Beyond the Wall - Game Thread - GAME OVER

[Andrej]

@Princess, if you click on the 'More Reply Options' button whenever you have a quote in the box, it'll take you to a separate window where editing is easier. In the top right portion of the command box, there's a little button that looks like a switch. It'll turn the quote bubbles into a hard code format, which may be easier for you to work with. I think VS is similar in that fashion.

[Andrej]

Top left portion, actually.

 

My bad

[PrincessBFlea]

Sorry, I fell asleep earlier while re-reading the thread, and then had to go out with my mom =_= Not that I don't like going out with her, it's just been a really long week.

 

So, has anyone answered my question yet? Where is Calder? I still don't think I've seen a post from them?? 

 

Also, at the moment, these are my very base reads, just on the re-read and what I've seen so far:

 

Suspicious

 

Zander

What Is Going On?

 

Keyholder

Calder

Dice

SiRReN

Balrog

John Snow

Sili

Sooh

Wildfire Sedai

 

Trustworthy-ish

 

Hallia

AJ

Lenlo

Kat

Shad

 

These have no evidence to back them up yet, just are how I'm feeling atm based on what I've seen. Gonna try and start some ISO's now that I know how to do them, but I needs a shower, and then I have work and friendship time tomorrow, so not sure how much I'll be able to get done and posted! THIS LIST IS DEFINITELY GOING TO CHANGE THOUGH.... simply because it always does ^_^

 

I don't typically like explaining my early reads anymore, because then I find myself pigeoned into only answering questions and trying to explain reads that are for the most part an initial knee-jerk reaction and really have no foundation. Happened last game, never got to my ISO's, town mis-lynched me for it. Was both hysterical, and aggravating. So as long as no one pesters me to back up these initial, quick, NOT SOLID explanations until I do my actual, official read's list with ISO's and evidence and whatnot, I don't mind giving a quick brief.

 

Anyone DOES ask me to go deeper on these, I'm flat out ignoring you, because to humor you would be a waste of my time scum-hunting.

 

For Zander, it's just something about his interactions so fa, at least those I've notice. They seem like he is intentionally trying instigate disagreements and defensiveness, without following it up or taking it anywhere. I could be wrong, but that's what has stood out to me so far.

 

For those in the trustworthy-ish pile... It's honestly just that I like ya'll interactions so far. You are asking questions, poking buttons, miscommunicating but then clearing it up, and following up and trying to get others involved or provide information that will help other players. All around helpful, basically. Again, this is just how things have stood out to me so far, and might mean nothing once I start the ISO's and realize I could have been mis-reading things, forgetting things, or seeing things/making connections that really aren't there!

 

Does that help?

[keyholder21]

OK I wanna see where you progress from his answer.

Okay, you do that :p.

[Andrej]

I am ok with my joke vote on Zander becoming a real one.

 

[PrincessBFlea]

I don't meant o sound harsh above about the not responding to more questions about these reads, but I seriously don't want to waste town time/scum-hunting time on reads that are basically ound to change and mean little to anything in the long-term game.

[PrincessBFlea]

@Princess, if you click on the 'More Reply Options' button whenever you have a quote in the box, it'll take you to a separate window where editing is easier. In the top right portion of the command box, there's a little button that looks like a switch. It'll turn the quote bubbles into a hard code format, which may be easier for you to work with. I think VS is similar in that fashion.

I mean, this helps with formatting, but I still can't make the box bigger... when I try to click and drag, the scroll keeps pushing me back up to where I can't change the post box size to see more text at a time, and it's frustrating for someone who WoT's :C And actually, this took away the wrap around on the post, so it's kinda more annoying :/

 

Thank you for trying though! I appreciate the help!

[Andrej]

Yeah, that's fair enough.

 

In the future though, if you want to really substantiate a read I would suggest that you give some reasoning behind it.

 

I get that it's early and those are just impressions, and I have no issues with that, but as the game evolves you'll need more explanations :)

 

Thanks for expanding. I appreciate openness.

[Andrej]

If Zander is scum I would say Sili's scum equity goes up and Key's goes down significantly.

 

#hottakes

[keyholder21]

 

AJ again with a hella good q.

You expect less?

 

 

I really do want him to answer that, though.

Lol :p.

 

No? But I am liking the questions you are asking so far and I am also a little jealous you asked because I wanted to.

[Lenlo]

If Zander is scum I would say Sili's scum equity goes up and Key's goes down significantly.

 

#hottakes

May I ask why? I can understand Sili's sorta but I havnt seen Zander interact with Key all that much.

[keyholder21]

But it's mostly feeling like the noob. I'm not sure where to start.

I think you jumped in pretty fine already haha.

[Andrej]

 

If Zander is scum I would say Sili's scum equity goes up and Key's goes down significantly.

 

#hottakes

 

May I ask why? I can understand Sili's sorta but I havnt seen Zander interact with Key all that much.

 

He sussed Key somewhat irt her questioning of Dice.

 

It's not like concrete, rock solid stuff... but it would certainly skew my reads.

[keyholder21]

Fwiw I'm not really disliking my joke vote on Kat atp.

