[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

Darthe · September 30, 2016

Ok so I'm finally caught up.

I don't know what that whole thing with Monstr was.

I've played with him before a few times and I don't remember him snapping like that.

That isn't to say it can't be some kind of gambit or whatever just saying it's not the normal monstr that I'm used to, if I can even claim to know what normal monstr is after only a couple games.

I'd say Besies tone has improved and makes me less leery of the why me freak out but I'd still probably lynch her.

Calder continues to be useless like every game would also lynch him.

Zanders muted behavior is also very odd but maybe he's very invested in BFGs game right now idk.

Would like to see more of him regardless.

Not asking for full blown Zander, just more.

Those are all the thoughts I have offhand.

I think I need to talk to Dice and Nego because I did not get a good read on them while catching up.

This post, I am going back and forth on it believe. Thoughts?

September 30, 2016

I just had a thought.

Zander loves being town and his WIM is always high when he is. This is universally known, right?

So even if we know that he's been in another game, and focusing his attention there, wouldn't he have given just as much attention here - had he been town?

Surely he would have wanted to help us find the scum that he loves lynching so much?

Thoughts? Z?

September 30, 2016

Zander

Nolder

Sooh

^^^^^Scum team - feel great about the top 2.

Could you please explain Sooh?

Sooh is all feel for me. She is playing a good game, in that I dont think it differs from her town one that much. It just feels off to me. Like a knockoff designer handbag trying to be passed off as the real deal. Sure it looks the same. But, that logo is busted.

Would you say seeing Sooh as town feels the same as seeing an optician who doesn't wear glasses?

September 30, 2016

Nego is never dying btw. Over my dead corpse.

Don't worry little bro, I got you. <3

Are you sure about that? You look younger than me on webcam.

September 30, 2016

Would I vote Negp?

Yes you would other Barry. Yes. You. Would.

If you think I'm scum, go ahead.
I'd prefer lynching actual scum though.
Wolfy that you felt the need to add this on tbh
:thumbsup:
Do you understand why?
Of course but I'm not worried about it.

Good, let's not make it a habit though or I will start to worry about it.

Let me wolf the way I want to wolf please.

Darthe · September 30, 2016

I just had a thought.

Zander loves being town and his WIM is always high when he is. This is universally known, right?

So even if we know that he's been in another game, and focusing his attention there, wouldn't he have given just as much attention here - had he been town?

Surely he would have wanted to help us find the scum that he loves lynching so much?

Thoughts? Z?

Kinda angleshooty feeling but id be lying if I said I didnt have the though too.

September 30, 2016

Ok so I'm finally caught up.

I don't know what that whole thing with Monstr was.

I've played with him before a few times and I don't remember him snapping like that.

That isn't to say it can't be some kind of gambit or whatever just saying it's not the normal monstr that I'm used to, if I can even claim to know what normal monstr is after only a couple games.

I'd say Besies tone has improved and makes me less leery of the why me freak out but I'd still probably lynch her.

Calder continues to be useless like every game would also lynch him.

Zanders muted behavior is also very odd but maybe he's very invested in BFGs game right now idk.

Would like to see more of him regardless.

Not asking for full blown Zander, just more.

Those are all the thoughts I have offhand.

I think I need to talk to Dice and Nego because I did not get a good read on them while catching up.

This post, I am going back and forth on it believe. Thoughts?

I'm not Believer but I found the last line in particular bad especially since he's done nothing to initiate either convo and when I initiated one with him he had no idea what to say.

It made me think he's just saying things to appear like he's contributing but has no will to actually figure out if dice or i are scum or not.

Darthe · September 30, 2016

Would I vote Negp?

Yes you would other Barry. Yes. You. Would.

If you think I'm scum, go ahead.
I'd prefer lynching actual scum though.
Wolfy that you felt the need to add this on tbh
:thumbsup:
Do you understand why?
Of course but I'm not worried about it.
Good, let's not make it a habit though or I will start to worry about it.

Let me wolf the way I want to wolf please.

Id prefer if you towned.

Darthe · September 30, 2016

Ok so I'm finally caught up.

I don't know what that whole thing with Monstr was.

I've played with him before a few times and I don't remember him snapping like that.

That isn't to say it can't be some kind of gambit or whatever just saying it's not the normal monstr that I'm used to, if I can even claim to know what normal monstr is after only a couple games.

I'd say Besies tone has improved and makes me less leery of the why me freak out but I'd still probably lynch her.

Calder continues to be useless like every game would also lynch him.

Zanders muted behavior is also very odd but maybe he's very invested in BFGs game right now idk.

Would like to see more of him regardless.

Not asking for full blown Zander, just more.

Those are all the thoughts I have offhand.

I think I need to talk to Dice and Nego because I did not get a good read on them while catching up.

