I still dont see what Eldrick is saying in regards to AJ/Tiink and the antagonistic response. Eldricks self meta is null, he was asked a question, dont really care about it. Here Eldrick posted like 4 times before DPR could explain a post. Could be figgiting about DPRs read, could just be hyper Eldrick. Gonna remember it though. This is gamblers fallacy and you know it (#446). This read by Bop (#472) seems really lazy to me. Lazy town or pocketing wolf? His reasing about post counts later on is alright though.

 

Did this bob vote ever get resolved? (#485). Cause Bop is claiming a role here that told him Bob is wolf. From what im reading everyone is glossing over it.

 

Pg 25 - 30: So Bop is asking questions and learning the people around here, which is good, but makes me more concerned over that random Bob claim. Hesitant AJ agreeing (#543) Already explained the red flag to Shad (#578). I disagree with Calder but I think the argument hes making comes from a towny mindset (#596), the whole no-lynch argument.

 

 

Pg 31 - 36: Around here, im noticing Nyn is throwin around alot of posts but not a whole lot of relevant gameplay. Only really getting involved with the no-lynch and PPP stuff. Prals in! I agree with this post by Shad (#644). The idea that Bop was covering for Eldrick is a reach, as neither was in that bad a place all things considered. Sooh and DPR worry me now, because thats a wolfy idea to be pushing imo. Possibly this and maybe that (#679), a good case does not make. Whats the case on Tiink? (#701). Decent post from Bop, but im awaiting Hallia as shes the one thats gonna decide the slot for me (#713).

 

Pg 37 - 40: WIFI (#737), I am to lazy to go back and get you post numbers, but basically DPR says "This post is Terrible", Eldrick says "What about it" and then 3 other posts immediatly after DPRs post. The red is just my general estimation of all his posts.

 

 

Things that need to be followed up on:

-BOP, wth is that not bob role read thing? This legit? WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT IT

 

Not ordered at all, just grouped

 

bopolis

Eldrick4221

Shad_

Wildfire Sedai

 

Darthe

Tiinker

BEWBS MCGEE (AKA Nynaeve + Hallia Hydra)

Pralaya

Randomh3r0

Andrej

Not Bob (鲍勃不是我的名字)

Calder

 

Sooh

DreadPirateRoberts

 

Where im at atm. Sorry I was absent, but those first like 20-30 pages just made my eyes glaze over with stupid amounts of fluff posts.

 

 

 

 

@Lenlo why are bop and I in your top pile?

Because aside from the NB thing Bop has asked alot of good questions, been active and in general just been... towny. I have problems with how he approached his NB "view" or whatever we wanna call it, but I dont know him enough to know if thats just something he does so its not gonna impact my read of him /to much/.

 

For you, I flip a coin afew times during the game as a sort of %error in my read. I like most of what you have posted and the coin landed on heads 3 times, so your town.

[Eldrick4221]

 

And I refuse to. I can see she's nice on my own tyvm :)

Wow you two have never played together before. I didn't realize that until just now.

I think we did once

[Shad_]

#1265

 

Lenlo's not 3p.

 

He's quite possibly town and I don't hate his Calder vote.

[Shad_]

oh hey Lenlo's on

 

sup

[Shad_]

I haven't seen any reason to think Calder's town yet and I have most of the roster in my town pile. pew pew?