[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[seph]

Did I miss why reg wants me lynched?

Also I'm just going to trust cory on clov for now, not like I could convince people to lynch him if I wanted to anyways... [unvote]

 

@cliv has princess posted at all?

[Cory Caboose]

Considering PBF vanished during Darthe's game and had to be subbed I'd guess we shouldn't expect her here

 

It's all =rand to me

[Cory Caboose]

Kat is your read on me basically because that's how Zander is reading me and typically you just trust his reads

Or do you actually have an issue with my posting

[Regy Rusty]

Reg I don't know and I don't know what to think about him... seems to be trying to make a lot out of nothing more than helping.Which seems more scummish.

 

 

 

Hm I don't care for this characterization of my playstyle

 

Misinterpretation or deliberate shade throwing?

[Regy Rusty]

Did I miss why reg wants me lynched?

Also I'm just going to trust cory on clov for now, not like I could convince people to lynch him if I wanted to anyways... [unvote]

 

@cliv has princess posted at all?

 

You gave me a bad vibe in your argument with Clov but nothing sticks out as lynch worthy. You're low on my list.

[Cory Caboose]

Also I'm just going to trust cory on clov for now, not like I could convince people to lynch him if I wanted to anyways... [unvote]

 

Clov will go on the "caution" list eternally

 

But his posts today look good, I think you'll see as such when you're caught up

[Katiora]

Kat is your read on me basically because that's how Zander is reading me and typically you just trust his reads

Or do you actually have an issue with my posting

it's just a feeling? I don't go off Zander's feelings until he's done something to really make me think he's town... and he hasn't done that... He feels town but I don't trust him by far... Of all the people here He's the only one I worry about pocketing me lol. 

 

You just feel off. Don't seem like yourself at all. But I would never vote you for that. You are just in the most suspicious pile. But like I said I have nothing to back that up and you would probably be the one I lynched last in that group. 

[SiRReN]

I don't know what to think about Kat's recent post but I don't like it. Everyone is either null or scummy to her.

[Katiora]

 

Reg I don't know and I don't know what to think about him... seems to be trying to make a lot out of nothing more than helping.Which seems more scummish.

 

 

 

Hm I don't care for this characterization of my playstyle

 

Misinterpretation or deliberate shade throwing?

 

I don't care that you don't care for my characterization. That's my interpretation and how I"m reading you. Sorry not sorry? lol 

 

If that's not how you are explain your playstyle better to me. Then I'll go back and re-read and see if it matches up... may make me feel better about you. I have a hard time reading people I know absolutely nothing about. 

[Cory Caboose]

 

 Last I talked with Zander he was thinking you're null for your intro so it's probably just me being nitpicky. Not sure i can appropriately explain my POV right now

Honestly you and Zander seem townish... probably... Zander definitely does...

 

 

 

I don't go off Zander's feelings until he's done something to really make me think he's town... and he hasn't done that... He feels town but I don't trust him by far...

 

I think I understand but you are just making my head spin Kat :P

[Katiora]

I don't know what to think about Kat's recent post but I don't like it. Everyone is either null or scummy to her.

Welcome to my day 1... I don't like it either... i have a hard time vetting anyone town d1. but i did give 3 town leans so I'm not exactly sure how you say that?? that's 1/4 of the players... 

[Cory Caboose]

Kat have we played together before? I remember one game but you had to sub and I don't think you really played.

 

How don't I seem like myself? What in particular has made you go "Cory seems different"?

[seph]

I don't know what to think about Kat's recent post but I don't like it. Everyone is either null or scummy to her.

everyone looking scummy would look better than worse to me tbh. being ovearly suspicious is a towny trait, but I would have to read it closely with tone.

[Katiora]

 

 

 Last I talked with Zander he was thinking you're null for your intro so it's probably just me being nitpicky. Not sure i can appropriately explain my POV right now

Honestly you and Zander seem townish... probably... Zander definitely does...

 

 

 

I don't go off Zander's feelings until he's done something to really make me think he's town... and he hasn't done that... He feels town but I don't trust him by far...