This post, I am going back and forth on it believe. Thoughts?

I'm not Believer but I found the last line in particular bad especially since he's done nothing to initiate either convo and when I initiated one with him he had no idea what to say.

It made me think he's just saying things to appear like he's contributing but has no will to actually figure out if dice or i are scum or not.

Idk, thats just a matter of sseing if he follows through or not.

Hallia · September 30, 2016

Zander (4): Calder, manbat, Darthe, Sooh

Believer (2): dice, Zander

dice (1): Believer, Nego

Darthe (1): Besie

Calder (1): Tiinker

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (4): The rest of you wankers.

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline:

Believer · September 30, 2016

Nego is never dying btw. Over my dead corpse.

Don't worry little bro, I got you. <3

Are you sure about that? You look younger than me on webcam.

You're Finnish, hence little brother. <3

Believer · September 30, 2016

Ok so I'm finally caught up.

I don't know what that whole thing with Monstr was.

I've played with him before a few times and I don't remember him snapping like that.

That isn't to say it can't be some kind of gambit or whatever just saying it's not the normal monstr that I'm used to, if I can even claim to know what normal monstr is after only a couple games.

I'd say Besies tone has improved and makes me less leery of the why me freak out but I'd still probably lynch her.

Calder continues to be useless like every game would also lynch him.

Zanders muted behavior is also very odd but maybe he's very invested in BFGs game right now idk.

Would like to see more of him regardless.

Not asking for full blown Zander, just more.

Those are all the thoughts I have offhand.

I think I need to talk to Dice and Nego because I did not get a good read on them while catching up.

This post, I am going back and forth on it believe. Thoughts?

Nothing pings me super strongly but he could hang.

Zander will resolve himself because of his play style, there is no possible universe where he lives until endgame as scum. So it's slightly strange to want more of him at this stage.

I think both dice and Nego have posted enough to be read.

Reads like posting for the sake of posting, to me.

September 30, 2016

Would I vote Negp?

Yes you would other Barry. Yes. You. Would.

If you think I'm scum, go ahead.
I'd prefer lynching actual scum though.
Wolfy that you felt the need to add this on tbh
:thumbsup:
Do you understand why?
Of course but I'm not worried about it.
Good, let's not make it a habit though or I will start to worry about it.
Let me wolf the way I want to wolf please.

Id prefer if you towned.

Good, then neither of us have nothing to worry about.

September 30, 2016

Zander (4): Calder, manbat, Darthe, Sooh

Believer (2): dice, Zander

dice (1): Believer, Nego

Darthe (1): Besie

Calder (1): Tiinker

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (4): The rest of you wankers.

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline:

So my vote does not count? Cool

September 30, 2016

Nego is never dying btw. Over my dead corpse.

Don't worry little bro, I got you. <3

Are you sure about that? You look younger than me on webcam.

You're Finnish, hence little brother. <3

September 30, 2016

I could go for a Nolder lynch too btw

Zander? · September 30, 2016

Thread is dead. Throw Zander off the plank.

Again the suss without reasoning.

I quoted your vote on me last night.

I want you to quote me the raisins you voted for me at the time.

September 30, 2016

p25-29

(Still my catchup thoughts and opinions)

as long as its on believer or tink im in

How people get these reads after such little interaction is beyond me.

Actually after no interaction. We haven't even spoken to each other yet itt. What's the deal Dice?

The insisting on interaction before someone can decide alignment is not true at all, and i’m going to say slight scum alignment, regardless of the actual content of these posts. Interaction means someone can talk themselves out of it. Your play by interaction with the other players should be towny enough without having to explain yourself to everyone. More thoughts on his saying this is in my ISO spoiler on p26 (#507)

Looking at the actual content, Dice explains himself immediately when asked (#488) so I still don’t think Tiink’s response was the correct one, or in the right way anyway.

Ok, caught up from yesterday. Thankfully not as much pages as I expected !

I do not have experience with a lot of people in this game. Haven't played with Besie, Nego. Played just a handful of games with manbat and calder, don't remember much how they play.

That said, I wanted to know how Blesie played because I kinda saw some kind of appealing tone in this game. I know that she has only played one town game so far and I went ahead and checked it (Lost Mafia- notice her tone. She sounded similar as she is here - excited, analyzing etc. She got mislynched D2 in that game.

I don't see anything that has stood out from her so far this game.

im here briefly just got home from work so too tired for a 10 page catchup.

@tink I didnt like the way you backed off ure zander vote

Tiinker plays quite safe when he is scum. I know it because I was scum with him in a recent game. I don't see him going for aggressive early votes like in this game as scum.

In these posts Pral seems to be looking at meta’s of players, including the ones he has not played with. I’m going with slight town indicative.

