[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[Sili Quirrels]

If we assume wifi and kat were always lynched back to back then Aj may as well bus because his partner is inevitably dying.

 

It's a common gambit in mafia.

[Cory Caboose]

Fair

[Cory Caboose]

It did really look like Kat was going to be lynched for awhile

 

AJ might just have made a mistake by pushing in the wrong direction too quickly

 

Idk

[Cory Caboose]

He pushed wifi/bfg as wolves on like... N1 and then didn't mention wifi beyond "wifi is unreadable" until d4

[Katiora]

 

I think the biggest question on Wifi is IF she is wolf, WHY does AJ go after her like he does? AJ really needs the mislynch, why her? Why not go ahead and lynch me, I was on the cusp. None of that makes sense unless maybe he was trying to get himself clear? 

 

Him doing it to help me makes no sense because he has NO problem WHATSOEVER bussing as mafia. Ya'll had mostly cleared him with just a shred of doubt probably don't vote him over Me Hallia or Wifi. Let me die. 2 mafia left still. Kill Reg/Sili/Cory, there's (probably) Cory Sili Hallia AJ left... not sure where that goes... *sighs* *bangs head against wall*

 

well, yes, we could say your lynch was inevitable back then.

 

I sure thought it was.... I don't understand.. unless he honestly thought it was going to go through anyway and he was trying to build a case for a lynch on the next day? 

[Cory Caboose]

If he was a wolf with WiFi he still needed to beat Hallia at f5 or f3

[Katiora]

That almost makes sense... he thinks that Hallia, Reg, and Sili will vote me. Then Wifi hammers. THen he builds the case on why it's wifi and gets her lynch so you think he's town... does that make sense? but he pushed too fast too hard and reg turned and that caused everyone else to turn as well. 

[Katiora]

If he was a wolf with WiFi he still needed to beat Hallia at f5 or f3

He probably thinks that's his best bet honestly. At one point ya'll had pretty much cleared him... actually no pretty much to it.. you and regy had cleared him. 

[Cory Caboose]

The problem was that he became supremely confident on WiFi's alignment after explaining the entire game that he couldn't read her at all because of her playstyle

 

At least for me

[Cory Caboose]

You had cleared him as well   

[Cory Caboose]

Really everyone but Seph had IIRC

[Sili Quirrels]

Wifi is still exploring this game, and that process usually results in twtbaw behavior.

[Cory Caboose]

Going to read other games by WildFire Sedai

 

Want to resolve slots through their own content still

[Katiora]

Really everyone but Seph had IIRC

Yep... tis true...  

 

which may be why he thought he was safe at f3. I think he knew Wifi was a goner, he wanted to be seen as an early adopter so to say. When I flip he says "see I thought she could be town, ya'll should have gone with Wifi" then he's like I knew it! Now it's just hallia for the win! and he'd be right... mafia win

[Sili Quirrels]

I think he'd gone after me as well to try and play me off hallia at f3

[Sili Quirrels]

Clov I feel is town still.

 

BFG has been dropping due to just well...not...being here?  I can't work with what I don't have.  I would be ok with switching.  Derf chilling a bit, I might consider switching to BFG based on that, and the fact that my town core is leaning there as well.

 

 

[Sili Quirrels]

Laine asked that I reread her content; I wouldn't feel comfortable jumping back there until I do.  I still feel weird from what I do recall from the slot.

 

It's between Kat and BFG I suppose.  Kat I can read as time goes though.  BFG I find her lack of being here strange because she's normally pretty involved.  I don't know if she said why she's scarce.

[Sili Quirrels]

Didn't AJ encourage me to go after Kat. He said my reasons were good.

[Sili Quirrels]

Then he goes after wifi.

 

[unvote]

[v]AJ[/v]

[Sili Quirrels]

/jk

 

[v]Wifi[/v]

[Sili Quirrels]

most of the early game wifi seems in her own bubble but she seems to be paying cursory attention to the concurrent thread. I believe that's a bad sign.

[Sili Quirrels]

Okay...now that I have more time, though I am still not fully read through (i've had a lot of interruptions today):

 

1. Sili Quirrels: town - he's not as aggressive as he was the last time we played together and he was mafia then.  Also he has been itt more than in the other game, answering questions and making statements.

2. Wildfire Sedai (PrincessBFlea): town - tis me, I know I'm town.

3. Zalanna: town - hasn't been posting crazy amounts in thread (z) , they both have been answering questions afaict from what i have read so far

4. Andrej: town - has been asking questions and answering them when asked

5. Hallia: town/mafia as I was going to give a reason for her being town, it occured to me that she might just be on the edge of being mafia....low post count and not that much investigating going on.

6. Katiora: town/mafia - Kat was mafia in the last 2 games I was in with her, only 2 games to be exact.  She has posted more here than she did then atp in game.  However she "always" seems to get into a "ruckus" with someone during the game play, coincidence??

7. Cory: town/mafia - town because he takes the time to quote things and give explanations, mafia because of all the "ruckus" that was happening around him.

8. Clovdyx : mafia - am going to wait till after supper to do this one cause I can't remember off the top of my head why.

9. BFG: mafia -  am going to wait till after supper to do this one cause I can't remember off the top of my head why.

10. Darthe: town/mafia - town because he is proactive in responding to posts about his alignment and asking/answering questions. Mafia because of low posts...when I was in HIS game he thanked me for being active but he's not active here...it just doesn't add up

11. Regy Rusty: town - asked/ answered questions in a good manner

12. Sirren: town - Kept her cool when she felt hurt and continued playing the game.  Asks good questions and answers them.

13. Seph: town/mafia - I know I originally had him as town but then been thinking on it and he hasn't posted that much so thinking might be mafia "Lurking?" Just a thought....other than that though town for questions/answers.

 

all town reads are because they ask questions or answer questions.

 

probably a way to cover up her read of AJ.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Wildfire kat and bfg would be a fitting team

Why are you voting WiFi over me?

 

=/

[Hallia]

 

Really everyone but Seph had IIRC

Yep... tis true...

 

which may be why he thought he was safe at f3. I think he knew Wifi was a goner, he wanted to be seen as an early adopter so to say. When I flip he says "see I thought she could be town, ya'll should have gone with Wifi" then he's like I knew it! Now it's just hallia for the win! and he'd be right... mafia win

Oh dang.

 

[unvote]

[Sili Quirrels]

i need to go soon, so i'll summarize my thoughts.

 

Hallia progresses like a villager day 1. She makes a lot of unnecessary posts if she's a wolf, and she pushes bfg over alternatives when it mattered. It doesn't guarantee much, but I've always found wolf!Hallia opportunistic.

 

Kat made a few mistakes. It's not out of the question she's a wolf, but it's like 40%.

 

Aj pushed Wifi like he knew wifi would flip wolf after ignoring wifi for a few days.  Aj doesn't get in anyone's way if they decide to clear Wifi, and he encouraged me when I cleared her for -potentially- lame reasons.

 

Wifi's vote on Seph is horribly fake. Wifi's wot readlist, which she treats like a pet idea, garnered a bad reaction so she never makes a wot again. She stumbles around, but all her assumptions about the thread are opportunistic from a wolf's vantage point. Take for instance her vote on me after Seph died. I have no idea if it was a joke but I think she was having fun.  She's also demonstrated knowledge outside her own bubble, which makes me think she's more capable of this when she's a villager. She reacted badly when Regy made a joke about her outing herself, and she took like 30 minutes to respond to me calling her out on it.