 

I think I understand but you are just making my head spin Kat :P

 

There's a difference in being "townish" and me REALLY thinking you're town. I don't depend on Zander until I REALLY feel 90% that Zander's town. And even then I second guess the crap out of myself and tinfoil and try to make him be pocketing me lol 

[Regy Rusty]

I don't make something out of nothing - I poke at people and see how they respond. I take that and build on it.

 

I make something out of something to put it another way.

 

I don't like how Sili responded to Hallia or to me and it read as mafia to me. So I kept prodding him and he kept responding in a way I found suspicious. Thus, my suspicions grew.

 

I don't think a Sili lynch is happening since people who know him better seem to disagree with me. That's okay, if he gives me more I'll keep trying to convince people, but in the mean time I've moved on to other lines of discussion.

[SiRReN]

Lainey... l'm not defensive at you really any more... Honestly you and Zander seem townish... probably... Zander definitely does... i don't read you well so i'm going to have to trust to my reading of him more I'm afraid. What I'm annoyed at right now are the people who are trying to take our 4-5 posts of talking to each other and make it into t/w, w/w when they have nothing to back it up. it's extremely frustrating and i'm not sure how to combat it. I'm also not sure what people want out of me. I've tried typing a reads list 2 times today... neither one I felt good about and then I got called away at work and when I came back there were 40-50 more posts which I felt made my lists inaccurate until I could read up... And i'm not sure with the way things are going today at work that I'll have time to really sit down and do a list like I'd like to. 

 

 

 

Honestly right now the only "person" I feel decent about are you and Zander.

Hallia is borderline.

Cory is meh.

Seph... bleh but obviously no one can read him so I don't feel bad about that.

Clov... ehhhhhh I'm leaning more town than null but barely.

Darthe and BFG are non existent to me.

Reg I don't know and I don't know what to think about him... seems to be trying to make a lot out of nothing more than helping.Which seems more scummish.

Sirren I have no clue about.

Sili... his activity looks good but he's being a bit whiney... (sorry sili.. just calling it how i see it) and I don't know how to interpret that...

 AJ I feel gut ok with but i'm not sure what I think about that lol... I don't remember what his town game looks like but he seems more towny than what I remember him being like as scum, but I could be completely wrong.

 

 

so in order right now it'd probably be 

Zander/Laine

AJ

Hallia

Clov

Sirren

Cory

Sili

Reg

 

 

BFG

Darth

 

And in that I'd say Darthe, Reg, Cory are my gut reads.. I don't love it... but that's pure gut and I have nothing specific I can point at to back that up. (just putting it out there) And I definitely don't feel good enough to vote on any of them cause I'm just not sure. 

 

I'm not sure why you've got BFG and Darthe at the very bottom of your list when you claim they're non-existent to you. Does non-existence read scummy to you? 

 

Look at all that grey. Like, I understand being unsure about people, but even the people you think might be town or have done scummy things you then duck yourself out of those reads by saying like this "But I'm not sure".

[Clovdyx]

 

Lol I have no thoughts on PBF

 

If she's busy enough to not show that's not alignment indicative whatsoever. In VS Hunt she missed almost all of Day 1 and then came back and was basically town MVP.

 

If she shows I am confident I can read her, if she's replaced for inactivity then who knows.

 

I didn't assume you did have thoughts on her.  I would probably try to lynch you today if you DID have thoughts on her.  I just thought it was odd you specifically stated you'd be willing to lynch Kat for being very null, so I thought I'd throw out somebody that basically has to be null to see how you'd react.

 

 

 

Thanks

Still @Regy: assume that Hallia, Sili and Clov are all off the table (I don't remember your reads, sowwy, etc.)

Who are your top 3 wolves?

 

watido :(

 

 

You did nothing

 

I also POISE my question to you? Yes? <3 (happy) ?

 

 

You took me off the table, and that hurts my feelings.

 

Uh....let's see...

 

1.  Kat

2.  PBF

3.  BFG

 

FEO Cory:

 

 

 

Don't ask about my methods for making this list.

