Hackers Mafia - Game Thread [Game Over]

[Eldrick4221]

Zander, did you post a reads list yet?

[Zander?]

Zander, did you post a reads list yet?

 

No

[Eldrick4221]

Can you, please?

[Eldrick4221]

Or at least a top town (besides Marsh and yourself) and top scum, with reasons.

[Cass]

Yey! Read to here (872) \o/ ( :P NotBob, :P )

 

Can pull specific quotes/explain points further later if required but random mobile thoughts:

 

Don't think I see Nyn reacting the way she did/to that extent as Scum.

 

Shad commenting on Zander's general level of participation but not voting him on it (yet) is Towny imo.

 

Interested to see Zander's reaction and effort from here. He still feels lacklustre at present and I associate that more with Wolf Z in a team he can't get hyped about (ZANDER! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO) but early direct pressure isn't the way you figure him out imo.

 

Eldrick's comment on keys to reading Zander is spot on imo. Trying hard to be objective about points of tinfoil this game and don't actually have Eldrick leaning scum aorn. He's less slimy in feels then I recall from scum games of his. Watching Sooh.

 

Calder and Random's response to Eldrick's Zander comment felt off. Calder because it's the reverse of my Zander understanding, Random because how could he agree if he's never played with Zander Scum?

 

No idea on Darthe. Not someone I want to D1 lynch.

 

NotBob is the same boat.

 

Don't know Amega but [v]Amegakure[/v] Please come play!

 

Pral - there's a tonne of spam in catch up, not as horrifying as it first looks. Thoughts?

 

GTH aorn Zander/Amega/Calder/Random pinging most

 

 

 

Also lol Meow, Jelly, and Shad's unexplained read of Sooh 'not' being picked on XD

[Eldrick4221]

@Cass I would like the brownie points, please.

 

Yay for quote trimming.

[Eldrick4221]

I agree with you on Zander. It's why for quite some time I wasn't able to read him as town. His effort level just isn't there.

 

The thing I quoted to dice irt zander's vote on Random is towny for him, but have to keep in mind that it was something discussed about ITT. Something that scum!Zander would be aware is missing in his game.

 

I stick by my reason for his lack of response to dice voting him as not being odd. I see dice's point of why he would expect a response though, so that is null.

 

Zander is a tentative town for me rn

[Ironeyes]

What the heck... How did you guys put up thirty-five pages while I slept off my jet lag? This is gonna be a long catch up.

 

Anyone want to give me a short summary of the current situation in the mean time please?

[Zander?]

Can you, please?

 

 

Or at least a top town (besides Marsh and yourself) and top scum, with reasons.

 

I have too many nulls atp tbqh.

 

Town-

 

Iron- IC

 

Notbob for now, were seeing eye to eye on reads and he doesnt seem to be pushing an agenda atp.

 

Monstr/Cass- I thought was Scummy but I dont think he reacts like that as well as Scum!Monstr.  Cass has looked ok upon catch up thus far.

 

Scum- Random/Dice/Sock- Want to see if my theory is right.

 

Random- Hasnt felt as involved as last game, picking and choosing when to use Meta on a reads list he felt prompted to respond with one.

 

Sock- Sooh's been posting but not really Scum hunting. Eldrick connection's post.

 

Dice- His reasoning for voting me is awful. But im having some doubts because I dont think Nyn would react like that as Scum

[Eldrick4221]

Either Im really wrong or Notbob is likely Town imo.

Where do you get that read from?

[Calder]

What the heck... How did you guys put up thirty-five pages while I slept off my jet lag? This is gonna be a long catch up.

Anyone want to give me a short summary of the current situation in the mean time please?

Manbat and Nyn got kicked out da game

 

Eldrick is posting a lot

 

Zander not posting as much as expected

 

Darthe not caring as usual

 

Calder being Calder

 

Dice is town

 

Notbob hates Eldrick

 

Amega/Cass/Pral left no impression

[Zander?]

Shad has looked ok so far but his activity level isnt where Id like it.

[Eldrick4221]

What the heck... How did you guys put up thirty-five pages while I slept off my jet lag? This is gonna be a long catch up.

 

Anyone want to give me a short summary of the current situation in the mean time please?

Technical points:

 

Nyn and manbat left.

Nyce is now just dice

Manbat replaced with Cass

[Zander?]

I find it kind of funny im getting flack for PC when people know I can lead PC as either alignment but really im 2nd in PC...

 

Eldrick4221

217 Zander 103 Sooh 87 Shad_ 85 manbat 75 randomh3r0 66 Nynaeve 62 Calder 51 Darthe 39 鲍勃不是我的名字 32 dicetosser1 26 Andrej 19 Cass 17 amegakure 5 Pralaya 2 Ironeyes 2

[Calder]

Shad has looked ok so far but his activity level isnt where Id like it.

Replace "Zander" with "Shad" and you get my exact Zander opinion atp lol.

[Calder]

2nd by a mile Zander.

[Ironeyes]

 

What the heck... How did you guys put up thirty-five pages while I slept off my jet lag? This is gonna be a long catch up.

 

Anyone want to give me a short summary of the current situation in the mean time please?

Technical points:

 

Nyn and manbat left.

Nyce is now just dice

Manbat replaced with Cass

Thabjs

[Zander?]

 

Shad has looked ok so far but his activity level isnt where Id like it.

Replace "Zander" with "Shad" and you get my exact Zander opinion atp lol.

 

 

 

2nd by a mile Zander.

[Eldrick4221]

@Zander Why does dice's vote on your being awful = dice is scum?

[Calder]

The Eldrick/Sooh team has 201 more posts than you.

[Cass]

 

No quotes for this cos I gotta drive home but

@Eldrick - My issue with your call on Darthe is that I read it simply as him playing, I don't understand the leap to "he's deliberately avoiding work and going to take someone else's response as what's happened in the game".

Can you explain why you voted Monstr if you had him null and NotBob scummy?

Also, you and Darthe are both saying you're not going back to reread. You call him scummy for it, then say it would be scummy if it was anyone else, and then state it yourself a few posts later.

I get that I was wrong about Darthe, that this is normal for him. It rubbed me the wrong way and I took it as scummy without stopping to think about meta.

The difference between Darthe and me is I have read the thread once. He was saying he was gonna skip reading it.

As for manbat vs Notbob, the way manbat handled random's question felt very bad. I agreed with what random was pointing out and voted accordingly. Dice's explanation made sense as to why manbat did what he did, so I unvoted.

By the time I got to wanting to vote Notbob, I had realized that I should discuss with Sooh before placing a serious vote. Not used to this hydra thing.

You can have Brownie points for quote trimming :D but still don't follow the logic here wrt Darthe. (Have been able to see where you might have been getting other conclusions to here, but not that initial jump, can't code that anything but reachy). If you're not pushing it, let's agree to disagree and move on to see what else shakes out.

 

Pral has also said he may not read/what do you make of that?

 

The vote on Monstr was still awful regardless of the unvote (which in itself could be equally Town/Scum motivated as far as I can weigh)

 

Thoughts on Calder and Random's response to your Zander comment?

 

NotBob's recent posting?

 

Zander aorn?

[Zander?]

@Zander Why does dice's vote on your being awful = dice is scum?

 

Dice reasoning for voting me is awful.

 

No that dont make him Scum and like I said i dont think Nyn reacts like that as Scum.

 

He's the best of the worst for me so to speak.

[Eldrick4221]

Blah that wasn't supposed to send yet. Keyboard freaked.

 

Also @ Zander

 

Notbob has basically only been talking about lynching me and Sooh. Only referencing posts that talk about that.

 

How did that give you a Town read of him? Even taking into account that you think I'm scum, how has his play been better than null?

[Eldrick4221]

 

@Zander Why does dice's vote on your being awful = dice is scum?

Dice reasoning for voting me is awful.

 

No that dont make him Scum and like I said i dont think Nyn reacts like that as Scum.

 

He's the best of the worst for me so to speak.

You say scum is sock, dice, random

 

You say dice isn't scum.

 

Either you think he is or isn't.

[Zander?]

Blah that wasn't supposed to send yet. Keyboard freaked.

 

Also @ Zander

 

Notbob has basically only been talking about lynching me and Sooh. Only referencing posts that talk about that.

 

How did that give you a Town read of him? Even taking into account that you think I'm scum, how has his play been better than null?

 

Ive touched on Notbob already.

 

Unless my reads are off I think he's Town most likely.

 

Its Notbob, he's low activity either way but as Scum he tries to push things with a weak agenda and Ive not really seen that yey from him.