 

I don't think she answered Lenlo very satisfactorily and I'm not sure what her original point was anyway.

 

Shad is here, so that's cool. I look forward to his additions.

 

Still waiting on the VS crowd to get more involved, but I can be patient seeing as this is a new forum to them and they're still learning the formats and what not.

 

Really don't have any solid reads on anyone yet.

I'm not sure I see mafia!Kat starting something over such little, unclear reasoning. Actually looks more town!Kat to me.

[PrincessBFlea]

Yeah, that's fair enough.

 

In the future though, if you want to really substantiate a read I would suggest that you give some reasoning behind it.

 

I get that it's early and those are just impressions, and I have no issues with that, but as the game evolves you'll need more explanations :)

 

Thanks for expanding. I appreciate openness.

Ahahahaha! I'm actually holding my sides laughing!!!

XD Oh, you don't know me yet, but I'm pretty sure you'll get later on why I find this funny! I think SiRReN already mentioned this, but getting explanations from me, once I do my ISO's and the game progresses, won't be a problem ;)

[keyholder21]

 

 

Im not awkward. My phrasing is even good. Its me not elaborating that makes you say im awkward. Thats something else. Happens when i dont think twice about communicating.

Do you ever think twice before communicating???

When it's important I do. But usually I just type like I talk,

 

Changed my mind when it seemed like you were thinking about peoplemore. Made me reconsider my view. It was just one post after all.

Why would Z thinking about people more chsnge your mind? What was one post?

[keyholder21]

I can understand a gut feeling on a tone read, but since I don't know her I can't really say if its a reasonable read on her. It didn't feel off to me at the time, but I could look at it again.

I like the thought behind this post instead of just jumping on someone - especially someone she(?) Doesn't know and who is being sussed by other people who do know her

[keyholder21]

Falling asleep as I type. I'll be back tomorrow when I can.

[Darthe]

Official vote count:

Zander (3/9): John Snow, Lenlo, Andrej
Sirren (1/9): sooh

Wildfire (1/9): Sili

Not voting (11/16):
Hallia, KeyFG, sirren, punished balrog, Calder, Shad, Zander, Wildfire Sedai, dicetosser1, katiora, princessBFlea 

 

 

Deadline is not firm yet due to the holiday weekend.  Expect one to be announced by tomorrow, probably for early Monday.

[Sooh]

Are you guys serious!?

 

14 pages since last night?

 

ugh

[Sooh]

 

 

So far it's due to participation and tone

Meh.

 

He hasn't done anything worthy of a town read yet imo

 

 

Silis normally awkward.  I want to see how he reacts and his involvement level.

 

I know where Hallia is coming from with this, and I see her point, though I find it perhaps a little early to make conclusions.

[PrincessBFlea]

@Sili Quirrel: You said you thought you were reading Shad_ on page one, but you had actually read John Snow and it was a null tell...

 

What was a null tell for JS? Why were you trying to read Shad? Did you ever go back and read Shad, and if so, what were your thoughts regarding his early

posts this game?

 

@AJ: when he admitted to this mix-up, why didn't you push him more about it, or follow up with questions like the one's I'm asking? Weren't you curious as

to why Sili was trying to read Shad, or is there something in his meta I'm not getting that made you dismiss this detail and not push him for a response?

 

What do you think about Sili currently? What do you think about the fact that Zander and Hallia both have defended Sili's behavior/actions up to this point?

 

@Zander/Hallia-- Why are you defensive of Sili so far, when Sili hasn't bothered to provide much explanation beyond being on their phone, and hasn't really

contributed anything substantial to the discussion? Or do you think he HAS contributed to the discussion, and if so, can you give an example?

 

((Still ISO'ing, but these questions popped up during my reads and I don't want to forget them!))

[PrincessBFlea]

I know I just had part of this explained to me recently, but what is OMGUS? And FOSing?

[Sooh]

Is it typical!Zander to respond to so much non-essential stuff?

Unfortunately, yes.

 

 

Anyone know where Calder is?

He might not be aware the game has started (ignore this if he has posted in the last 10 pages I haven't read yet).

 

 

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/98242-how-to-iso/?p=3670591

ISOing on VS is better

 

Doesn't take much for it to be easier and better than here.

 

 

 

 

lucky u   can u use onbe to vote zander??  maybe we can lynch himn while HE's sleeping for once.....

Maybe I'll vote him later. Right now I'm welcoming Sirren.

 

This pinged me a bit when I first read it and still kind of does, and it's stupid and trivial but lulz if you're a wolf Sooh.

 

Ok? I have no idea what's pinging you. It was a joke.

 

I agree with AJ that Sirren seems towny, and I will give AJ a town read as well. Lenlo seems to be towny, and I think Hallia's early comment that Sili seems town probably makes her more likely to be town as well.

 

Zander is sorta overdoing the whole "commenting while reading"-thing this game, and half the time I don't understand why it was necessary for him to comment on the post he was commenting on. I'm not sure how to feel about Kat yet, but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt. I'll also say that from my experience with Princess I think she's probably town this game.

[Sooh]

I know I just had part of this explained to me recently, but what is OMGUS? And FOSing?

Oh My God U Suck

 

Finger Of Suspicion