 

 

[Cory Caboose]

Yeah that's what I was guessing :P

It's fine, d1s are the hardest to "get right" and it takes a lot of false machismo and risk-takng to make reads with confidence early. Take your time Kat, there's 24+ hours left in the day phase :P

[SiRReN]

 

I don't know what to think about Kat's recent post but I don't like it. Everyone is either null or scummy to her.

Welcome to my day 1... I don't like it either... i have a hard time vetting anyone town d1. but i did give 3 town leans so I'm not exactly sure how you say that?? that's 1/4 of the players... 

 

Who are you reading firmly as town? Because you go back on yourself and say things like "I'm not sure though".

[Regy Rusty]

FWIW after her more recent posts I feel Kat is trending away from null and into scum territory.

[Cory Caboose]

FWIW after her more recent posts I feel Kat is trending away from null and into scum territory.

 

I actually feel the opposite *shrug!*

[Regy Rusty]

 

 

Lol I have no thoughts on PBF

 

If she's busy enough to not show that's not alignment indicative whatsoever. In VS Hunt she missed almost all of Day 1 and then came back and was basically town MVP.

 

If she shows I am confident I can read her, if she's replaced for inactivity then who knows.

 

I didn't assume you did have thoughts on her.  I would probably try to lynch you today if you DID have thoughts on her.  I just thought it was odd you specifically stated you'd be willing to lynch Kat for being very null, so I thought I'd throw out somebody that basically has to be null to see how you'd react.

 

 I think I consider posting but not giving me much impression vs. inactive for real life reasons to be different flavors of null if you will

[Katiora]

Yeah that's what I was guessing :P

 

It's fine, d1s are the hardest to "get right" and it takes a lot of false machismo and risk-takng to make reads with confidence early. Take your time Kat, there's 24+ hours left in the day phase :P

If I ever say anything with confidence d1 I'm scum and lynch me... 

 

 

 

I don't know what to think about Kat's recent post but I don't like it. Everyone is either null or scummy to her.

Welcome to my day 1... I don't like it either... i have a hard time vetting anyone town d1. but i did give 3 town leans so I'm not exactly sure how you say that?? that's 1/4 of the players... 

 

Who are you reading firmly as town? Because you go back on yourself and say things like "I'm not sure though".

 

 

I didn't say I was reading anyone FIRMLY as town. I JUST SAID I don't do that d1. I don't know how ANYONE can read someone FIRMLY as town D1. unless they know who's mafia already. Then you can make some pretty good educated guesses. 

 

FWIW after her more recent posts I feel Kat is trending away from null and into scum territory.

And could that be because I'm questioning you and think that you may be scum?? Or is it because of something scummy I'm doing (because if I am, PLEASE point it out)? Ya'll wanted me to talk more and now that I do I'm scum... Very original... And when I quit posting because I'm at work and I get busy you'll say I stopped posting because i'm scum... 

[Clovdyx]

 

I don't know what to think about Kat's recent post but I don't like it. Everyone is either null or scummy to her.

 

 

I'm not sure why you've got BFG and Darthe at the very bottom of your list when you claim they're non-existent to you. Does non-existence read scummy to you? 

 

Look at all that grey. Like, I understand being unsure about people, but even the people you think might be town or have done scummy things you then duck yourself out of those reads by saying like this "But I'm not sure".

 

 

I was just going to ask if I could set her reads list on fire just because she had reads of "meh" "bleh" and "eh" and basically being a massive list of nulls, and I really, really like this analysis from Sirren taking it even further.

 

From what I remember of Kat in the last game I played, she took a LITTLE bit to get some thoughts out there - and I think I had to drag them out of her, but I could be well off about that - so this isn't entirely out of the possibility for her being town.  Definitely not reassuring, though, and I think Sirren looks better for pointing it out.

 

 

Well done, hat.

[Regy Rusty]

No need to be so testy about it Kat

 

I just think your reads post wasn't great and could be fake/intended to further the mafia cause and keep you in the game