[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[monstrman]

T.5 hours

[monstrman]

T-5.5 hours*

[Guest]

D1 Final:

Zander (5): Calder, Sooh, Tiinker, Darthe, monstr

Calder (4): Besie, Zander, Pral, dice

Nolder (1): Believer

dice (1): Nego

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (2): Hellian, Nolder

 

Votes during D1:

Besie: Darthe > Calder

Nego-Dya: Believer > Besie > Dice

Monstrman: Zander > Besie > Calder > Calder > Calder > Nolder > Calder > Nolder > Zander > Calder > Zander

Pral/Kat: Calder

Tiink: Zander > Calder > Zander

Hellian-Wildfire: -

 

Zander: Besie > Believer > Calder

Calder: Zander

Sooh: Tiink > Zander

Believer: Nego > Dice > Nolder

Dice: Believer > Calder > Nolder > Calder

Nolder: -

Darthe: Besie > Zander > Nolder > Zander

 

I obviously need to learn the difference between posts made by scum vs. town PR

 

***************************

 

D2 Final:

Believer (6): Darthe, Sooh, Wifi, Tiinker, dice, Besie
Besie (2): manbat, Pral
Tiinker (1): Nolder
Sooh (1): Believer

Waiting for the opportune moment (1): Dyachei

 

Votes during D2:

Besie: Monstrman > Tiink > Believer

Nego-Dya: -

Monstrman: Believer > Sooh > Besie

Pral/Kat: Besie

Tiink: Nego > Besie > Believer

Hellian-Wildfire: Believer

 

Believer: Darthe > Monstrman > Tiink > Sooh

Dice: Nolder > Believer

Sooh: Believer

Nolder: Tiink

Darthe: Besie > Besie > Believer

 

**************************

 

D3 Final:

Nolder (5): Pral, Besie, manbat, Tiinker, Wifi
Tiinker (2): Nolder, dyachei

Not voting (1): Darthe

 

Votes during D3:

Besie: Tiink > Nolder

Nego-Dya: Tiink

Monstrman: Nolder > Nolder

Pral/Kat: Nolder

Tiink: Nolder

Hellian-Wildfire: Nolder > Tiink > Nolder

 

Nolder: Tiink

Darthe: Nolder

 

**************************

 

Votes during D4 so far:

Besie: Tiink > 0

Nego-Dya:

Monstrman: Besie > Besie > Tiink > Wildfire > 0

Pral/Kat:

Tiink: Besie

Hellian-Wildfire:

 

Also posting this

[Nynaeve]

Official Vote count

 

Besie (1): Tiinker

 

Not voting (5): Wifi, Pral, dyachei, Besie, monstr

 

 

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

 

 

Deadline:

[Guest]

I'll stare at the votes I posted and try to find some logical deduction from it. I just want to eat first.

 

Pral & Dya, while you're here please answer this?

 

1. Do you think there is a deepwolf?

2. If yes, who do you think the deepwolf is, and why? Or at least, between who?

[Guest]

Can I have Tiink, Wildfire, Dya and Pral's opinions on who the scum are, please?

 

The deepwolfing thing will only actually help next day, if there is one.

[monstrman]

I have too much to do today ugh

 

today of all days

[Guest]

I have too much to do today ugh

 

today of all days

 

I get you. Work starts tomorrow for me.

[Guest]

Okay, here we go.

If someone else can find some other pattern or whatever, please say.

 

 

 

D1 Final:

Zander (5): Calder, Sooh, Tiinker, Darthe, monstr

Calder (4): Besie, Zander, Pral, dice

Nolder (1): Believer

dice (1): Nego

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (2): Hellian, Nolder

 

Votes during D1:

Besie: Darthe > Calder

Nego-Dya: Believer > Besie > Dice

Monstrman: Zander > Besie > Calder > Calder > Calder > Nolder > Calder > Nolder > Zander > Calder > Zander

Pral/Kat: Calder

Tiink: Zander > Calder > Zander

Hellian-Wildfire: -

 

Zander: Besie > Believer > Calder

Calder: Zander

Sooh: Tiink > Zander

Believer: Nego > Dice > Nolder

Dice: Believer > Calder > Nolder > Calder

Nolder: -

Darthe: Besie > Zander > Nolder > Zander

 

I obviously need to learn the difference between posts made by scum vs. town PR

 

***************************

 

D2 Final:

Believer (6): Darthe, Sooh, Wifi, Tiinker, dice, Besie
Besie (2): manbat, Pral
Tiinker (1): Nolder
Sooh (1): Believer

Waiting for the opportune moment (1): Dyachei

 

Votes during D2:

Besie: Monstrman > Tiink > Believer

Nego-Dya: -

Monstrman: Believer > Sooh > Besie

Pral/Kat: Besie

Tiink: Nego > Besie > Believer

Hellian-Wildfire: Believer

 

Believer: Darthe > Monstrman > Tiink > Sooh

Dice: Nolder > Believer

Sooh: Believer

Nolder: Tiink

Darthe: Besie > Besie > Believer

 

**************************

 

D3 Final:

Nolder (5): Pral, Besie, manbat, Tiinker, Wifi
Tiinker (2): Nolder, dyachei

Not voting (1): Darthe

 

Votes during D3:

Besie: Tiink > Nolder

Nego-Dya: Tiink

Monstrman: Nolder > Nolder

Pral/Kat: Nolder

Tiink: Nolder

Hellian-Wildfire: Nolder > Tiink > Nolder

 

Nolder: Tiink

Darthe: Nolder

 

**************************

 

Votes during D4 so far:

Besie: Tiink > 0

Nego-Dya:

Monstrman: Besie > Besie > Tiink > Wildfire > 0

Pral/Kat:

Tiink: Besie

Hellian-Wildfire:

 

Also posting this

 

 

 

Us 6 voted by...

 

 

Besie:

Voted D1 by Nego, Monstrman, Zander, Darthe.

Voted D2 by Monstrman, Pral/Kat, Tiink, Darthe.

Not voted D3.

 

Nego-Dya:

Not voted D1.

Voted D2 by Tiink.

Not voted D3.

 

Monstrman:

Not voted D1.

Voted D2 by Besie, Believer.

Not voted D3.

 

Pral/Kat:

Not voted D1.

Not voted D2.

Not voted D3.

 

Tiink:

Voted D1 by Sooh.

Voted D2 by Besie, Believer, Nolder.

Voted D3 by Besie, Nego-Dya, Hellian-Wildfire, Nolder.

 

Hellian-Wildfire:

Not voted D1.

Not voted D2.

Not voted D3.

 

 

 

Regarding being voted, I was voted the most D1 and my votes decreased since D1, Tiink's votes increased since D1. There was overall confusion D2: Tiink is the only vote Nego-Dya got in all 3 days, and Believer and voted Monstrman. Pral/Kat and Hellian-Wildfire were never voted. Has the Hellian-Wildfire slot been getting a free pass and is just continuing on the trend, hoping to stay unnoticed?

 

Us 6 voting...

 

 

Besie:

D1: Voted Darthe, Calder

D2: Voted Monstrman, Tiink, Believer

D3: Voted Tiink, Nolder

 

Nego-Dya:

D1: Voted Believer, Besie, Dice

D2: Didn't vote

D3: Voted Tiink

 

Monstrman:

D1: Voted Zander, Besie, Calder, Nolder

D2: Voted Believer, Sooh, Besie

D3: Voted Nolder

 

Pral/Kat:

D1: Voted Calder

D2: Voted Besie

D3: Voted Nolder

 

Tiink:

D1: Voted Zander, Calder

D2: Voted Nego, Besie, Believer

D3: Voted Nolder

 

Hellian-Wildfire:

D1: Didn't vote

D2: Voted Believer

D3: Voted Nolder, Tiink

 

 

 

 

[Guest]

And I don't think that helps me at all. Time wasted. 

 

I don't know what to do. I'm not going to bother with figuring out whether there is or isn't, and who, the deepwolf is until D5.

I can try and figure out who the wolf is between Wildfire and Tiink but I don't know.

I've had Tiink as scummy for a long time - and you can see it in my votes. But the fact that Sooh did the same thing to him as to me means that he's probably town too.

Hellian got a free pass D1 because we wanted him to be active. D2 we gave to Wildfire to catch up, and she voted where everyone was going towards. D3 she voted where it looked like everyone was going, but changed her mind, and changed it back again.

 

Please can I have some opinions on this? Please.

[Guest]

This post is missing an "I" - I added it in bold below.

 

Okay, here we go.

 

*snip*

 

Regarding being voted, I was voted the most D1 and my votes decreased since D1, Tiink's votes increased since D1. There was overall confusion D2: Tiink is the only vote Nego-Dya got in all 3 days, and Believer and I voted Monstrman. Pral/Kat and Hellian-Wildfire were never voted. Has the Hellian-Wildfire slot been getting a free pass and is just continuing on the trend, hoping to stay unnoticed?

 

*snip*

[Tiinker]

Can I have Tiink, Wildfire, Dya and Pral's opinions on who the scum are, please?

 

The deepwolfing thing will only actually help next day, if there is one.

 

You/WiFi, You/Pral

[Tiinker]

And I don't think that helps me at all. Time wasted. 

 

I don't know what to do. I'm not going to bother with figuring out whether there is or isn't, and who, the deepwolf is until D5.

I can try and figure out who the wolf is between Wildfire and Tiink but I don't know.

I've had Tiink as scummy for a long time - and you can see it in my votes. But the fact that Sooh did the same thing to him as to me means that he's probably town too.

Hellian got a free pass D1 because we wanted him to be active. D2 we gave to Wildfire to catch up, and she voted where everyone was going towards. D3 she voted where it looked like everyone was going, but changed her mind, and changed it back again.

 

Please can I have some opinions on this? Please.

 

This imo is the definition of reaching now. You have flip flopped way too much to get to this read. 

[Wildfire Sedai]

Can I have Tiink, Wildfire, Dya and Pral's opinions on who the scum are, please?

 

The deepwolfing thing will only actually help next day, if there is one.

 

I think tiink/manbat.  It may change as game progresses or a fleeting thought. 

[Tiinker]

 

Because maybe I'm overcomplicating it with thinking there's a deepwolf.

It's possible.

 

I think Tiinks d1 still looks bad because there was lots of promise of work with no delivery and then he made one giant reads list, but since then he hasn't been focusing on making reads so much as defending his position

 

I felt like he was being genuine when he said "me besie w/w doesn't make sense to me" it just sounded like the truth idk how else to explain it

 

 

What promise work? I mean I have been the target for lynch literally every day. I made a reads list D1. D2 I made a case on Besie and Nego and pushed Besie as scum. D3 Nolder got lynched. D4 I'm still pushing my Besie case and have had to defend myself again to stop you guys from losing the game. Not sure what else you're expecting from me.

[Tiinker]

 

Can I have Tiink, Wildfire, Dya and Pral's opinions on who the scum are, please?

 

The deepwolfing thing will only actually help next day, if there is one.

 

I think tiink/manbat.  It may change as game progresses or a fleeting thought. 

 

 

It may change as game progresses? Dude, it's LyLo. There is no game to progress the deadline is in 3 hours.

[Tiinker]

I'm not moving my vote.

[monstrman]

[V]besie [/v]

 

Nah I can't walk back from my besie w read, one of you is a wolf or we lose. Also one of you is a wolf or we would have already lost

 

Glgl us I'll prolly check in one my time but I gotta go

 

If it's besie I think besie/wild then

[Guest]

 

And I don't think that helps me at all. Time wasted. 

 

I don't know what to do. I'm not going to bother with figuring out whether there is or isn't, and who, the deepwolf is until D5.

I can try and figure out who the wolf is between Wildfire and Tiink but I don't know.

I've had Tiink as scummy for a long time - and you can see it in my votes. But the fact that Sooh did the same thing to him as to me means that he's probably town too.

Hellian got a free pass D1 because we wanted him to be active. D2 we gave to Wildfire to catch up, and she voted where everyone was going towards. D3 she voted where it looked like everyone was going, but changed her mind, and changed it back again.

 

Please can I have some opinions on this? Please.

 

This imo is the definition of reaching now. You have flip flopped way too much to get to this read. 

 

 

Did you read the post where I put down all of Sooh's interactions?

[Guest]

If you say I'm wrong and that she treated you differently, then you're literally removing the only thing I have to say that you're probably the wolf between you and Wildfire, if you're not both scum.

[Pralaya]

Sorry, it is a Sunday and kind of busy for me (family time). I am also off to sleep soon

 

It is what it is. If I am wrong, well played.

 

[v]besie[/v]

[Tiinker]

You basically posted something to link to all of her posts as if there's some crazy analysis to be done and concluded with "she treated us kinda similar so I'm moving Tink from ultra scum to ultra town". Makes no sense.

[monstrman]

Tiink/besie never w/w ya

[Guest]

You basically posted something to link to all of her posts as if there's some crazy analysis to be done and concluded with "she treated us kinda similar so I'm moving Tink from ultra scum to ultra town". Makes no sense.

 

Well, then. You and I have very different thought processes. I think logical. You don't.

[Tiinker]

How logical are you if you're so selective with what you include in your logic?