Null on players that have little content makes sense of course. But, when players have a lot, I think you are pressed to defend a null stance on them.

I understand Calder’s reasoning here, even though it wasn’t necessary at this point in time. This was at Tiink who couldn’t give specifics yet (even in high posters) due to him not having been able to read the thread properly yet. Not alignment indicative atm, I think.

How can you blatantly say that you havent read enough to make an informed decision then not read enough to make an informed decision and just say "null is good enough for now?"

I agree with Calder it's not a good look

Quoted this cause I’m not going back to quote the original (p27 by Tiink) and mess up the order/time of the quotes in this post.

Tiink is asked for reads on two of the most active posters and says it’s null for him for the sake of saying something. This seems unlikely as he must’ve felt something whilst reading it, but it also shows that Tiink has not been involved in the game by this stage at all. I’ve no alignment indicative opinion on this at this stage.

The wolfy response is "that sounds like work" or "I'll dodge that question instead by not really answering it with any thought"

Villagers can think about why they find someone suspicious and it forces the wolves to try to pretend to when every villager starts thinking

This is one example - he keeps giving advice as to how to play as villager. Kinda reminds me of cory. Slight town indicative. It feels like he has nothing to hide. Plus, by constantly “giving advice” he is sharing his thoughts on how he thinks a villa should play – and I have not seen anything that is wrong. His three posts directly after one another is a bit odd in that it felt like he feels like he should add more and more to clarify – but this doesn’t mean anything alignment to me atm.

Zander? · September 30, 2016

Couch was comfy. It made me take a nap.

Also

[v]Tiink[/v]

Why are you voting Tink?

This is why I don't play this game

I won't fling obscenities but I'm done putting the effort forth

Don't really give a crap if you lynch me enjoy turboing your own win equity

[V]zander [/v]

I am voting zander right now because his thread presence is incredibly concerningly low

for zander this is not right

especially because he wouldn't just take the push from calder lying down imo

Dude I stated in the signup thread I was in 2 games.

Yesterday was DL in it.

Also I know Im normally #1 in this but for seriously wtf:

Darthe

121 BlomBesie 107 manbat 98 Nego 96 Zander 93 Sooh 76 Calder 64 Tiinker 41 dicetosser1 35 Nynaeve 33 Believer 26 Pralaya 23 Nolder 18 Hallia 11

And I missed pretty much a full rl day

Im catching up and Ill see whats up from Calder irt his vote on me Monstr, Ive asked about it and once Im caught up I'll see whats up with it.

There are Wolves trying to push and exploit me splitting time between 2 games but if they think Im going down without a fight, they are sadly sadly mistaken.

Zander? · September 30, 2016

I know of exactly two people that will try to use that to lynch me and as a preemptive measure: "you are not good at this game."

K.

Brah, my job aint to maintain your wim or to champ you. Thats a risk for me, cause idk your alignment and everything is treated as gameplay whether it really is or not.

Hold your ground and fill the slot you were dealt, thats your job. Dont bring all this non game related nonsense in here, take it to a mod pm or save it til post game.

I was not referring to you

I was referring to zander and pral as the most likely candidates (because they are)

Excuse me man, youre trying to tell people I would try and tell YOU you werent good at his game???

Thats straight up BS Monstr.

And unless im missing something its also a straight up lie.

Zander? · September 30, 2016

Darthe, you seem to have played with manbat a lot. Is this kind of reaction townie for him?

Anyone else who has played with manbat can also let me know.

Normal for Town!Monstr from the limited exp I have in games with him.

Not something he cant fake tho.

But I think its the level of frustration and keeping it up that I would think would be hard for Scum!Monstr to keep up or maintain imo.

I mean I know zander has the second most posts I just want to know where he is right now

I'm almost inclined to think it's just because he's busy or something

Again 2 games at once.

Ill be caught up and current soon.

Then we can talk real time and if youre actually a Villager which I think you may slighty be atp, that you'll see whats what.

Darthe · September 30, 2016

Thread is dead. Throw Zander off the plank.

Again the suss without reasoning.

I quoted your vote on me last night.

I want you to quote me the raisins you voted for me at the time.

Complaining that you're getting voted isn't much of a defense, you know this.

Darthe · September 30, 2016

There are Wolves trying to push and exploit me splitting time between 2 games but if they think Im going down without a fight, they are sadly sadly mistaken.

Wolf post

Darthe · September 30, 2016

Then we can talk real time and if youre actually a Villager which I think you may slighty be atp, that you'll see whats what.

We can lynch zander. We can lynch him now.

Zander? · September 30, 2016

You guys can hunt for anyone you want (as long as its Zander).

"Welcome to the Zander zone."

- Vin Diesel

Why is no one asking Calder why hes voting for me???

[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

Recommended Posts

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Guest

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook