[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Nynaeve]

6. Nyn- null to town. Not too much content. understandable due to RL. (I hope your dog is getting better) Nothing really pinging at this time.

 

Seems to me like you're smoking the same thing Eld is.... >.>  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Can I have some?

[Eldrick4221]

Just ISOd Nyn. My read hasn't changed. At all. Most of her posts are fluff. There are a couple good posts (e.g. the general thoughts catchup post), But most of it isn't game-related, and she isn't engaging that much either, even before she mentioned the problems with her dog.

[Sooh]

About two games ago? Besie's second game, I was having a discussion with Zander about her. I didn't successfully convince him that she was scum (I think?), but it lead me to the conclusion that he was town because of how we were talking. I haven't been able to do that here, but I realize that my case on him isn't as strong as my head thought it was when I started it. 

 

I want to give him some more time to hopefully read him better, but here's the thing though. Last game people were having trouble reading him he was scum. When they couldn't clear him by his posting he flipped as scum. It wasn't because his posts were scummy, because they weren't. Most people kept him in their nulls, and that was as scummy as he got. I am not 100% sure how many have cleared him this game. Laine perhaps? She had him in green I remember. Anyone else? Basically what I'm worried about is that he's flying under the radar on null and blaming this new posting style. 

 

I guess all in all probably don't lynch him D1, but also don't forget to look at him later unless he somehow becomes more clear to people.

 

ION, my head is better, fever is gone. I still don't sleep very well, but at least more than 4 hours per 24 hour period. I'll try to go back and read the game from the beginning and see if I can't make some reads on people other than Zander. I feel like all my energy this game has been used on him. Sooh!tunnel? 

[Nynaeve]

Just ISOd Nyn. My read hasn't changed. At all. Most of her posts are fluff. There are a couple good posts (e.g. the general thoughts catchup post), But most of it isn't game-related, and she isn't engaging that much either, even before she mentioned the problems with her dog.

 

My posts are mostly fluff. lol

 

From you that means... absolutely nothing.

[Nynaeve]

Basically what I'm worried about is that he's flying under the radar on null and blaming this new posting style. 

 

I don't see how anything he's done so far can be construed as flying under the radar. 

[Nynaeve]

Glad you're feeling better, though.

[Sooh]

 

Basically what I'm worried about is that he's flying under the radar on null and blaming this new posting style. 

 

I don't see how anything he's done so far can be construed as flying under the radar. 

 

You're misunderstanding what I mean by that. I meant flying under the radar as in not posting scummily enough to be a valid lynch option, but at the same time not being towny enough to be cleared.

[Nynaeve]

You're misunderstanding what I mean by that. I meant flying under the radar as in not posting scummily enough to be a valid lynch option, but at the same time not being towny enough to be cleared.

 

But you don't think the above, do you?. You thought he was scummy enough to merit a vote. And your unvoting post indicates that you still think that way but you're backing off to change people's perception of you. Has that opinion changed? Or are you talking about how everyone else is perceiving him?

[Eldrick4221]

 

Just ISOd Nyn. My read hasn't changed. At all. Most of her posts are fluff. There are a couple good posts (e.g. the general thoughts catchup post), But most of it isn't game-related, and she isn't engaging that much either, even before she mentioned the problems with her dog.

 

My posts are mostly fluff. lol

 

From you that means... absolutely nothing.

 

I know I had a good amount of fluff at the beginning too. Doesn't change the fact that I can't read you yet by what you've said so far. And apparently I'm not the only one.

[Eldrick4221]

Glad you're feeling better, though.

+1

[Eldrick4221]

 

6. Nyn- null to town. Not too much content. understandable due to RL. (I hope your dog is getting better) Nothing really pinging at this time.

 

Seems to me like you're smoking the same thing Eld is.... >.>  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Can I have some?

 

It's stuff like this that doesn't help your case. It's vaguely game related by acknowledging that we don't have a read on you, and then just joking it off.

[Nynaeve]

I know I had a good amount of fluff at the beginning too. Doesn't change the fact that I can't read you yet by what you've said so far. And apparently I'm not the only one.

 

Lets get something straight. I can totally respect you not being able to read me yet. That's fine. And You're welcome to ask me anything if you think it'll help you understand where I'm coming from. But you're not just gonna strut in, label most of my content as fluff, and walk away. That's not gonna fly with me. And it's hypocritical because I had a quick look at your own content and... lol. So. When you have something constructive to say, lmk.

[Eldrick4221]

Admittedly I have a history of not being able to read you. This isn't new.

[Nynaeve]

It's stuff like this that doesn't help your case. It's vaguely game related by acknowledging that we don't have a read on you, and then just joking it off.

 

I'm not joking it off. I think it's a stupid and false observation and I'm treating it as such.

[Nynaeve]

Admittedly I have a history of not being able to read you. This isn't new.

 

Again, that's perfectly fine. We're at D1 and it's okay. That's not my issue.

[Nynaeve]

It's not the read that bothers me. It's what you're basing it on. I can't articulate it in a clearer way than this so I hope it sinks in this time :P

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Thane, can you please expand on all these reads?

 

I wish i could. I explained what reads i had in my post. The problem i have is the same as in every single game i play in: i need a flip, or two, to start connecting dots. I dislike D1, cause it's more or less shooting blind. I work with tone a lot early game. Also, i just had 3 hours of sleep after working all night, and I need coffee right now.

 

@Turin: I'd say it would be normal if I interact with the people I am online with at a certain time of day. Unfortunately, I can't stay awake 24/7 and interact with everybody. Sorry about that. *hands a cookie*

 

People linking Laine and Zander.... As far as I can tell, they interact well every single game they play in together, so I don't know if that would be a scumtell for either of them to be honest. The fact that players are commenting on it is interesting and should be kept in mind for a later stage in the game.

 

I'm not fit today, and have some errands to run (silly paperwork andpick up my new cosplay outfit) Feel like a trainwreck so probably not as active today. Trying to stay awake to not mess up my biorhythm completely is hard.

[Sooh]

 

You're misunderstanding what I mean by that. I meant flying under the radar as in not posting scummily enough to be a valid lynch option, but at the same time not being towny enough to be cleared.

 

But you don't think the above, do you?. You thought he was scummy enough to merit a vote. And your unvoting post indicates that you still think that way but you're backing off to change people's perception of you. Has that opinion changed? Or are you talking about how everyone else is perceiving him?

 

I still think he's scummy enough to merit a vote, but I realize that I won't get him lynched today, perhaps never, so my vote is wasted on him. I'm not trying to get people to change their opinions of me merely based on an unvote, but because of how I do the game from here now that I'm feeling better. IRT Zander I'm talking about other people's perception yes. Basically if he's not an easy town read for you you should hear warning bells IMO.

 

 

Glad you're feeling better, though.

+1

 

Thank you, both of you

[Eldrick4221]

Going back and looking for stuff to actually coment on.

 

When you explained that your vote was initially a joke vote, you also said that you were being cautious of him because of how he was handling Lily and my exchange about the signup thing. You left his vote on him. It pings me when people give reasons to a joke vote to be able to leave it there.

[BFG]

 

 

Thane, can you please expand on all these reads?

 

I wish i could. I explained what reads i had in my post. The problem i have is the same as in every single game i play in: i need a flip, or two, to start connecting dots. I dislike D1, cause it's more or less shooting blind. I work with tone a lot early game. Also, i just had 3 hours of sleep after working all night, and I need coffee right now.

 

@Turin: I'd say it would be normal if I interact with the people I am online with at a certain time of day. Unfortunately, I can't stay awake 24/7 and interact with everybody. Sorry about that. *hands a cookie*

 

People linking Laine and Zander.... As far as I can tell, they interact well every single game they play in together, so I don't know if that would be a scumtell for either of them to be honest. The fact that players are commenting on it is interesting and should be kept in mind for a later stage in the game.

 

I'm not fit today, and have some errands to run (silly paperwork andpick up my new cosplay outfit) Feel like a trainwreck so probably not as active today. Trying to stay awake to not mess up my biorhythm completely is hard.

The order would be "most likely to be town to least likely to be town" at this point. I'm really liking Turin so far. Zander, who i am slowly starting the figure out (the lolololol-guy was easier to read imo, but whatever), is in the town pile for now. Though early softclaiming and all, not really a fan of it. Eldrick, at this point, looking worst of all. Nolder's play gives me a little tingle when reading it. not going to put him to the townie folk, slight wolfie lean. all the other people? If you're black, i still need some time to figure you out, so you're null, for now. You're green without comment? I like the tone and/or gameplay so far

 

The above are your stated reasons, except they're not reasons saying you like Turin isn't a reason for liking him...

 

Would it surprise you if I told you that in the 5 games I ISOd last night that you have never had completely unreasoned leans Day 1 as town except GnD which you basically didn't play till end Day 2 and this includes games you were clearly struggling Toledo up?

 

Ok though, can you expand your read on Eldrick? He's scummiest for you, why?

[BFG]

Nyn how do you feel about Thane now he's come back in thread?

[Nynaeve]

When you explained that your vote was initially a joke vote, you also said that you were being cautious of him because of how he was handling Lily and my exchange about the signup thing. You left his vote on him. It pings me when people give reasons to a joke vote to be able to leave it there.

 

I unvoted when I felt like unvoting and I was very clear about my joke vote vs. my concerns about Zander that have since cleared up quite a bit. Beyond that, don't really have much to add.

[Eldrick4221]

 

It's stuff like this that doesn't help your case. It's vaguely game related by acknowledging that we don't have a read on you, and then just joking it off.

 

I'm not joking it off. I think it's a stupid and false observation and I'm treating it as such.

 

 

Here is your posts out of the first 175 posts. Bolded is game related. The ratio hasn't really changed much.

 

 

Post #53,54,56. Nyn bumps. Fluff

Post #57. Can't remember last time you played. Liked Thane's enthusiasm.

Mostly fluff. I suppose the enthusiasm thing can be vaguely game-related.

Post #59 IRT Thane saying he needs hunting wolves for a distraction at work.

You agree. Fluff.

Post #60 Vote on Zander, explained later as being joke vote for previous game with him.

Post #61 Comment on similarities between BG and BFG's names. Effectively fluff, even though it's game related in a way.

Post #62 Asking Zander why he thinks Lily and I were "trying hard" to sell a connection between us.

Post #63 GIF of you listening to music and crying. Fluff.

Post #74 You approve of BFG nominating BG. Fluff.

Post #80 You explain that your vote on Z is a joke vote, but then give reason to keep it there because you are iffy about his Lily/Me theory. Your "being cautious with him" is to leave your vote on him after saying it's a joke.

Post #81 You snerk at Nolder's reason for voting Laine. Game related, as it's a reaction to game content.

Post #85,88 Talk about BFG's list being about "comparing boob sizes". Fluff.

Post #96 Reaction to co-mod "checking in". Fluff.

Post #156 Commenting to Z that his post didn't come off as a joke.

Post #158 Telling us you're still catching up.

Post #160 More Bumps fluff.

Post #161 Replying to Z about the joke issue. Explaining why it wasn't clear to you.

Post #165 Fluff comment about Clov commenting about his "not reading the thread yet". In retrospect, I didn't realize at the time that he wasn't a player when I responded to it.

Post #167 Unvote Zander

Post #175 Seconding the comment that Cory is affecting your read on Zander

[Eldrick4221]

It's not the read that bothers me. It's what you're basing it on. I can't articulate it in a clearer way than this so I hope it sinks in this time :P

 

It bothers you that I have you as null because I haven't seen much town content from you? Then show me more town content.

[BFG]

Eldrick, in a subversion of how the hero term is usually used you're my hero town call.

 

I really hope I'm not wrong because despite looking through some of your previous games I'm not sure how to read you and will probably take another look tonight :/