[Role Madness] Overwatch Mafia - Game Over

[Cory Caboose]

I'm going to wait on Nolder's response re: LYLO before voting but feel free

 

He needs 4, so we all have to be on board basically

[Tiinker]

 

Players

1. Zander - Bastion - Killed R2.5

2. Lenlo - Reinhardt - Killed R2.5

3. Shad - D.Va

4. Hallia - Mercy - Killed R1.5

5. Pralaya - Genji - Lynched R2

6. Cory - Pharah

7. Tiinker - Lucio

8. Wildfire Sedai - Ana

9. Katioria - Widowmaker - Lynched R1

10. Crusher - Roadhog

 

It's time to go scum hunting: 

So we have: Shad, Cory, Tiinker, Crusher and Wildfire left.  I KNOW I am TOWN...SO cross me out.  Cory is like working the thread awesomely.  he is really putting effort in and asking pointed questions.  If he's scum I'm gonna cry. cross him off.  Same with Shad. cross him off.  So it's tiink and crush left...Just got to ISO tiink first...Yeah tiink looks townie to me. even though he sus me. so cross him off. hmmm that leaves: crusher: [v] crusher [/v]

 

 

I'll get to Shad's when I can. I read it over but I'm cooking so I'll go through it in a bit not that I'll have much to add. ^ This post sure seems opportunistic though. 

[Tiinker]

I feel like I'm never going to get a Wifi lynch to roll through though given how everyone meta reads her but if she's town at end game I'll have definitely learned something. 

[The Crusher]

Nice write up Shad. I can't defend what you think of what I did. I noticed you because what you did stuck out more. Not sure why that is. Just did. You very well might be the last wolf. Smart move to do the work to get me lynched. Cory mind has been made up so not much I can do.I'm very happy with the game I played considering working with no meta. Wifi golly gee'd herself to a hell of a win if it's her. I will not vote myself. You got earn that that one brother. Had. Lot of fun and will play with you guys again .

[Cory Caboose]

It's irrelevant basically. We know WiFi's abilities - one is proven and the other is about as close to proven as possible and doesn't seem to be a threat to us - and we can lynch Crusher and then lynch WiFi if we are wrong.

 

We cannot lynch WiFi and then lynch Crusher due to Crusher's day ability.

[Cory Caboose]

Crusher <3

[The Crusher]

Crusher <3

It's all good. I am town and I did all I could do to get town a win. Just hope Shad isn't last one. I will flip exactly what I said.

[Cory Caboose]

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

[Shad_]

Nice write up Shad. I can't defend what you think of what I did. I noticed you because what you did stuck out more. Not sure why that is. Just did. You very well might be the last wolf. Smart move to do the work to get me lynched. Cory mind has been made up so not much I can do.I'm very happy with the game I played considering working with no meta. Wifi golly gee'd herself to a hell of a win if it's her. I will not vote myself. You got earn that that one brother. Had. Lot of fun and will play with you guys again .

 

At least if I'm wrong I won't feel bad about it.  I was too tired last night to get a grasp on anything.  Woke up this morning with a fresh head and put in the work and so many things you'd done/not done pinged me that I felt stupid for not gunning you down sooner.  If you're a villager sorry? but I think if I saw all this again I'd lynch it again regardless of how you flip here.

[Shad_]

Why didn't you check with Lenlo to see if he'd blocked Pral?

[The Crusher]

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

[Shad_]

Wolves know what's been claimed better than villagers.  I rarely take notes as a villager.   Lots of people don't take notes as a villager.  Wolves are guaranteed to have it all laid out in their QT because they need to determine who to kill/block/etc.  And if you were a villager and wolves noticed you blatantly lying god they would jump at a chance to call it out.  What made you think your reaction test was valuable?

[Shad_]

 

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

 

 

I called out very specific points that bothered me and did not appear to make sense from a villager POV.  You can address them or ?.

[The Crusher]

 

Nice write up Shad. I can't defend what you think of what I did. I noticed you because what you did stuck out more. Not sure why that is. Just did. You very well might be the last wolf. Smart move to do the work to get me lynched. Cory mind has been made up so not much I can do.I'm very happy with the game I played considering working with no meta. Wifi golly gee'd herself to a hell of a win if it's her. I will not vote myself. You got earn that that one brother. Had. Lot of fun and will play with you guys again .

At least if I'm wrong I won't feel bad about it. I was too tired last night to get a grasp on anything. Woke up this morning with a fresh head and put in the work and so many things you'd done/not done pinged me that I felt stupid for not gunning you down sooner. If you're a villager sorry? but I think if I saw all this again I'd lynch it again regardless of how you flip here.

. I am a townie. Don't like wolf/villager nomenclature. Don't apologize for being wrong. Maybe next time we play again both of I will do a better job. I hope your scum because I can boast catching you day 1. LOL

[The Crusher]

 

 

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

I called out very specific points that bothered me and did not appear to make sense from a villager POV. You can address them or ?.

I can but I have office hours 2-8.

[Shad_]

 

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

 

 

I might have stuck out more to a villager because other villagers were calling me wolfy.  That's something that can happen sort of subconsciously.  So ok.  Why did you wait until now to state a change in your read on me based on red, especially considering you also knew I couldn't have shot Hallia?  What made other people's town reads on Tiink and Halli for pretty much the same reasons ok? 

[The Crusher]

Wolves know what's been claimed better than villagers. I rarely take notes as a villager. Lots of people don't take notes as a villager. Wolves are guaranteed to have it all laid out in their QT because they need to determine who to kill/block/etc. And if you were a villager and wolves noticed you blatantly lying god they would jump at a chance to call it out. What made you think your reaction test was valuable?

Not true. Yes scum have to make decisions on who to block or whatever but town has to find scum by reading closely. At JN scum skim and the QTd are mostly filled with jokes. Townies play closer attention. Hell most of the time scum are hiding out.

[Shad_]

Is it normal for you to completely ignore reading some people as a villager?  Kat's excusable given her content, but why did you never share thoughts on Tiink or Pral all game?  Even after Pral was basically outed you never talked about him.  In determining who to vote betweeen Pral and Z yesterday you just talked about why you thought Zander had some points in his favor and didn't discuss Pral.

[The Crusher]

 

 

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

I might have stuck out more to a villager because other villagers were calling me wolfy. That's something that can happen sort of subconsciously. So ok. Why did you wait until now to state a change in your read on me based on red, especially considering you also knew I couldn't have shot Hallia? What made other people's town reads on Tiink and Halli for pretty much the same reasons ok?

I can't speak for other townies. Also I was confusing you and Cory a bit so that didn't help. At a point in the game your post started reading like I was thinking. Interesting enough it was when you started defending wifi.I agreed with that at the time . Wasn't until she Weymouth fully golly gee no way it's me scum I started to doubt her.

[Cory Caboose]

Meeting a client up north so I'll be sporadic

[Shad_]

Could be a cultural thing I guess.

 

Wolves are prone to poor coordination here gameplay wise, but I've never been a wolf where I was the only person in QT trying to sniff out power roles. 

[The Crusher]

Is it normal for you to completely ignore reading some people as a villager? Kat's excusable given her content, but why did you never share thoughts on Tiink or Pral all game? Even after Pral was basically outed you never talked about him. In determining who to vote betweeen Pral and Z yesterday you just talked about why you thought Zander had some points in his favor and didn't discuss Pral.

 

100%. I scum hunt and try to create situations that pull scum out. I hate when people declare one another town early. Later it's important but early it's a scum tactic. Hell at JN Lilly and Leelou made it to end game as scum claiming myself and another player town from their first post. Owned us.

[Shad_]

 

 

 

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

 

I might have stuck out more to a villager because other villagers were calling me wolfy. That's something that can happen sort of subconsciously. So ok. Why did you wait until now to state a change in your read on me based on red, especially considering you also knew I couldn't have shot Hallia? What made other people's town reads on Tiink and Halli for pretty much the same reasons ok?

 

I can't speak for other townies. Also I was confusing you and Cory a bit so that didn't help. At a point in the game your post started reading like I was thinking. Interesting enough it was when you started defending wifi.I agreed with that at the time . Wasn't until she Weymouth fully golly gee no way it's me scum I started to doubt her.

 

Ok. That was before you roleblocked me so you couldn't have been feeling too great yet. But a read made behind closed doors isn't worth jack. If you don't state your progression until days after the fact when you're about to get lynched, I have a much harder time believing it.

[The Crusher]

Could be a cultural thing I guess.

 

Wolves are prone to poor coordination here gameplay wise, but I've never been a wolf where I was the only person in QT trying to sniff out power roles.

 

 

Sniffing out power roles is of course scum play. That is done more on the feel of how someone is playing. Not the details as much as town trying to find scum. Yet those two get confused and we do tend to put power roles at JN a lot.

[The Crusher]

 

 

 

 

If it's Shad he's blown me away this game completely

I saw what I saw earlier but he picked up on the middle. His wrote up on me is nothing more than a narrative describing what he thinks of my play. I know they always are . But again I thought I was very clear and explained myself and answered questions very well.

I might have stuck out more to a villager because other villagers were calling me wolfy. That's something that can happen sort of subconsciously. So ok. Why did you wait until now to state a change in your read on me based on red, especially considering you also knew I couldn't have shot Hallia? What made other people's town reads on Tiink and Halli for pretty much the same reasons ok?

I can't speak for other townies. Also I was confusing you and Cory a bit so that didn't help. At a point in the game your post started reading like I was thinking. Interesting enough it was when you started defending wifi.I agreed with that at the time . Wasn't until she Weymouth fully golly gee no way it's me scum I started to doubt her.

Ok. That was before you roleblocked me so you couldn't have been feeling too great yet. But a read made behind closed doors isn't worth jack. If you don't state your progression until days after the fact when you're about to get lynched, I have a much harder time believing it.

I role looked you n1. Was the start of me trusting you.